| Year | [1]Seniors (Trood Award & Rodda Medal) | Reserves (Rex Hartley Medal) | Under 18's (Bruce Wilkinson Medal) | Under 16's (Shaw/Carter Medal) |
| 1954 |  Bob Mason (Sale) (20 Votes) | Rex Donnelly (Moe) (19) | | |
| 1955 | Bob Mason (Sale) (23) | Ron Hayes (Warragul) (20) | | |
| 1956 |  Noel Alford (Traralgon) (18) | "Mossy" Morgan (Trafalgar) (33) | | |
| 1957 | John Nix (Sale) (21) | "Mossy" Morgan (Trafalgar) (16) | M.James (Morwell) (19) | |
| 1958 |  Lester Ross (Moe) (31) | Tom Hart (Sale) (33) | M.West (Warragul) (14) | |
| 1959 | Peter Bevilacqua (Yarragon) (19) | Ray Pollock (Yallourn) | N.Hall (Yallourn) (12) | |
| 1960 |  Steve Szabo (Morwell) (20) | Allan Rankin (Trafalgar) (20) | G.Townsend (St Pat's) (22) | |
| 1961 |  Kevin Coverdale (Bairnsdale) (24) | Jack Vinall (Yallourn) (20) | G.Townsend (St Pat's) (31) | |
| 1962 | Ric Belford (Yallourn) (27) | Tom O'Callaghan (Traralgon) (18) | T.Hunter (Traralgon) (29) | |
| 1963 | Allan Steele (Moe) (18) | Ron Serong (Warragul) (32) | R.Foster (St Pat's A) (35) | WEST ZONE (Under 18's) |
| 1964 | Mike Collins (Yallourn) (17) | Max Prendergast (Bairnsdale) (27) | J.Barnett (Sale) (23) | B.Pickering (Trar. Colts) (12) |
| 1965 | Steve Szabo (Morwell) (26) | Richard Evans (Maffra) (20) | J.Barnett (Sale) (25) | P.Lerstang (Traraglon Colts) (23) |
| 1966 | Terry Hunter (Traralgon) (15) | Les Roberts (Sale) (21) | G.Fletcher (St Pat's) (20) | C.Luxford (Morwell) (18) |
| 1967 | George Brayshaw (Traralgon) (15) | Les Roberts (Sale) (12) | D.Scott (Heyfield) (23) | R.Baldry (Warragul) (12) |
| 1968 |  Les Hawken (Trafalgar) (31) | Peter Rodaughan (Moe) (28) | J.Welsh (St Pat's) (30) | E.Gray (Trar. Colts) (25) |
| 1969 | John Gallus (Bairnsdale) (37) | Barry Taylor (Yallourn) (14) | P.Speed (Sale) (22) | M.Mancuso (Traralgon) (11) |
| 1970 |  John Gallus (Maffra) (30) | Lyle Berry (Heyfield) (18) | A.Gallagher (St Pat's) (27) | G.McFarlane (Morwell) (13) |
| 1971 |  Terry Benton (Leongatha) (20) | Graeme Anderson (Heyfield) (18) | I.Stanley (Traralgon) (19) | P.Shields (Moe) (15) |
| 1972 | Henro Kornacki (Morwell) (27) | Barry Taylor (Yallourn) (13) | T.Munro (Traralgon) (23) | L.Ponton (Trar. Colts) (18) |
| 1973 | Barry Rowlings (Moe) (35) | Jack Vardy (Maffra) (21) | A.Williams (Traralgon) (19) | C.Carr (Morwell) (18) |
| 1974 | Barry Rowlings (Moe) (28) | Gus Eaton (Moe) (20) | J.Buntine (Sale) (24) | S.McNamara (Leongatha) (15) |
| 1975 |  John Gallus (Warragul) (28) | Peter Pacunskis (Traralgon) (15) | P.Boyce (Moe) (20) | |
| 1976 | Ray Christie (Bairnsdale) (19) | Jack Vardy (Maffra) (17) | J.Morrison (St Pat's) (25) | |
| 1977 | Peter Hall (Traralgon) (14) | Jack Vardy (Maffra) (14) | C.Dowd (Leongatha) | |
| 1978 | Jeff Mogel (Morwell) (22) | John Kimberley (Yallourn) (18) | W.McInnes (Yallourn) (25) | |
| 1979 | Jeff Gieschen (Maffra) (22) | Allan Light (Warragul) (24) | A.Morrison (Warragul) (24) | |
| 1980 | Ian Salmon (Leongatha) (24) | Jeff Swenson (Newborough) (24) | R.Copeland (Morwell) | |
| 1981 | Ray Mildenhall (Yallourn/YNth) (24) | Jock Eason (Moe) (15) | M.Trewella (Warragul) (27) | |
| 1982 | Jeff Gieschen (Maffra) (27) | Kasey Plemper (Moe) (17) | G.Scott (Bairnsdale) (27) | |
| | David Vogel (Morwell) (27) | | | |
| 1983 | Ray Mildenhall (Yallourn/YNth) (24) | Greg Roughead (Leongatha) (27) | C.Dilettoso (Maffra) (33) | |
| 1984 | Peter Hall (Traralgon) (27) | Gary House (TTU) (17) | G.Rankin (Warragul) (22) | |
| 1985 | Rod Kerr (Morwell) (30) | | | |
| 1986 | Jim Silvestro (Traralgon) (26) | | | |
| 1987 | Jim Silvestro (Traralgon) (19) | | | |
| 1988 | Lachlan Sim (Moe) (27) | | | |
| 1989 | Peter Geddes (Maffra) (20) | | | |
| 1990 | John McDonald (Traralgon) (15)
Peter Helms (Leongatha) (15) | | | |
| 1991 | Chris Grumley (Maffra) (22) | | | |
| 1992 | Greg Morley (Traralgon) (16) | | | |
| 1993 | Anthony Gravener (Maffra) (14) | | | |
| 1994 | Andrew Pratt (Warragul) (19) | | | |
| 1995 | Darren Read (Leongatha) (25) | | | |
| 1996 | David Mills (Warragul) (16) | | | |
| 1997 | Neil Robertson (Traralgon) (17) | | | |
| 1998 | Greg Morley (Traralgon) (21) | | | |
| 1999 |  Chris Day (Wonthaggi) (20) | | | |
| 2000 | Jason Shields (Moe) (17) | | | |
| 2001 | Hayden Burgiel (Maffra) (31) | | | |
| 2002 | Adam Mabilia (Wonthaggi) (20)
Gary Jones (Maffra) (20) | | | |
| 2003 | Greg Morley (Traralgon) (17) | | | |
| 2004 | Hayden Burgiel (Maffra) (28) | | | |
| 2005 | Andrew Soumilas (Garfield) (23) | | | |
| 2006 | Desi Barr (Warragul) (26) | | | |
| 2007 | Nick Hider (Maffra) (23) | | | |
| 2008 | Nick Hider (Maffra) (24) | | | |
| 2009 | Adrian Cox (Sale) (14)
Michael Geary (Traralgon) (14) | | | |
| 2010 | Gary Jones (Maffra) (26) | | | |
| 2011 |  Andrew Soumilas (Drouin) (25) | | | |
| 2012 | Luke Collins (Sale) (23) | | | |
| 2013 | Kelvin Porter (Maffra) (20) | | | |
