Battle of Lao Cai

Battle of Lào Cai
Part of Sino-Vietnamese War
Sapa town in Lào Cai Province
Date 17 February–5 March 1979 Location Northern Hoàng Liên Sơn Province and northeastern Lai Châu Province, Vietnam Result Chinese Pyrrhic victory
Belligerents
China	Vietnam
Commanders and leaders
Yang Dezhi	Unknown
Units involved
11th Army 13th Army 14th Army 50th Army 149th Division	316th Division 345th Division Militia, regional, and border guard units
Strength
~125,000	~20,000
Casualties and losses
Unknown Chinese claim: 7,886 casualties (including 2,812 killed) Vietnamese claim: 11,500 casualties	Unknown Chinese claim: 13,500 casualties

The Battle of Lao Cai was fought during the brief but bloody Sino-Vietnamese War. Though the Chinese themselves took a heavy toll from the Vietnamese defending the area, they were eventually successful in capturing and occupying the province from a mixed force of regulars, militia, and government border troops.^[1]

Planning and order of battle

The Chinese People's Liberation Army (PLA) Kunming Military Region took responsibility for Chinese operations in Lào Cai direction, which involved the 11th and 13th Armies from the Kunming Military Region itself, and the 14th Army from the Chengdu Military Region, totalling about 125,000 troops.^[2] The three armies was followed by the reserve 149th Division of the 50th Army, as well as many support units.^[3] The invasion comprised three prongs of advances: while the 11th Army was assigned to attack Phong Thổ before hooking up to Sapa and Lào Cai from the west, the 14th Army was ordered to take Mường Khương and move against Lào Cai from the east; the central thrust was undertaken by the 13th Army, targeting Lào Cai itself, as well as the township of Cam Đường to the south.^[4]

For the Vietnamese side, it is believed by historians that the defense of the Hoàng Liên Sơn Province (modern-day Lào Cai and Yên Bái Provinces) was conducted by several regiments of the Vietnam People's Army (VPA), some of which consisted of the regular 345th and 316th Divisions.^[4][5] A force at the size of two divisions was equivalent to around 20,000 Vietnamese troops present in Lào Cai area at the beginning of the war.^[4]

Battle

The battle was begun before the dawn of 17 February by a Chinese artillery barrage against Vietnamese positions.^[6] The first objectives for the PLA were the towns of Bát Xát, Mường Khương, and Pha Long.^[4] 20,000 troops from the PLA 13th Army crossed the Red River into Bát Xát using pontoon bridges, quickly overrunning the Vietnamese defense held by the VPA 192nd Regiment, as well as the independant 2nd and Lao Cai Battalions.^[3] No attack was staged against Phong Thổ at all on the first day of the war.^[4]

The brunt of Chinese assaults fell on the VPA 345th Division, which resisted toughly.^[4] Two Chinese regiments were held off at Mống Xến and in the area south of Chu Dang and west of Nhạc Sơn, which forced the PLA to change their plan into a mop-up operation against the Vietnamese strongholds. By the dusk of 18 February, the Vietnamese defenders in Bảo Thắng and Cốc Lếu had been completely encircled.^[3] However, not until 14:00 on 19 February were the PLA able to capture Lào Cai City.^[4] In response to the lost of the provincial capital, the VPA 345th Division command sent one battalion from its 118th Regiment to reinforce its 121th Regiment's positions at Coc Tha, Dien Na, Dung Ha and Chan Uy, while the VPA 316th Division was mobilized eastward to Sapa from Bình Lư.^[7]

Having Lào Cai taken, the PLA then sent a group of troops (probably from the 13th Army) to Cam Đường to the south, and another group (probably from the 14th Army) advancing along Highway 4D to Sapa, which was 38 km to the southwest.^[4] The Kunming Military Region Command used fresh elements from the 149th Division and the 11th Army to reinforce the 13th Army in the efforts against Cam Đường. A blocking position was established by four companies from the PLA 39th Division of the 13th Army on Highway 10 at Thay Nai to cut the VPA 345th Division from supply.^[7] The VPA 316th Division was then ordered to march from Sapa to meet the approaching Chinese forces, and ran into contact on the secondary road between Lào Cai and Sapa on 22 February.^[4] From 22 to 25 February, its 148th Regiment launched repetitive attacks against the Chinese block at Thay Nai, yet failed to secure its way to Cam Đường.^[7] Two PLA divisions from the 13th Army, the 37th and 38th, were deployed against the VPA 345th Division, which was defending a narrow area north of Cam Đường.^[8] By 25 February, the Chinese had seized Cam Đường, yet were still struggling to exterminate pockets of Vietnamese resistance in Lào Cai and other towns under their control, a situation which had not ended until 27 February.^[4]

On 24 February, the PLA decided to supplement their reserves, the 149th Division, to the fight against the VPA 316th Division.^[9] Chinese efforts now concentrating on cutting off the retreat of the VPA 316th Division, as the PLA 447th Regiment skirted around Mount Phan Xi Pang through the Hoang Lien Son Pass and maneuvered toward the direction of Bình Lư, which was 44 km west of Sapa.^[10][9] In meantime, the rest of the 149th Division pushed toward Sapa along two roads parallel to Highway 10. Despite showing excellent combat performance, the VPA 316th Division was finally forced to retreat due to the lack of troops to halt enemy's massive attacks.^[9] At 14:45 on 1 March, Sapa fell to the PLA. On the eastern wing of the offensive, Khoc Tiam was captured after a night assault raging from 20:00 on 2 March to 14:45 on 3 March. At 19:00 on 3 March, all roads that connected Phong Thổ with Bình Lư and Pa Tần had been under Chinese control. On 4 March, Chinese forces eventually captured the town, thus successfully blocking the supply route to the VPA 316th Division from Lai Châu; the blocking position was at least 40 km from the Sino-Vietnamese border, becoming the deepest Chinese penetration in the war. However, it was not until 5 March did the Vietnamese division finally cease to fight.^[10]

Aftermath

In the battle, the Chinese claimed to have inflicted 13,500 Vietnamese casualties, while suffered 2,812 killed out of 7,886 casualties of their own.^[11] On the other hand, Vietnamese accounts put the number of Chinese casualties at 11,500.^[12] Similar to the fighting in other fronts, during the Lao Cai campaign, the "human wave" tactic was thoroughly applied by the PLA for every smallest objective, as portrayed by a Vietnamese soldier in an interview by French journalist Jean-Pierre Gallois: "The Chinese infantry advance shoulder to shoulder to make sure the minefields are cleared... When they moved out of Lao Cai they were as numerous and close together as rice in the paddy fields."^[10][13] As Sapa was a town possessing almost no strategic value, the Chinese campaign in the western front did not end with a notable victory. The PLA did, however, succeed in one of their key goals – to engage a considerable Vietnamese regular force, and inflict heavy losses on it – even at a high price for themselves as well.^[11]

Notes

1. Chen, p. 108.
2. O'Dowd, p. 61-62.
3. Zhang, p. 100.
4. O'Dowd, p. 62.
5. Li Man Kin, p. 92-93.
6. O'Dowd, p. 61.
7. Zhang, p. 101.
8. Zhang, p. 102.
9. Zhang, p. 103.
10. O'Dowd, p. 63.
11. Zhang, p. 104
12. (in Vietnamese) Trường Sơn, "Biên giới phía Bắc 1979: 30 ngày không thể nào quên (2)", Infonet, 17 February 2015.
13. FBIS, Southeast Asia, 26 February 1979, p. K-13.

References

• Edward C. O'Dowd (2007). Chinese Military Strategy in the Third Indochina War: The Last Maoist War. New York: Routledge. ISBN 0203088964.
• King C. Chen (1987). China's War with Vietnam, 1979: Issues, Decisions, and Implications. Stanford: Hoover Institution Press. ISBN 0817985719.
• Xiaoming Zhang (2015). Deng Xiaoping's Long War: The Military Conflict between China and Vietnam, 1979-1991. University of North Carolina Press. ISBN 9781469621258.
• Li Man Kin (1981). The Sino-Vietnamese War. Hong Kong: Kingsway Publications.