Criticism of eBay

eBay has experienced controversy – including cases of fraud – of its policy requiring sellers to use PayPal, and concerns over forgeries and intellectual property violations in auction items.

Fraud

eBay Customer Support claims that its data indicate that less than .1% of all transactions result in a confirmed case of fraud.[1] One mechanism eBay claims combats fraud is its feedback system. When a user feels that a seller or buyer has been dishonest, a dispute can be filed with eBay. An eBay seller may be suspended if there are too many complaints made against them. eBay does not allow sellers to give negative feedback to buyers.

Until June 2008,[2] eBay allowed Mystery Box and Mystery Envelope auctions. However, these are almost all fraudulent auctions since the seller can manipulate the box contents to make sure it is never a good deal for the buyer.[3] Mystery Envelope auctions offer cash prizes of an undisclosed amount to auction winners. The auction winner usually receives from 10% to 30% of the money he paid for the auction back in 'winnings'.[4]

Scammers like to target new members to take advantage of their unfamiliarity with how eBay or PayPal works. New members can be easily tricked into thinking there is a special Web site they should make payments through (which is in fact a fake site set up by a scammer) or they may be tricked more easily into using a fake escrow company.

Many complaints have been made about eBay's system of dealing with fraud, leading to its being featured on the British consumer rights television program Watchdog. It is also regularly featured in The Daily Mirror's Consumer Awareness page. The complaints are generally that eBay fails to respond when a claim is made.

Fraud committed by Ebay includes:

Frauds that can be committed by sellers include:

Frauds committed by buyers include:

Fraud is prevented by:

Shill bidding

Shill bidding is undisclosed vendor bidding that is used to artificially inflate the price of a certain item. It is usually carried out with "shill" account(s), by either the seller under an alternate account or another person in collusion with the seller. Shill bidding is nominally prohibited by eBay.[5] However, eBay has been criticized for not doing enough to combat the problem.[6][7] Still, there are techniques, like sniping, which let buyers avoid shill bidders.[8]

Forgeries

It is estimated that about a quarter of all ancient coins and about two-thirds of all antiquities sold on eBay are modern forgeries.[9] In March 2008, Professional Coin Grading Service issued an alert noting counterfeit PCGS slabs and various United States and Chinese coins originating from the People's Republic of China being sold on eBay.[10]

In court papers introduced by attorney for jeweler Tiffany & Co., it was claimed that researchers for Tiffany had determined that over 70% of the Tiffany silver jewelry offered for sale on eBay was fake.[11] Tiffany & Co. filed a lawsuit against eBay in 2004 which claimed that eBay profited from the sales of counterfeit Tiffany items that infringed on its trademark. On July 14, 2008, a Federal District Court judge ruled that eBay does not have a legal responsibility to monitor users selling counterfeit items.[12] In 2010, the Second Circuit affirmed this decision (see Tiffany v. eBay).

Feedback system

eBay does allow buyers to rate any seller using a feedback system that allows both positive and negative comments; however, sellers are prohibited from leaving anything other than positive feedback for buyers. Before eBay's January 29, 2008, policy-change announcement, at the end of every transaction, both the buyer and seller had the option of rating each other. Both parties had the ability to rate each other and the experience as a "positive", "negative", or "neutral" rating and leave a comment no longer than 80 characters. As of CEO's John Donahoe's announcement however, the option for sellers to leave anything other than positive feedback to buyers (in response to an outcry from buyers who received negative feedback in retaliation for leaving the seller a negative) was removed.[13][14][15]

According to critics, weaknesses of the feedback system include:[16][17]

Intellectual property in auctions

Holders of intellectual property rights, have claimed that eBay profits from the infringement of intellectual property rights. The company responded by creating the Verified Rights Owner (VeRO) program, which provides to rights holders auction takedowns and private information on eBay users on demand.

eBay requires sellers to use PayPal

In some countries, eBay requires sellers to offer the PayPal payment service, which was formerly owned by eBay's parent company. eBay stated that this mandate was due to the safety and security of the service.[31] However, critics contended that the requirement was meant to leverage their former co-ownership, as eBay would receive service fees, on top of transaction fees via PayPal for product and shipping payments.[32]

Although, since July 2015, PayPal and eBay have operated as separate companies, a five-year agreement between the two companies contractually requires that PayPal serve at least 80% of eBay transactions. In August 2015, eBay announced that it would ban the use of competing services Propay and Skrill effective September 27, 2015, citing low usage. However, critics argued that the change was meant to comply with eBay's requirement to maintain the integrity of the PayPal service.[33]

Australia

In April 2008 eBay announced an introduction of a 'PayPal only' policy in Australia.[34] The new policy would have meant that sellers will only be able to offer PayPal or cash payment on pick-up as payment methods. eBay claims that PayPal is the most secure method of payment.[35]

Under the Australian Trade Practices Act 1974, it is unlawful for a company to require the use of a third party's products or services in order for a person to deal with the company, known as Third Line Forcing.[36] eBay submitted a notification under the Act,[37] which provides automatic exemption from this provision unless the notification is subsequently revoked by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC).

As part of its assessment of the notification, the ACCC called for submissions from interested parties.[38] This attracted a record number of complaints from eBay members, banks, Google, and members of the business community and the Reserve Bank of Australia.[39] During this period, rival auction site OZtion experienced a record number of new members.[40]

The ACCC completed an initial draft proposal to revoke eBay's notification, stating that it believed consumers were in a better position to judge risk on individual transactions than eBay's management and has ruled the plan anti-competitive.[41] However, before a final decision could be announced on July 3, 2008, eBay announced that it had withdrawn the notification to the ACCC and shelved its "PayPal only" plans.[42][43]

United Kingdom

A similar policy requiring sellers to offer PayPal was also introduced in the United Kingdom, though in stages. The first stage, which was adopted on March 25, 2008, was aimed at sellers with feedback scores under 100 and in certain high risk categories. The requirement was extended to all sellers from June 3, 2008.[44][45]

Other eBay controversies

Other notable controversies involving eBay include:

Ebay Motors class action lawsuit

On July 27, 2010, the Court allowed the individual plaintiffs Yingling and Scott to represent all persons who paid so-called Final Value Fees in conjunction with a listing of an item within eBay, Inc.'s defined category of "Parts & Accessories" on the eBay Motors website, which listing was placed between April 21, 2005, and August 26, 2009. This ruling also allows the law firm of Figari & Davenport LLP to act as "Class Counsel" and to represent the Class Members as their attorneys. The Court's ruling does not mean that the Court views the claims in this Lawsuit as having merit or not. This Settlement applies to the same persons defined above; however, all listings made using eBay's Store Inventory Format are excluded from the Settlement. This group of persons is the "Settlement Class." eBay's records were used to send email or postal mail notice to all members of the Settlement Class.

References

  1. "eBay: Community: Chat: Rob Chestnut". Pages.ebay.com. 2002-08-08. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  2. "eBay Policy Updates". .ebay.com. 2008-05-19. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  3. Ford, Michael (2007). Scams And Scoundrels. Elite Minds Inc. ISBN 978-0-9774760-2-2.
  4. Ford, Michael (2007). "8". Scams And Scoundrels. Elite Minds Inc. ISBN 978-0-9774760-2-2.
  5. "Shill bidding policy". Pages.ebay.com. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  6. Metz, Cade (10 July 2009). "Net sleuth calls eBay on carpet over shill bidding". The Register. Retrieved 4 January 2014.
  7. "Shill Bidding on eBay: a Case Study". 22 December 2012. Retrieved 4 January 2014.
  8. Hannemyr, Gisle. "eBay School: The seller". DPanswers website. Retrieved 2013-06-27.
  9. "Counterfeit Coin Detection". Retrieved 2008-01-21.
  10. "Counterfeit pcgs holders". Professional Coin Grading Service. Retrieved 2008-04-13.
  11. "Technology". The New York Times. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  12. Stone, Brad (2008-07-14). "Court Clears eBay in Sale of Counterfeit Items". The New York Times. Retrieved 2008-07-14.
  13. "Buyer accountability". Pages.ebay.com. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  14. "BBC, 5-Feb-2008, eBay to ban negative seller views". BBC News. February 5, 2008. Retrieved January 2, 2010.
  15. David Steiner (2008-01-29). "Upcoming Changes to Feedback on eBay". Blog.auctionbytes.com. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  16. LaPlante, Alice (January 2, 2007). "eBay Feedback: Fatally Flawed?". Forbes.
  17. "Bias on eBay | SF Bay Guardian". Sfbg.com. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  18. "User Privacy Notice". Pages.ebay.com. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  19. "Contact 16: Embroidery software buyer under investigation". WNDU-TV. 2005-09-07.
  20. "AutoDesk bans eBay sales | News". Geek.com. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  21. "Design right threat fails to stop eBay sales". Out-law.com. 2006-11-14. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  22. "Business | Court fines eBay over fake goods". BBC News. 2008-06-30. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  23. "11% - Fortune". Legalpad.blogs.fortune.cnn.com. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  24. "L'actualité d'eBay: Article". Actualites.ebay.fr. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  25. "Tiffany sues eBay, says fake items sold on web site". USA Today. 2004-03-22.
  26. "Sure you bagged a bargain?". Courier Mail (News Limited). 2006-05-24. Archived from the original on June 29, 2006.
  27. "Transmission1 • View topic - Midland/Alan new product ban on eBay & Amazon". Transmission1.co.uk. Retrieved 2012-02-23.
  28. https://web.archive.org/20111102083525/http://midland-uk.com:80/become-a-midland-dealer.html. Archived from the original on November 2, 2011. Retrieved November 16, 2011. Missing or empty |title= (help)
  29. "Trade backlash at eBay's PayPal-only policy". Antiques Trade Gazette. 2008-06-30. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  30. "eBay: pro-choice, but only when it suits". Apcmag.com. 2008-07-01. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  31. "eBay Bans Sellers from Offering PayPal Rivals". eCommerce Bytes. Retrieved 31 August 2015.
  32. "PayPal mandatory, says eBay Australia". News Limited (Australian IT). 2008-04-10. Archived from the original on April 14, 2008. Retrieved 2008-04-23.
  33. "eBay boss: "not offering PayPal is like buying heroin" - APC". Apcmag.com. 2008-05-06. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  34. (PDF) https://web.archive.org/20080910033926/http://legislation.gov.au/ComLaw/Legislation/ActCompilation1.nsf/0/52F720BED6E14719CA2572BF0017EBCB/$file/TradePrac1974Vol1_WD02.pdf. Archived from the original (PDF) on September 10, 2008. Retrieved September 27, 2008. Missing or empty |title= (help)
  35. "eBay International AG - Notification - N93365". Accc.gov.au. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  36. "ACCC puts eBay's PayPal plans under scrutiny". April 17, 2008.
  37. "RBA wary of eBay's PayPal push - ABC News (Australian Broadcasting Corporation)". Abc.net.au. 2008-05-09. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  38. Darren Osborne (May 9, 2008). "eBay stands firm despite user discontent". Melbourne: Theage.com.au. Retrieved 2010-09-12.
  39. https://web.archive.org/20080723134737/http://www.gocebit.com.au/?q=news/accc-stymies-ebay-paypal-plan. Archived from the original on July 23, 2008. Retrieved September 27, 2008. Missing or empty |title= (help)
  40. "eBay backs down on PayPal changes - web - Technology". Smh.com.au. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  41. "The Sheet". Thesheet.com. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  42. https://web.archive.org/web/20080215143942/http://web.ebay.co.uk/businesshub/index.php?page=safe_payments. Archived from the original on February 15, 2008. Retrieved November 1, 2011. Missing or empty |title= (help)
  43. "ebay Comapany Information - Dover Online ™". Dover-online.com. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  44. "EBAY INC. ET AL. v. MERCEXCHANGE, L. L. C." (PDF). US Supreme Court. Retrieved 2006-06-17.
  45. "PayPal to pay $10 million to settle online gambling charge". USA Today. July 25, 2003. Retrieved April 30, 2010.
  46. "eBay picks up PayPal for $1.5 billion - CNET News". Archive.is. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  47. 1 2 "eBay Scams and Lawsuits". Consumeraffairs.com. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  48. Oates, John (24 April 2007). "eBay, PayPal face court action". The Register. Retrieved 6 January 2014.
  49. https://web.archive.org/20080321174157/http://www.itnews.com.au:80/News/59641,ebay-deceiving-millions-of-users.aspx. Archived from the original on March 21, 2008. Retrieved September 27, 2008. Missing or empty |title= (help)
  50. "eBay Lowers Insertion Fees, Raises Commission Fees". Auctionbytes.com. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  51. Hansell, Saul (January 29, 2008). "Sellers Give Negative Feedback on eBay Changes". The New York Times. Retrieved April 30, 2010.
  52. "Fees 2008 Overview". Pages.ebay.com. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  53. "EBay sues Craigslist ad website". BBC News. April 23, 2008. Retrieved April 30, 2010.
  54. "Craigslist strikes back at eBay". BBC. 2008-05-13. Retrieved 2008-05-13.
  55. Michelle Megna (2008-07-14). "Power Sellers Say Bye-Bye to eBay Over Buy.com Deal". ECommerce-Guide. Retrieved 2008-07-17.
  56. Palmer, Richard (2010-01-29). "Dad’s Army board game banned ‘for being racist’ | UK | News | Daily Express". Express.co.uk. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  57. "Selling items online, through classified advertisements and at car boot sales". Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs. Retrieved 4 January 2014.
  58. "HMRC guides UK eBay traders on income tax". The Register. 9 February 2007. Retrieved 4 January 2014.
  59. "PayPal Freezes Wikileaks Account". Wired.com. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  60. Template:Date=February 2015
  61. "Hackers take down website of bank that froze WikiLeaks funds". Rawstory.com. 2010-12-06. Retrieved 2015-02-26.
  62. "Carl Icahn Is Buying eBay Inc. Hand Over Fist. Should You?". fool.com. 2014-05-01. Retrieved 2015-07-02.
  63. "Fears for Irish jobs as eBay announces plans to cut 2,400 positions". thejournal.ie. 2014-05-01. Retrieved 2015-07-02.
  64. "Best Workplaces in Ireland". Greatplacetowork.ie. 2015-01-01. Retrieved 2015-07-02.
This article is issued from Wikipedia - version of the Sunday, April 24, 2016. The text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution/Share Alike but additional terms may apply for the media files.