Brunolf Baade

Brunolf Baade
Roll-out of the "152/I V-1" passenger jet (Dresden-Klotzsche, April 1958)
Born	Carl Wilhelm Brunolf Baade 15 March 1904 Berlin-Roxdorf, Germany
Died	5 November 1969 Berlin-Buch, German Democratic Republic
Occupation	Aeronautical engineer
Political party	NSDAP (1937) SED (1954)
Spouse(s)	Anna Stierle

Brunolf Baade (15 March 1904 – 5 November 1969) was an important German aeronautical engineer.^[1] He led the team that developed the Baade 152.^[2]

Life

Early years

Brunolf Baade was born and grew up on the southern edge of Rixdorf (today Neukölln),^[3] a densely populated district then just outside the northern perimeter of Berlin. (Rixdorf would be incorporated into Greater Berlin in 1920.) His father was employed in a small electronics company, later rising to the position of assembly and technical worker.^[4] Brunolf had two younger sisters. His mother contributed to the household budget by running a small shop. Baade's father came from farming stock, but his mother's ancestry included teachers and artisans, along with the popular nineteenth century poet Hofmann von Fallersleben, an ancestor of whom Brunolf Baade was particularly proud.^[3]

Baade attended the "Emperor Frederick Grammar School" ("Kaiser-Friedrich-Realgymnasium") locally from 1910, successfully completing his school leaving exam in 1922. When he was 14 his enthusiastic if brief involvement in some of the preparations for revolution which erupted in postwar Germany alarmed his parents, who were never themselves particularly political, and suggested that his rather conservative school environment had released a rebellious streak in the boy.^[3]

He then studied at the Technical University of Berlin.^[4] He combined his time as a student with an internship at Blohm + Voss in Hamburg, reflecting his ambition at that time to make his career in the booming ship building industry. In Hamburg he was involved in the construction of the "Waskenland". Later, after the ship had been fitted out, she made her maiden voyage to South America. Baade joined the crew as a "coal trimmer", and then took the opportunity to explore South America, discovering its people and customs.

Building aircraft

Returning to Berlin, Baade resumed his studies, now increasingly focused on the potential of the aircraft business, to which he had been introduced during his stay in South America. He joined the Academic Flying League and started to construct gliders. (Production and operation of powered aircraft in Germany had been restricted under the provisions of the Treaty of Versailles signed in 1919.) Baade also learned to fly and participated in the annual glider competitions at the Wasserkuppe.^[5]

At the end of 1927 he learned to fly powered aircraft, undertaking a course with the still semi-clandestine German Flying School (DVS) and obtaining a pilots licence. Incorporated into his study period with the DVS was an internship that ran from 27 November 1927 till 5 December 1928 and based in Berlin, which involved responsibility for static load testing.^[5] He now spent a year at the Technical University of Munich, concluding his undergraduate studies, in 1929 finally obtaining a degree in mechanical engineering. While studying in Bavaria he also undertook a further brief period of internship, from 16 March till 20 April 1929, with the Bavarian Aircraft Works (BFW / Bayerische Flugzeugwerke AG).^[4] For another year he continued to work for Bavarian Aircraft Works through a period of financial crisis from which some years later the company emerged as "Messerschmitt AG". Willy Messerschmitt had been working in partnership with BFW since 1926, and during 1929/30 Baade worked with Messerschmitt on a succession of innovative passenger aircraft including the M18, the M20 and the M24.^[5]

In 1930 Baade traveled to the USA, sent by BFW in order to hand over some production licenses to American firms. Once there, however, he loosened his ties with BFW, remaining in the USA for some years, working at various times for Eastern Aircraft, North American Aviation and the US subsidiary of the (since 1919 Dutch domiciled) Fokker Company. In 1932 he switched to Goodyear^[5] where his projects are thought to have included work on the futuristic Comet railcar project. 1932 was also the year in which he married Anna Stierle, like him a German expatriate.^[3]

Despite apparent professional success in North America, Baade maintained his contacts with the German aeronautical industry. During the early 1930s employment prospects for aircraft engineers in Germany remained dire,^[3] but in the second half of 1936 he returned to Germany with his wife. There is some ambiguity as to whether, at this stage, the couple had expected to stay in Germany, but on 1 October 1936 Baade took a job to the south of Berlin, at Dessau with Junkers. High calibre aircraft engineers were now becoming highly valued: he achieved rapid promotion, an unexpectedly large salary and ended up living in a large house, all of which led to the abandonment of any half formed intentions that he might have had to return back across the Atlantic.^[3] Appointed to head up the Development and Design Department, Baade stayed with Junkers through the war which was declared by several western European governments in 1939, following Germany's invasion of Poland in the late summer. With Junkers Baade was involved in development of a succession of military aircraft including the Ju 88, Ju 188, Ju 388 and Ju 287.^[3]

After the war

The war ended in May 1945, but the previous month Brunolf Baade had been arrested by an advance party of US soldiers that had surprised him at the outsourced Junkers design office at Raguhn.^[3] Baade had been a member of the German Nazi Party since 1937 and was held prisoner by the Americans in Bad Hersfeld for a couple of months. With his gifts for easy friendship and fluent English he was able to engage his captors in conversation. Baade would later recall emphatic assurances received at this time from US officers that Germany would be radically de-industrialised and certainly not permitted an aircraft industry for many decades. It was, he said, this that persuaded him to support a German future determined by the Soviet Union.^[3] Between April and June the Americans occupied Dessau: they comprehensively looted the Junkers library and technical documents, along with the latest aircraft and engines which their soldiers removed apparently as trophies.^[3] The Americans released Baade in June 1945 and early in July American forces were replaced in central Germany by Soviet troops, respecting the division of Germany into occupation zones, already agreed between the allies at the Yalta Conference. Dessau was now in the Soviet occupation zone.^[3]

The Soviet Union

The Soviets had their own plans for post-war Germany. In Autumn/Fall 1945 Baade was mandated by the Soviet Military Administration to reconstruct the Junkers research facilities, using whatever remained of the wreckage in Dessau factory. The physical assets having been removed by the Americans, the Soviets were chiefly dependent on the "intellectual property" that could be extracted from plant personnel.^[3] Engineering and production specialists were required to write down everything they could remember. In the end more than 2,000 written reports were prepared and shipped to the Soviet Union,^[6] though as matters turned out the subsequent researches of the Junkers engineers would be of greater value than their memories of the past.^[3]

Progress resumed on the company's advanced jet-engined designs and work began on rebuilding the former Junkers factory at Dessau. On 22 October 1946, however, Soviet troops appeared outside the houses of selected company personnel who were given four hours to pack their possessions and prepare for a two week journey by truck to a village north of Moscow, and close to Dubna, called Podberezye (Подберезье).^[6] Some were accompanied by their wives, while for others their families followed a few weeks later.^[6] When they arrived they were confronted by a large complex of otherwise abandoned military buildings containing a considerable quantity of machinery that the Soviets had managed to gather from various formerly German aircraft manufacturing facilities.^[6] There had never been any doubt that the Soviets viewed formerly German military-industrial assets in their occupation zone as Soviet property, and while their commitment to progress on the advanced aircraft design for which Junkers was known was genuine enough, it now transpired that further work would be undertaken back in the Soviet Union. It is not clear whether Baade was one of those abruptly transported of whether he was already in the Soviet Union. In any event, Baade, whose talents for leadership and for charming people were not in doubt,^[6] quickly emerged as the leader of the relocated German engineers, and as a man whom the Soviets were in large part prepared to trust.^[6] Unlike the other German engineers in Podberezye, Baade was apparently allowed to move freely, and was even seen, early in 1947, on holiday in the Crimea while the other Germans aircraft specialists had no choice but to shiver through the coldest winter the Moscow region had known for many years.^[6]

Under Baade work continued on developing the Junkers Ju 287 jet bomber with its characteristic "forward-swept" wings, now renamed as the OKB-1 EF 131, although progress was hampered by the Soviet refusal to allow the German engineers near the military airfield used to test the prototypes. The project was abandoned in June 1948. The final prototype was adapted for use in the OKB-1 140 programme. The other principal project of Baade's team of involuntary expatriates was the OKB-1 150, a jet bomber jet bomber on which serious work began in 1948. The design incorporated innovative ideas on materials and design. As with the earlier project, progress was hampered by the inconsistent nature of support from the Soviets when it came to obtaining materials and permitting the German expatriates the freedom necessary to develop and test the aircraft effectively. By 1951 the OKB-1 150 had been developed into a heavy bomber with a range of approximately 1,500 km and a bomb capacity of around 600 kg, but in 1952 this project, too, was abandoned as resources were again reprioritized.^[6]

While the German aircraft engineers were enduring the hospitality of the Soviet Union, Germany's Soviet occupation zone had become the German Democratic Republic, formally founded in October 1949. Economic hardships in the young country, exacerbated by the large reparations payments still being made to the Soviet Union and the high cost of supporting the Soviet military presence, are seen by some historians as a key cause, directly and indirectly, of the East German uprising in 1953. High profile show trials of officially designated enemies of the state were also a feature of East Germany in the first half of the 1950s. Nevertheless, 1953 was also the year in which Stalin died, and as the decade unfolded the political temperature in Moscow and East Berlin started, slowly, to become a little less nervous, and Moscow's approach to its East German ally became less antagonistic.^[6] After a period of uncertainty, in December 1953 Baade persuaded the Soviets to permit his team to develop the abandoned OKB-1 150 bomber into a world-class jet engined passenger aircraft.^[6] Holding the German aeronautical engineers in a village north of Moscow made less sense once the decision had been taken to lift the ban on aircraft manufacture in East Germany with effect from 1955. In 1954 Brunolf Baade relocated back to East Germany and joined the country's ruling Socialist Unity Party of Germany (SED) / Sozialistische Einheitspartei Deutschlands).^[4] By June 1954 the last of the German engineers had been repatriated back to Germany or Austria.^[3]

Back in the GDR

After returning the German Democratic Republic with Soviet assent to the passenger jet promised, Brunolf Baarde was given responsibility for developing and producing what now came to be known as the 152.^[2] In terms of stealing a march on the west, political support from the national leadership was enthusiastic, but sources written with the benefit hindsight nevertheless surmise that Baarde had underestimated the challenges.^[2] When his 300 aeronautical engineers arrived back from the Soviet Union, there was not even space to accommodate them.^[2] There was no longer any infrastructure to support an aeronautical industry in terms of a supply chain, and although there was plenty of available enthusiasm, there was no experienced labour pool from which to draw workers. High wages in West Germany and elsewhere were sucking the country dry of its skilled workforce. A survey in 1956 found that only 11% of the specialist workers engaged on the project had worked in aeronautics the last time Germany had had an industry, before 1945.^[2] In respect of the development work already undertaken in the Soviet Union, Baade no longer had access to the Soviet test pilots who had been permitted to fly the earlier military versions of the plane. He had been forced to leave key technical documentation behind, and never passed over: it was never entirely clear whether this resulted from overlapping bureaucratic structures in the Soviet system or from some high level decision.^[2] Nevertheless, Baade's connections in the Soviet Union meant that where key components could not be obtained in East Germany, they would be delivered from the Soviet Union.^[2]

Finance was found for the construction of a new development centre at a former Luftwaffe airfield at Klotzsche on the edge of Dresden and work began on recruitment and training of the necessary workforce.^[6] Meanwhile developments to the west of what had come to be known as the Iron Curtain, such as the prototype maiden flights of the Comet (1949), Boeing 367-80 (1954) and Caravelle (1955) led Baade's team to distance the 152 further from its bomber origins, increasing the seating capacity, fracture load factor and (marginally) maximum speed without changing the basic architecture of the design or significantly increasing its weight.^[2] Time-line slippage was inevitable and it became clear that a critical constraint would be development of the Pirna 014 engines.^[3] In order to secure continued funding and political support, Baade was committed to a 1958 launch, but when the 152 appeared outside the hangar at Klotzsche for its high-profile "roll-out" in April 1958, the "152-V1", it did so without engines. A 35 minute first flight was achieved for December 1958 when the prototype was powered not by the Pirna engines designed for the purpose, but by Soviet built Tumansky RD-9 engines,^[6] for which the controls and fuel feed components had been adapted.^[7] A second flight took place in March 1959, still with the Soviet engines, in order to pass low over the prestigious Leipzig Trade Fair and provide photo-opportunities,^[6] but on this occasion the engines stalled and "152-V1" crashed while descending towards the Klotzsche airfield, as it rehearsed for the public demonstration scheduled to take place half an hour later. The four people on-board were killed and the accident was attributed to pilot error.^[7] Much later, more considered verdicts concur around the suspicion that the engines were starved because of issues involving the fuel feed system^[7] and/or the 16 rubber fuel bladders positioned in the wings.^[2]

Aircraft development at the Dresden facility and Pirna engine plant ended formally in 1961. In March 1961 Baarde became director of the newly founded Institute for Lightweight construction and the economical use of Materials (IfL), based in Dresden-Klotzsche.^[4] He had previously held a position, since 1955, as a lecturer at what was at the time the Faculty for Aeronautical Engineering at the Dresden University of Technology.^[4]

Death

Brunolf Baarde retired from the Institute when he reached 65, in March 1969. He died on 5 November 1969 in a Berlin hospital^[7] or in Dresden,^[4] from complications caused by stomach cancer. He is buried at Eichwalde on the edge of Berlin. At least one source indicates that he had never recovered his full health after returning from the Soviet Union in 1954.^[7]

There is some consensus between the sources that Baade's real brilliance lay not so much in his engineering talents as in his personal gifts as a political and institutional fixer. He was an imposing man, capable of great achievements when supported by good technicians and economists.^[6][8]

Awards and honours

• 1959: Patriotic Order of Merit

Many streets are named after him, including the Brunolf-Baade-Straße (Brunolf Baade Street) alongside Berlin's Schönefeld Airport^[9] and another in Ludwigsfelde.^[10]

References

1. "Brunolf Baade (1904 - 1969)". Flughafen Berlin Brandenburg GmbH. Retrieved 4 March 2015.
2. Holger Lorenz, Technical journalist. "Walter Ulbrichts Traum vom Überflügeln des Westens: Die junge DDR baut das erste deutsche Passagierflugzeug mit Strahlantrieb" (PDF). Holger Lorenz, Chemnitz. Retrieved 4 March 2015.
3. Holger Lorenz, Technical journalist. "Prof. Brunolf Baade: Ein Leben für den deutschen und internationalen Flugzeugbau". Holger Lorenz, Chemnitz. Retrieved 4 March 2015.
4. Helmut Müller-Enbergs; Andreas Kahlow. "Baade, Brunolf * 15.3.1904, † 14.10.1969 Generalkonstrukteur der Luftfahrtindustrie" (in German). Bundesstiftung zur Aufarbeitung der SED-Diktatur: Biographische Datenbanken. Retrieved 3 March 2015.
5. Reinhard Müller (2010). Brunolf Baade und die Luftfahrtindustrie der DDR – die wahre Geschichte des Strahlverkehrsflugzeuges. Erfurt: Sutton Verlag. ISBN 978-3-866-80721-1.
6. Fred Stahl (February 1996). "The Rise and Fall of the East German Aircraft Industry: Under the inconstant patronage of the Soviet Union, the warplane builders of the Third Reich reached for their former glory.". Air & Space Magazine, Smithsonian National Air and Space Museum, Washington, D.C. Archived from the original on January 29, 2006. Retrieved 4 March 2015.
7. Stephen Trimble (10 December 2013). "IN FOCUS Heroic failures: 11 aircraft that should have flown high but never quite took off...Baade 152". Flightglobal (Reed Business Information). Retrieved 5 March 2015.
8. Holger Lorenz, Technical journalist. "Prof. Brunolf Baade: Ein Leben für den deutschen und internationalen Flugzeugbau". "Meine eigene Einschätzung ist die, daß Baade kein begabter Techniker war, dafür ein begnadeter politischer Lenker und Weichensteller, der mit guten Technikern und Ökonomen an seiner Seite, Großes vollbringen konnte." H.L. Holger Lorenz, Chemnitz. Retrieved 4 March 2015.
9. http://www.openstreetmap.org/way/179661332/history
10. http://www.berliner-stadtplan.com/Prof-Brunolf-Baade-Strasse-14974-Ludwigsfelde_a38500