Confirmation and overclaiming of aerial victories during World War II

In aerial warfare, the term overclaiming describes a combatant (or group) that claims the destruction of more enemy aircraft than actually achieved. The net effect is that the actual losses and claimed victories are unequal.

Honest overclaiming typically occurs in one of two ways: (1) more than one fighter pilot attacks the same target in quick succession and when they see it destroyed each claims a victory in good faith, and (2) a target is hit and appears to go down, but the pilot is able to land the plane. In some instances of combat over friendly territory a damaged aircraft may have been claimed as an aerial victory by its opponent while the aircraft was later salvaged and restored to an operational status. In this situation the loss may not appear in the records while the claim remains confirmed.^[1]

Most discussion of overclaiming centers on air combat during World War II, because of the significant amount of air combat relative to conflicts before or since.

German methodology for confirming aerial victories

The Luftwaffe's aerial victory confirmation procedure was based on directive 55270/41 named "Confirmation of aerial victories, destructions and sinking of ships" (German: Anerkennung von Abschüssen, Zerstörungen und Schiffsvernichtung) and was issued by the Oberbefehlshaber der Luftwaffe. This directive was first issued in 1939 and was updated several times during World War II.^[2] In theory, this approval process for the confirmation of aerial victories was very stringent.^[3]

• Without a witness, a Luftwaffe fighter pilot had no chance to have his victory claim confirmed. Such a claim, even if filed, would not pass beyond group level.^[3]
• The final destruction or explosion of an enemy aircraft in the air, or bail-out of the pilot, had to be observed either on gun-camera film or by at least one other human witness. The witness could be the German pilot's wingman, another in the squadron, or an observer on the ground.^[3]

In practice, however, even in the early stages of the war, overclaiming by the Luftwaffe occurred. As the war entered its final, chaotic phase in 1945, many German aces' claims from late 1944 onward were left unvalidated due to the breakdown in administration within the Luftwaffe,^[4] and at times bore little relationship to reality.

In the 1990s, the German archives made available microfilm rolls of wartime records, not seen since January 1945, available to the public.^[5] These showed that while in theory the Luftwaffe did not accept a kill without a witness, which was considered only a probable, in practice some units habitually submitted unwitnessed claims and these sometimes made it through the verification process, particularly if they were made by pilots with already established records.^[5] In theory the Luftwaffe did not accept shared claims, but it happened. In theory each separate claim should have referred to a particular aircraft, but in practice some victories were awarded to other pilots who had claimed the destruction of the same aircraft.^[5] In 1943 the daily OKW communiques (Wehrmachtbericht) of this period habitually overstated American bomber losses by a factor of two or more. Defenders of German fighter pilots have always maintained that these were reduced during the confirmation process. But the microfilms prove this not to be the case.^[5] Some 80 - 90 percent of the claims submitted were confirmed or found to be "in order" for confirmation up to the time the system broke down altogether in 1945.^[5]

Examples of overclaiming

Date	Unit/Air Force	Notes
10 July 1940	Luftwaffe	III./ZG 76 claimed 12 Hawker Hurricanes. The RAF lost just one Hurricane that day, in a collision with a Dornier Do 17[6]
13 July 1940	Royal Air Force	No. 56 Squadron RAF claimed seven Ju 87s from Sturzkampfgeschwader 1 destroyed over Portland. StG 1 recorded the loss of only two Ju 87s shot down.[7]
12 August 1940	Luftwaffe	The Germans claimed 22 British aircraft destroyed, actual British losses were 3. In one engagement Bf 109s from JG 2 claimed six RAF fighters, while bombers from KG 54 claimed 14. Only one fighter was shot down and six damaged.[8]
18 August 1940	Luftwaffe	The Germans claimed 147 British aircraft destroyed, actual recorded British losses were 68.[9]
15 September 1940	Royal Air Force	On the day termed as "the Battle of Britain Day", the RAF claimed 185 German aircraft shot down. German recorded losses were 60.[9]
1940	Luftwaffe	Overall, German claims for British fighters destroyed during the Battle of Britain was 3,058 against recorded losses of 915 - 334% overclaiming, compared with RAF overclaiming of about 155%.[10] This, coupled with underestimation of British production, had severe intelligence repercussions.[11]
June 1941 - December 1941	Soviet Air Force	The Soviet Air Forces of the South Western Front claimed 85 Bf 109s. A further 53 were claimed by anti-aircraft units in October and another 54 in November. Only 31 Bf 109s were recorded as lost by the Luftwaffe in this period. VVS claims on the Eastern Front amount to 3,879, anti-aircraft units claimed 752, and a further 3,257 were claimed destroyed on the ground.[12] The Luftwaffe reported the loss of 3,827 aircraft to all causes on the Eastern Front in 1941. The VVS overclaiming more than 100%.[13]
June 1941 - December 1941	Royal Air Force	During this period RAF Fighter Command launched a sustained 'fighter offensive' over Northern Europe, designed to tie down Luftwaffe fighter units, and hence indirectly take pressure off the Eastern Front, and to hopefully draw those Luftwaffe units encountered into a war of attrition. Fighting exclusively over enemy territory, and thus usually unable to accurately verify their pilot's combat reports, Fighter Command claimed 711 Luftwaffe fighters shot down, while losing 411 of its own fighters. The loss to JG 2 and JG 26, the principal opponents, were reportedly just 103 fighters.[14]
6 April 1942	Soviet Air Force	A Red Air Force unit claimed seven Finnish Brewsters shot down in a single action over Tiiksjärvi-Rukajärvi area and four destroyed on the ground. Not a single Finnish aircraft was confirmed by Finnish records. Soviet pilot V. I. Solomatin claimed to have shot down five Brewster fighters and was later honoured with Hero of the Soviet Union.[15][16]
8 June 1942	Soviet Air Force	6 GIAP/VVS ChF claimed nine German aircraft shot down in a single action. Not a single German aircraft of any type was recorded as lost.[17]
4 June 1942	Japanese Imperial Navy	In the attack on Midway Island Japanese Zero pilots claimed more than 40 American fighters shot down and several probably destroyed. The U.S. Marine Corps squadron, VMF-221, had sent up 25 Brewster Buffalos and Grumman F4F Wildcats, losing 15.[18]
20 July 1942 - 10 August 1942	Luftwaffe	During this period, Fliegerkorps VIII claimed to have shot down 606 Soviet aircraft while destroying another 107 on the ground. Actual losses of 8 VA were 230 aircraft - 114 fighters, 70 Shturmoviks, 29 Pe-2s, four Su-2s and 13 night bombers.[19]
26 July 1942	434 IAP and 512 IAP	These units claimed 18 and 12 kills against Macchi C.200s of the Italian 21 Gruppo Autonomo C.T. during Fall Blau. The Italian unit lost three Macchis.[20]
15 September 1942	Luftwaffe Desert Air Force	Jagdgeschwader 27 claimed 19-20 aerial victories while Royal Australian Air Force and RAF records report the loss of five aircraft (a further Allied fighter was lost to friendly ground fire).[21] The Allies claimed two destroyed, two probables and three damaged in the same engagement.[22] The Germans lost Lt. Hoffmann of I. Gruppe and Uffz. Prien to a midair collision, killing Prien. No further losses had been reported.[23]
15 December 1942	IJAAF	Burma: 50th Sentai pilots submitted claims for six Hawker Hurricanes shot down over Chittagong. Not one Hurricane was even damaged.[24]
25 December 1942	United States Army Air Forces	Burma: 16th Fighter Squadron, 23rd Fighter Group pilots submitted claims for ten enemy aircraft shot down, five probable, and one damaged. The 64th Sentai lost one Ki-43 and three Ki-48s from 8th Sentai were damaged.[25]
2 March 1943	No. 54 Squadron RAF & No. 457 Squadron RAAF; 202nd Kōkūtai, Imperial Japanese Navy Air Service	Each side claimed three enemy aircraft destroyed. Neither side suffered any losses.[26]
17 April 1943	United States Army Air Forces	During a mission against the Focke Wulf plant near Bremen, the 91st and 306th Bomb Groups claimed 63 German fighters destroyed, plus 15 probable and 17 damaged. Only two were confirmed destroyed, with nine damaged.[27]
5 July 1943 - 8 July 1943	Soviet Air Force: 2.VA, and 16.VA	During the Battle of Kursk, the Soviet unit 2.VA claimed 487 aircraft from Fliegerkorps VIII shot down. German records show the Luftwaffe lost only 41. According to the Generalquartiemeister der Luftwaffe 58 were lost to all causes. The 16 VA unit claimed 391 against Luftflotte 6. Actual losses were 39. The Soviets claimed a total of 878 German aircraft destroyed. Losses were 97.[28]
17 August 1943	United States Army Air Forces, Luftwaffe	After the Schweinfurt-Regensburg mission Gunners on the bombers claimed 288 fighters shot down. Spitfire pilots claimed another 7 German fighters shot down and P-47 pilots claimed 14.[29] Luftwaffe records show 40 aircraft lost. The Luftwaffe claimed 101 bombers and five fighters shot down, however only 60 B-17s and no fighters were reported lost.[30]
14 October 1943	United States Army Air Forces, Luftwaffe	After the Second Raid on Schweinfurt Gunners aboard the B-17 bombers claimed to have shot down 138 German fighters.[31] German records state only 38 were lost + 20 damaged.[32] German fighters claimed 121 bombers, the actual figure was 60.[33]
6 January 1944	United States Army Air Forces	On this date bomber crews claimed 210 German fighters and their escorts claiming 31, for a total of 241 claims. German losses amounted to 39 in total.[34]
3 March 1944	United States Army Air Forces, Luftwaffe	On a bombing mission to Berlin the Eighth Air Force dispatched the 1st and 2nd Air Divisions, comprising 95th, 100th and 390th Bomb Groups. The B-17 gunners claimed 97 German fighters on this mission. American fighters claimed a further 82 destroyed. German losses amounted to 66. German claims amounted to 108 bombers and 20 fighters. USAAF losses were 69 bombers and 11 fighters.[35]
14 June 1944	United States Army Air Forces	During the Oil Campaign of World War II fifteen P-38 Lightning escorts from 49th Squadron, 14 FG was engaged by 32 Bf 109G-6s from the 101. Honi Légvédelmi Vadászrepülő Osztály, Royal Hungarian Air Force over central Hungary. American fighter pilots reported 13 Bf 109s destroyed, 1 probable destroyed and 5 damaged. In the preliminary report the Hungarian fighter pilots filed claims for twelve probably destroyed P-38s, and ultimately filed claims for seven; five were eventually claimed confirmed. The actual losses of the day: five P-38s were shot down, with pilots MIA, two were severely damaged while several aircraft were lightly damaged; one Bf 109G was destroyed in air combat (pilot KIA), one Bf 109G destroyed during forced landing as a result of air combat (pilot safe); one Bf 109G damaged during a landing accident.[36]
18 June 1944	Luftwaffe	The Luftwaffe claimed 39 B-24s and five P-51s shot down over Schleswig-Holstein. Just 13 B-24s and two P-51s were lost.[37]
25 July 1944	31st Fighter Group vs Luftwaffe	31st FG HQ/307th Fighter Squadron/308th Fighter Squadron/309th Fighter Squadron vs Hans Rudel's SG.2 and Hungarian Stukas of 102/2. Dive Squadron and I./Stg 77. USAF Claims of 26 [38] to 28 Enemy aircraft.[39] German/Hungarian losses were 8[40]
1944–1945	Luftwaffe	Oberleutnant Kurt Welter, claimed perhaps 25 Mosquitoes shot down by night and two further Mosquitoes by day while flying the Me 262, adding to his previous seven Mosquito kills in "hot-rodded" Bf 109G-6/AS or Fw 190 A-8 fighters. As far as can be ascertained, just three of his Me 262 claims over Mosquitoes coincide with RAF records.[41]
1 January 1945	Luftwaffe	On this date German pilots overclaimed by between 4 and 3:1 .[42] During Operation Bodenplatte the Luftwaffe claimed 55 destroyed and 11 probably destroyed in air-to-air combat (according to document: Fernschreiben II.JakoIc Nr.140/44 geh.vom 3.1.1945). Other German sources (according to document: Luftwaffenführungsstab Ic, Fremde Luftwaffen West, Nr. 1160/45 g.Kdos.vom 25.2.1945), quote 65 claims and 12 probables. Just 31 Allied aircraft were hit. 15 were shot down in aerial combat, two were destroyed whilst on take-off and seven were damaged by enemy action.[43][44]
24 March 1945	U.S. Army Air Force	The 332nd Fighter Group was awarded a Distinguished Unit Citation (DUC) for a mission flown on 24 March 1945, escorting B-17s to bomb the Daimler-Benz tank factory at Berlin, Germany. The American pilots were credited with destroying three Me-262 jets of the Luftwaffe's all-jet Jagdgeschwader 7, despite the American unit initially claiming 11 Me 262s.[45] Upon examination of JG 7 records, just four Me 262s were lost and all of their pilots survived.[45] The bombers also made substantial claims, making it impossible to tell which units were responsible for those individual four kills.[46]

References

Citations

1. Spick 1996, p. 217.
2. Lorant & Goyat 2005, p. vi.
3. Brown 2000, pp. 281–282.
4. 'Combat Kill'; Morgan & Seibel, 1997.
5. Caldwell & Muller 2007, p. 96."
6. Weal 1999. p. 45.
7. Ward 2004, p. 97.
8. Bungay 2000, p. 208.
9. Military History Journal - Vol 5 No 1 Myths of the Battle of Britain by Major D. P. Tidy
10. Bickers p. 246
11. Galland p. 103
12. Bergstrom 2007, p. 117.
13. Bergstrom 2007, p. 118.(Barbarossa title)
14. Caldwell, Don. The JG 26 War Diary, Volume 1 (Grub Street, 1996) p. 199.
15. Hannu Valtonen: Luftwaffen pohjoinen sivusta : Saksan ilmavoimat Suomessa ja Pohjois-Norjassa 1941-1944. Hannu Valtonen: The north flank of Luftwaffe
16. Geust C-F.: Geust C-F, 4/1997 page 16, airbattle in Tiiksjärvi 6th of April 1942
17. Bergstrom 2007, p. 47.(Stalingrad title)
18. Tillman 1990, p. 53
19. Bergstrom 2007, p. 62.(Stalingrad title)
20. Bergstrom 2007, p. 58.(Stalingrad title)
21. Christopher Shores and Hans Ring (Fighters over the Desert, 1969), cited by Brown 2000, p. 258.
22. Brown , pp. 166–167.
23. Prien, Rodeike and Stemmer 1998, p. 175.
24. Shores, 2005 p.40
25. Shores 2005, p. 45.
26. Thomas 2008, p. 71.
27. Weal 2006, p. 22-23.
28. Bergstrom 2007, p. 120. (Kursk title)
29. Hess 1994, p. 60.
30. Caldwell and Muller 2007, p. 114.
31. url =http://www.historynet.com/world-war-ii-eighth-air-force-raid-on-schweinfurt.htm
32. Caldwell and Muller 2007, p. 136.
33. Caldwell 2007, p. 137.
34. Hess 1994, p. 71.
35. Hess 1994, p. 84.
36. Pataky-Rozsos-Sárhidai, 1988. pp. 41-53.
37. Caldwell & Muller 2007, p. 211.
38. US Air Forces Forum
39. 12 oclock High forum
40. 12 oclock High Forum
41. Hinchcliffe 1996
42. Manrho and Pütz 2004, p. 272-73.
43. Manrho and Pütz 2004, p. 287.
44. Manrho and Pütz 2004, p. 290.
45. Caldwell and Muller 2007, p. 276.
46. "Air Force Historical Study 82." AFHRA Maxwell AFB, 1969. Retrieved: February 16, 2007.

Bibliography

• Bergström, Christer (2007). Barbarossa - The Air Battle: July–December 1941. London: Chervron/Ian Allan. ISBN 978-1-85780-270-2.
• Bergstrom, Christer (2007). Stalingrad - The Air Battle: November 1942 - February 1943. London: Chervron/Ian Allan. ISBN 978-1-85780-276-4 .
• Bergström, Christer (2007). Kursk - The Air Battle: July 1943. London: Chervron/Ian Allan. ISBN 978-1-903223-88-8.
• Bickers, Richard Towsend (1999). The Battle of Britain. London, Salamander Books. ISNBN 1-84065-081-8
• Brown, Russell (2000). Desert Warriors: Australian P-40 Pilots at War in the Middle East and North Africa, 1941-1943. Maryborough, Queensland, Australia: Banner Books. ISBN 1-875593-22-5.
• Caldwell, Donald & Muller, Richard (2007). The Luftwaffe over Germany: Defense of the Reich. London: Greenhill Books. ISBN 978-1-85367-712-0
• Galland, Adolf (1953). Die Ersten und dir Letzen. Germany, Franz Schneekluth (Page number from Readers Book Club Edition (1956)
• Hess, William N. (1994). B-17 Flying Fortress: Combat and Development History. St. Paul, Minnesota: Motorbook International. ISBN 0-87938-881-1
• Hinchcliffe, Peter. The Other Battle: Luftwaffe Night Aces vs Bomber Command. London: Zenith Press, 1996. ISBN 0-7603-0265-0.
• Lorant, Jean Yves; Goyat, Richard (2005). Jagdgeschwader 300 "Wilde Sau" — Volume One: June 1943 – September 1944. Hamilton, Montana: Eagle Edition. ISBN 978-0-9761034-0-0.
• Manrho, John, Putz, Ron. Bodenplatte: The Luftwaffe's Last Hope–The Attack on Allied Airfields, New Year's Day 1945. Ottringham, United Kingdom: Hikoki Publications, 2004. ISBN 1-902109-40-6
• Prien, Jochen & Rodeike, Peter & Stemmer, Gerhard (1998). Messerschmidt Bf 109 im Einsatz bei Stab und I./Jagdgeschwader 27 1939 - 1945. struve-druck, Eutin. ISBN 3-923457-46-4
• Iván, Pataki - László, Rozsos - Gyula, Sárhidai: Légi háború Magyarország felett. Második kötet. Budapest: Zrínyi Kiadó, 1988. ISBN 963-327-163-0
• Spick, Mike (1996). Luftwaffe Fighter Aces. New York: Ivy Books. ISBN 0-8041-1696-2.
• Shores, Christopher (2005) Air War for Burma. London: Grub Street ISBN 1-904010-95-4.
• Thomas, Andrew. Griffon Spitfire Aces. London: Oxford. ISBN 978-1-84603-298-1
• Tillman, Barrett. Wildcat: The F4F in WW II. Annapolis: Naval Institute Press (1990). ISBN 0-87021-789-5
• Ward, John. (2004). Hitler's Stuka Squadrons: The Ju 87 at war, 1936 - 1945. Eagles of War. London. ISBN 1-86227-246-8
• Weal, John (2006). Bf 109 Defence of the Reich Aces. Oxford: Osprey. ISBN 1-84176-879-0
• Weal, John. Messerschmitt Bf 110 Zerstörer Aces World War Two. London: Osprey, 1999. ISBN 1-85532-753-8.