Marc Beaudoin

Marc Beaudoin (born 1935 died 2012) is a judge and former politician in the Canadian province of Quebec. He served on the Montreal city council from 1978 to 1986 as a member of mayor Jean Drapeau's Civic Party and was a member of the Montreal executive committee (i.e., the municipal cabinet). In 1991, he was appointed as a judge on the Quebec Superior Court.

Private career

Beaudoin was a lawyer in private life. A Montreal Gazette report indicates that he was fifty years old in 1986.^[1]

Councillor

Beaudoin was first elected to the Montreal city council in the 1978 municipal election and was re-elected in 1982. He served as vice-president of the Montreal executive committee for a time and was chair of council from 1982 to 1986. In May 1986, Beaudoin presided over the first Montreal city council meeting in which journalists were allowed to bring cameras and recording equipment into the chambers.^[2]

When Drapeau announced his retirement in 1986, Beaudoin supported Claude Dupras's successful bid to become the Civic Party's new leader and mayoral candidate.^[3] Dupras was defeated by Montreal Citizens' Movement candidate Jean Doré in the general election, while Beaudoin was defeated in Gabriel-Sagard by MCM candidate Vittorio Capparelli.

Beaudoin became the Civic Party's vice-president after the election. He resigned from the party executive in February 1989, saying that the party's attempts at democratization "[had] not achieved the desired results."^[4]

Federal politics

Beaudoin was a supporter of the Progressive Conservative Party of Canada at the federal level.^[5] He was chosen as president of the party's Rosemont association in August 1988, with support from the party establishment. Rosemont's Member of Parliament (MP) at the time was Suzanne Blais-Grenier, who questioned the legitimacy of Beaudoin's election and suggested that it was part of an effort to pressure her into resigning.^[6] Her supporters set up a rival association with a different president, and a quarrel ensued as to which group controlled the local party finances.^[7]

Blais-Grenier was ultimately kicked out of the Progressive Conservative party, and Beaudoin's association was recognized as official. Shortly thereafter, Beaudoin resigned as president to become the Progressive Conservative candidate for Saint-Léonard in the 1988 federal election. This contest was expected to be close, but it was not; Beaudoin finished a fairly distant second against Liberal incumbent Alfonso Gagliano.^[8]

Judge

In December 1991, Canadian federal justice minister Kim Campbell appointed Beaudoin as a judge on the Quebec Superior Court.^[9]

Notable rulings

Beaudoin ruled in July 1993 that the last remaining English-language school overseen by the Montreal Catholic School Commission in Côte-des-Neiges could be redesignated as a French-language school. Several parents of anglophone children argued that the commission made its decision without proper consultation; Beaudoin concluded that the parents did not prove their case.^[10]

In 1997, Beaudoin dismissed a lawsuit from a Quebec resident who had sued McDonald's for $33,864 after suffering second-degree burns from spilled coffee. The litigant was seated in a car that was not moving at the time of the incident, and Beaudoin ruled that only the Quebec automobile-insurance board (rather than the company) could be held liable for "damage caused by an automobile." The Quebec Court of Appeal later overturned Beaudoin's decision, concluding that there was no link between the litigant's injuries and the use or ownership of a car.^[11]

Beaudoin reviewed a class-action lawsuit by former Jonquière Wal-Mart employees in 2005, following the company's decision to close their Jonquière branch after a successful unionization drive by the employees. Wal-Mart claimed that the store was not sufficiently profitable, while opponents argued the company's decision was intended to intimidate workers in other branches.^[12] Beaudoin ultimately ruled that the lawsuit could not proceed, on the grounds that the dispute with Wal-Mart was the exclusive jurisdiction of the Quebec labour board. The former employees announced they would appeal the decision.^[13]

Electoral record

Canadian federal election, 1988: Saint-Léonard—Saint-Michel
Party		Candidate	Votes	%	∆%	Expenditures
	Liberal	Alfonso Gagliano	23,014	50.25	–	$44,847
	Progressive Conservative	Marc Beaudoin	17,055	37.24		$43,281
	New Democratic	Michel Roche	4,663	10.18		$742
	Green	Rolf Bramann	833	1.82		$140
	Non-affiliated	Bernard Papillon	231	0.50		$130
Total valid votes			45,796	100.00
Total rejected ballots			1,018
Turnout			46,814	74.49
Electors on the lists			62,845
Source: Report of the Chief Electoral Officer, Thirty-fourth General Election, 1988.

1986 Montreal municipal election results: Councillor, Gabriel-Sagard Party Candidate Total votes % of total votes Montreal Citizens' Movement Vittorio Capparelli 3,139 49.05 Civic Party of Montreal Marc Beaudoin (incumbent) 1,874 29.28 Independent Marcel Paquet 1,387 21.67 Total valid votes 6,400 100 Source: Election results, 1833-2005 (in French), City of Montreal.

1982 Montreal municipal election results: Councillor, Gabriel-Sagard Party Candidate Total votes % of total votes Civic Party of Montreal Marc Beaudoin (incumbent) 3,448 50.26 Montreal Citizens' Movement Consolato Gattuso 1,900 27.69 Municipal Action Group Pierre Harel 1,124 16.38 Independent Marcel Paquet 389 5.67 Total valid votes 6,861 100 Source: Election results, 1833-2005 (in French), City of Montreal.

1978 Montreal municipal election results: Councillor, Gabriel-Sagard Party Candidate Total votes % of total votes Civic Party of Montreal Marc Beaudoin 4,287 60.80 Municipal Action Group Yvon Marcotte 1,961 27.81 Montreal Citizens' Movement Daniel Lauzon 803 11.39 Total valid votes 7,051 100 Source: Election results, 1833-2005 (in French), City of Montreal. Party identifications are taken from Le Devoir, 11 November 1978.

References

1. Ingrid Peritz, "Dupras has contenders if Civic Party pulls it off," Montreal Gazette, 1 November 1986, B1.
2. Ingrid Peritz, "City council yields, lets cameras, tapes into session," Montreal Gazette, 7 May 1985, A1.
3. Ingrid Peritz, "Dupras has contenders if Civic Party pulls it off," Montreal Gazette, 1 November 1986, B1.
4. "Civic Party without leader as top executives resign," Montreal Gazette, 25 February 1989, A3.
5. Ingrid Peritz, "Dupras has contenders if Civic Party pulls it off," Montreal Gazette, 1 November 1986, B1.
6. Elizabeth Thompson, "Blais-Grenier denies feeling any pressure to step down," Montreal Gazette, 17 August 1988, A5.
7. Elizabeth Thompson, "Potential candidate drops out of running for Rosemont seat," Montreal Gazette, 15 September 1988, A3; Elizabeth Thompson, "Tories, Blais-Grenier tangling over funds," Montreal Gazette, 27 September 1988, A5.
8. William Marsden, "Liberal credits Italian vote in re-election," Montreal Gazette, 22 November 1988, B12.
9. "Campbell appoints 18 to provincial courts," Globe and Mail, 24 December 1991, A8.
10. Catherine Buckie, "Judge rules that St. Kevin School be turned over to French students," Montreal Gazette, 15 July 1993, A4.
11. Bernard Perusse, "Buyer, store agree on refund," Montreal Gazette, 21 April 2000, D12.
12. Paul Delean, "Wal-Mart ruling on hold," Montreal Gazette, 27 September 2005, B3.
13. "Unionized workers at a Wal-Mart store in Jonquiere, Que., that closed in April will appeal a Superior Court decision that threw out their class-action lawsuit seeking damages for wrongful dismissal," Canadian Press, 2 December 2005.