Robert Kean

Robert W. Kean
Member of the U.S. House of Representatives from New Jersey's 12th district
In office January 3, 1939 – January 3, 1959
Preceded by	Frank W. Towey, Jr.
Succeeded by	George M. Wallhauser
Essex County Republican Chairman
In office June 1959 – June 1962
Personal details
Born	Robert Winthrop Kean September 28, 1893 Elberon, New Jersey, U.S.
Died	September 21, 1980 (aged 86) Livingston, New Jersey, U.S.
Political party	Republican
Spouse(s)	Elizabeth Stuyvesant Howard (1898-1988)
Relations	Thomas Kean, Jr. (Grandson) Hamilton Fish Kean (Father) John Kean (Uncle) John Kean (Great-Great-Grandfather) Moses Taylor (Great-Grandfather)
Children	Katherine W. Kean Robert W. Kean, Jr. Hamilton Fish Kean II Elizabeth Kean Hicks Rose Kean Lansbury Thomas Kean
Residence	Livingston, New Jersey
Alma mater	Harvard University (1915)
Occupation	Banker
Religion	Presbyterian

Robert Winthrop Kean (September 28, 1893 – September 21, 1980) was an American Republican Party politician and member of one of the nation's oldest and longest serving political families.^[1] He served ten terms in the United States House of Representatives representing New Jersey.

Early Years

Kean was born September 28, 1893 in Elberon, New Jersey. His father, Hamilton Fish Kean (1862-1941), was a United States Senator from New Jersey and his son, Thomas Kean, served two terms as the Governor of New Jersey. Robert Kean was the great-great-grandson of John Kean, a Delegate to the Continental Congress from South Carolina (1756-1795). His uncle, John Kean (1852-1914), was also a United States Senator from New Jersey. His grandson, Thomas Kean, Jr., is presently the Minority Leader of the New Jersey State Senate. His mother, Katherine Taylor Winthrop (1866-1943), was a descendant of John Winthrop, a wealthy English Puritan lawyer and one of the leading figures in the founding of the Massachusetts Bay Colony, the first major settlement in what is now New England after Plymouth Colony. Winthrop led the first large wave of migrants from England in 1630, and served as governor for 12 of the colony's first 20 years of existence. Kean is also a descendant of William Livingston, the first Governor of New Jersey.

His maternal great-grandfather was Moses Taylor (1806-1882), a 19th-century New York merchant and banker and one of the wealthiest men of that century. At his death, his estate was reported to be worth $70 million, or about $1.7 billion in today's dollars. He controlled the National City Bank of New York (later to become Citibank), the Delaware, Lackawanna & Western railroad, the Moses Taylor & Co. import business, and he held numerous other investments in railroads and industry. His real estate holdings in New York brought him into close association with Boss Tweed of New York's Tammany Hall, and in 1871, Taylor sat on a committee made up of New York's most influential and successful businessmen and signed his name to a report that commended Tweed's controller for his honesty and integrity, a report that was a notorious whitewash.

He was a 1911 graduate of St. Mark's School and a 1915 graduate of Harvard University. He served in the National Guard and later in the United States Army during World War I earning the rank of lieutenant, the Silver Star, and the Distinguished Service Cross.^[2] He served under the command of General John J. Pershing.^[3]

Kean became involved in politics at a young age. In 1905, His uncle got him appointed as a U.S. Senate page so he could observe the Inauguration of President Theodore Roosevelt. He attended the 1912 Republican National Convention, where he was escorted by his uncle's secretary, Donald H. McLean, with whom he would late serve in Congress. Young Kean was a Roosevelt supporter, although his uncle and father had publicly endorsed the incumbent President, William Howard Taft. After he returned from the war, Kean took on campaign responsibilities on behalf of his father, who was the Republican National Committeeman from New Jersey from 1918 to 1928. He was heavily involved in his father's successful campaign for the U.S. Senate in 1928, and his unsuccessful 1934 re-election bid.^[3]

After the war, Kean worked in investment banking in New Jersey and New York City, heading a firm known as Kean, Taylor & Company. He was a founder of the Livingston National Bank.^[2]

U.S. Congressman

Kean became a candidate for the U.S. House of Representatives in 1938, running in New Jersey's 12th congressional district.^[4] Republicans had held the seat from 1914 until 1936, when Democrat Frank W. Towey, Jr. won it on the coattails of President Franklin Roosevelt's re-election. The seat was viewed as likely to return Republican, and six Republicans sought the nomination in the September 20 primary. Kean won by a narrow 713 vote margin, 13,923 to 13,210 over Montclair Town Commissioner Dallas S. Townsend.^[5] Kean was endorsed by the "Clean Government" faction of the Essex GOP, while Townsend had the backing of the "Suburban Republican" faction.^[6] In the General Election, Kean defeated Towey by 12,118 votes, 48,854 (55%) to 36,736 (41%).^[7]

Kean was re-elected in 1940 (54%), 1942 (61%), 1944 (51%), 1946 (64%), 1948 (51%), 1950 (53%), 1952 (55%), 1954 (53%), and 1956 (60%).^[8] He was not a candidate for re-election to an 11th term in 1958 and was succeeded by Republican George M. Wallhauser.

During his twenty years as a Congressman, Kean was the Ranking Minority Member of the House Ways and Means Committee and served on the House Banking and Currency Committee. He was considered an expert on Social Security and Taxation law, and was called "Mr. Social Security" in Washington.^[9]

Campaign for U.S. Senate

Kean was close to announcing his candidacy for the United States Senate in 1954. By early 1954, New Jersey Republican leaders had decided to withdraw party support for the incumbent Senator, Robert C. Hendrickson. Two Republicans, former U.S. Rep. Clifford Case and former New Jersey State Treasurer Walter Margetts had already announced their candidacies. Kean wanted tor run, and had secured commitments of endorsements from several key GOP leaders, but he refused to announce his own campaign until Hendrickson declared his intentions publicly. Hendrickson waited until the day before the filing deadline to say he was retiring. That was too late for Kean, who filed as a candidate for re-election to the House.^[10]

U.S. Senator H. Alexander Smith decided not to seek re-election in 1958 and Kean became a candidate for the open seat in the United States Senate. He won the Republican Primary by 23894 votes over Bernard M. Shanley, who had served as Deputy Chief of Staff to President Dwight Eisenhower. Kean received 152,884 votes (43.00%) to 128,990 (36.28%) for Shanley. Robert J. Morris, who had served as Chief Counsel to the United States Senate Subcommittee on Internal Security, finished third with 73,658 votes (20.72%).^[8]

The 1958 Election occurred in the middle of President Eisenhower's second term. As is common in midterm elections, the party in the White House lost seats, but losses that year were on a huge scale, perhaps due to the high unemployment of the Recession of 1958. The Eisenhower Administration's position on right-to-work issues galvanized labor unions which supported Democrats. The launch of Sputnik may also have been a factor. The Democratic Party took thirteen Republican seats (10 of them by defeating incumbents), and also won both Senate seats in the new state of Alaska. Senate elections in 1959 in the new state of Hawaii were split between the two parties; combined with the 1958 results, this yielded an aggregate gain of 16 seats for the Democrats for a party balance of 65-35. This was the second-largest swing in the history of the Senate, only behind the Republican gains of 18 seats in 1866, and is only the third time in U.S.history that 10 or more Senate seats changed hands in a midterm election (after 1866 and 1946).

Kean was unable to buck the national political tide, and lost the General Election to Democrat Harrison A. Williams, a former Congressman. Kean lost by 84,545 votes, 966,832 (51.39%)to 882,287 (46.90%).^[8]

Essex County Republican Chairman

Kean made a political comeback in 1959, challenging incumbent William Yeomans for Essex County Republican Chairman. Essex County Republicans were divided into two factions; Kean organized a slate of reform candidates opposed to Yeomans headed by Alfred C. Clapp, a popular former State Senator and Superior Court Judge. Yeomans backed Essex County Prosecutor Charles V. Webb, Jr. for the State Senate, but Clapp won the nomination by a massive 20,000 vote margin (72%-28%). All twelve Assembly candidates running on the Kean/Clapp line won the primary. Yeomans dropped his re-election bid, clearing the way for Kean to take over what was viewed as the most powerful Republican organization in the state.^[11] Among the political newcomers who ran on the Clapp ticket was C. Robert Sarcone.

Kean had a tough time as a party leader. Democrats held the Essex County State Senate seat, with incumbent Donal C. Fox defeating Clapp in the General Election; Democrats won five of Essex County's twelve Assembly seats in 1959, and eight of the nine seats in 1961. Kean backed the losing candidate in the 1961 Republican gubernatorial primary, Bergen County State Senator Walter H. Jones. A Kean rival, former U.S. Attorney William F. Tompkins, challenged Kean for re-election in 1961 after Tompkins' candidate, former U.S. Secretary of Labor, James P. Mitchell, won the gubernatorial nomination. Kean beat Tompkins, 409 to 268.^[12]

Kean stepped down as County Chairman in 1962 and endorsed former Livingston Mayor Andrew C. Axtell as his successor. Tompkins ran again, but Axtell beat him 438 to 416.^[13]

Retirement and Family

Kean married Elizabeth Stuyvesant Howard on October 18, 1920 in New York City. Following the death of his uncle, Alexander Kean, in 1922, Kean inherited an estate and mansion in Livingston, New Jersey, where they moved in 1924.^[3] They had six children: three sons, Robert, Hamilton and Thomas, and three daughters, Elizabeth, Rose and Katharine.^[14]

Kean died in Livingston on September 21, 1980, at Saint Barnabas Medical Center due to a heart attack.^[2]

Honors

Kean University is named in honor of Robert Kean and the Kean family and its Liberty Hall Campus houses the historic property and home of the Kean family.^[2]

Electoral history

General Elections

Office	Year	Republican	Votes	Democrat	Votes
U.S. House of Representatives	1938	Robert W. Kean	48,854	Frank W. Towey, Jr. (Incumbent)	36,736
U.S. House of Representatives	1940	Robert W. Kean	67,996	Thomas J. Holleran	53,677
U.S. House of Representatives	1942	Robert W. Kean	43,942	Joseph Siegler	26,188
U.S. House of Representatives	1944	Robert W. Kean	67,680	John W. Suling	63,087
U.S. House of Representatives	1946	Robert W. Kean	55,732	Raymond C. Connell	30,389
U.S. House of Representatives	1948	Robert W. Kean	63,232	Harry Dudkin	58,495
U.S. House of Representatives	1950	Robert W. Kean	54,123	Harry Dudkin	45,525
U.S. House of Representatives	1952	Robert W. Kean	84,949	Martin S. Fox	70,046
U.S. House of Representatives	1954	Robert W. Kean	59,151	Martin S. Fox	52,314
U.S. House of Representatives	1956	Robert W. Kean	90,032	Irving L. Hodes	58,364
United States Senate	1958	Robert W. Kean	882,287	Harrison A. Williams	966,832

Primary Elections

Office	Year	Republican	Votes
U.S. House of Representatives	1938	Robert W. Kean	13,923
U.S. House of Representatives	1938	Dallas S. Townsend	13,210
U.S. House of Representatives	1938	Harold W. Phillhower	2,161
U.S. House of Representatives	1938	Maurice J. McKeown	777
U.S. House of Representatives	1938	A. Frank Zega	442
U.S. House of Representatives	1938	Clarence A. Seaman	431
United States Senate	1958	Robert W. Kean	152,884
United States Senate	1958	Bernard M. Shanley	128,990
United States Senate	1958	Robert J. Morris	73,658

References

1. Roberts, Sam. "Early Census Is Found in a New Jersey University’s Files", The New York Times, May 18, 2010. Accessed February 24, 2011. "Kean (pronounced cane), a merchant, originally used the ledger, made in England in the early 18th century, to keep track of his accounts and later was chosen by Washington to audit the Revolutionary Army."
2. Cook, Joan (24 September 1980). "Robert W. Kean, 86; Formerly in House; Jersey Republican Won Reputation as Expert on Social Security". New York Times. Retrieved 11 January 2015. Robert Winthrop Kean, a former United States Representative and for years a leading figure in Republican politics in New Jersey, died Sunday in St. Barnabas Medical Center, Livingston, N.J., from a heart attack. He was 86 years old and lived in Livingston.
3. Felzenberg, Alvin (2006). Governor Tom Kean: From the New Jersey Statehouse to the 911 Commission. Rutgers University Press. p. 10.
4. "R. W. Kean in Congress Race". New York Times. 3 June 1938.
5. "Results of the Primary Election" (PDF). New Jersey Division of Elections. State of New Jersey. Retrieved 11 January 2015.
6. "Barbour-Ely Vote Surprises Jersey; Large 'Complimentary' Count for Senate Rivals Draws Wide Interest in State Vreeland and Kean Win Baird Groups to Control". New York Times. 22 September 1938.
7. "Results of the General Election" (PDF). New Jersey Division of Election. State of New Jersey. Retrieved 11 January 2015.
8. "Our Campaigns". www.ourcampaigns.com. Retrieved 11 January 2015.
9. Meislin, Richard W. (21 September 1981). "Kean Ends Urban Tour, Terming Trip a Lesson". New York Times. Retrieved 11 January 2015.
10. Edge, Wally (3 June 2007). "Twenty years before Watergate, Rodino almost gave up his House seat to run statewide". PolitickerNJ.com. Retrieved 14 January 2015.
11. Wright, George Cable. "Regular Sweep G.O.P. Essex Vote; Clapp Is Victorious -- Other Party Organization Slates Win -- Balloting Is Light". New York Times.
12. "Democrats in Essex Re-Elect Carey, 2-1". New York Times. 26 April 1961.
13. Wright, George Cable (25 April 1962). "G.O.P. Chairman Elected in Essex; Axtell Wins--433-416 Vote Is Closest in Years Defeats Become Issue". New York Times.
14. "Elizabeth S. Kean, 90, Mother of Governor". New York Times. 29 January 1988. Retrieved 11 January 2015.

External links

• United States Congress. "Robert Kean (id: K000029)". Biographical Directory of the United States Congress. Retrieved on 2008-01-26