Southern Plains villagers

The Southern Plains villagers were semi-sedentary Indians who lived on the Great Plains in western Oklahoma, Texas, Kansas, and southeastern Colorado from about 800 AD until 1500 AD. They grew maize and other crops, hunted bison and other game, and gathered wild plants for food. They generally lived in hamlets of a few dwellings adjacent to flood plains of rivers such as the Washita and South Canadian rivers in Oklahoma and Texas. Thousands of hamlets have been identified.^[1]

The approximate area occupied by the Southern Plains villagers

The Southern Plains villagers were likely the ancestors, at least in part, of the historic Wichita and other Caddoan peoples. Some of the Southern Plains Villagers survived into the historic era in the 16th century when Spanish explorers first ventured onto the Great Plains. The Wichita's first contact with Europeans was in 1541 when they were visited by Francisco Coronado in Kansas.^[2]

The semi-agricultural economy of the Southern Plains villagers was always vulnerable due to frequent droughts and climatic variations, although the livelihood of the villagers was enhanced by the periodic abundance of bison.^[3]

The Southern Plains villagers, especially on their western fringe, were influenced by the agricultural Puebloan peoples of the Rio Grande River Valley of New Mexico. They traded bison meat, robes, and stone for making tools to the Pueblos on their west and to the Caddoans on their east for maize, pottery, Osage Orange wood for making bows, and luxury goods such as turquoise.^[4]

Archaeologists have divided the Southern Plains villagers into many different archaeological variants based on differences in what has been found of their material possessions. The Redbud Plains variant includes the Paoli, Washita River, Custer, and Turkey Creek phases of western Oklahoma; the Henrietta and Wylie Creek focuses are located in north-central Texas; the Upper Canark variant in the Texas and Oklahoma panhandles includes the Antelope Creek Phase, and the Buried City and Zimms complexes; the Apishapa phase in southeastern Colorado; and the Bluff Creek, Wilmore, and Pratt complexes are in south central Kansas. The proto-historic Wichita villages in central Kansas are called the Great Bend aspect.^[5]

Origins

In the opinion of archaeologists the Southern Plains villagers were likely, in whole or part, speakers of Caddoan languages, the ancestors of the historical Wichita, Kichai, and possibly the Pawnee. Some of the easternmost sites of the Southern Plains villagers show an almost unbroken record of occupation for thousands of years and thus it appears, again in whole or part, that the villager's culture developed from people who had long lived in the area rather than being introduced by migrants. The apparent Caddoan origin of the villagers, however, does not preclude the possibility of non-Caddoan speakers and linguistic and ethnic diversity in the region.^[6]

Three technological developments in the early centuries of the Common Era led to the replacement of nomadic hunter-gatherer cultures by semi-sedentary cultures on the Southern Great Plains: the replacement of spears and the atlatl by the bow and arrow, a more efficient tool for hunting; the introduction of pottery for storage and cookery; and the adoption of maize agriculture as a major source of food. None of these new technologies was likely invented in the Southern Plains region but rather the knowledge seeped into the area from outside. With these new technologies the population probably expanded and it became possible or necessary for the former hunter-gatherers of the Southern Plains to become semi-sedentary agriculturalists.^[7]

Characteristics

Some of the earliest remains of the Southern Plains Villagers may be in what is called the Paoli phase, the location of which is centered on the Oklahoma town of Paoli and the Washita River Valley and the nearby South Canadian River Valley. Radiocarbon dates for Paoli sites are from 900 AD until about 1250 when the Paoli culture evolved into the Washita River phase from 1250 to 1450. It appears that the villages of the Paoli sites developed in place from earlier hunter-gatherer cultures. The Paoli and Washita River people lived in hamlets of up to 10 thatched-roof houses each usually located on terraces above the rivers. Hamlets were often only a few hundred meters from each other indicating a fairly dense population. The Washita phase is distinguished from Paoli by differences in arrowheads, pottery, and houses.^[8]

The inhabitants cultivated maize and the indigenous marshelder, hunted and caught deer, rabbits, fish, and mussels, and gathered edible wild plants such as Chenopodium, Amaranth, sunflower, little barley, maygrass, dropseed, and erect knotweed. Cultivation of beans and squash began about 1200 AD. As cultivation of maize, beans, and squash—the "Three Sisters" of Native American agriculture—expanded, the cultivation of indigenous crops declined. The remains of bison are scarce in earlier sites, but bison became more important as a source of food around 1300, indicating that bison may have become more abundant in the region of the Paoli and Washita settlements.^[9]

The Custer (800-1250 AD) and Turkey Creek phases (1250-1450 AD) were located further west on the same Washita and South Canadian Rivers where the Paoli and Washita phases were located. Their projectile points were derived from the Alibates quarries of the Texas Panhandle; there is no evidence that they grew squash and beans in addition to maize. They possibly had a greater reliance on gathering wild foods rather than agriculture—-a finding consistent with the drier climate of western Oklahoma compared to the more easterly Paoli and Washita phases. During the later Turkey Creek phase reliance on bison as a major food source increased.^[10]

The Henrietta focus or Henrietta complex extends from the Red River valley of Oklahoma and Texas southward to the Clear Fork of the Brazos River near Graham, Texas. The Henrietta focus dates from approximately 1100 AD to 1500 AD. The best known site of the focus is Harrell, near Graham, which is also the southernmost major site at which southern plains villagers lived. South of Harrell the pre-Columbian Indians in Texas were hunter-gatherers who apparently did not practice agriculture. The Harrell site features a large cemetery demonstrating that the site was inhabited for thousands of year.^[11] The Wylie focus is located north of Dallas and reflects a blend of the woodland agricultural society of the Caddo in East Texas and the Great Plains societies to its west. It dates from 1000 AD or earlier.^[12]

Arrowheads made from Alibates flint found in the Texas panhandle were widely traded by the Southern Plains Villagers.

The Upper Canark variant includes the Antelope Creek Phase, Panhandle phase, Optima focus, and the Buried City and Zimms complexes. All these manifestations of Canark were located in the Texas and Oklahoma panhandles, the Zimms complex extending into western Oklahoma.^[13] The Canark variant dates from about 1100 AD to 1500. It is distinguished by the stone-slab foundations of its dwellings, which included both multi-family and single-family structures. The people of the Canark variant may have borrowed the technology of their construction from the Puebloan people in the Rio Grande Valley in New Mexico—and were possibly related linguistically to the Pueboans. The majority opinion, however, is that they were Caddoan speakers, related to the Southern Plains villagers living to their east.^[14]

The people of the Canark variant grew corn, beans, squash and probably sunflowers in addition to hunting (mainly bison) and gathering wild plants for food. The area they occupied is marginal for agriculture without irrigation, prone to drought and with the bulk of the 16–24 inches annual rainfall coming in a few thunderstorms that cause flooding. Thus, the Antelope Creek people probably utilized water harvesting or “Ak-Chin” dryland farming techniques similar to those practiced by the Puebloans.^[15]

The Apishapa Phase in southeastern Colorado dates from 900 AD to 1400 AD and is characterized by stone slab architecture, often in defensible positions on mesas. The Apishaspa people probably evolved in place from the earlier Graneros phase. They appear to have been primarily hunter-gatherers, but archaeologists have found some evidence of maize cultivation. Agriculture however was probably relatively unimportant due to the semi-arid climate and the rocky canyons and dry mesas where many Apishapa dwellings have been found. It is uncertain whether the abundant petroglyphs of the area were the work of the Apishapa people.^[16]

The Bluff Creek, Pratt, and Wilmore complexes are located in south central Kansas near and along the tributaries of the Arkansas River. Bluff Creek is the earliest dating from about 1000 AD to 1500 AD. Pratt and Wilmore perhaps derive from Bluff Creek, dating from about 1400 to 1500. The Kansas sites are similar to the sites of the Southern Plains Villagers further south in Oklahoma. Along the Arkansas River in northernmost Oklahoma is the Uncas site which is quite different than the others in the character of its dwellings and pottery, and possibly represents intrusion by a non-related people.^[17]

Proto-historic period

Most of the Southern Plains villagers disappeared about 1450. Several theories have been advanced to explain their disappearance. First, nomadic and semi-nomadic Athabaskcans, later called Apaches, were moving south and displacing the villagers. Second. bison populations on the Southern Great Plains fluctuated They may have increased in numbers around 1400 AD and villagers may have begun to rely on hunting rather than agriculture which required them to be more mobile and less sedentary. Third, a long-lasting drought or climatic change to drier conditions may have reduced the feasibility of an agricultural economy on the southern plains. These theories are not mutually exclusive.^[18]

When Coronado traversed the Great Plains of Texas, Oklahoma, and Kansas in 1541 he found only bison-hunting nomads rather than farming villages. The Querechos he found near present day Amarillo, Texas were almost certainly Apaches. The Teyas he found east of present day Lubbock, Texas might have been Apaches also, or perhaps the Caddoan descendants of the Southern Plains villagers. Coronado found maize-growing Wichita Indians in Rice County, Kansas. In 1601 Juan de Oñate found the agricultural Rayados (also Wichita) near Arkansas City, Kansas. Both locations are more than 200 miles east—and in much more favorable climates for agriculture than where maize and other crops had been grown by the South Plains villagers hundreds of years earlier.^[19] The proto-historic Wichita settlements in Kansas are called the Great Bend Aspect by archaeologists.

References

1. Drass, Richard. R. (1998), "The Southern Plains Villagers" in Archaeology on the Great Plains, W. Raymond Wood, ed., Lawrence: University Press of Kansas, pp. 415-447. Downloaded from JSTOR.
2. Schlessier, Karl H. (1994), Plains Indians, A.D. 500-1500, Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, pp. 355-359
3. Drass, Richard R. (February 2008), "Corn, Beans, and Bison: Cultivated Plants and Changing Economies of the Late Prehistoric Villagers on the Plains of Oklahoma and Northwest Texas", Plains Anthropologist, Vol. 53, No. 205, pp 9-10. Downloaded from JSTOR.
4. Vehik, Susan C. "Trade and Political Development on the Southern Plains" (January 2002), American Antiquity, Vol. 67, No. 1, pp. 37-41. Downloaded from JSTOR; Texas Beyond History http://www.texasbeyondhistory.net/villagers/research/antelope.html, accessed 15 Feb 2015
5. Drass (1998), pp 415-416
6. "Putting the Pieces Together:the Harrell Site Reconsidered", Texas Before History, http://www.texasbeyondhistorynet/harrell/reconsidered.html, accessed 1 Feb 2015; "The Roulston-Rogers site" Oklahoma's Past" http://www.ou.edu/cas/archsur/counties/seminole.htm, accessed 1 Feb 2015
7. "Putting the Pieces Together: the Harrell Site Reconsidered", Texas Before History, http://www.texasbeyondhistorynet/harrell/reconsidered.html, accessed 1 Feb 2015
8. Drass, Richard R. (1999), "Redefining Plains Village Complexes in Oklahoma: The Paoli Phase and the Redbud Plains Variant", Plains Anthropologist, Vol 44, No. 168, pp. 123-133. Downloaded from JSTOR.
9. Drass (1999), pp. 123-133
10. Drass (1999), pp. 133-137
11. "The Harrell Site", Texas Beyond History, http://www.texasbeyondhistory.net/harrell/index.html, accessed 3 Feb 2015
12. Lynott, Mark J. (August 1977), "Radiocarbon Dating the Wylie Focus North Central Texas", Plains Anthropologist, Vol. 22, No. 77, pp. 233-327. Downloaded from JSTOR
13. Gibbon, Guy E. Ed. Archaeology of Pre-Historic Native America: An Encyclopedia. NY:Routledge, 1998, p. 20
14. Drass (1998), pp. 415-418
15. Texas Beyond History. http://www.texasbeyondhistory.net/villagers/buried city/life.html, accessed Nov 17, 2010; Drass (1998), pp. 415-418
16. Drass (1998), pp. 422-425
17. Drass (1998), pp. 439-441
18. Drass (1998), pr. 446-447
19. Flint, Richard (2008), No Settlement, No Conquest, Albuquerque: U of NM Press, p. 157; Drass, Richard R. and Baugh, Tomothy, G. (1997), "The Wheeler Phase and Cultural Continuity in the Southern Plains." Plains Anthropologist, Vol. 42, No. 160, 198-200