| Issue | Date | Interviews | Features | Reviews |
| #1 | Oct 99 | David Boreanaz | 'Ask Joss', 'Slayer Palooza' (Music in the Bronze), 'How to identify a Vampire', Comic: "Wu-tang Fang" | (None) |
| #2 | Nov 99 | James Marsters, Juliet Landau, Robia La Morte | 'Ask Joss', 'Dust to Dust' (Digital special effects) Comic: "The Final Cut" | (None) |
| #3 | Dec 99 | Anthony Stewart Head | 'High School Hell' (tales from cast and crew about their school experiences), 'Thoroughly Modern Magic' (use of witchcraft in show), Comic: "Hey, Good Looking, part 1" | (None) |
| #4 | Jan 2000 | Charisma Carpenter | Villain guide part 1, Comic: Comic: "Hey, Good Looking, part 2" | (None) |
| #5 | Feb 2000 | (None) | Report on Angel series, Villain guide part 2, Comic: "A Boy Named 'Sue'" | (None) |
| #6 | Mar 2000 | Seth Green, Bianca Lawson | Episode Guide (Buffy Season 1), 'Dead and Loving It' (Vampires in pop culture) Comic: "A Nice Girl Like You" | (None) |
| #7 | Apr 2000 | James Marsters, Juliet Landau, Mark Metcalf | 'Sunnydale Tour': cemetery, 'Evil Twin' (Vamp Willow feature), Comic: "Love Sick Blues I" | (None) |
| #8 | May 2000 | Kristine Sutherland | Episode Guide (Buffy Season 2), 'Sunnydale Tour': Sunnydale High, 'Taking the Fall (Stunt team feature), Comic: "Love Sick Blues II" | (None) |
| #9 | Jun 2000 | Nicholas Brendon, Eliza Dushku | Buffy tour (Buffy's bedroom), Comic: "Lost Highway" | (None) |
| #10 | Jul 2000 | Harry Groener | Episode Guide (Buffy Season 3), 'Safe at Home' (Buffy's house - set feature), Comic: She's No Lady I | (None) |
| #11 | Aug 2000 | Joss Whedon, Emma Caulfield | Library set-report, feature on costume design Comic: "She's No Lady I" | (None) |
| #12 | Sep 2000 | Joss Whedon, Armin Shimerman | Make-up feature, Comic: "Old Friend" | (None) |
| #13 | Oct 2000 | Glenn Quinn, Danny Strong | 'Bite Club' (poll on fave vamps), Comic: "Double Cross" | (None) |
| #14 | Nov 2000 | Marc Blucas, Mercedes McNab, Dagny Kerr | 'Sunndale Tour': Buffy's dorm room, Episode Spotlight: "Fear Itself", Make-up feature, Comic: "Paint the Town Red I" | (None) |
| #15 | Dec 2000 | Alyson Hannigan, Parker Abrams (pretend interview) | 'Sunndale Tour': Initiative, Episode Spotlight: "Hush", How to Survive College, Comic: "Paint the Town Red II" | (None) |
| #16 | Jan 2001 | Amber Benson | Episode Guide (Angel Season 1), 'Sunndale Tour': UC Sunnydale, 'Ghost Hunters' (report on real-life paranormal investigators), Set report: Cordy's apartment, Episode Spotlight: "A New Man", Comic: "The Blood of Carthage I" | "Ring of Fire", "Pretty Maids All in a Row", "Ghoul Trouble" |
| #17 | Feb 2001 | Bai Ling | 'Demonic Poession', Episode Guide (Buffy Season 4), Set reports: Xander's room & Angel's Season 1 offices, Episode Spotlight: "Welcome to the Hellmouth", Comic: "The Blood of Carthage II" | Top 5 novels (Xander Years novelizations, "Blooded", "Power of Persuasion", "How I Survived My Summer Vacation", and "The Gatekeeper") |
| #18 | Mar 2001 | Lindsay Crouse, Randall Slavin and Carey Cannon (The Oracles) | Set-report: Angel's apartment, Buffy's Love Quiz, Top 10 sexiest men in Buffyverse poll, Buffy Art Team Comic: "The Blood of Carthage III" | Watcher's Guide II, "Doomsday Deck", "Jonathan" |
| #19 | Apr 2001 | George Hertzberg, Elisabeth Röhm | Angel inhuries (feature on the beatings of Angel), Wolfram and Hart feature, Top 10 sexiest women in Buffyverse poll, Comic: "The Blood of Carthage IV" | "Surrogates", Buffy/Angel video sets |
| #20 | May 2001 | Joss Whedon, Bailey Chase & Leonard Roberts (Initiative members Forrest & Graham) | Analysis of "Restless", 'Sunndale Tour': Spike's crypt, Episode Spotlight: "This Year's Girl/Who Are You?", Comic: "The Blood of Carthage V" | "Revenant", "Hollywood Noir" |
| #21 | Spring 2001 | Alexis Denisof, Mercedes McNab | Watcher Test, Demonology part 1, Episode Spotlight: "Helpless", Comic: "The Blood of Carthage VI" | "Not Forgotten", "Close to the Ground", "Redemption", "Shakedown", "Hollywood Noir", "Avatar" |
| #22 | Jun 2001 | Joss Whedon (about Fray), Julie Benz | Demonology part 2, Episode Spotlight: "Angel" (Buffy Season 1 episode), Comic: "The Blood of Carthage VII" | "Fray #1", "The Blood of Carthage", "The Book of Fours" |
| #23 | Jul 2001 | J. August Richards, Jane Espenson, D'Hoffryn (pretend interview) | Feature about set designs, Buffy best episodes poll, Comic: "The Blood of Carthage VIII" | "Earthly Possessions" |
| #24 | Aug 2001 | Joss Whedon (Q&A), Emma Caulfield, Tim Minear, Phantom Dennis (pretend interview), Tom Sniegoski (about Soul Trade) | Episode Spotlight: "Prophecy Girl", Comic: "The Blood of Carthage IX" | Unseen I, Soul Trade |
| #25 | Sep 2001 | Doug Petrie, Michelle Trachtenberg, Amber Benson | 'Saved by the Edit (feature on editing the show), Comic: "The Blood of Carthage X" | "Unseen II" |
| #26 | Oct 2001 | Mere Smith, David Boreanaz, Andy Hallett, Christian Kane | Episode Spotlight: "Becoming II", Film noir article, Comic: "Heart of the Slayer I" | - |
| #27 | Nov 2001 | Rudolph Martin (played 'Dracula'), Clare Kramer, Brendon Wayne Ka Tang, Juliet Landau | Set report: Dracula's place, Comic: "Heart of the Slayer II" | "Bruja", "Food Chain", "Lost Slayer I: Prophecies" |
| #28 | Dec 2001 | Nicholas Brendon, Anthony Stewart Head, David Fury | Getting onto the show feature, make-up feature, Comic: "Heart of the Slayer III" | "Lost Slayer II: Dark Times" |
| #29 | Jan 2001 | Shawn Ryan, James Marsters | Monster Mash, Demon on Wheels (feature on Angel's car), Episode Spotlight: "Passion", Comic: "Heart of the Slayer IV" | "Lost Slayer III: King of the Dead", "Unseen III" |
| #30 | Feb 2001 | Joss Whedon, Rebecca Rand Kirshner, Anthony Stewart Head, Yvonne Navarro | Episode Spotlight: "Lovers Walk", Comic: "Cemetery of Lost Love I" | "Lost Slayer IV: Original Sins", "Tales of the Slayer", "Autumnal" |
| #31 | Mar 2002 | Steven S. DeKnight, Amy Acker | 'Getting Down to What's Important'(Open letter from Marti Noxon about story telling in the post-911 world), "Smashed" set report, Love lines (a look at romance in the Buffyverse), Comic: "Cemetery of Lost Love II" | "Tales of the Slayers" |
| #32 | Apr 2002 | Amber Benson, Julie Benz, Marti Noxon | Comic: "Out of the Woodwork I" | "The Summoned", "Past Lives" |
| #33 | May 2002 | Marti Noxon, Tim Minear | Feature about stunts, Episode Spotlight: "Something Blue", Comic: "Out of the Woodwork II" | "Haunted" |
| #34 | June 2002 | David Boreanaz, Mercedes McNab, Christopher Golden | Comic: "Out of the Woodwork III" | "Tempted Champions", "Music for Elevators" (album by Anthony Stewart Head) |
| #35 | Summer 2002 | J. August Richards, David Fury, Rebecca Rand Kirshner | Comic: "Out of the Woodwork IV" | (None) |
| #36 | Jul 2002 | David Greenwalt, Danny Strong, Adam Busch, Tom Lenk | 'How to Cut It as a Vampire Slayer', Episode Spotlight: "Bewitched, Bothered and Bewildered", Comic: "Out of the Woodwork V" | "Strange Bedfellows", "Out of the Woodwork", "Sweet Sixteen" |
| #37 | Aug 2002 | Michelle Trachtenberg | Feature on Angel locations, Episode Spotlight: "The Body", Comic: "Out of the Woodwork VI" | "Oz", "Into the Wild", "Creatures of Habit", "Image" |
| #38 | Sep 2002 | James Marsters, Stephanie Romanov, Doug Petrie | 'Telling Tales' (feature about how to write a Buffy episode), Episode Spotlight: "School Hard", Comic: "Out of the Woodwork VII" | "Crossings (Buffy novel)" |
| #39 | Oct 2002 | Amber Benson | 'Pop Idols' (feature about music in Buffyverse), "Once More with Feeling, Episode Spotlight: "", Comic: "Out of the Woodwork VIII" | "Stranger to the Sun", "False Memories", "Long Night's Journey" |
| #40 | Nov 2002 | Anthony Stewart Head | Top ten scariest episodes, Giles' best moments, Panel on Buffy Season 6 (featuring views from Buffy writers and actors), Episode Spotlight: "Fool for Love", Comic: "Death of Buffy I" | "Wisdom of War", "Vengeance", "Ugly Little Monsters" |
| Yearbook | Winter 2002/3 | Joss Whedon, David Boreanaz, Alyson Hannigan, Nicholas Brendon, Alexis Denisof, James Marsters, Michelle Trachtenberg, Robin Sachs | Sarah Michelle Gellar profile, 'Welcome to the Hellmouth' (Classic moments), Buffy episode guide (Seasons 1-6), Angel episode guide (Seasons 1-3) | None |
| #41 | Dec 2002 | J. August Richards, Amy Acker, Adam Busch | 'Casualties of War (feature paying tribute to deceased characters), Episode Spotlight: "Doppelgangland", Comic: "Death of Buffy II" | "Little Things", "These Our Actors", "Haunted" |
| #42 | Jan 2003 | Joss Whedon, Mark Lutz | 'Heroes and Villains, Behind the Scenes on Buffy the Vampire Slayer (Xbox), Episode Spotlight: "New Moon Rising", Comic: "Death of Buffy III" | - |
| #43 | Feb 2003 | Julie Benz, Tim Minear | 'Coolest Kick-ass Moments' Episode Spotlight: "Surprise"/"Innocence", Comic: "Death of Buffy IV" | "The Longest Night" |
| #44 | Mar 2003 | Emma Caulfield, Elizabeth Anne Allen.. | Set report: "Selfless", "Make-up Secrets" (feature about the creation of the monsters), Comic: "Death of Buffy V".. | "The Longest Night" and Cordelia Collection Vol. 1 (novilisations of some key Cordelia Buffy episodes) |
| #45 | Apr 2003 | Nicholas Brendon, Jane Espenson, Jason Carter (actor who portrayed Repo-man in "Double or Nothing") | Episode Spotlight: "The Replacement", Comic: "Death of Buffy VI" | "Tales of the Slayer: Vol. 2", "Death of Buffy", "Lost Slayer Omnibus" |
| #46 | May 2003 | Amber Benson, Alexis Denisof, Marti Noxon | Episode Spotlight: "Earshot", Comic: "Note from the Underground I" | "Impressions" |
| #47 | Jun 2003 | Drew Greenberg, Emma Caulfield | Slayer Mythology guide, Episode Spotlight: "Bad Girls", Comic: "Note from the Underground II" | "Sanctuary", "Monster Island" |
| #48 | Jul 2003 | James Marsters, Marti Noxon | Comic: "Note from the Underground III" | "Willow & Tara" |
| #49 | Summer 2003 | Amy Acker | Set report: "Lies My Parents Told Me", Episode Spotlight: "Buffy vs. Dracula", Comic: "Note from the Underground IV" | "Blood and Fog" |
| #50 | Aug 2003 | Joss Whedon | Buffy Wrap Party, Top 10 merchadise, Comic: "Note from the Underground V" | "Viva Las Buffy" |
| #51 | Sep 2003 | Tom Lenk | Make-up feature, Episode Spotlight: "Chosen", Comic: "Note from the Underground VI" | "Seven Crows", "Chaos Bleeds comic", "Chaos Bleeds" |
| #52 | Oct 2003 | Anthony Stewart Head, Camden Toy (appeared as numerous demons) | Costume design feature, Comic: "Note from the Underground VII" | "Chaos Bleeds novel", "Wrath of the Darkhul King" |
| #53 | Nov 2003 | Alyson Hannigan | Article about Willow, 'Final episode journal' (report from insider on "Chosen"), Episode Spotlight: "Two to Go"/"Grave", Comic: "Note from the Underground VIII" | "Chaos Bleeds" |
| #54 | Dec 2003 | Marti Noxon, Robin Sachs | Baddest villains, Comic: "Reunion I" | "Radio Sunnydale", "Mortal Fear" |
| Year | Winter 2003 | Joss Whedon, Alyson Hannigan, Nicholas Brendon, James Marsters, Michelle Trachtenberg, Amber Benson | Buffy episode checklist (Seasons 1-7), A Slayer's Life (Buffy profile), How to Cut it as a Vampire Slayer, Fall Guys (stunts article), Growing Pains (article about the Scobbies emotional turmoil), Buffy Writers' Memories (mini interviews with Noxon, Petire, Espenson Kirshner, Fury), Once More With Feeling article, Willow the Witch, Buffy Set report: "Selfless", Writer's revelations Episode spotlights: Prophecy Girl, Fool for Love, Bewitched, Bothered and Bewildered, Doppelgängland, New Moon Rising, The Gift, A New Man | None |
| #55 | Jan 2004 | Eliza Dushku, D.B. Woodside | Behind scenes of CD (Radio Sunnydale), Article about Faith, Episode Spotlight: "Dirty Girls", Comic: "Reunion II" | "Cursed", "Fearless" |
| #56 | Feb 2004 | Iyari Limon, Nathan Fillion ('Caleb') | Episode Guide (Buffy Season 7), Episode Spotlight: "Superstar" | "Play With Fire" |
| #57 | Mar 2004 | Joss Whedon, Juliet Landau, Amber Benson, Bianca Lawson | Top 10 snogs, 'Love is in the Air', Article about Spike, Episode Spotlight: "The Prom" | Round-up of books and novels released in previous 12 months. |
| #58 | Apr 2004 | James Marsters, Clare Kramer, April Weeden-Washington ('Nikki Wood'), Johnathan Woodward ('Holden Webster') | Villain analysis | "Tales of the Slayer: Vol. 3", "Tales of the Vampires #1" |
| #59 | May 2004 | Jane Espenson, Nicholas Brendon, Kristine Sutherland, Rudolph Martin (played 'Dracula') | Article about Anya, Buffy Finales | "Tales of the Vampires #2" |
| #60 | Spring 2004 | Emma Caulfield, Kali Rocha, Robia La Morte | Article about Willow, 'Buffy Comedy' | "Tales of the Vampires #1" |
| #61 | June 2004 | Marti Noxon, James Leary, Michelle Trachtenberg, Mark Metcalf | Unaired Buffy pilot, article about Dawn | "Tales of the Vampires #4", "Wicked Willow I: Darkening" |
| #62 | July 2004 | Anthony Stewart Head, Doug Petrie, George Hertzberg, Max Perlich ('Whistler'), Yvonne Navarro | Classic Scene: "The Gift", Top 50 moments | "Wicked Willow II: Shattered Twilight" |
| #63 | Aug 2004 | Drew Greenberg, Eliza Dushku, Seth Green, Robert Duncan (composer), Julia Lee ('Anne Steele') | Classic Scene: "New Moon Rising", Convention report ("Fusion"), | "Tales of the Vampires #4", "A Stake to the Heart" |
| #64 | Sep 2004 | Nathan Fillion ('Caleb'), James Marsters, Adam Busch, | Article about Buffy Summers, 'Director's Cut' (feature about Buffy directors) | "Heat" |
| #65 | Oct 2004 | Nicholas Brendon, Rebecca Rand Kirshner, Tom Lenk, Elizabeth Anne Allen, Paige Moss ('Veruca') | 'Unlikely Romances | "Wicked Willow III: Broken Sunrise" |
| #66 | Nov 2004 | James Marsters, Juliet Landau, Doug Jones (lead 'Gentleman' from "Hush"), Seth Green | Monster make-up, Classic monsters, Episode Spotlight: "Halloween" | (None) |
| #67 | Dec 2004 | Sarah Michelle Gellar, Sarah Hagan | Article about Faith, 'The Watchers', Episode Spotlight: "Consequences" | (None) |
| #68 | Jan 2005 | Emma Caulfield, Charlie Weber ('Ben'), Ken Lerner & Armin Shimerman & D.B. Woodside (Principles of Sunnydale High; Flutie, Snyder and Wood) | Christmas feature | (None) |
| #69 | Feb 2005 | Amber Benson, Andy Umberger (D'Hoffryn) | Convention report, Top 10 teasers, Nerf Herder article | - |
| #70 | Mar 2005 | Marc Blucas, Kelly Donovan (Nicholas Brendon's twin brother), Joel Gray ('Doc'), Jeff Kober ('Kralick'/'Rack') | Buffyverse Love Triangles, Buffy Animated article, Episode Spotlight: "Into the Woods", Michelle Branch article, | "Tales of the Vampires" |
| #71 | Apr 2005 | David Boreanaz, James Marsters, Jane Espenson, Robert Joseph Levy, Nancy Holder, Larry Bagby ('Larry Blaisdell') | Sarah McLachlan article, Buffy trivia revealed | (None) |
| #72 | Spring 2005 | Drew Goddard, Danny Strong, Adam Busch, Tom Lenk, Phina Oruche ('Olivia') | Top of the Pops (best songs), Ultimate Buffy quiz, Four Star Mary article | (None) |
| #73 | May 2005 | Alyson Hannigan, Dagney Kerr ('Kathy'), Marti Noxon | Top 10 charms, Guide to Sunnydale, Episode Spotlight: "Smashed", K's Choice article | "The Suicide King" |
| #74 | Jun 2005 | Anthony Stewart Head, Tom Lenk, Leonard Roberts ('Forrest') | Article on censorship of the show, 'Scooby-Who' (personality test), The Breeders article | (None) |
| #75 | Jul 2005 | Alexis Denisof, Kevin Weisman ('Dreg'), Musetta Vanda ('Natalie French') | Clothes feature, 'Living Doll' (action figure article), Bif Naked article, Episode Spotlight: "Go Fish" | (None) |