| Name | Term |
| Hayes, BenjaminBenjamin Hayes | 1850–1851 |
| Dryden, William G.William G. Dryden | 1851–1852 |
| Brent, Joseph LancasterJoseph Lancaster Brent | 1852–1853 |
| Carr, Charles E.Charles E. Carr | 1853 |
| Brent, Joseph LancasterJoseph Lancaster Brent | 1853 |
| Hartman, IsaacIsaac Hartman | 1854–1855 |
| Granger, LewisLewis Granger | 1855–1856 |
| Thom, Cameron E.Cameron E. Thom | 1856–1858 |
| Lader, JamesJames H. Lader | 1858–1859 |
| Reynolds, Samuel F.Samuel F. Reynolds | 1859–1861 |
| Lader, JamesJames H. Lader | 1861–1862 |
| Newmark, Myer JosephMyer Joseph Newmark | 1862 |
| Chapman, AlfredAlfred Chapman | 1862–1865 |
| Lader, JamesJames H. Lader | 1865 |
| King, Andrew J.Andrew J. King | 1866–1868 |
| Larrabee, Charles H.Charles H. Larrabee |
1868 (did not serve)[lower-alpha 1] |
| McPherson, WilliamWilliam McPherson | 1868–1870 |
| Howard, Frank H.Frank H. Howard | 1870–1872 |
| Hutton, Aurelius W.Aurelius W. Hutton | 1872–1876 |
| Godfrey, John FranklinJohn Franklin Godfrey | 1876–1880 |
| Hazard, Henry T.Henry T. Hazard | 1880–1882 |
| Stephenson, WilliamWalter D. Stephenson | 1882–1884 |
| McKinley, James WilfredJames Wilfred McKinley | 1884–1886 |
| Daly, J.C.J.C. Daly | 1886–1888 |
| McFarland, CharlesCharles H. McFarland | 1888–1894 |
| Dunn, William EllsworthWilliam Ellsworth Dunn | 1894–1898 |
| Haas, Walter F.Walter F. Haas | 1898–1900 |
| Mathews, W.B.W.B. Mathews | 1900–1906 |
| Hewitt, Leslie R.Leslie R. Hewitt | 1906–1910 |
| Shenk, John W.John W. Shenk | 1910–1913 |
| Stephens, AlfredAlfred Lee Stephens | 1913–1919 |
| Burnell, Charles S.Charles S. Burnell | 1919–1921 |
| Stephens, Jess E.Jess E. Stephens | 1921–1929 |
| Warner, ErwinErwin P. Warner | 1929–1933 |
| Chesebro, Ray L.Ray L. Chesebro | 1933–1953 |
| Arnebergh, RogerRoger Arnebergh | 1953–1973 |
| Pines, BurtBurt Pines | 1973–1981 |
| Reiner, IraIra Reiner | 1981–1985 |
| Hahn, JamesJames Hahn | 1985–2001 |
| Delgadillo, RockyRocky Delgadillo | 2001–2009 |
| Trutanich, CarmenCarmen Trutanich | 2009–2013 |
| Feuer, MikeMike Feuer | 2013–present |