Elbmarsch

Elbmarsch is a Samtgemeinde ("collective municipality") in the district of Harburg, in Lower Saxony, Germany. It is situated on the southern (left) bank of the river Elbe, approx. 30 km southeast of Hamburg, and 20 km north of Lüneburg. Its seat is in the village Marschacht. The name refers to the marshes (German: Marsch) along the Elbe.

The Samtgemeinde Elbmarsch consists of the following municipalities:

1. Drage
2. Marschacht
3. Tespe

Cancer cluster

Elbmarsch is the epicenter of a notable pediatric cancer cluster that persisted for over 15 years. Although a sparsely populated region a high rate of childhood leukemia was observed with an incidence in the region that is significantly higher compared to Germany as a whole. No unique hazards have been identified. The community is surrounded by two nuclear establishments. A possible accidental release of radionuclides in 1986 was hypothesized.^[1]

Ionizing radiation is another exposure conclusively linked with childhood leukemia.^[2] Survivors (within 1000 m) of Hiroshima and Nagasaki developed leukemia 20 times more frequently than in unexposed populations.^[3]

The Krümmel Nuclear Power Plant began operations near Elbmarsch, Germany in 1983. Like Fallon, Nevada, the nearby population is quite small, including approximately 9,000 children within 10 km of the plant. Over a one and a half year period, six cases of leukemia and one case of aplastic anemia were identified among children in this area, a 41.5 increase over national incidence rates. Four more cases were diagnosed during a subsequent two-year period. Public health officials began to suspect that high levels of airborne tritium “might be involved either directly or as an indicator for earlier releases of other short-lived radionuclides”.^[4]

The community surrounding the Savannah River nuclear facility in the U.S. was chosen for comparison with the “cluster” noted around the Kruemmel site. The tritium burden around the Savannah River site is significantly higher than the measured burden in Germany; however, the incidence of leukemia in South Carolina was not increased. Differences in population density, proximity to the power plant, and route of tritium exposure (inhalational versus oral via drinking water) may account for the lack of correlation between the two sites, or there may be alternative explanations for the increased incidence of hematopoietic malignancy between 1989 and 1991 in Elbmarsch.^[4]

Some of these alternative hypotheses have included electromagnetic fields, parental radiation exposure prior to conception, other carcinogens, and benzene exposure; however, none have been supported by the existing evidence. Intriguingly, a larger case-control study in Lower Saxony found a correlation between the “untrained immune system” (as judged as contact with other children, vaccinations, etc.) and leukemia risk, suggested that an immature immune system that has not been challenged is at greater risk for developing malignancy, possibly secondary to an undefined environment insult. ^[4]

References

1. Hoffmann, Wolfgang; Terschueren, Claudia; Richardson, David B. (2007). "Childhood Leukemia in the Vicinity of the Geesthacht Nuclear Establishments near Hamburg, Germany". Environmental Health Perspectives 115 (6): 947–952. doi:10.1289/ehp.9861. ISSN 0091-6765.
2. Linet, Martha (2005). "Etiology of Childhood Leukemia: Environment, Genes, Controversies, and Conundrums". Cancer Investigation 23 (1): 99–99. doi:10.1081/CNV-46398. ISSN 0735-7907.
3. Brain JD, Kavet R, McCormick DL, Poole C, Silverman LB, Smith TJ, Valberg PA, Van Etten RA, Weaver JC. Childhood leukemia: Electric and magnetic fields as possible risk factors. Environmental Health Perspectives. 111(7): 962-870. June 2003.
4. Grosche B, Lackland D, Mohr L, Dunbar J, Nicholas J, Burkart W, Hoel D. Leukaemia in the vicinity of two tritium-releasing nuclear facilities: A comparison of the Kruemmel site, Germany, and the Savannah River site, South Carolina, USA. Journal of Radiological Protection. 19(3): 243-252. September 1999.

Coordinates: 53°24′58″N 10°22′35″E / 53.41611°N 10.37639°E