Pauline Green

Dame Pauline Green DBE
Dame Pauline Green speaking at a co-operative meeting, 2005
President of the International Co-operative Alliance
Incumbent
Assumed office November 2009
Preceded by	Ivano Barberini
Chief Executive of Co-operatives UK
In office 1 January 2000 – 9 October 2009
Preceded by	Lloyd Wilkinson (The Co-operative Union)
Succeeded by	Ed Mayo (Secretary General)
President of ICA Europe
In office 2002 – November 2009
Preceded by	Lars Hillbom
President, Co-operative Congress[1]
In office 1997–1997
Preceded by	GW Money, MBE
Succeeded by	Alan Middleton
Leader of the Parliamentary Group of the Party of European Socialists
In office 1994–1999
Preceded by	Jean-Pierre Cot
Succeeded by	Enrique Barón Crespo
Leader of the European Parliamentary Labour Party
In office June 1993 – 1994
Preceded by	Glyn Ford
Succeeded by	Wayne David
Member of the European Parliament for London London North (1989–1999)
In office 15 June 1989 – 15 December 1999
Preceded by	John Leslie Marshall
Succeeded by	Mary Honeyball
Personal details
Born	Pauline Wiltshire 8 December 1948 Gżira, Crown Colony of Malta
Nationality	British
Political party	Labour and Co-operative
Spouse(s)	Paul Green
Alma mater	Open University, London School of Economics

Dame Pauline Green DBE (born 8 December 1948)^[2] is a former Labour and Co-operative Member of the European Parliament and former Leader of the Parliamentary Group of the Party of European Socialists (PES).^[3] As leader of the PES, she had a central role in the controversy surrounding the failure to discharge the European Commission (EC)'s 1996 budget, bringing the first motion of censure against the Commission but voting against it.^[4] She then changed her position following corruption allegations raised by EC official Paul van Buitenen to call for Jacques Santer (then President of the European Commission) to react promptly or be sacked.^[5] Green lost the leadership of the PES in 1999, which was attributed in part to her handling of the incident.^[6][7][8]

Following her re-election as an MEP in 1999, Green announced that she was retiring politics to take up a position as the first female Chief Executive of Co-operatives UK,^[9] a position that she held until 2009.^[10] Her work with the organisation included sitting on and responding to the recommendations of the Co-operative Commission,^[11] facilitating the organisation's merger with the Industrial Common Ownership Movement (ICOM) and working to "secure and celebrate" the Co-operative Advantage.^[12]

In the 2013 Green was appointed as a Dame Commander of the Most Excellent Order of the British Empire (DBE) while also holding the office of the President of ICA Europe^[13] until her election as President of the International Co-operative Alliance (ICA) in November 2009. As with her appointment to Co-operatives UK, she is the first female president in the organisation's history.^[14]

Early life

Green was born Pauline Wiltshire in Gżira^[2] on the island of Malta to an English soldier serving with the Royal Artillery and his Maltese sweetheart in 1948. The family moved between Malta, Egypt and Germany, following Green's father wherever he was stationed.^[15] As a result, Green spent "a lot of [her] very young days in army barracks" and "missed out on secondary and further education".^[4]

Following her father's return to civilian life, the family moved to Kilburn in London when Green was aged fourteen,^[16] and – acquiescing to her father's wishes that she did something "safe and steady" – Green studied for an Ordinary National Diploma in business studies. She started her career as a secretary with a wallpaper manufacturers, before joining the Metropolitan Police on her 21st birthday.^[4] She later said that it was working on the beat and witnessing first hand the cycle of those caught in poverty turning to crime that turned her into a socialist.^[15]

In 1971, she was working in the West Hampstead division when she met and married PC Paul Green,^[2] resigning from the force in 1974 five months before the birth of her first child.^[4] Paul Green went on to become Chief Superintendent Green, borough commander for Brent, and was awarded the Queen's Police Medal in the 1999 New Year's Honours^[17] before retiring in 2000.^[18] He and Green divorced in 2003.^[19]

Whilst staying at home to look after her two children (a son and a daughter), Green studied for a degree from the Open University. She then spent two full-time years studying at the LSE for an MSc (Econ) in Comparative Government. She spent two years between 1982 and 1984 as a lecturer at Barnet College of Further Education, before becoming an assistant teacher at a Special Educational Unit.^[2] During this period Green was increasing active in local politics,^[4] becoming secretary and then chair of the Chipping Barnet Labour Party, before standing in (and losing) the elections for a seat on the area's council in 1986.^[20] In 1985, she left her teaching career to become Parliamentary Advisor on European Affairs to the Co-operative Union, a position which she left in 1989 as her political career began.^[2]

Political career

Early career

Due to the changing political landscape, Green found that her job increasingly saw her lobbying to Brussels, with her particular interest being a directive backed by the co-operative movement creating common standards for food hygiene across Europe. In June 1989, she announced her intention to stand for a seat in the European elections to help ensure the adoption of the draft directive. She visited "most of the 65 local branches" of the constituency of London North^[4] and won the seat with a majority of 5,387. She was re-elected to the seat in 1994 with a majority of 48,348.^[21]

Green was elected Leader of the European Parliamentary Labour Party (EPLP) in 1993, beating incumbent leader Glyn Ford. She only served for one year, however, after having been chosen and championed by then Labour leader John Smith to become the new leader of the PES.^[4]

At the 1994 Party Leaders' Conference in Corfu, a "package deal" was agreed to fill the upcoming political posts, and it was agreed that Green would take the leadership post with strong backing from the Labour contingent. Green was strongly involved in the fight against Apartheid in South Africa.^[22]

Ian White, an MEP elected at the same time as Green, said: "Although the parliamentary group formally elected Pauline, the "deal" was put together by the national party leaders. I believe that, had it been an open election, she would have won in any case, hands down, on competence alone."^[23]

She held the position for five years (1994–99), and was involved at senior levels of policy making in the European Union and member governments. In 1998 there were rumours that she would stand to be Labour's candidate for Mayor of London. Whilst she expressed an interest in the position, she maintained that she would not be able to commit to the position until after the 1999 leadership elections because of her European commitments.^[24][25]

Controversies

Green was seen as a strong advocate of EU parliamentary and institutional reform: she was vocal in her criticisms of any hint of impropriety, for example calling ex-commissioner Martin Bangemann's appointment to Spanish telecommunications giant Telefonica "sleaze soaked" for the impression it gave that he had used his position in the EC for his own advantage – even though he had broken no rules.^[26] However, her own final year as leader saw its own controversy with allegations of corruption against the EC.

One of the Parliament's duties was to discharge the budget, confirming that the year's spending had been in line with the plans originally set by the EC and that the money had been spent honestly and efficiently. However, the parliamentary budget committee decided that it could not fulfill this duty with regard to the 1996 budget until points concerning the reduction of fraud in the transport system had been clarified. For six months, the debate raged, with Green initially supporting the campaign to discharge the budget (whilst calling for more radical change), but only after a group of specialists that included two senior Socialist MEPs announced that there had been a slight improvement. Parties from the centre and the right began to claim that the PES were only supporting their own members, and ultimately the move to discharge the budget was defeated.

Green speaking in the European Parliament

It was then that Green asserted that the argument would normally be solved in a national democracy by a vote of confidence: since that option did not exist in EU legislation, she instead tabled a motion of censure against the EC. Green explained that "One of the fundamental reasons for tabling this motion of censure was to decide now – immediately – whether or not the European Commission is able to do its work."

Because of their belief that the EC should be allowed to continue its reform work, Green and the PES announced that they would be voting against their own motion of censure^[27] – effectively trying to defeat a call for the sacking of the EC that they had made.^[28]

As the argument continued, the parliament also refused to discharge the 1997 budget – and at the same time, allegations of corruption were made against the French commissioner Édith Cresson. Commission official Paul van Buitenen accused Cresson of having employed her friend and dentist for eight months as a special advisor on the Environment, at a cost of £30,000. The position was described by sub-contractors in sworn statements as a job "for which he is not required to do any work".^[29] The EC agreed to launch an enquiry in return for the parliament ending its moves to censure the commission.^[30]

The eventual report found that the allegations were correct, and Green joined those calling for Santer to respond promptly or risk losing his own position. A second censure motion was tabled, but before it was voted on the entire EC resigned^[31] – although they were still allowed to keep their salaries and jobs as an interim arrangement to electing a new Commission.^[4] Green saw the resignation as an opportunity to improve the running of the EU, in particularly the ability of the parliament to veto the appointment of the next head of the Commission. She said: "We have to use this opportunity to keep pushing for more openness, more transparency, more public control and accountability in the way Europe is run. We now have a real opportunity to go to the voters in the June elections and prove to them that the European Parliament has done its job and changed the political culture of Brussels once and for all."^[32]

The EU member governments – including Tony Blair’s – were not keen on extending the Parliament's powers, but on May Day the Amsterdam Treaty came into effect, which extended their influence somewhat.^[25] The Parliament had the opportunity to vote their approval of new EC head Romano Prodi, and did so 392 votes for to 72 against.^[33] However, Green's stock was damaged by the long controversy, with even her friends and supporters considering that her handling of the affair did not come across as a coherent strategy,^[4] although one commentator at the time did praise the way she had "ridden the Brussels storm with verve and conviction."^[32] It was against this background – and allegations that she had improperly used her official car^[34] that Green dismissed as a "cheap jibe" that had been blown out of all proportion^[25] – that Green had to stand for re-election in her London constituency.

Green retained her seat in the 1999 European Parliament election^[35] with a reduced majority of 26,477.^[36] This was typical of the Labour Party's performance, with its share of the vote slipping from 44.24% in 1994 to 28.03% causing a resultant reduction in seats from 62 to 29.^[37] The European Socialists also did badly in the elections, and lost their dominance of the Parliament,^[38] with the European People's Party becoming the largest group in Parliament.^[39]

Green was asked by Prime Minister Tony Blair to restand for the Parliamentary Group leadership.^[4] However she withdrew when it became clear she faced opposition from Spanish, German and French socialists^[40] to allow the brokering of a deal making Robin Cook to become PES president.^[41] The following September, she also lost her seat on the Labour National Executive Committee, with the slump in her popularity being largely attributed to her earlier handling of the EC "scandal" and Labour's poor performance in the European parliamentary elections.

In November 1999, Green announced that she would be retiring as an MEP to become the first female chief executive of the Co-operative Union, officially taking up the position on New Year's Day 2000.^[9] The decision led to criticism from some quarters, as the mechanics of the electoral system meant that the public would not vote in Green's successor, and instead the next candidate on Labour's list automatically replaced her. Theresa Villiers, a fellow MEP for the Conservatives said Green's "resignation demonstrates a total lack of regard for the electorate".^[42]

Green was caught up in further controversy the following year, regarding the list of voters eligible to decide the Labour candidate for the 2000 London Mayor elections. Complaints were made about Green's inclusion on the list despite her resignation as an MEP^[43] with her vote reported as being "worth a thousand times that of any ordinary member".^[44]

Co-operation

Green already had a track record in the UK co-operative movement. As well as her status as a Labour and Co-operative MEP and advisory position with the Co-operative Union, she had been a Woodcraft Folk leader and was made president of the Industrial Common Ownership Movement (ICOM) in 1999.^[45] As an MEP, she had also been elected President of the 1997 Co-operative Congress.^[46] She was welcomed to the movement by the 2000 Congress President, Pat Wheatley, who described her as "someone of great wisdom, true co-operative principles" and "a shining example of 'courage under fire'" for her work with the PES.^[47]

Holyoake House, head office of Co-operatives UK where Green was Chief Executive

Within two weeks of starting work at the Union, Green sat down with other high profile members of the co-operative movement and drafted a letter to Tony Blair. The letter – signed by Green, Lord Graham of Edmonton, Graham Melmoth, and Len Fyfe – called on the Prime Minister to sponsor a commission to review the co-operative movement and determine its future development and modernisation. The letter arrived against a background of the impending merger of the Co-operative Wholesale Society (CWS) and Co-operative Retail Services to create the Co-operative Group,^[48] as well as recent efforts by entrepreneur Andrew Regan to demutualise the CWS.^[49] Blair responded favourably to the request, and pledged his support in setting up a Co-operative Commission.^[48]

The Commission was officially launched under chair John Monks on 24 February 2000,^[48] with Green being invited to serve as one of the 12 commissioners.^[46] There was a whispering campaign amongst Labour MPs that the Commission was intended to look at the party's funding relationship with the co-operative movement, which Green dismissed as "nonsense."^[49] The Commission's final report was published in January 2001,^[50] leaving Green to begin the work of co-ordinating the Union's response.

The Union began a "deliberate attempt to secure and celebrate [the] co-operative advantage" by increasing its ties with other organisations across the co-operative movement: they began providing professional and admin services for the United Kingdom Co-operative Council (UKCC) and ICOM, and working with co-operative support organisations across the country to establish the "first ever 'all movement' Co-ordination Movement".^[11] This work continued into 2001, with Green using her joint positions in ICOM and the Union to facilitate a merger of the two organisations, bringing together the worker and consumer co-operative sectors that had existed separately for over 100 years.^[51] The membership voted in December 2002 in favour of a change in the Union's name to reflect its new make-up^[52] and in January 2003 the organisation was officially relaunched as Co-operatives UK.^[53]

Green continued to work at "driving a culture change in Co-operatives UK" – for example leading the organisation to become the first co-operative to partner with the National Association of Co-operative Officials (NACO) as its recognised trade union^[54] or successfully opposing recommendations from the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) that would have seen co-operative members' share capital classed as debt, "destroying" the co-operative advantage.^[55]

In October 2002, Green was elected as the President of ICA Europe, the umbrella body for European co-operatives.^[13] This led in turn to her becoming co-chair of Co-operatives Europe in November 2006, sharing her duties with Etienne Pflimlin.^[56] The organisation was formed by ICA Europe and the Co-ordinating Committee of European Co-operative Organisations (CCACE) to "work together on issues of importance to co-operatives in Europe", following a drive by Green for closer co-operation between the major European co-operative bodies.^[57]

Green announced that she intended to retire as chief executive of the organisation in 2009, saying: "I will be 60 at [that time] and I have always intended to retire when I reached that milestone. The Board [of Co-operatives UK] and I agreed that it made sense for me to finish after Co-operative Congress 2009, which is, to all intents and purposes, the end of our co-operative year."^[58] She was succeeded in November 2009 by Ed Mayo.^[59]

Green was elected Chair of the Board of Supporters Direct following her retirement from Co-operatives UK,^[60] and also elected President of the International Co-operative Alliance (ICA). Following her election, she stood down from her position within Co-operatives Europe.

Honours

In 1988, Green was awarded honorary Doctorates from the University of North London and Middlesex University, and was made Commander of the Order of Honour in 1994 by the President of Greece. She has since been awarded the Grand Golden Cross with Star by the President of the Republic of Austria, and been made Grand Commander of the Order of Merit of the Republic of Cyprus.^[2] In the New Year’s Honours 2003 Green was appointed as a Dame Commander of the Most Excellent Order of the British Empire (DBE) "for services to the Co-operative Movement and to the development of the European Union"^[61]

She has been described as "strong, confident and well organised" by Neil Kinnock, "a refreshing no-nonsense figure" by Phillip Whitehead and "guided by common sense and an antagonism (which amounts almost to contempt) towards the superficialities of political image-making" by Roy Hattersley.^[4]

References

1. Congress Presidents 1869 to 2002 (PDF), February 2002, retrieved 1 October 2007
2. Sleeman, Elizabeth (2001), The International Who's Who of Women 2002, Routledge, p. 216, ISBN 1-85743-122-7
3. CMBS Board of Directors, 21 November 2006, archived from the original on 15 December 2007, retrieved 3 October 2007
4. Hattersley, Roy (5 June 1999), "The perils of Pauline", The Guardian, retrieved 29 November 2007
5. Walker, Martin (15 March 1999), "Santer gets 'sack or be sacked' ultimatum over fraud", The Guardian, retrieved 3 October 2007
6. MacAskill, Ewen (4 September 1999), "Skinner back on Labour NEC", Guardian Unlimited, retrieved 3 October 2007
7. "Skinner back on Labour's ruling body", BBC online, 3 September 1999, retrieved 28 September 2007
8. Grice, Andrew (4 September 1999), "Scourge of Blairites is elected to Labour NEC", The Independent, retrieved 3 October 2007
9. "in Brief: Green to Quit Strasbourg", Guardian Unlimited, 27 November 1999, retrieved 3 October 2007
10. The Staff Team, 27 September 2007, archived from the original on 26 October 2007, retrieved 7 November 2007
11. co-operative union ltd annual report & financial statements year ended 31 December 2000, 31 December 2000
12. Green, Pauline (31 December 2000), "Chief Executive & General Secretary's review of the year", co-operative union ltd annual report & financial statements year ended 31 December 2000, pp. 8–9
13. Green, Pauline (11 November 2006), Co-operatives Europe Regional Assembly, Saturday 11 November 2006 Statutory Meeting (PDF), retrieved 2 October 2007
14. New Board of Directors for the International Co-operative Alliance (ICA), November 2009, retrieved 10 December 2009
15. Marshall, Andrew (5 February 1996), "Labour's Other Leader", The Independent
16. Castle, Stephen (12 January 1999), "Former police officer takes centre stage", The Independent
17. "Special Report: 1999: 12: 99: New Years Honours", BBC News, 31 December 1999, retrieved 25 September 2007
18. Bound Volume Hansard – Debate, 23 June 2000, retrieved 25 September 2007
19. Who's Who 2007 (159 ed.), A&C Black, 3 January 2007, ISBN 0-7136-7527-6
20. Former UK Women Members of the European Parliament, 2000, retrieved 26 September 2007
21. United Kingdom European Parliamentary Election results 1979–99: London, 1999, retrieved 28 September 2007
22. Nelson Mandela and Co-operative Movements fight apartheid, thenews.coop; accessed 7 April 2016.
23. Baker, David; Seawright, David (1998), Britain For and Against Europe, Oxford University Press, p. 210, ISBN 0-19-828078-5
24. "To Be Mayor Or Not To Be, That Is The Question", Hillingdon Times, 10 October 1998, retrieved 3 October 2007
25. Mann, Nyta (1 April 1999), "Looking forward to more Euro-trouble", BBC online, retrieved 1 October 2007
26. Walker, Martin (1 July 1999), "Anger as EU commissioner takes top telecom job", The Guardian, retrieved 3 October 2007
27. Debates of the European Parliament: 14 January 1999
28. BBC Democracy Live: 14 January 1999: Crisis in the EU
29. Walker, Martin (25 February 1999), "MEPs brandish new budget stick at commission", The Guardian, retrieved 3 October 2007
30. Walker, Martin (28 January 1999), "Team for Brussels fraud enquiry agreed", The Guardian, retrieved 3 October 2007
31. Walker, Martin (16 March 1999), "EU chiefs resign en masse", The Guardian, retrieved 3 October 2007
32. Walker, Martin (19 March 1999), "British MEP keeps sights set on reform", The Guardian, retrieved 3 October 2007
33. "EU parliament give Prodi vote of approval", The Guardian, 5 May 1999, retrieved 3 October 2007
34. Bates, Stephen (24 May 1999), "Party leaders got cars on the cheap", The Guardian, retrieved 3 October 2007
35. Members elected to the European Parliament, June 1999, 10 June 1999, archived from the original on 28 January 2007, retrieved 26 September 2007
36. European Election 10 June 1999, 10 June 1999, retrieved 28 September 2007
37. European Parliament elections 1999 – Results and explanations : United Kingdom, 10 June 1999, retrieved 26 September 2007
38. Political European Election Study 1999, 2 March 2002, retrieved 1 October 2007
39. Political Groups in the Parliament: European People's Party and European Democrats, 17 February 2006, archived from the original on 12 February 2007, retrieved 1 October 2007
40. Walker, Martin (7 July 1999), "Britain loses leadership of European socialists", Guardian Unlimited, retrieved 3 October 2007
41. Walker, Martin (8 July 1999), "Cook Steers EU Socialists in Balkan Role", Guardian Unlimited, retrieved 3 October 2007
42. Government, 29 November 1999, retrieved 26 September 2007
43. Carr-Brown, Jonathon; Dillon, Jo (20 February 2000), "It's a fix, says Ken as he heads into tight finish", The Independent, retrieved 3 October 2007
44. Seddon, Mark (21 February 2000), "We was robbed", Guardian Unlimited, retrieved 3 October 2007
45. Green, Pauline (1999), Europe and Social Partnership: NCVO Annual Conference Keynote Speech, retrieved 26 September 2007
46. The Co-operative Commission: Choose a Commissioner, 2002, retrieved 1 October 2007
47. Wheatley, Pat (2000), Co-operative Congress Manchester 2000: President's Address
48. Process and Overview, 2002, retrieved 1 October 2007
49. Hyland, Anne (3 March 2000), "Co-op finally puts survival on agenda", The Guardian, retrieved 1 October 2007
50. the co-operative advantage: Creating a successful family of Co-operative businesses, January 2001
51. Green, Pauline (31 December 2001), "Chief Executive & General Secretary's review of the year", Co-operative Union LTD incorporating ICOM – the worker co-op federation Annual Report & Financial Statements 2001, p. 3
52. Green, Pauline (31 December 2002), "New strategic purpose and direction", Co-operatives UK Annual Report & Financial Statements 2002, p. 5
53. History, 13 May 2005, archived from the original on 14 September 2007, retrieved 1 October 2007
54. NACO for all at Co-operatives UK, 13 August 2006, archived from the original on 18 December 2007, retrieved 4 October 2007
55. Co-operativesUK Blocks Major Threat to Co-operatives Movement, 14 February 2005, retrieved 4 October 2007
56. the Espriu Foundation: Information, 11 November 2006, retrieved 2 October 2007
57. Co-operatives to Collaborate on European Stage, 30 April 2004, archived from the original on 12 October 2006, retrieved 2 October 2007
58. Dame Pauline to step down as CEO in 2009, 6 October 2008, retrieved 7 October 2008
59. Welcoming Ed Mayo, 2 November 2009, retrieved 9 November 2009
60. Dame Pauline Green elected Chair of Supporters Direct, 2 November 2009, retrieved 9 November 2009
61. The London Gazette: (Supplement) no. 56797. p. 7. 31 December 2002.

External links

• Co-operatives UK official site
• ICA Europe official site