Murder of Marianne Vaatstra

Monument for Marianne Vaatstra

Marianne Vaatstra (Dutch pronunciation: [mɑˈrjɑnə ˈvaːtstraː]; born in Zwaagwesteinde on 10 August 1982, died in Veenklooster on 1 May 1999) was a Dutch girl, whose rape and murder became a high-profile criminal case in the Netherlands that was only resolved in 2012, thirteen years after the fact. Vaatstra, then sixteen years old, was last seen alive cycling from Kollum to her parents' house in Zwaagwesteinde. Her body was found the next day, in a field close to Veenklooster, her throat slit.[1] Traces of the perpetrator's blood and semen from were also found at the scene.[2]

The blame was quickly pointed to inhabitants of the local asylum seekers' refuge, and a riot against asylum seekers ensued.[1]

The murder was a cold case until it was reopened in 2012 with large-scale DNA profiling in the area around the crime scene. This led to the arrest of local farmer Jasper S. on 18 November of that year. He confessed to the rape and murder, and was convicted to eighteen years' imprisonment.[3] The case was one of the first in the country to be resolved mainly using DNA evidence and led to widespread debate about the use of DNA for criminal investigations.[4]

Initial investigation and riots

The population of Kollum was quick to blame inhabitants of the local asylum seekers' center for the murder. The center's security was upgraded, and riot police was readied in the weeks following the murder, to intervene in the case of fighting between locals and refugees.[5] At a municipal information meeting in October 1999, about the opening of a new center in the town, locals rioted, with Kollumer youth egging the mayor.[6] At least one woman, who had incited the riots, was convicted for a racist offense.[1]

A first suspect, a 32-year-old man from Zwaagwesteinde, is arrested in late May, but subsequently released because his DNA doesn't match that found at the crime scene. He would become the first in a series of twelve suspects who are similarly arrested and released.[5]

From August 1999, police investigation of Vaatstra's murder focuses on the asylum seekers' center near Kollum. The center's guards had reported that an Iraqi refugee had left the center on the night of the murder, and had been missing since. He was tracked down by Interpol and arrested in Istanbul in October, but the investigation became a national controversy after an official of the Public Prosecution Service had stated the arrest was made under political pressure.[7] The Iraqi was found innocent of the murder by DNA evidence.[7] In 2002, a final decision was made to open an asylum seekers' refuge at the planned location, without drawing local protests.[6]

A DNA sweep is started in December, initially targeting 170 men in the area, of whom 162 cooperate. No match is found. The following year, investigators publish a psychological profile of the perpetrator, who they suspect is a white, Western European male, living less than 15km from the crime scene.[5] Eventually, the case is closed, then reopened in 2002 for a year, and closed again.[5]

Investigation and suspect

The public prosecution service had arrested at least 12 people as a suspect. DNA was collected from more than 900 people as part of a so-called 'large scale DNA-investigation'.

The murder got a lot of attention from the local press. A theme that was mentioned a lot was that they suspected that the murderer could be a civilian from the refugee camp nearby Kollum. Two asylum seekers from Iraq and Afghanistan became suspects, but based on the genetic fingerprints DNA-profiling they were no longer the suspects. The search went on, and it had to be a Dutch perpetrator from the area.

In May of 2006 member of parliament Hilbrand Nawijn called to reinvestigate the police-analyses. In June 2007 and in June 2010 member of parliament Fred Teeven (VVD) asked questions about the case during a meeting. Also the television program Peter R. de Vries, misdaadverslaggever took a lot of time to investigate on this case.

On 29 September 2012 a DNA test, started in a 5 km radius of the crime scene, in which about 8000 males participated.[8]

This investigation was all based on free will, they were looking for men with a Y-chromosome DNA-profile like the perpetrator. This resulted in a DNA-match. On 18 of November, Jasper S. was arrested, a 45-year-old man from Oudwoude, only 2.5 km from the crime scene. The suspect consented to give a sample. On 6 December, Jasper S. confessed to the murder on Marianne Vaatstra.

Story

During the night of May 1, 1999, Jasper saw Marianne on her bike. He stated that he did not know her. Jasper forced Marianne with a knife into the field where she was later found dead. Marianne was sixteen years old when she was found raped and murdered. On September 29, 2012, police began a ‘DNA relationship testing’ in a 5 km radius of the crime scene of approximately 8000 men. In this study, on a voluntary basis, police studied whether there were people who had a similar chromosomal Y-DNA profile as that of the perpetrator. If so, they could try to find a match with familial DNA to trace the killer. On November 19, 2012, police announced it had found a match. Jasper S. was arrested. He did not immediately talk to the police but within 10 minutes of meeting his lawyer, he told him the truth.13 years ago he had raped and murdered Marianne Vaatstra.

In a packed courtroom in Leeuwarden, Jasper S. described how he grabbed 16-year-old Marianne Vaatstra as she walked along a path in Veenklooster, Friesland, on the night of April 30, 1999. S., now 45, said he was hit by the sudden thought: “You’re mine.” He pulled out a pocket knife, seized the girl and raped her before strangling her with her own bra. He then slit her throat with three strokes of the knife. “I don’t know where that thought came from,” he told the court on the first day of a hearing to outline the facts of the case. “I’ve never had that thought before or since. My conscience switched off. I don’t know how or why.” The killing was an act of panic when he realised the consequences of being caught for rape. “I just thought of my family and the discovery and what would happen after that. It all hit me at once.” The murder of Marianne Vaatstra sparked a huge police hunt and sent shockwaves through the quiet Frisian community.

The only clue was a cigarette lighter found at the scene, which had been bought locally and contained a trace of the killer’s DNA. He told the court he had chosen to keep quiet to save his young children from the experience of growing up with a father in prison. “In the last 13 years I considered several times whether to go to the police,” he said. “But everyone could see how much uproar the case had caused. “I’d destroyed her family. I couldn’t change that. I decided to spare my family the pain. My children were five and eight years old at the time.” But he realised that it was a matter of time before the past caught up with him. When police finally gained permission for the unprecedented large-scale DNA sweep,[9] Jasper S. consented to give a sample, knowing that he would otherwise be identified through his close relatives. Even as his unmasking became inevitable, Jasper S. admitted he lacked the “courage” to go to the police confess to the crime. Instead he waited six months for the results to confirm what he knew and the moment that came on the night of November 18 last year, when police arrived at his farm in Oudwoude to arrest him for Marianne Vaatstra’s murder.

Lawsuit

The criminal procedure against Jasper.S started at the 28 March. The requisite of the public prosecutor sums 20 years. On 19 April 2013 the court in Leeuwarden sentenced Japser.S to an imprisonment of 18 years for the rape and murder of Marianne Vaatstra.

Further developments

Vaatstra's father Bauke Vaatstra was awarded the "Machiavelli Prize" in 2013, for forcing a breakthrough in the use of DNA profiling as a means of investigation.[10] The award became controversial after the director the NGO VluchtelingenWerk, which looks after the interests of refugees, filed a complaint against Vaatstra, who allegedly had made death threats against him in 1999. The police did not investigate, since the statute had expired. Vaatstra denied having made the threats.[11]

Later in 2013, author Wim Dankbaar was sued by Vaatstra's mother Maaike Terpstra, when Dankbaar planned to publish her diaries. Dankbaar, a former collaborator of crime reporter Peter R. de Vries (who distanced himself from Dankbaar), cited from the diaries (obtained via a friend of Terpstra's) in the context of his conspiracy theory regarding the murder case.[12]

Another conspiracy theorist, Micha Kat, was arrested in January 2013 for threatening Jasper S.'s lawyer. He had accused the attorney of being "one of Jasper's executioners", involved in a conspiracy to use Jasper S. as a scapegoat. Kat was tried for making death threats, as well as several unrelated allegations, including that of Holocaust denial.[13]

References

  1. 1 2 3 Fons de Poel (24 February 2013). "Vreemdeling uit eigen kring". Brandpunt. KRO.
  2. ↑ "Jasper S. bekende moord meteen aan advocaat". NRC Handelsblad. 6 December 2012.
  3. ↑ "18 jaar voor Jasper S. in zaak Vaatstra". rechtspraak.nl. Netherlands Judiciary. 19 April 2013.
  4. ↑ "Geef jij je wangslijm aan de overheid? Debat over DNA-onderzoek barst los". NRC Handelsblad. 20 November 2012.
  5. 1 2 3 4 "Doorbraak na dertien jaar: de belangrijkste momenten in zaak-Vaatstra". NRC Handelsblad. 19 November 2012.
  6. 1 2 "Toch asielzoekerscentrum Kollum". NRC Handelsblad. 7 June 2002.
  7. 1 2 "Korthals: voldoende verdenking tegen Irakees voor aanhouding". NRC Handelsblad. 26 June 2001.
  8. ↑ www.amsterdamherald.com/index.php/rss/581-20121119-dna-sweep-solves-murder-teenage-girl-13-years-marianne-vaatstra-peter-r-de-vries-veenklooster-friesland-police-om-public-prosecutor-netherlands-dutch-crime
  9. ↑ "DNA sweep solves murder of teenage girl after 13 years". Amsterdam Herald. Amsterdam Herald.
  10. ↑ "Bauke Vaatstra neemt Machiavelliprijs in ontvangst". Algemeen Dagblad. 12 February 2013.
  11. ↑ "Aangifte tegen Bauke Vaatstra - ‘mag Machiavelliprijs niet krijgen’". NRC Handelsblad. 19 January 2013.
  12. ↑ "Moeder Vaatstra eist dwangsom om quotes dagboek". NRC Handelsblad. 11 December 2013. De Vries's distancing himself from Dankbaar happens in the video excerpt from De wereld draait door, at the bottom of the article.
  13. ↑ "Publicist Micha Kat gearresteerd wegens bedreiging advocaat Jasper S.". NRC Handelsblad. 19 January 2013.
This article is issued from Wikipedia - version of the Sunday, April 24, 2016. The text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution/Share Alike but additional terms may apply for the media files.