Ian Comfort

Ian Comfort CEO of AET

Ian Comfort at the AET Annual Conference June 2015
Born May 1953
Education Open University Mathematics, University of Law, Postgraduate Diploma in Law, Plymouth University, Master of Laws
Occupation Educationalist

Ian Comfort was born in 1953. He has been a successful law practitioner but as a leader of the Academies Enterprise Trust he has been involved in controversies (see below) criticising OFSTED for challenging the standards within the Academy chain which he was responsible for leading.

Career history

During his career Ian Comfort has been a maths teacher, a leader of the London local authority and has combined this with active work as a barrister of the Inner Temple.[1] In 2012 he became the CEO of Academies Enterprise Trust, which at that time was the largest Multi-Academy Trust in England.[2] Prior to joining AET (Academies Enterprise Trust) in 2009, Ian Comfort, was the Chief Executive of Edutrust,[3] a Multi-academy Trust which was renamed as E-ACT in 2010.[4] Ian left E-ACT (now called Edutrust Academies Charitable Trust) under controversial circumstances. His contract was ended amidst Trust accusations of 'poor performance' whilst he himself counter-claimed that he was being victimised for being a whistleblower. The case was settled out of court for an undisclosed sum, following a significant period of being at home on full salary.[5]

Ian Comfort began his teaching career as a Maths teacher and progressed to become a Director of a Local Education Authority before becoming the Chief Operating Officer for the Ark Academies Chain [6] Joining AET in 2009 Ian Comfort was initially Group Secretary and General Counsel.[7] Following the retirement of David Triggs, the previous CEO in Sept 2013,[8] AET posted the notice of Ian Comfort's appointment as interim CEO on 2 April 2014.[9]

As CEO of Academies Enterprise Trust Ian Comfort is also CEO of London Academies Enterprise Trust[10] which is a subsidiary trust within the AET family, containing 4 secondary schools.

Financial matters

In June 2015 Ian Comfort was reported as earning £220,000 per annum,[11] which was the second highest pay of CEOs in England leading Multi-Academy Trusts[11] In 2013 concerns were expressed nationally about the fact that he had received £329,000 in addition to his salary for "project management services".[12] This contributed to criticism of the Department for Education for allowing "related party payments" within Academy Trusts.[13]


By March 2016 Sir Michael Wilshaw, the head of OFSTED, was criticising excessive salaries for CEO's of Academy chains as a "poor use of public money" referring to Ian Comfort's salary by stating that "Given these worrying findings about the performance of disadvantaged pupils and the lack of leadership capacity and strategic oversight by trustees, salary levels for the chief executives of some of these MATs do not appear to be commensurate with the level of performance of their trusts or constituent academies, with one chief executive's salary reaching £225,000."[14] Dia Chakravarty, from the TaxPayers' Alliance stated "Taxpayers don't begrudge just rewards for good results but far too often taxpayer-funded salaries are handed out to fat cats irrespective of performance. Parents will want to keep a very close eye to make sure that it really is good value for money."[15] Dr Mary Bousted, general secretary of the Association of Teachers and Lecturers (ATL), said: ‘It is becoming increasingly difficult for some academies to justify paying their chief executives and heads such high salaries.[16]

In September 2014 Ian Comfort announced a downsizing of the Academy chain, which saw it reduce from 77 Academies to 68.[17] In the summer of 2014 Ian Comfort led a proposal for a Joint Venture with a for-profit business partner, which would have led to the largest outsourcing of school services within England. Following a letter of concerns on 10 Jun 2014, from 8 main teaching unions, the proposal was dropped.[18]

Controversies

During his career with AET Ian Comfort has led the organisation through a period of controversies. In 2014 there was an OFSTED inspection which accused the Academy chain of having low expectations and failing its pupils.[19] Ian Comfort robustly denied those findings and AET "criticised inspectors' findings as "unfairly negative" and (said) that "turning a school around takes time"".[20] However, when OFSTED returned to reinspect the chain, this led to a further report criticising AET in February 2016, for "medicore performance" and for still "failing too many of its pupils."[21] This "damning indictment" and "sharp rebuke" as the national press referred to it,[22] was once again rejected by AET as "unfair". Ian Comfort disagreed and explicitly rejected OFSTED's views and was reported as stating that "In all areas we are performing above the national average."[22] Unfortunately AET's own board minutes showed that its proportion of pupils achieving the key government milestone of 5GCSEs A-C grades (including English and Maths) was 43% in 2015, compared to a national average of 56%, meaning that AET was therefore 13% below the national average.[23] It was also noted by the Times Education Supplement, that far from standards within AET schools being "above the national average," the situation "has become so serious that representatives from the Department for Education now sit in on the trust’s board meetings"[24]

Under Ian Comfort's leadership AET also was involved in controversy about why the academy chain shrank in size. It has been claimed in the press that it was because the academy chain had expanded too fast and Christine Blower the head of the NUT stated “It is obvious that AET’s rate and scale of expansion was unsustainable and that it is unable to adequately support its schools."[22] However AET denied that it had been 'banned' from expanding and insisted that it had instead chosen to "pause and consolidate".

In 2015 Ian Comfort also directly contradicted the Government (DfE's) claim that Academy status creates extra freedoms for headteachers, by claiming that headteachers of Academies had significantly less freedom than headteachers of non-academies.[25]

Individual Academy matters

In June 2015 Ian Comfort met with Sir George Young, the Hampshire MP to discuss concerns about school improvement at Winton Community Academy[26] In October 2015 Sir David Carter wrote a public letter to Ian Comfort warning about the unacceptably low standards at Millbrook Academy, a secondary school within the Academies Enterprise Trust group.[27] On the Isle of Wight, low pupil numbers following the decline of Weston Primary school into Special Measures, meant that the school had to be closed. Ian Comfort led the closure commenting publicly on how sad it was, but that it was no longer possible to provide the quality of education which pupils deserve, when numbers had dropped so low.[28]

In the spring of 2015, following a campaign led by MP Priti Patel, Ian Comfort announced that AET would no longer be considering merging the Academies in Witham.[29] In the summer of 2015 Ian Comfort also made national news by announcing that Academy Principals within AET have less freedom than headteachers of maintained non-academy schools.[30]

References

  1. ↑ "Sponsor for Wembley Academy" (PDF). Brent Local Authority. Brent. Retrieved 9 March 2016.
  2. ↑ Clark, Thomas. "Michael Gove's ideological vandalism of the education system". Another Angry Voice Blogspot. Retrieved 17 Dec 2015.
  3. ↑ Curtis, Polly (28 Nov 2008). "Government launches inquiry into academy funds allegations". The Guardian. Retrieved 17 Dec 2015.
  4. ↑ Paton, Graeme (24 Feb 2014). "Academies chain stripped of 10 under-performing schools". The Telegraph. Retrieved 17 Dec 2015. See also "England's Schools Not Open For Business" (PDF). ATL Union. ATL. Retrieved 17 Dec 2015.
  5. ↑ Curtis, Polly (28 Nov 2008). "Government launches inquiry into academy funds allegations". The Guardian. Retrieved 9 March 2016.
  6. ↑ "Ian Comfort: Group CEO". Academies Enterprise Trust. Academies Enterprise Trust. Retrieved 17 Dec 2015.
  7. ↑ Archard, Michelle (12 Sep 2013). "Top head quits role at academy trust". Southend Standard. Retrieved 17 Dec 2015.
  8. ↑ Vaughan, Richard (10 Sep 2013). "Head of country's largest academy chain steps down". TES. Retrieved 17 Dec 2015.
  9. ↑ "Ian Comfort". Academies Enterprise Trust. Academies Enterprise Trust. Retrieved 17 Dec 2015.
  10. ↑ "London Academies Enterprise Trust". Endole. Endole. Retrieved 17 Dec 2015.
  11. 1 2 McGauran, Ann (5 Jun 2015). "Academy CEO Pay: How much do the biggest trusts pay?". Schools Week. Retrieved 17 Dec 2015.
  12. ↑ Boffey, Daniel (20 Jul 2013). "Academy chain under fire following revelation of payments made to bosses". The Guardian. Retrieved 17 Dec 2015.
  13. ↑ Sweet, Pat (10 Mar 2014). "DFE Slammed over related party payments at academies". Accountancy Live. Retrieved 17 Dec 2015.
  14. ↑ Richardson, Hannah (10 Mar 2016). "School results don't justify academy trust pay, says Ofsted". BBC. Retrieved 11 March 2016.
  15. ↑ Harris, Sarah (11 Mar 2016). "OFSTED head blasts Academy chiefs who earn more than PM". The Daily Mail (p4).
  16. ↑ Harding, Eleanor (9 Feb 2016). "Revealed: Academy school head who is paid £400,000 - almost three times the salary of the Prime Minister - after receiving a bumper pay rise". Mail on Line. Retrieved 11 March 2016.
  17. ↑ Hurst, Greg (1 Sep 2014). "Academy chain AET may lose control of schools". The Times. Retrieved 17 Dec 2015.
  18. ↑ "AET proposed Joint Venture" (PDF). UNISON. UNISON. Retrieved 17 Dec 2015.
  19. ↑ "Academies Enterprise Trust (AET) inspection outcome letter". Gov.Uk. DfE. Retrieved 9 March 2016.
  20. ↑ Coughlan, Sean. "England's largest academy chain 'failing too many pupils'". BBC. BBC. Retrieved 9 March 2016.
  21. ↑ "Focused inspection of Academies Enterprise Trust". Gov.Uk. DFE. Retrieved 9 March 2016.
  22. 1 2 3 Weale, Sally (4 Feb 2016). "Largest academy chain letting down too many pupils, says DfE". The Guardian. Guardian. Retrieved 9 March 2016.
  23. ↑ Beverley Perin's (AET Director of Challenge and Business Intervention) Report to the Trustees, 20th Oct 2015, retrieved 09-Mar-2016
  24. ↑ Barker, Irena (4 Dec 2015). "Exclusive: Ofsted inspects academy chain for the second time after performance 'concerns'". TES. Retrieved 9 March 2016.
  25. ↑ "ASCL Leader Magazine". ASCL. ASCL. Retrieved 9 March 2016.
  26. ↑ "Sir George Young and Kit Malthouse meet AET to discuss Winton Academy in Andover". Retrieved 17 Dec 2015.
  27. ↑ Carter, Sir David. "Pre Warning Letter" (PDF). Department for Education. Department for Education. Retrieved 17 Dec 2015.
  28. ↑ Weeks, Jon. "Weston Academy Closure Approved". Isle of Wight Radio. Retrieved 17 Dec 2015.
  29. ↑ Lodge, Will (27 Feb 2015). "Witham schools merger plan shelved by Trust". East Anglian Daily Times. Retrieved 17 Dec 2015.
  30. ↑ Wiggins, Kaye (17 Jul 2015). "Academies boss: Maintained-school headteachers have more freedom than those in academy chains". TES. Retrieved 17 Dec 2015.
This article is issued from Wikipedia - version of the Monday, March 28, 2016. The text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution/Share Alike but additional terms may apply for the media files.