2014 Lesotho political crisis

2014 Lesotho political crisis
Tom Thabane, who was elected as prime minister in 2012.
Date 30 August 2014 Location  Lesotho Result Early election called Initial flight of prime minister and eventual return under southern African police protection Failed coup attempt
Belligerents
Lesotho Police Government of Lesotho	Lesotho Army Government of Lesotho
Commanders and leaders
Prime Minister Tom Thabane	Lieutenant General Kennedy Tlali Kamoli Deputy Prime Minister Mothetjoa Metsing
Casualties and losses
1 policeman

On 30 August 2014, the Prime Minister of Lesotho, Tom Thabane, alleged a coup d'état had been launched against him. This followed a previous allegation that caused him to suspend parliament over possible extra-constitutional manoeuvres. It also followed pressure from South Africa to maintain the democratic process. The next day, the Deputy Prime Minister, Mothetjoa Metsing, assumed responsibility for running the government. As a result of South African-led SADC mediation, an early election was scheduled and held in February 2015, giving power to the opposition.^[1]

Background

Following the general election of 2012, the All Basotho Convention's Tom Thabane was elected as prime minister as head of a three party coalition after ousting long serving Prime Minister Pakalitha Mosisili. On 19 June 2014, Thabane suspended parliament over fears of a coup d'état, allowing him to avoid a vote of confidence; this was sanctioned by King Letsie III. In reaction, South Africa issued a statement that read it "notes with concern the unfolding political and security situation in the Kingdom of Lesotho which has resulted in the prorogation of the country's parliament. The South African government has further noted with grave concern the unusual movements of the Lesotho Defence Force Units in the capital, Maseru. South Africa will not tolerate any unconstitutional change of government in the region and continent."^[2] Deputy Prime Minister Mothetjoa Metsing also suggested he would form a new government upon Thabane's removal. Meanwhile, in addition to South Africa, the Southern African Development Community also warned the political rivals of unconstitutional changes of government which would not be tolerated.^[3]

Coup d'état

On 30 August, at about 3:00 gunshots were heard at Basildon Peta in Maseru. Though the city was calm later in the day, people were said to be staying at home. Though there were no reports of deaths, the Lesotho Times termed it a "bloodless coup attempt." The army was said to have acted after Thabane tried to remove its chief, Lieutenant General Kennedy Tlali Kamoli, but the army said he was still in charge and that the military "supports the democratically elected government of the day." Army spokesman Major Ntlele Ntoi denied staging a coup saying: "There is nothing like that, the situation has returned to normalcy...the military has returned to their barracks." This followed a military presence on the streets of the capital and radio stations, including private ones^[4] and Radio Lesotho,^[5] being taken off air and phone lines cut, but they were working later in the day. Sports Minister Thesele Maseribane said that soldiers had surrounded State House, including government and police headquarters.^[4][6] He added that an unnamed military commander was looking for him, Thabane and Mothetjoa Metsing to take to the king and that "in our country, that means a coup" yet he insisted Thabane's government was still in control of the country. A reinforced military contingent was reportedly guarding Thabane's official residence and that soldiers were patrolling the streets of Maseru.^[3] The military had also disarmed police.^[7]

Thabane said he fled to South Africa amid fear for his life and that he would return "as soon as I know I am not going to get killed." He added that the alleged coup had rendered the government "dysfunctional" and that "I have been removed from control not by the people but by the armed forces, and that is illegal."^[4] He left with his family after getting reports he was targeted for assassination. He later said the action resulted from "total indiscipline" in the army with soldiers "running around the streets, threatening people" and "quite openly stating that they want my neck." He further accused an unnamed military commander of leading the unrest and that it was a reaction to his government's attempt to stem corruption; while he also called for SADC to help restore order. Conversely, officials who denied the coup plot said that they had moved against police elements suspected of trying to arm a political faction and that soldiers had returned to their barracks.^[8] One policeman was killed in the incident.^[9]

Aftermath

The next day, Metsing assumed responsibility for running the government.^[8] Following calls by Thabane for South African peacekeepers,^[10] by 3 September, South African police had escorted Thabane back to Maseru, according to Assistant Police Commissioner Lehloka Maphatsoe. Police Commissioner Khothatso Tsooana said that the South African police were present for extra security and that he had ordered the Lesotho police to return to work after being told to stop work and not wear uniforms to prevent attacks on police. Metsing also said the leader of the third party in the coalition also returned to Lesotho. The SADC added that it was sending an envoy and an observer team to help restore stability and security; while Lesotho's leaders agreed on a roadmap with a "clear timeline" towards removing the parliamentary suspension and agreed to release a joint statement "appealing for calm and exercise restraint with a view to rapidly bring law and order back in the kingdom,"^[7]

A 12 September deadline to reach a consensus was passed without agreement.^[11] South Africa Deputy President Cyril Ramaphosa then took responsibility from Jacob Zuma’s mediation efforts to get an agreement amongst the governing coalition.^[12] Chief among the discussion was the re-calling of the legislature. As a result of the failure, South Africa called for an emergency meeting of the SADC. One of those who fled the country, Thesele Maseribane, then asked: "How can you open your own parliament when you still have foreign troops here, protecting you? Everyone’s interested in parliament, but what about what recently happened here? This is not a movie. This is reality. This was an attempted coup." Deputy Prime Minister Mothetjoa Metsing’s Lesotho Congress for Democracy (LCD) was blamed, along with General Kamoli, for the putsch. Kamoli raided government armouries in preparation for a possible showdown, while his allies warned of a "bloodbath" if he is forcibly removed. The SADC has also rebuffed calls by some domestic leaders for a military intervention, instead opting for a political resolution.^[13]

On 30 September, under the SADC mandate to help creating dialogue, Ramaphosa arrived in the country.^[14] In ongoing developments at the time, Senate Chief Whip Khoabane Theko said that the prime minister's office had too much constitutional power and there was no provision for coalition dispute resolution, yet he also rejected calls to empower the king in order to help resolve political disagreements. "In our constitution, there is nowhere, where the prime minister is obliged maybe to consult when he does anything with his partner in the coalition. So we still have that problem on the ground. [Yet] I don’t want to put the monarchy in danger. I don’t want my king to be beheaded like Charles I in England in the old times." He further noted: "It is very unsettling because nobody is sure what is going to happen. There was an attempted coup...[and] that has made the people very unsettled on our political spectrum. There is so much uncertainty and of course business is not doing well because...Every time it’s 6 “O’clock in the evening everybody wants to get to his household to make sure that he does not meet a bullet or something like that." He suggested that the tensions could be reduced if the root cause involving Kamoli, who refused to step down when Thabane replaced him with Lieutenant General Maaparankoe Mahao as head of Lesotho Defense Force, leads to "Kamoli himself really relinquishes power and maybe make way for...Lieutenant General Maaparankoe Mahao." It could, however, also worsen if the other side gets its way. "There are a lot of people who are in a hurry so that they can call for a motion of no confidence against the incumbent prime minister, which I think is a very quick fix consolation that cannot help Basotho at all."^[15]

Thabane and unnamed allies were then receiving round-the-clock protection from Namibian and South African police in the country.^[9] In a resolution to the conflict, the Maseru Facilitation Declaration was signed.^[16] The scheduled election was brought forward by two years and would occur in February 2015. The announcement was made by Ramaphosa, who added that the exact date would be determined by King Letsie III. Thabane said that the time had come to "go back to the electorate and get a fresh mandate. I still have it in me to go to the hustings and campaign."^[17] Russia also welcomed the deal.^[18]

On 17 October, parliament reconvened in a bid to avert the political crisis with Thabane's advisor Tumisang Mosotho saying: "It’s a milestone. We want to hope this is the first step in the right direction, in liberating our country from the danger that has surrounded us these past few months."^[19] Senate Chief Whip Khoabane Theko said: "This is what we can call maybe the beginning of the process that takes us to the elections, because we are going to have a budget and maybe deliberate other laws … ahead of our elections from here on."^[20] Parliament was officially re-convened in October by Letsie III and was celebrated by opposition MPs.^[21]

Investigation

Lesotho police opened an investigation into two of its employees over treason and murder for being allegedly complicit in working with the military. Deputy Police Commissioner Masupha Masupha said that "even I've been implicated. But investigating and charging are different things. If I find something, I won't shy away from confronting anyone with their unlawful acts." Lehloka Maphatsoe – an assistant police commissioner who leads the Interpol national central bureau – said that the two police officers under investigation were having their cellphones sent to South Africa where Bloemfontein police were checking for "suspicious communications" and if there were attempts to delete the evidence. Masupha hosted a meeting of all officers to hear grievances. Some said they do not trust management and made accusations of complicity because "some of you have been involved in this mess." He look to assure the officers and they could approach him anonymously with information.^[9]

Reactions

Domestic

Minister Thesele Maseribane, a possible target in the putsch, said he was not surprised by the accusation and that he suspected Kamoli and Metsing to have attempted the coup in order to halt corruption investigations against them. Police officers present on 30 August reported that soldiers demanded to see police files on the two of them. Maseribane added that "If you plan a coup, it must succeed. Because once it fails, people start talking. Many are now nervous, as others put the puzzle together and point fingers."^[9]

International

South Africa's International Relations Department's spokesperson Clayson Monyela said: "The department will either convene a media briefing or issue a statement later today regarding the situation in Lesotho."^[6] He also added that though no one claimed, the action had the markings of a putsch.^[8] Following the return of Thabane, the Methodist Church of Southern Africa welcomed the calmness in the country with Bishop Zipho Siwa saying prayers were offered for a "blood-less" resolution. "May the parties unite through peaceful dialogue and work towards a solution that will re-establish harmony, the rule of law and good governance in the country." He called for the people of Lesotho to support Thabane other officials' quest for a solution. He further lauded South African President Jacob Zuma for co-ordinating the dialogue that resulted in dispatching a SADC observer team to Lesotho.^[22]

References

1. "Lesotho looks to hold on to peace after early elections". Reuters. 5 March 2015. Retrieved 14 May 2015.
2. "Parliament suspended amid fears of a coup in Lesotho". Mail & Guardian (mg.co.za). Retrieved 30 August 2014.
3. "Military coup under way in Lesotho". aljazeera.com. Retrieved 12 September 2014.
4. "Lesotho 'coup' forces PM Thabane to South Africa". bbc.com. Retrieved 12 September 2014.
5. "Corruption and crime are roots of Lesotho conflict". Business Day Live. Retrieved 12 October 2014.
6. "Lesotho army siezes [sic] main buildings". ewn.co.za. Retrieved 30 August 2014.
7. ABC News. "Lesotho Prime Minister Escorted Back Home". ABC News. Retrieved 12 September 2014.
8. "SADC, Lesotho Leaders to Discuss Political Crisis". voanews.com. Retrieved 12 September 2014.
9. "Lesotho cops suspect own in coup attempt". News24. Retrieved 12 October 2014.
10. "Lesotho 'coup': Thabane calls on South Africa to send peacekeeping troops". theguardian.com. Retrieved 12 September 2014.
11. "New summit over Lesotho deadlock". Iol.co.za. Retrieved 12 October 2014.
12. "Ramaphosa steps in to defuse Lesotho". The M&G Online. Retrieved 12 October 2014.
13. "SA calls crisis summit as Lesotho peace talks stall". Business Day Live. Retrieved 12 October 2014.
14. "Ramaphosa arrives in crisis hit Lesotho". News24. Retrieved 12 October 2014.
15. "South African, Lesotho Leaders to Discuss Political Crisis". VOA. Retrieved 12 October 2014.
16. "Lesotho PM Thabane to Seek Re-Election Next Year". VOA. Retrieved 12 October 2014.
17. "BBC News - Lesotho crisis: PM Thabane to contest early poll". BBC News. Retrieved 12 October 2014.
18. "Russia Praises Lesotho Peace Deal As Nation Heads for Snap Elections: Foreign Ministry". RIA Novosti. Retrieved 12 October 2014.
19. "Lesotho parliament to reconvene in bid to end crisis". Business Day Live. Retrieved 23 October 2014.
20. "Lesotho Parliament Set to Open on Friday". VOA. Retrieved 23 October 2014.
21. "Lesotho MPs dance as parliament re-opens after coup crisis". The Citizen. Retrieved 23 October 2014.
22. "Methodist church welcomes Lesotho progress". The Citizen. 5 September 2014.