| 1. |
"Adelaide" (Live in Adelaide 2011+) | | |
3:11 |
| 2. |
"Air" (from Godzilla: The Album) | Folds, Darren Jesse & Robert Sledge | Ben Folds Five |
3:21 |
| 3. |
"All Shook Up" (Elvis Presley cover) (B-side of "Kate") | Otis Blackwell | Ben Folds Five |
1:55 |
| 4. |
"Ascent of Stan" (Live in NYC 2002+) | | |
4:16 |
| 5. |
"Birds" (B-side of "Army") | | Ben Folds Five |
2:09 |
| 6. |
"Bitch Went Nutz" (Live in Amsterdam 2008+) | | |
4:36 |
| 7. |
"Bizarre Christmas Incident" (from Maybe This Christmas & 7" vinyl single) | | |
2:23 |
| 8. |
"Brick" (Live Acoustic Version 2003+) | Folds & Jesse | The Bens |
4:50 |
| 9. |
"Champagne Supernova" (Oasis cover) (Live in London 1996) (B-side of "Battle of Who Could Care Less") | Noel Gallagher | Ben Folds Five |
1:34 |
| 10. |
"Cologne" (Piano Orchestra Version 2008) (from Stems and Seeds) | | |
6:08 |
| 11. |
"Dr. Yang" (Live in Belgium 2008+) | | |
2:35 |
| 12. |
"Evaporated" (Demo 1992) | | Ben Folds Five |
4:11 |
| 13. |
"Family of Me" (from Over the Hedge) | | |
1:28 |
| 14. |
"For All the Pretty People" (B-side of "Kate") | | Ben Folds Five |
3:22 |
| 15. |
"Free Coffee" (Live in Germany 2008+) | | |
4:05 |
| 16. |
"Girl" (B-side of "Rockin' the Suburbs") | | |
3:43 |
| 17. |
"Golden Slumbers" (The Beatles cover) (Live in NYC 2001+) | John Lennon & Paul McCartney | |
2:13 |
| 18. |
"Hava Nagila" (Live) (B-side of "Battle of Who Could Care Less") | Abraham Zevi Idelsohn | Ben Folds Five |
1:35 |
| 19. |
"Heist" (from Over the Hedge) | | |
3:01 |
| 20. |
"Hiro's Song" (Shaker Version) (Live in Melbourne 2011+) | | |
3:02 |
| 21. |
"Honey Don't" (Carl Perkins cover) (Alternate Take 2000+) | Carl Perkins | Ben Folds Five |
2:40 |
| 22. |
"Hospital Song" (Live in Philadelphia 1999+) | | Ben Folds Five |
2:22 |
| 23. |
"House" (Original Mix 2011+) | | Ben Folds Five |
3:41 |
| 24. |
"I Knew That Cha Could" (Demo 2000+) | | |
2:50 |
| 25. |
"In Between Days" (The Cure cover) (Live 2005) | Robert Smith | |
3:03 |
| 26. |
"In Love" (Demo 1998+) | | Fear of Pop |
4:28 |
| 27. |
"It's Alright with God" (Mitch Easter Sessions 2000+) | | Ben Folds Five |
7:59 |
| 28. |
"Jesusland" (Live in Jakarta 2011+) | | |
3:59 |
| 29. |
"Jesusland" (Stadium Version) (Live in London 2005+) | | |
2:35 |
| 30. |
"Lonely" (Demo 1996+) | | Ben Folds Five |
3:18 |
| 31. |
"Lost in the Supermarket" (The Clash cover) (from Over the Hedge) | Mick Jones & Joe Strummer | |
3:30 |
| 32. |
"Make Me Mommy" (B-side of "Rockin' the Suburbs") | | |
2:18 |
| 33. |
"Mess" (Live in Boston 2007+) | | Folds with Neil Hannon |
4:03 |
| 34. |
"Mitchell Lane" (Outtake from Whatever and Ever Amen) | | Ben Folds Five |
3:44 |
| 35. |
"Narcolepsy" (Live+) | | Ben Folds Five |
5:35 |
| 36. |
"One Down" (B-side of "Rockin' the Suburbs") | | |
4:22 |
| 37. |
"Prince Charming" (Mitch Easter Sessions 2000+) | | Ben Folds Five |
3:41 |
| 38. |
"Prologue" (Outtake from Over the Hedge) | | |
1:09 |
| 39. |
"Protection" (Demo 1992+) | | |
3:24 |
| 40. |
"Radio Jingles for Tokyo's Inter-FM" | | |
0:52 |
| 41. |
"Rockin' the Suburbs" ('06 Remix) (Outtake from Over the Hedge) | | |
3:21 |
| 42. |
"Say Yes" (Elliott Smith cover) (Live at The A.V. Club 2010+) | Elliott Smith | |
2:08 |
| 43. |
"She Don't Use Jelly" (The Flaming Lips cover) (Lounge-A-Palooza Version) | Wayne Coyne | Ben Folds Five |
4:12 |
| 44. |
"Side of the Road" (Lucinda Williams cover) (Alternate Cello Version+) | Lucinda Williams | |
3:01 |
| 45. |
"Silver Street" (Demo 1994+) | | Ben Folds Five |
3:29 |
| 46. |
"Smoke" (Demo 1994+) | Folds & Anna Goodman | Ben Folds Five |
4:22 |
| 47. |
"Song for the Dumped" (Demo 1996+) | Folds & Jesse | Ben Folds Five |
3:51 |
| 48. |
"Steven's Last Night in Town" (Demo 1996+) | | Ben Folds Five |
3:06 |
| 49. |
"Theme from 'Dr. Pyser'" (Studio Version) | | Ben Folds Five |
3:14 |
| 50. |
"Underground" (Demo 1992+) | | Ben Folds Five |
5:06 |
| 51. |
"Video Killed the Radio Star" (The Buggles cover) (Outtake from Whatever and Ever Amen) | Geoff Downes, Trevor Horn & Bruce Woolley | Ben Folds Five |
3:41 |
| 52. |
"Where's Summer B.?" (Live at WNEW 1996+) | Folds & Jesse | Ben Folds Five |
4:14 |
| 53. |
"Wild Mountain Thyme" (Alternate Take 2010+) | Francis McPeake & Robert Tannahill | |
2:48 |
| 54. |
"You to Thank" (Live in Adelaide 2011+) | | |
3:44 |
| 55. |
"Your Cheatin' Heart" (Hank Williams cover) (Live 1996+) | Hank Williams | Ben Folds Five |
1:35 |
| 56. |
"Your Redneck Past" (Live in London 1999+) | | Ben Folds Five |
4:16 |
