Robert J. Cindrich

Robert Cindrich
Judge of the United States District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania
In office October 7, 1994 – January 30, 2004
Appointed by	Bill Clinton
Preceded by	Gustave Diamond
Succeeded by	Nora Barry Fischer
Personal details
Born	September 22, 1943 Washington, Pennsylvania, U.S.
Alma mater	Wittenberg University University of Pittsburgh School of Law

Robert James Cindrich (born September 22, 1943) is a former U.S. district judge and a former federal judicial nominee to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit.

Early life and education

Born in Washington, Pennsylvania, Cindrich earned a bachelor's degree from Wittenberg University in 1965 and earned a law degree magna cum laude from the University of Pittsburgh School of Law in 1968. After law school, Cindrich clerked for Third Circuit Court of Appeals Judge Ruggero Aldisert from 1968 until 1969.^[1]

Professional career prior to becoming a judge

After a stint as a U.S. Army Reserve specialist from 1968 until 1971, Cindrich worked for Allegheny County, Pennsylvania as an assistant public defender from 1969 until 1970 and as an assistant district attorney from 1970 until 1972. Cindrich shifted to private legal practice from 1972 until 1978. Cindrich served as a U.S. attorney for the Western District of Pennsylvania from 1978 until 1981, when he again returned to private legal practice until being appointed to the federal bench.^[1] While Cindrich was in private practice, he hired future Third Circuit Judge Thomas Hardiman as an associate at his firm.^[2]

Federal judicial service

On August 12, 1994, President Clinton nominated Cindrich to become a judge for the United States District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania. The U.S. Senate unanimously confirmed Cindrich in a voice vote on October 6, 1994.^[3]

Nomination to the Third Circuit

On February 9, 2000, President Clinton nominated Cindrich for a seat on the Third Circuit, to replace Timothy K. Lewis, who had resigned at age 44 to work in private practice.^[4] With Republicans in control of the Senate in the final year of Clinton's presidency, however, Cindrich's nomination languished, never receiving a hearing before the U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee. Cindrich's nomination to the Third Circuit was terminated with the end of Clinton's presidency.

In 2001, President Bush nominated D. Brooks Smith to the Third Circuit seat to which Cindrich had been nominated. Smith was confirmed by the U.S. Senate the following year.

Resignation and life after being a judge

On January 5, 2004, Cindrich announced that he would resign as district judge on January 30, 2004 to become chief legal counsel to the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, effective February 1, 2004. Cindrich said he was quitting in part for financial reasons, noting that his lifetime salary offered no survivor's benefit for his wife. "If death takes me early, she is stuck," he told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette in an article that appeared on January 6, 2004. "She gets zero. In the private sector, by federal law, every pension must contain a survivor's benefit." Cindrich said he also was frustrated by strict sentencing guidelines that he believed removed discretion from judges.^[5] "When the law provides a result that is repugnant, we must still follow the law," Cindrich told the Associated Press in a story that appeared in its feed on February 2, 2004. "And you can only do that so many times before you start to wonder, 'How many more times am I going to put my name on this sentence that I don't believe in?'"^[6]

See also

• Bill Clinton judicial appointment controversies

References

1. History of Western District of Pennsylvania
2. Judge Hardiman considered for federal appeals post
3. Judges of the United States Courts
4. President Clinton Nominates Robert J. Cindrich, Kent R. Markus, John Antoon II, and Phyllis J. Hamilton to the Federal Bench, The White House - Office of the Press Secretary (February 9, 2000).
5. Federal Judge Steps Down to Become Chief Counsel to Pittsburgh Medical Center. | Pittsburgh Post-Gazette (Pittsburgh, PA) (, 2004)
6. Dissenting Opinions: More Judges Leaving Bench for Better Pay

External links

• Robert J. Cindrich at the Biographical Directory of Federal Judges, a public domain publication of the Federal Judicial Center.