List of Compact Disc and DVD copy protection schemes

This is a list of notable copy protection schemes for CD and DVD.

For other medias, see List of Copy Protection Schemes.

Commercial CD protection schemes

CD-Cops

Requires the user to enter CD-code (or reads embedded CD-code) that describes geometry of CD to correctly locate data on the disc.

SafeDisc (versions 1-5)

Adds unique digital signature at the time of manufacturing which is designed to be difficult to copy or transfer so that software is able to detect copied media.

SafeCast

The encryption key will expire after pre-determined date so the media can be used only temporarily. Also used to implement trial editions of programs.^[1]

SecuROM

Limits the number of PCs activated at the same time from the same key.

StarForce

Asks for Serial ID at install or startup to verify the license.

TAGES

Verifies authentic copy by checking existence of "twin sectors" which are sectors with same logical address but different data. However, twin sectors may be hard to read in order to copy but are easy to write.

Commercial DVD protection schemes

Analog Protection System

Adds pulses to analog video signals to negatively impact the AGC circuit of a recording device so the images on copied DVDs becomes garbled.

Sony ARccOS Protection

Inserting corrupted sectors in areas where normal players will not access but ripping software does to trigger errors during replication.

Burst Cutting Area

Writing barcode in circular area near the center of the disc (referred to as burst cutting area) which cannot be written without using special equipment.

DVD-Cops

See CD-Cops in previous section.

DVD region code

Restricts region where media can be played by matching region number with configuration flag in DVD players.

LaserLock

Includes hidden directory on the CD containing corrupted data which will cause errors while being copied.

ProtectDISC Software

Adds unique digital signature to the CD or DVD that cannot be transferred from copy to copy. A solution for software and games on CD or DVD provided by Protect Software.

ProtectDISC Video

Prevents ripping software to analyze the structure of the DVD. A solution for Video-DVDs provided by Protect Software.

SafeDisc (version 4)

See SafeDisc (versions 1-5) in previous section.

SecuROM

See previous section.

TAGES

See previous section.

Commercial Audio CD/DVD protection schemes

Cactus Data Shield

By intentionally violating Red Book CD Digital Audio standards, such as erroneous disc navigation and corrupted data, prevents successful ripping of the data. However, the original copy itself does not play correctly in some CD/DVD players.

Disc Wobble

Encode hidden protection data in discs' grooves so only discs which reproduce the wobble in the disc's groove will be playable.

Extended Copy Protection (XCP)

Installs a software on the computer after agreement to EULA at the first time the media is inserted, and the software will watch for any ripper software trying to access the CD-drive.

Key2Audio

Intended to make the CD play only on CD players and not on computers by applying bogus data track onto the disc during manufacturing, which CD players will ignore as non-audio tracks. The system could be disabled by tracing the outer edge of a CD with a felt-tip marker.^[2]

MediaMax CD3

Installs software on the computer that tries to play the media so other software cannot read data directly from audio discs in the CD-ROM drive. Silently installing software on a computer created a controversy about modifying a computer's behaviour without a user's consent.

Console CD protection schemes

Dreamcast (GD-ROM)

Multiple table of contents (TOC) made normal cd player to not read beyond first track. However, one could read GD-ROM on CD reader by swapping the disc after reading fake TOC.

FADE

Creates fake scratches on the disk image which copying programs will automatically try to fix. Instead of alerting the user that the copied disc is detected, the program will play the game in buggy manner.^[3]

PlayStation (CD-ROM)

The authority pattern pressed on internal circumference of the media, which could not be copied, is used to detect authorized copies. Some titles also uses Libcrypt mechanism to validate the disc by using checksum as magic number to subroutines.

PlayStation 2 (CD-ROM, DVD-ROM)

A map file that contains all of the exact positions and file size info of the disc is stored at a position that is beyond the file limit. The game calls this place directly so that burned copy with no data beyond file limit cannot be played.

PSP (Universal Media Disc)

Since no blank media or writer exists, the media itself cannot be copied, but one could make ISO image (a file version of the UMD) on a memory card. The unique format also made the media difficult to adapt and expensive.

Xbox (DVD)

It has been theorized that the discs have a second partition that is read from the outside in (opposite current standards thus making the second partition unreadable in PC DVD drives). Also, the Xbox is said to use a different DVD file system (instead of UDF).

References

1. "Macrovision Unveils SAFECAST Copy Protection Solution; SAFECAST Technology Designed to Secure Pre-Release Software from Unauthorized Copying" The Free Library 17 March 1999. 9 February 2013 <Unveils SAFECAST Copy Protection Solution; SAFECAST...-a054129804>.
2. Coerner, Brendan (3 June 2002). "Can You Violate Copyright Law With a Magic Marker?". Retrieved 2013-02-11.
3. Grayson, Nathan (17 Nov 2011). "Interview: Bohemia Interactive’s CEO on fighting piracy, creative DRM". Retrieved 2013-02-11.