William Sulzer

William Sulzer
39th Governor of New York
In office January 1, 1913 – October 17, 1913
Lieutenant	Martin H. Glynn
Preceded by	John Alden Dix
Succeeded by	Martin H. Glynn
Member of the U.S. House of Representatives from New York's 10th district
In office March 4, 1903 – December 31, 1912
Preceded by	Edward Swann
Succeeded by	Herman A. Metz
Member of the U.S. House of Representatives from New York's 11th district
In office March 4, 1895 – March 3, 1903
Preceded by	Amos J. Cummings
Succeeded by	William Randolph Hearst
Member of the New York State Assembly from the New York County, 10th district
In office January 1, 1893 – December 31, 1894
Preceded by	William Sohmer
Succeeded by	Jacob Kunzenman
Member of the New York State Assembly from the New York County, 14th district
In office January 1, 1890 – December 31, 1892
Preceded by	Thomas J. Creamer
Succeeded by	Daniel F. Martin
Personal details
Born	March 18, 1863 Elizabeth, New Jersey
Died	November 6, 1941 (aged 78) New York City
Political party	Democratic
Religion	Presbyterian

William Sulzer (March 18, 1863 – November 6, 1941) was an American lawyer and politician, nicknamed Plain Bill Sulzer. He was the 39th Governor of New York and a long-serving congressman from the same state. He was the first and so far only New York Governor to be impeached. He broke with his sponsors at Tammany Hall, and they produced convincing evidence that Sulzer had falsified his sworn statement of campaign expenditures.

Early life and career

William Sulzer was born in Elizabeth, New Jersey on March 18, 1863. He attended the public schools and took night classes at Cooper Union before attending and graduating from Columbia College. Then he studied law, was admitted to the bar in 1884, and commenced practice in New York City. Even before beginning his law practice he was a member of Tammany Hall political machine serving as a popular stump speaker.^[1]

Sulzer’s career in politics began in 1884 when he worked for the Tammany Hall political machine on New York’s East Side as a stump speaker for various Democratic campaigns including the presidential campaign of then-Governor Grover Cleveland

Sulzer was a member of the New York State Assembly in 1890, 1891, 1892 (all three New York Co., 14th D.), 1893 and 1894 (both New York Co., 10th D.). His participation in the machine helped assure that he was appointed to the Committee on General Laws in his first term.^[2] During his time in the Assembly he introduced bills seeking to abolish debtors' prisons, and to limit hours for workers. His popularity and loyalty to Tammany machine were such that in 1893, Tammany Boss Richard Croker selected Sulzer to be elected as Speaker of the New York State Assembly. The term was noted as being highly corrupt and highly partisan, as the Democratic machine dominated all committees, and with them the state budget. Sulzer himself declared during the term that “[A]ll legislation came from Tammany Hall and was dictated by that great statesmen, Richard Croker.”^[3]

During his time in the Assembly, Sulzer was a delegate to the 1892 Democratic National Convention, and returned as such to every national convention until 1912.

United States Congressman

Pennsylvania Governor Tener (center) with Governors Dix and Sulzer of New York^[4] in 1912.

Sulzer was elected to the Fifty-fourth United States Congress in 1894, and served as a U.S. Representative in the eight succeeding Congresses, from March 4, 1895, to December 31, 1912, representing the 10th Congressional District.

In Congress he became known as a Populist, and became known for his oratory. Declaring himself to be a “friend to all humanity and a champion of liberty”, he supported the Cuban rebels during their War of Independence, and during the Second Boer War introduced a resolution supporting the Boer Republics and banning the sale of military supplies and munitions to the British Empire. Repeatedly he called for resolutions condemning Czarist Russia over the issue of pogroms. In the Sixty-second United States Congress he chaired the Committee on Foreign Affairs, from which he proposed a resolution praising the Revolution of 1911. He also opposed United States intervention in the Mexican Revolution, and proposed a unanimously supported bill to annul the Treaty of 1832 with Russia due to a Russian refusal to recognize the passports of Jewish-Americans.^[5]

Sulzer during his time in Congress supported numerous Progressive goals in terms of popular democracy and efficiency. He was a supporter of the creation of the United States Department of Labor, the direct election of senators --- for which he proposed a resolution in support of --- and the eight-hour day. In the Election of 1896 he supported the nomination of and campaigned for William Jennings Bryan.^[6]

In 1896,for the first time he announced his candidacy for the governorship but was rejected by Tammany and the Democratic Party at large. In 1898 Richard Croker openly opposed his attempt for the Democratic nomination.^[7] For the next six elections Sulzer was continually rejected for the Democratic nomination for Governor, losing to Tammany supported politicians such as William Randolph Hearst, and John Alden Dix.

In 1912 though, the split between the Republicans and the Progressives meant that the Democratic nomination was likely to win. This in turn prompted a fight in the Democrats, as reformers disappointed in Governor Dix’s support for Tammany moved to oust him from contention. The Empire State Democracy Party was even founded by reformers such as State Senator Franklin D. Roosevelt to run against Dix or any other clear Tammany candidate. In this crisis Sulzer found himself selected as a compromise candidate, acceptable to reform-minded and Tammany Democrats. The party united, Sulzer went on to defeat Republican Job E. Hedges and Progressive Oscar S. Straus.

He resigned from Congress effective December 31, 1912, having been elected Governor of New York in November 1912 for the term beginning on January 1, 1913.

Governor of New York

Sulzer was elected with the support of William Jennings Bryan, William Randolph Hearst and Woodrow Wilson, as well as the reform and Tammany factions of the state Democratic Party. Upon taking office Sulzer and Croker’s successor ”Silent Charlie” Murphy began to turn against each other as Sulzer claimed control of the state Democratic Party, rather than staying loyal to Tammany.

Attempts at Reform

On taking office as Governor, Sulzer in an initial move announced the renaming of the Executive Mansion “The People’s House”.^[8] The populist rhetoric of this move was followed by a campaign to “let the people rule”, through a series of reforms, including a move to promote open primaries for party nominations, and investigations into corruption in the legislature and executive branches of state government. At the same time Sulzer refused to follow Tammany decisions for state appointments. These moves would damage the power of Tammany and other machines, Democratic and Republican throughout the state, and empower Sulzer. The campaign for direct primaries would win him the support of Theodore Roosevelt and his Progressives, but also moved Tammany to stand firmly against him.^[9]

Critics claimed that Sulzer was using the direct primary issue to build his own machine or to co-opt Tammany and assume control of it from Murphy, based on his populist appeal. Meanwhile, Sulzer and his supporters countered that the effort was necessary to promote fair government.^[10]

By the end of April investigations against previously appointed Tammany officials had further developed the party split. And then on the 26th as the Open Primaries Bill moved to a vote Sulzer declared that “If any Democrat in this State is against the Democratic State platform, that man is no true Democrat, and he as the Democratic Governor of the State I shall do everything in my power to drive that recreant Democrat out of the Democratic Party.”^[11] In spite of the threat, both Machine and Independent Democrats voted against the bill overwhelmingly. The Machine delegates, led by Speaker Al Smith followed the orders of Murphy, while the Independent Democrats, mostly from rural, Upstate New York opposed the bill fearing that Open primaries would silence their influence and power against the weight of the urban vote.

Sulzer’s refusal to work with Tammany on appointments was a major threat to the organization, which had since its foundation been dependent on Civil Service work to develop its power. One of the appointments that Sulzer refused to make was that of James E. Gaffney, owner of the 1914 "Miracle" Braves, to State Commissioner of Highways.^[12]

Even after the defeat of the vote, Sulzer vowed to continue his fight with Murphy and the other bosses, and that there would be no Compromise. In response, the Tammany-allied State Comptroller William Sohmer moved to freeze payrolls for state highway and prison projects, and the State Senate under the leadership of another Tammany officer Robert F. Wagner refused to approve the Governor’s appointments to the New York Public Service Commission.

Impeachment

As the conflict between Sulzer and Tammany moved on, accusations arose against the Governor, claiming that he committed perjury in an 1890 lawsuit, and that he was involved in fraudulent companies in Cuba while a Congressman. These scandals being followed quickly by another as he was sued by a Philadelphia model, who swore that he had broken a 1903 promise to marry her. In all instances he rejected the claims and characterized the lawsuit as a “frame-up.”^[13]

In May 1913, a Joint Committee was established by the state legislature to investigate the financial conduct of state institutions, with Senator James J. Frawley, a loyal Tammany Democrat, appointed its chairman. Over the next two months the committee moved to find misconduct on the part of the Governor.

That summer the Frawley committee, using Tammany-provided information, accused Sulzer of having diverted campaign contributions to purchase stocks for himself and to have lied under oath in regards to it. Sulzer, his supporters and many historians later affirmed that the impeachment charges were made under instructions from Murphy, to remove him as an obstacle to Tammany Hall's influence in state politics. Sulzer’s opposition to the committee was based on questioning its constitutionality, but as evidence was raised over the use of campaign funds, he began to lose the support of the national Democratic Party, Theodore Roosevelt and William Randolph Hearst.

On August 11, 1913 the findings of the Frawley committee were announced to the state legislature, and moves began towards impeachment, managed by Tammany Hall’s legislative leaders. The only support Sulzer had was in the Progressive legislators, who were too few to slow the process down.^[14] Over the next two days the Governor opposed the secession at every term but was powerless to stop it, as Al Smith and Robert F. Wagner, Sr. maintained control of their respective houses.

In a last minute attempt to prevent impeachment, the Governor’s wife admitted to having been responsible for the theft of campaign funds, while the minority in the state Assembly allied to the Governor attempted to postpone proceedings based on the new evidence, but were unsuccessful and the decision came to a vote.^[15]

On August 13, 1913, the New York Assembly voted to impeach Governor Sulzer, by a vote of 79 to 45. Sulzer was served with a summons to appear before the Court for the Trial of Impeachments, and Lieutenant Governor Martin H. Glynn was empowered to act in his place pending the outcome of the trial. However, Sulzer maintained that the proceedings against him were unconstitutional and refused to vacate his office.^[16] Both Sulzer and Glynn claimed to be Governor. Lt.Gov. Glynn began signing documents as "Acting Governor" beginning on August 21.^[17]

The trial of Sulzer before the Impeachment Court began in Albany on September 18. Sulzer had called upon Louis Marshall to head his defense team and Marshall agreed, telling his wife that he was not enthusiastic about the outcome.^[18] The trial did not go well; Sulzer didn't even testify in his own defense. The court convicted Sulzer on three of the Articles of Impeachment on the afternoon of October 16, finding him guilty of filing a false report with the Secretary of State concerning his campaign contributions, committing perjury, and advising another person to commit perjury before an Assembly committee.^[19] The following day, the court voted on a resolution to remove Sulzer from office. On October 17, 1913, Sulzer was removed by the same margin, a vote of 43–12, and Lt. Gov. Glynn succeeded to the governorship.^[20]

According to the hagiographic 1914 book, The Boss or the Governor, by Samuel Bell Thomas, a crowd of 10,000 gathered outside the Executive Mansion on the night Governor Sulzer left Albany, leading to an exchange as follows:

Mr. Sulzer: "My friends, this is a stormy night. It is certainly very good of you to come here to bid Mrs. Sulzer and me good-bye."

A voice from the crowd: "You will come back, Bill, next year."

Mr. Sulzer: "You know why we are going away."

A voice: "Because you were too honest."

Mr. Sulzer: "I impeach the criminal conspirators, these looters and grafters, for stealing the taxpayers' money. That is what I never did."

From the crowd: Cheers.

Mr. Sulzer: "Yes my friends, I know that the court of public opinion before long will reverse the judgement of Murphy's 'court of infamy.'"

From the crowd: Cheers.

Mr. Sulzer: "Posterity will do me justice. Time sets all things right. I shall be patient."

From the crowd: Cheers.

Some in Albany maintained that he was impeached unfairly, as he had been the first person ever to have been impeached for acts committed before taking office. There have been several pieces of legislation introduced in the New York State Assembly and Senate to have his political record repaired. None have been successful to date.

Sulzer's official portrait is one of several Governors of New York that do not hang in the "Hall of Governors," the main hallway leading to the Executive Chamber, located within the New York State Capitol in Albany.^[21]

William Sulzer in The Broad Ax newspaper December 23, 1922^[22]

Later life and political career

Sulzer was able to recover somewhat politically. Just a few weeks after the impeachment, he was elected on the Progressive ticket to the New York State Assembly, and was a member of the 137th New York State Legislature (New York Co., 6th D.) in 1914.

For the New York state election, 1914, he organized the American Party as a spoiler, to defeat Martin H. Glynn, his former Lieutenant Governor who had succeeded him as Governor, and was running for re-election. Sulzer also attempted to gain the Progressive Party nomination for Governor, but was defeated in the primary, partly due to the intervention of Theodore Roosevelt who in a letter to all members of the party declared that "the trouble with Sulzer is that he does not tell the truth."^[23] However, Sulzer found support in the Prohibition Party which, on the basis of a speech he gave denouncing rum, nominated him for governor in 1914.^[24] He came in third, behind Republican Charles S. Whitman, who was elected Governor, and Glynn who was unseated. Sulzer thus claimed that the result was a moral victory, as the Democrats who had impeached him had were swept out of power.

In the Election of 1916 Sulzer campaigned for the Prohibition Party’s nomination for President but was defeated by Frank Hanly. When offered the American Party nomination he declined it.^[25]

Leaving politics he engaged in the practice of law in New York City. He wrote and spoke in support of the Bahá'í Faith from the 1920s occasionally after having met `Abdu'l-Bahá during his visit including the United States in 1912.^[26] He died in New York November 6, 1941, aged 78. He was buried at the Evergreen Cemetery in Hillside, New Jersey.

In popular culture

The Great McGinty, Preston Sturges' 1940 film, was based in part on William Sulzer's story, per film historian Kevin Brownlow.

Bitten by the Tiger: The True Story of Impeachment, the Governor & Tammany Hall a 2013 book written by Jack O'Donnell and published by Chapel Hill Press, goes in depth about William Sulzer's political rise, achievements and his impeachment.^[27]

Sources

• United States Congress. "William Sulzer (id: S001065)". Biographical Directory of the United States Congress.

References

1. Jacob Alexis Fredman The Impeachment of Governor William Sulzer (1939), Pg. 16
2. Matthew L. Lifflander The Impeachment of Governor William Sulzer: A Story of American Politics (2012) Pg. 7
3. Fredman The Impeachment of Governor William Sulzer Pg. 21
4. "DIX, JOHN A. GOVERNOR OF NEW YORK, 1910-1912. WITH HIS SUCCESSOR, SULZER, AND GOVERNOR TENER OF PENNSYLVANIA". Hdl.loc.gov. Retrieved 2014-08-07.
5. Fredman The Impeachment of Governor William Sulzer Pg. 27
6. Lifflander The Impeachment of Governor William Sulzer: A story of American Politics Pg. 18
7. Fredman The Impeachment of Governor William Sulzer Pg. 24
8. Fredman The Impeachment of Governor William Sulzer Pg. 40
9. Jay W. Forrest and James Malcolm Tammany’s Treason: Impeachment of Governor Sulzer; the complete story written from behind the scenes, showing how Tammany plays the game, how men are bought, sold and delivered (1913) Pg 22
10. Forrest, Malcom Tammany's Treason Pg 46
11. Fredman The Impeachment of Governor William Sulzer Pg. 111
12. "SULZER GIVES GRAFT CLUES - Quotes Senator O'Gorman as Saying Gaffney Couldn't "Blackjack" His Client, - View Article - NYTimes.com". New York Times. 1914-01-22. Retrieved 2014-08-07.
13. Lifflander The Impeachment of Governor William Sulzer: A story of American Politics Pg. 132
14. Fredman The Impeachment of Governor William Sulzer Pg. 131
15. Fredman The Impeachment of Governor William Sulzer Pg. 161
16. "SULZER IMPEACHED BY ASSEMBLY BUT REFUSES TO SURRENDER OFFICE", Syracuse Herald, August 13, 1913, p. 1.
17. "Sulzer and Glynn Keep on Playing a Waiting Game," Syracuse Herald, August 21, 1913, p. 1.
18. Alpert, Herbert. Louis Marshall: 1856-1929.p.36-37, 2008. ISBN 978-0-595-48230-6.
19. "REPORT SAYS COURT WILL CONVICT GOVERNOR ON THREE OF ARTICLES", Syracuse Herald, October 16, 1913, p. 1.
20. "HIGH COURT REMOVES SULZER FROM OFFICE BY A VOTE OF 43 TO 12", Syracuse Herald, October 17, 1913, p. 1.
21. "Hall of Governors re-opened to the public". Alloveralbany.com. 2011-01-13. Retrieved 2014-08-07.
22. Taylor, Julius F. (December 23, 1922). "The Broad Ax" (14). Retrieved 17 June 2015.
23. Fredman The Impeachment of Governor William Sulzer Pg. 266
24. Fredman The Impeachment of Governor William Sulzer Pg. 266-68
25. Fredman The Impeachment of Governor William Sulzer Pg. 270
26. Menon, Jonathan (April 27, 2012). "At 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue". 239 Days in America - a Social Media Documentary. Retrieved June 19, 2014. Note Sulzer would share a stage with`Abdu'l-Bahá, "Persia Confab plans complete". The Washington Herald (Washington, District of Columbia). 7 April 1912. p. 7. Retrieved June 19, 2014. and go on to write expansively of the Baha'i Faith as he understood it:
    • Sulzer, William (14 February 1920). "What is Bahaism?". The Broad Ax (Salt Lake City, Utah). p. 2. Retrieved June 19, 2014.
    • "William Sulzer will speak…". The Brooklyn Daily Eagle (Brooklyn, New York). 20 February 1932. p. 13. Retrieved June 19, 2014.
27. "About the Book". Bitten by the Tiger: The True Story of Impeachment, the Governor & Tammany Hall. Retrieved 23 September 2014.

Further reading

• Dunne, John R., and Michael AL Balboni. "New York's Impeachment Law and the Trial of Governor Sulzer: A Case for Reform." Fordham Urban Law Journal 15 (1986): 567+. online
• Friedman, Jacob Alexis. The Impeachment of Governor William Sulzer (Columbia University Press, 1939)

External links

• Men of Mark in America Biography & Portrait

William Sulzer at Find a Grave

• The Impeachment of Governor Sulzer: A Story of American Politics (SUNY Press, 2012)
• Interview with New York State historian on 100th anniversary of Governor Sulzer's impeachment
• Governor Sulzer Impeached (New York State Library)
• Bitten by the Tiger Jack O'Donnell Book on Sulzer