Rudolf Schwarz (conductor)

Rudolf Schwarz

Rudolf Schwarz CBE (29 April 1905 – 30 January 1994) was an Austrian-born conductor of Jewish ancestry. He became a British citizen and spent the latter half of his life in England.

Biography

Early life

Schwarz was born in a Jewish family in Vienna and at the age of six began piano lessons followed shortly by the violin. His father was opposed to his son's ambition to become a conductor and money for music lessons and gallery tickets at the Opera came from him given lessons himself.^[1] He studied with the composers Richard Robert, Hans Gál and Richard Strauss.^[2] At the age of 17 he played viola in the Vienna State Opera orchestra and Vienna Philharmonic, in 1922, and he made his conducting debut in Düsseldorf as assistant to Georg Szell in 1924. Schwarz also acted as director of the choral society in Rheydt.^[1]

Conducting in Germany

After opera experience in Düsseldorf, Schwarz moved to Karlsruhe in 1927 as first conductor at the State Theatre alongside Josef Krips and Joseph Keilberth. There, he conducted all Wagner operas except Tristan und Isolde, and led symphony concerts. The Civil Service Law of 7 April 1933 led to his dismissal by the Nazis because he was Jewish.^[2][3]

In 1936, he became a director of the Kulturbund Deutscher Juden (JKB) in Berlin, a German-Jewish cultural organization backed by the Nazi Propaganda Ministry of Joseph Goebbels,^[3] which allowed Jewish artists to perform for Jewish audiences. He also conducted in Gothenburg between 1936 and 1938. The Nazis imprisoned him from 1939 to 1940. When the JKB was dissolved in 1941, he was deported to Auschwitz, but Wilhelm Furtwängler's wife Zitla secured his release. He was then sent to Sachsenhausen and ended up in Belsen concentration camp in 1945.^[4] While at Auschwitz, he suffered a broken shoulder-blade, which inhibited his gestures as a conductor in later life.^[2] The effects of this injury on his conducting style can be seen in a DVD of him conducting the finale of the Brahms Violin Concerto with David Oistrakh in May 1958.^[5]

It is not clear why Schwarz did not attempt to leave Germany in 1939. Possible explanations include the security of his employment with JKB and the difficulty of finding work elsewhere.^[6]

Career in Britain

After the end of World War II, Schwarz went to Sweden to recover from typhoid,^[7] and there met his future second wife Greta. In 1946 he received an offer to join Berlin Opera as conductor, which he refused.^[1]

He was preparing to go to America when in 1947 his brother in London sent him an advertisement for a post in Bournemouth. After the trial concerts, the orchestra voted unanimously for his appointment in 1947 to lead the newly reformed Bournemouth Municipal Orchestra, despite objections from the Musicians' Union which tried to prevent his appointment on the grounds that there were already too many non-British musicians in the country.^[1] He was central to rebuilding the Bournemouth Municipal Orchestra, with notable performances of Beethoven's 9th Symphony, Mahler's The Song of the Earth with Kathleen Ferrier and Richard Lewis, and Arnold Bax's 3rd Symphony at the Festival Hall in 1951.^[8] The workload was immense, as Schwarz was required to lead 150 concerts in his first season.

Schwarz received praise from Thomas Beecham as an "able conductor" for his work with the Bournemouth orchestra,^[9] and subsequently held Principal Conductor positions with the City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra (1951–1957) and the BBC Symphony Orchestra. With the BBC SO, he was praised for his efforts "to reach the truth of the music".^[10] However, in the 1961-1962 season his interpretation of Mahler's Symphony No. 9 was criticized in the press as "blatant misrepresentation", and as moving "from bad to worse".^[10] In addition to press criticism, Schwarz contended with the appointment in 1959 of William Glock as Director of Music at the BBC. Conflict between Glock and Schwarz over such matters as style and repertoire may have contributed to the conductor's departure from the organization in 1962.^[4]

In 1964, Schwarz was appointed Artistic Director and Principal Conductor of the Northern Sinfonia, where he served until 1973.^[11] Schwarz returned to Bournemouth as a regular guest from 1970 to 1979, and also held guest appointments in Bergen, and with the English Opera Group and National Youth Orchestra. In June 1973 he was appointed a Commander of the Order of the British Empire (CBE).^[12]

Rudolf Schwarz died in London in 1994, aged 88.

Musicianship

Schwarz received much praise from Northern Sinfonia musicians who played under him: violinist Martin Hughes said that his "sense of rhythm, structure and tempo was exceptional"^[2] and clarinettist George McDonald reflected that "he made the Sinfonia listen to themselves -- blend with each other ... he helped form the Orchestra's style and gave them musical discipline."^[2]

Oboist Janet Craxton praised his selflessness, while David Patmore considers that he "may not have been a great conductor, but he certainly was a great musician".^[4]

Simon Rattle acknowledged Schwarz as a "formative influence" who taught him "the paramount importance of imposing his pulse on the music he played".^[13] According to Rattle, Schwarz never "gave any interpretation that didn’t have a real truth about it".^[4]

Recordings

Schwarz's 1958 recording of Mahler's Symphony No. 5 with the London Symphony Orchestra originally for the Everest label has been highly praised.^[14][15] In addition he conducted for many concerto recordings, as well as the Dvořák Slavonic Dances (BBCSO), and Liszt Hungarian Rhapsodies (Philharmonia). He started and ended his recording career with the Bournemouth orchestra: several overtures in the early 1950s and an LP of Schubert overtures in 1980 (all EMI). There are further broadcast recordings by Schwarz in the British Library Sound Archive.

References

1. Brook, Donald. Rudolf Schwarz. In: International Gallery of Conductors. Rockliff Publishing Corporation Ltd, London, 1951, p179-187.
2. Griffiths, pp. 17-18
3. Bernard Josephs (15 February 2007). "Stepson hits back at academic over Nazi slur on father". Jewish Chronicle. Retrieved 2007-08-18.
4. Patmore (2008)
5. EMI Classic Archives DVD 4928379; David Oistrakh
6. Patmore (2008), p. 50
7. Bournemouth Sinfonietta concert programme, November 1975.
8. Carpenter R. Obituary - Rudolf Schwarz 1905-1994. Quarter Note, Magazine of Bournemouth Orchestras, No 18, Spring 1994.
9. Jenkins, Lyndon (2005). While Spring And Summer Sang: Thomas Beecham and the Music of Frederick Delius. Ashgate. p. 115. ISBN 0-7546-0721-6.
10. Briggs, Asa (1995). The History of Broadcasting in the United Kingdom. Oxford University Press. p. 230. ISBN 0-19-212967-8.
11. Griffiths, p. 101
12. Bournemouth Symphony Orchestra concert programme. Western Orchestral Society, September 1977.
13. Lebrecht, Norman (2001). The Maestro Myth: Great Conductors in Pursuit of Power (Revised and Updated ed.). Citadel Press. pp. 292–293. ISBN 0-8065-2088-4.
14. Smoley, Lewis M. (1996). Gustav Mahler's Symphonies: critical commentary on recordings since 1986 (first ed.). Westport, CT: Greenwood Press. pp. 132–133. ISBN 0-313-29771-1. Sound and balances are superb for this vintage recording and playing is generally clear and precise as well as idiomatic. The opening of the first movement has a magnificent martial quality with a superb march tread... The klagend outburst near the close is shattering.
15. Duggan, Tony (May 2000). "Mahler: Symphony No.5 Schwarz: Classical CD Reviews". MusicWeb. Retrieved 2007-07-21.

Bibliography

• Griffiths, Bill (2004). Northern Sinfonia: A Magic of Its Own. Newcastle-upon-Tyne, UK: Northumbria University Press. ISBN 1-904794-07-6.
• Patmore, David (Summer 2008). "Rudolf Schwarz -- the Musician’s Musician". Classic Record Collector. No. 53. pp. 49–54. (This article draws extensively on doctoral research by Caroline Exon, University of Birmingham, 2004.)

External links

• Hans Gál page