Railway accidents in Vietnam

Residences directly adjacent to railway tracks in Hanoi.

Railway accidents in Vietnam are common. In 2010, 451 railway accidents were reported across the country's railway network, having caused 211 deaths and 284 injuries.^[1] A joint Japanese-Vietnamese evaluation team reported in 2007 that the poor state of railway infrastructure was the fundamental cause for most railway accidents, of which the most common types were train crashes against vehicles and persons, especially at illegal level crossings; derailments caused by failure to decrease speed were also noted as a common cause of accidents.^[2] As of 2010, around 90% of all railway accidents occurred at level crossings without safety fences, and most were said to have been caused by motorists failing to follow traffic safety laws.^[3][4]

Along with recent efforts aimed at infrastructure rehabilitation, the recent adoption of safety measures by national railway operator Vietnam Railways has led to a decline in railway accidents. These measures include: public awareness campaigns on railway safety in the media; construction of fences and safety barriers at critical level crossings in major cities; mobilization of volunteers for traffic control at train stations and level crossings, especially during holiday seasons; the installation of additional auto-signal systems; and the construction of flyovers and underpasses to redirect traffic.^[2]

Statistics

According to statistics released by Vietnam Railways, 442 railway accidents were reported across the country's railway network in 2008, having caused 190 deaths and 262 injuries; most of these accidents were said to have been caused by motorists failing to follow railway safety regulations.^[5] By way of comparison, the number of fatalities due to railway accidents was recorded as 115 in 1998, and 82 in 1988.^[6] The following table gives recent statistics for railway accidents in Vietnam:

Railway accidents in Vietnam, 2007–2011
Year	Accidents	Fatalities	Injuries
2011[7]	524	263	350
2010[1]	451	211	284
2009[4]	564	208	391
2008[5]	442	190	262
2007[8]	>530	230	n/a[nb 1]

As a whole, railway accidents account for 1.5% to 1.6% of all transportation accidents occurring in Vietnam, contributing to 1.8% to 2.35% of all fatalities and 0.7% to 0.8% of all injuries.^[9] Averaged over a ten-year period from 1988 to 1998, the number of railway accidents taking place at level crossings was recorded as 2,595, or 66.3% of all railway accidents during that period. This rate can also be expressed as 12.34 accidents per million train-km, which is 4 times higher than the accident rate in Canada, and 100 times that of India.^[6]

Types of accidents

Collisions at level crossings

An unprotected level crossing near Da Nang.

Railway accidents in Vietnam occur mainly at unprotected or unauthorized level crossings; as of 2010, around 90% of all accidents were reported to occur at level crossings without safety fences. A study carried out by Vietnam Railways in 2010 noted that, out of 5,400 level crossings in Vietnam, only 750 (or 14%) were manned or had alarm systems to signal the arrival of trains. Along the North–South Railway line, 3,650 level crossings were counted, 3,000 (or 82%) of which had no barriers, alarm systems or guards. The city of Hanoi, along with the provinces of Nghệ An, Khánh Hòa and Đồng Nai have the highest density of road-rail crossings.^[3]

While on a visit to Vietnam to evaluate infrastructure development projects sponsored by the Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA), researcher A. Maria Toyoda noted "There are numerous safety issues with level crossings, residences right up against the tracks, and other areas of activity that are dangerously close ... People will cross the tracks at great risk, dodging in front of the train. ...usually, an accident occurs every day."^[10] In the first 10 months of 2009, 431 railway accidents reportedly took place throughout Vietnam, causing 166 casualties and injuring 319 people.^[11]

Derailments

Failure by train drivers to decrease speed along dangerous sections of track occasionally cause derailments;^[2] the 2005 Phú Lộc derailment is one such example, which led to 13 casualties and hundreds of injuries when a train derailed along the Hải Vân Pass between Da Nang and Huế. Weather can also be a factor in derailments, as seen on September 6, 2010, when a passenger train from Hanoi to Lào Cai was derailed by a landslide that followed several days of heavy rain, killing two people.^[12]

Bridge failure

Main railway lines have a maximum speed of 70 km/h (43 mph), but trains regularly slow to 30 km/h (19 mph) (and even 5 km/h (3.1 mph) in some cases) around bridges, many of which were damaged during the war and which still suffer from structural safety problems.^[13] Along with speed limits, weight limits are also in place on bridges.^[2] At least one major railway accident, the 1953 Col des Nuages derailment, happened due to a bridge failure; however, the failure was due to a bomb attack carried out by the Viet Minh, rather than pre-existing structural weakness.

Prevention

Rehabilitation and development

A level crossing in Da Nang, before and after the installation of full-height fences.

The condition of railway infrastructure in Vietnam, although improving, is still poor enough overall to require rehabilitation. Rail transport only became a national priority for the Vietnamese government around the mid-1990s, at which point most of the railway network was severely degraded, having received only temporary repair from damages suffered during decades of war.^[2][14]

From 1994 to 2005, a major bridge rehabilitation project took place on the North–South Railway line, with the Pacific Consultants International Group and Japan Transportation Consultants providing consultancy services. The overall project cost was JPY 11,020 million, or 18% less than the budgeted cost. The overall results of the project included a reduction in running hours from one end of the line to the other (from 36 hours in 1994 to 29 hours in 2007); an increase of speed limits on rehabilitated bridges (from 15 to 30 km/h (9.3 to 18.6 mph) to 60 to 80 km/h (37 to 50 mph)), which contributed to the reduction in running hours; and a reduction in the number of railway accidents throughout the line.^[2]

Workers dig up the shoulder near the North–South Railway, in Da Nang.

In 2007, Vietnam Railways awarded an additional VND 150 billion (USD 9.5 million) five-year contract for consultancy services to Japan Transportation Consultants, the Pacific Consultants International Group, and the Japan Railway Technical Service (Jarts), regarding a VND 2.47 trillion project to further improve bridge and railway safety on the North–South line. The project's goals include the refurbishment of 44 bridges and 37.6 km (23.4 mi) of railway tracks, the building of two new railway bridges and a new railway station at Ninh Bình, and the purchase of 23 track machines. The project was expected to be completed in 2010.^[15]

Improving maintenance has been identified as a priority for the rail transport sector, specifically maintenance and repair work in rail workshops due to its direct impact on passenger safety.^[14] In some cases, a lack of proper maintenance of infrastructure can contribute to accidents even when safety measures are in place. On November 22, 2009, for instance, nine people were killed when a bus collided with a southbound train at a level crossing in Hanoi; one set of warning lights at the crossing was out of order, and the other set had collapsed.^[16] The replacement of old and damaged rolling stock is also a priority; a 2006 report by the Japanese Ministry of Foreign Affairs identified the poor condition of trains and rolling stock as a major cause in 50% of railway accidents.^[9]

Besides the above, Vietnam Railways has taken a number of other steps to improve railway safety, including the construction of fences and safety barriers at critical level crossings in major cities, the installation of additional auto-signal systems, and the construction of flyovers and underpasses to redirect traffic around railway lines.^[2]

Education and policy

A number of education and training initiatives have been proposed or carried out by Vietnam Railways. Public awareness campaigns in the media have been carried out to educate the public about railway safety.^[2] The training and professional development of train operators has also been suggested as a major area of focus. One train driver interviewed in 2009 reported that he had worked as a driver for Vietnam Railways for over 10 years without receiving any training or professional development to improve his skills, which he had learned in Russia. Checks on drivers have also been suggested, along with random blood testing to detect whether drivers have used alcohol.^[4]

The Japanese Ministry of Foreign Affairs has identified poor management practices and the weak enforcement of safety laws and regulations as contributing to railway accidents as well.^[9] To ensure the enforcement of safety laws, railway authorities have announced their intention to increase the number of spot checks on safety at level crossings, prevent people from using unauthorised crossings, and build more access roads to level crossings.^[3] Volunteers have also been mobilized to provide traffic control at both level crossings and train stations, especially during holiday seasons.^[2]

List of notable accidents

The Hải Vân Pass, the scene of one of Vietnam's earliest documented rail accidents.

As discussed above, the state of railway safety in Vietnam lends itself to frequent accidents, many of them fatal. Although listing them all would be impractical, certain notable accidents can be highlighted.

• June 24, 1953 – 1953 Col des Nuages derailment: "About 100 or more" were killed when two locomotives and 18 cars of a passenger train plunged 50 feet through a sabotaged viaduct in the Col des Nuages, now known as the Hai Van Pass. Officials said that a strong explosive charge went off just as the train arrived at the viaduct, tumbling a 25-foot span into the ravine. The pass had frequently been the scene of attacks by the Viet Minh.^[17]
• 1982 - In what has been called "the worst tragedy" in Vietnam's railway history, over 200 people were killed when a train running from Nha Trang to Ho Chi Minh City lost control at speeds of over 100 km/h and derailed near Bàu Cá, Đồng Nai Province, scattering the locomotives and coaches throughout the nearby terrain.^[18]
• August 4, 2003 – Fourteen Vietnamese war veterans were killed on their way to visit historical sites when their minibus collided with a southbound train at a crossing in Cam Lộ District, Quảng Trị Province. Twelve people were declared dead at the scene, while two more later died of their injuries.^[19]
• March 12, 2005 – 2005 Phú Lộc derailment: An express passenger train on the North–South Railway derailed in central Vietnam, killing 11 people and injuring hundreds, many of which were in a serious condition after the crash. The accident occurred near the Hai Van Pass, in Phú Lộc District, Thừa Thiên–Huế Province while the train was traveling southbound from Hanoi to Ho Chi Minh City.^[20]
• February 8, 2007 – An express train collides with a "passenger car" in Khánh Hòa Province, killing 13 people and injuring 24, most of whom were returning home on the occasion of Tết.^[21]
• November 22, 2009 – Nine people were killed when a bus returning from an engagement ceremony collided with a southbound train at a level crossing in Thuong Tin, Hanoi. One set of warning lights at the crossing was out of order, and the other set had collapsed.^[16]
• February 6, 2011 – A SE-2 Saigon-Hanoi passenger train collided head-on with 6 vehicles including cars and pick-up trucks at a one-lane rail-road bridge in Biên Hòa, killing 2 people and injured 26. The vehicles and other scooter riding commuters on the bridge were unable to move due to a traffic jam and the accident was blamed on human failure to signal the incoming train to stop.^[22]
• March 30, 2011 – Again in Thuong Tin, Hanoi, a minibus carrying 18 people to a wedding collided with northbound cargo train at an ungated level crossing. The accident killed 9 people and left 6 injured, all in the same family.^[23]
• March 10, 2015 - The Dien Sanh train crash occurred when a passenger train struck a lorry obstructing the line on a level crossing near Dien Sanh station, Quảng Trị Province, Vietnam. One person was killed and four were seriously injured.^[24]

See also

• Rail transport in Vietnam

Notes and references

Notes

1. Statistics not available.

References

1. Gần 500 người chết do tai nạn đường sắt năm 2010. Muabanoto.vn. January 6, 2011. Vietnamese.
2. "Hanoi-Ho Chi Minh City Railway Bridge Rehabilitation Project" (PDF). Japan International Cooperation Agency. 2007. Retrieved 2010-06-30.
3. Unsafe rail crossing kill 300. VietnamNet. August 2, 2010.
4. "Alcohol tests urged for train drivers". Bao Moi. Vietnam News Service. 2009-12-29. Retrieved 2011-01-07.
5. Báo động tai nạn giao thông đường sắt tại đường ngang. Cục cảnh sát giao thông đường bộ, đường sắt. January 14, 2009. Vietnamese.
6. Evaluation of Cost-Effective Systems for Railway Level-Crossing Protection (ST/ESCAP/2088). UNESCAP. 2000.
7. Tai nạn đường sắt liên tục: Bất thường!. VietnamNet. February 6, 2012. Vietnamese.
8. Năm 2007: Tai nạn giao thông đường sắt tăng 9%. Vietbao.vn. January 10, 2008.
9. Vietnam-Japan Joint Evaluation on the Japanese ODA Program for the Transport Infrastructure Development in the Red River Delta Area of the Socialist Republic of Vietnam. Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Government of Japan. February 2006.
10. A.Maria Toyoda (2007-08-17). "Report to JBIC on Expert Evaluation Mission to Northern Vietnam and the Philippines: Refocusing on Infrastructure" (PDF). Retrieved 2010-07-20.
11. "Những điểm giao cắt đường sắt nguy hiểm giữa thủ đô". VNExpress.net. 2009-11-25. Retrieved 2010-07-22. (Vietnamese)
12. "2 killed in tourist train derailment in Vietnam". Xinhua. 2010-09-06. Retrieved 2011-01-07.
13. "Proposed Loan and Administration of Loan from Agence Française de Développement: Yen Vien–Lao Cai Railway Upgrading Project" (pdf). November 2006. Retrieved 2010-06-27.
14. Evaluation of development activities - 2009/1. Ministry for the Economy, Industry and Employment. Government of France. April 2009.
15. "Vietnam to upgrade trunk route". International Railway Journal. September 2005. Retrieved 2010-07-22.
16. Nine killed as bus hits train on northern railway. VietnamNet. November 26, 2009.
17. Fort Walton Beach, Florida, "Indochina Rail Crash Kills 100". Playground News, 25 June 1953, Volume 8, Number 22, p. 8.
18. Tran Dinh Ba. Minister of Transport should ‘travel incognito’ on railway. VietnamNet Bridge. 2011-11-16.
19. "14 killed in Vietnam train smash". ABC.net.au. 2003-08-04. Retrieved 2011-01-07.
20. Vietnam train derail kills 11, injuring 200. Xinhua. March 13, 2005.
21. "Tragic train accident kills 13". VietnamNet. 2007-02-09. Retrieved 2011-01-07.
22. "Tàu hỏa đâm 6 ô tô, 2 người chết", veitnamnet.vn, 7 February 2011
23. "Tàu hỏa húc xe khách, 9 người đi ăn cưới tử nạn". vnexpress.net (in Vietnamese) (Vnexpress). 30 March 2011.
24. "Tàu hỏa đâm xe tải, lái tàu chết tại chỗ" [The train crashed into the lorry, driver was killed instantly] (in Vietnamese). Vietnam News. 11 March 2015. Retrieved 12 March 2015.