Spaceflight non-fatal training accidents

Test pilot Stuart Present ejects safely from the Lunar Landing Training Vehicle. Neil Armstrong also made such an ejection. (NASA)

This article lists verifiable spaceflight-related accidents and incidents resulting in non-fatality during training for manned space missions, and testing, assembly, preparation or flight of manned and unmanned spacecraft.

List

1960-1969

• Three of the five Lunar Landing Research and Training vehicles (LLRV and LLTV) were destroyed in crashes near Houston, Texas:
  • 1968 May 6: LLRV No. 1 crashed at Ellington AFB, Texas, caused by loss of helium pressure that controlled the steering jets. Neil Armstrong ejected safely.^[1]
  • 1968 December 8: LLTV No. 1 crashed at Ellington AFB, Texas, caused by failure of the fly-by-wire control system. MSC test pilot Joseph Algranti ejected safely.^[2]
  • 1971 January 29: An LLTV crashed at Ellington AFB, Texas, caused by failure of the fly-by-wire control system. NASA test pilot Stuart Present ejected safely.^[3]
• 1960 July 16: Injured during centrifuge training : Soviet cosmonaut Anatoly Yakovlevich Kartashov suffered pinpoint hemorrhages of the spine during centrifuge training. Due to the injuries he was grounded by the medical staff and retired from the cosmonaut group on 7 April 1962^[4][5]
• 1961 August 19: Parachute training accident, broken left foot : Cosmonaut Pavel Belyayev broke his left foot during a parachute jump related to cosmonaut training. As a result, he was out of cosmonaut training until 30 August 1962.^[6]
• 1961 Sep 2: T-33 jet engine failure, emergency landing : Astronauts Gus Grissom and Alan Shepard experienced a broken rotor blade in the jet engine of their T-33 jet while flying a training mission over Lake Erie. Grissom made an emergency landing at Selfridge Air Force Base near Detroit, MI. Both astronauts were unharmed and the aircraft was not damaged. The astronauts left in the same jet a day later.^[7]
• 1962 Oct 22: Experimental Paraglider, hard landing : Astronaut Gus Grissom was piloting an experimental paraglider at Edwards Air Force Base, CA, that was towed aloft by another aircraft and released. The paraglider made a hard landing that crumpled the nose wheel. The craft remained upright and Grissom walked away unhurt. The craft was part of experiments that were to lead up to landing Gemini spacecraft using a similar paraglider wing on dry land.^[8]
• 1963 March 13: F-102 jet, ran off paved runway : Astronaut Elliot See was piloting a NASA F-102 fighter jet used to maintain astronaut pilot proficiency when it ran off the end of the paved runway while landing at Ellington AFB near Houston, TX. Officials said the astronaut landed the plane too fast and was unable to stop on the paved portion of the runway. Astronaut See was not injured and the aircraft was not damaged and was flown later in the day by another astronaut.^[9]
• 1964 Aug 25 : Simulated Moon Walk in Spacesuit, fall on steep, rocky lava bed : Astronaut Walter Cunningham was wearing a full spacesuit with 13.5 kg backpack. He was simulating a moon walk on a rocky lava bed near Bend, Oregon. While climbing a 15 meter, 30 degree slope, he was 3 meters from the top when he fell backward. At first, observers thought he might roll all the way to the bottom of the slope, but Cunningham spread out to slow his motion and a nearby engineer also provided assistance. Cunningham was uninjured, but there was a slight pressure loss in the suit from a glove puncture.^[10][11]
• 1964 Nov 4 : T-38 jet, ran off wet runway, landing gear damaged : Astronauts Charles "Pete" Conrad and James Lovell were landing at Ellington AFB near Houston, TX, during a rainstorm, on a flight from Washington, DC. They were returning from the funeral of astronaut Theodore C. Freeman. They were unable to stop their aircraft on the wet runway. The aircraft ran off the runway and into a muddy, grassy area damaging the landing gear. The two astronauts were not injured in the mishap.^[12]
• 1966 Jan 14 : Altitude Chamber, oxygen valve explosion, fire : Astronaut Edward Givens was testing the Gemini 9 astronaut maneuvering unit (AMU) while wearing a spacesuit in an altitude chamber at the Manned Spacecraft Center (Johnson Space Center), Houston, TX. While in the altitude chamber, an oxygen valve exploded outside the altitude chamber burning four technicians and sending one of them to the hospital. One of the technicians' clothes was set on fire and the other three technicians suffered minor burns extinguishing the burning clothing. Astronaut Givens was not injured in the incident.^[13]
• 1966 January 28 : Zero G Training, dislocated shoulder requiring surgery : Astronaut Donn F. Eisele underwent surgical repair of his left shoulder due to a dislocation received during zero G flight training in 1965. The shoulder was reinjured during physical training at the Manned Spacecraft (Johnson Space) Center later the same year.^[14]
• 1966 July 18 : T-38 jet takeoff abort, ran off runway : Astronauts Edward H. White and Russell Schweickart experienced an engine failure during takeoff from El Paso International airport, TX, on their T-38 jet aircraft. The takeoff was aborted and the aircraft ran off the end of the runway, suffering a nose gear collapse and blowouts of both main landing gear tires. The astronauts were flying from Houston, TX to Los Angeles, CA. The stop in El Paso was to refuel. Both astronauts were uninjured and continued their journey on a commercial airliner.^[15]
• 1966 October 8: Parachute training accident, broken foot : Cosmonaut Georgi Grechko broke his foot during a parachute jump related to training for the Soyuz 7K manned lunar flyby missions. The injury forced him out of training for those lunar flyby missions.^[16][17]
• 1968 May 15 : Parachute training, fracture : Astronaut Dr. Robert A. R. Parker suffered a fractured coccyx (the final bone in the spine), while taking part in parachute training. The injury occurred at Williams Air Force Base, Arizona. The injury was not thought to be serious.^[18]
• 1968 September 26 : Physical training, fractured collar bone : Astronaut Dr. Karl G. Henize suffered a fractured collar bone during a physical development class as part of astronaut training. He was placed on non-flying status for about five weeks.^[19]
• 1969 : Rope training accident, serious leg injury : Cosmonaut Vladimir Kovalyonok suffered a serious injury to his leg while rope training (climbing?) during cosmonaut training. He recovered and was able to continue cosmonaut training and graduated 18 August 1969.^[20]
• 1969 Aug 2 : helicopter landing accident : During NASA astronaut helicopter flight training, astronaut Edward G. Gibson, flying solo, landed a helicopter on a mud flat, near Laporte, TX. The helicopter sank in the mud, flipped over and its spinning rotor blades tore the craft apart. Gibson was uninjured.^[21][22]
• 1969 Aug 15: T-33 jet crash landing : Astronaut Joseph Kerwin made a belly landing on a foam covered runway in his T-33 jet trainer at Ellington AFB near Houston, Texas due to a landing gear problem. He survived the crash landing uninjured.^[23]

1970-1979

• 1971 January 23: helicopter crash: Eugene Cernan was flying a Bell 47G helicopter as part of his Lunar Module training as Backup Commander for Apollo 14. The helicopter crashed into the Indian River at Cape Canaveral, Florida. Cernan nearly drowned because he was not wearing a life vest and received some second-degree burns on his face and singed hair.^[24] According to official reports at the time, the crash was the result of mechanical failure. Later accounts, written by Cernan himself in an autobiography, admit he was flying too low and showing off for nearby boaters. The helicopter dipped a skid into the water and crashed. James McDivitt, an Apollo Manager at the time, demanded that Cernan be removed from flight status and not be given command of Apollo 17. Cernan was defended by Deke Slayton and given the Apollo 17 command. James McDivitt resigned as an Apollo Manager shortly after the Apollo 16 mission.^[25]
• 1971 Apr 2 : T-38 jet, rear cockpit canopy lost, takeoff aborted : Astronaut Richard Truly was taking off from Kellogg Field, Battle Creek, MI in a NASA T-38 jet. During the takeoff roll, the rear cockpit canopy flew off the aircraft. Astronaut Truly aborted the takeoff and was not injured. The aircraft suffered minor damage.^[26]
• 1972 May 10 : T-38 jet, electrical malfunction, out of fuel, ejected : Astronaut Charles "Pete" Conrad ejected safely from his NASA T-38 jet near Bergstrom AFB, Austin, TX. He landed about 90 meters from the base operations building. An electrical malfunction that caused loss of instruments during severe weather was listed by the review board as a major factor in the accident. Conrad was on a flight from Dover, DE via Dobbins AFB, GA to Ellington AFB, Houston, TX. Due to bad weather, he was diverted first to Hobby Airport, Houston because Ellington AFB was below minimums for landing. While on final approach to Hobby Airport, in darkness, heavy rain and lightning, the T-38 generator failed, causing a loss of cockpit lighting and partial loss of navigation instruments. Conrad broke off the approach and tried to climb above the bad weather. The generator was brought back online along with cockpit lighting. Because of the electrical problems, he requested a diversion to an airport that was under visual flight rules. Controllers sent him toward Randolph AFB, San Antonio, TX. It soon became apparent the T-38 did not have enough fuel to reach Randolph AFB. Controllers then diverted him to Bergstrom AFB. The T-38 ran out of fuel as it reached Bergstron AFB. Conrad ejected at 1100 meters. The aircraft was destroyed. He was taken to the base hospital for a routine examination and returned to Houston later that night.^[27][28][29]
• 1974 Feb 6 : T-38 jet, landing mishap, gear collapse : Astronaut Dr. Karl G. Henize was involved in a "landing mishap" in his T-38 jet aircraft while landing at Bergstrom AFB near Austin, TX in low visibility conditions. He was on an instrument flight from Ellington AFB near Houston, TX. A landing gear on the T-38 collapsed and the aircraft was damaged. Henize was not injured.^[30][31]
• 1979 October 19: Altitude chamber accident, electrical burns, brain concussion : Cosmonaut Alexander S. Viktorenko was conducting tests in an altitude chamber as part of cosmonaut training. Due to errors by a person operating the altitude chamber, Viktorenko was struck by an electric current, causing burns, a fall and a brain concussion. He was unconscious for 17 hours. As a result of the injuries and recovery, he did not complete his cosmonaut training until 24 February 1982.^[32][33][34]

1980-1989

• 1982 May 21: T-38 jet struck by lightning, damaged : Astronaut Gordon Fullerton was piloting a solo flight of a NASA T-38 jet aircraft from Houston, Texas to Cleveland, Ohio to make a speaking engagement. While on final approach to Cleveland's Hopkins Airport, his aircraft was struck by lightning. Fullerton landed safely but a post-landing inspection showed that a 2-foot by 6-foot section had been torn from the tail of the aircraft. The astronaut later commented, "It felt like a howitzer hit the cockpit. It was as strong a lightning (bolt) as I've ever experienced.".^[35][36]
• 1982 Dec 1: T-38 jet landing accident, ran off runway : Astronaut Thomas K. Mattingly was not injured when his T-38 jet aircraft ran off the runway at Ellington AFB near Houston, Texas. The aircraft ended up 30 feet off the end of the runway during a landing in heavy rain. There was substantial damage to the wings, nose and landing gear of the aircraft during the incident.^[37]
• 1984 Apr 5 : T-38 jet, struck birds, engine flameout, aborted takeoff : Astronaut James van Hoften was taking off in a T-38 jet on the KSC Space Shuttle runway for a training flight. This was training for the STS-41-C mission of Challenger that launched the next day. At about 1.5 km (1 mi) down the 4.8 km (3 mi) runway, while going 260 km/h (162 mph), his jet struck a flock of birds, causing the right engine to flame out. He applied the brakes and safely aborted takeoff without further aircraft damage. Bird remains were later found on the nose landing gear and the aircraft engine needed to be removed and inspected for further damage.^[38]
• 1987 Feb 24: T-38 jet engine failure, fire, emergency landing : Astronaut Brewster Shaw and NASA pilot Robert Rivers experienced an engine failure and fire in their T-38 jet aircraft. The jet was on approach to Los Alamitos Army Air Field, CA, when the right engine failed and caught fire. There was smoke in the cockpit. The crew chose to land the plane rather than bail out because it was over a populated area. They landed successfully and climbed out of the burning jet. The jet experienced substantial damage. The crew was taken to the Long Beach Naval Hospital for observation and later released.^[39]
• 1989 May 15 : T-38 jet, near midair collision with airliner : Astronaut David M. Walker was flying a NASA T-38 jet into Dulles Airport near Washington, D.C. for a presidential ceremony. At about 8 km (5 mi) from the airport at an altitude of 2100 meters, he came within 150 meters of colliding with a Pan Am Airbus 310 airliner. He was later found at fault for the incident and suspended from flying for 60 days by NASA. He was also removed as commander of the STS-44 mission.^[40][41]

1990-1999

• 1993 May 3 : Emergency egress training, broken bones in foot : Astronaut Dr. M. Rhea Seddon broke four metatarsal bones in her left foot during emergency egress training from the Johnson Space Center orbiter training facility. She was using an inflatable slide similar to those used on airliners during landing emergency evacuations. While sliding down the slide, her left foot became pinned under her, breaking four minor bones. She returned to full-time training after a few weeks.^[42]
• 1993 May 28 : frostbitten fingers in thermal vacuum chamber : While training in a thermal vacuum chamber for the STS-61 Hubble repair mission, astronaut Story Musgrave suffered frostbite on the fingertips of his right hand. He was working in a spacesuit in the chamber for about six hours at low temperatures. His fingertips were blackened and numb from the incident. Surgery was not required and they were sufficiently healed in time for the repair mission in December 1993.^[43]
• 1993 Oct 16: Medical experiment, heart and breathing stopped : Astronaut Bonnie Dunbar suffered an allergic reaction to an experimental drug and collapsed during medical tests at Johnson Space Center, Texas. Her breathing and heart stopped and she was rushed to a local hospital. She recovered and was later declared in good health. The experiment involved injecting dye and a drug to measure the effect of weightlessness on fluids in the body.^[44][45]

2000-2009

• 2000 Mar 15 : sprained ankle delays shuttle launch : Astronaut and commander of the STS-101 mission, James D. Halsell sprained his ankle climbing down steps inside of a space shuttle simulator at Johnson Space Center, Houston. This caused him to miss some training activities and delayed the launch of his mission by about a week.^[46]
• 2003 Dec 2 : NASA Gulfstream II Shuttle Training Aircraft - engine thrust reverser fell off aircraft in flight : A NASA Gulfstream II shuttle Training Aircraft (STA) was flying a series of simulated shuttle landings to the Kennedy Space Center shuttle landing facility. On board the aircraft was an unidentified NASA astronaut pilot and two training personnel. The aircraft was on final approach at 13,000 feet when on-board instruments indicated a malfunction on one of the jet engine thrust reversers. The aircraft landed safely. A post-landing inspection showed that one of the 585-pound, 4-foot-wide, 5-foot-long thrust reversers had fallen off the aircraft. Divers later found the thrust reverser on the bottom of the nearby Banana River. An investigation showed that a bolt failed, causing the part to fall off the aircraft.^[47][48]
• 2003 Dec 17 : SpaceShipOne - Landing accident, ran off runway : While piloting SpaceShipOne on its first powered test flight, 11P, astronaut Brian Binnie reached a peak altitude of 20.7 km (13 mi) and exceeded the speed of sound. Upon landing, SpaceShipOne experienced a roll oscillation that caused the left main gear to collapse. The craft ran off the runway and rolled to a stop in soft sand. The craft sustained minor damage, later repaired, and the pilot was uninjured.^[49]

2010-2019

This list is incomplete; you can help by expanding it.

See also

• List of spaceflight-related accidents and incidents

References

1. "Jet Moon Flight Trainer Crashes", St. Petersburg, FL Times newspaper, May 7, 1968
2. "Moon Lander Crashes In Final Major Test", Oxnard, CA - The Press-Courier, Dec. 9, 1968
3. "Test Pilot Ejects Safely As Lunar Lander Crashes", Toledo Blade newspaper, Jan. 30, 1971
4. "Kartashov", Encyclopedia Astronautica, Dec 26, 2010
5. "The first Soviet cosmonaut team: their lives, legacy, and historical impact ", by Colin Burgess and Rex Hall, pg 353, published by Praxis 2010
6. "Biography of Pavel Belyayev", Russian Federal Space Agency, Jan 2, 2011
7. "Astronauts In Close Call", Montreal Gazette newspaper, Sep 5, 1961
8. "Grissom Walks Away From Hard Landing", Ocala, FL - Gazette newspaper, Oct 24, 1962
9. "Astronaut Lands Fast in 'Hot" Jet", Spokane, WA - Spokesman-Review newspaper, March 17, 1963
10. "Astronaut Falls On Lava Bed In Simulated Walk On Moon", Toledo, OH - Blade newspaper, Aug 26, 1964
11. "Astronaut Takes Spill In Test Of Moon Gear", Palm Beach, FL - Post newspaper, Aug 26, 1964
12. "Astronauts Safe in Bad Landing", Milwaukee Journal newspaper, Nov 14, 1964
13. "Explosion at Space Center Injures One", St. Joseph, MO - News-Press newspaper, Jan 16, 1966
14. "NASA Manned Spacecraft Center - 1966 Press Releases", MSC 65-12, January 27, 1966, PDF page 30 accessed 5 Jan, 2011
15. "Astronauts' Flight Halted, Aircraft's Engines Fail on Takeoff", Reading, PA - Eagle newspaper', Jul 19, 1966
16. "Soviet urges space cooperation", Lawrence Journal-World newspaper, Oct 16, 1990
17. "Biography of Georgiy Grechko", Russian Federal Space Agency, Jan 2, 2011
18. "Sinus Case Grounds One Astronaut", St. Joseph Gazette newspaper, May 16, 1968
19. "NASA Manned Spacecraft Center - 1968 Press Releases", MSC 68-73, September 27, 1968, PDF page 134 accessed 5 Jan, 2011
20. "Biography of Vladimir Kovalyonok", Russian Federal Space Agency, Jan 2, 2011
21. "A helicopter, piloted by scientist-astronaut Edward Gibson, flipped over during a landing", Reading, PA - Eagle newspaper', August 3, 1969
22. "Astronaut Gibson Is Example of Living Paradox in Program", Lewiston, Maine - Daily Sun newspaper', Nov 16, 1973
23. "Astronaut has close call", Richland, WA - Tri-City Herald newspaper, Aug 17, 1969
24. "Astronaut Cernan Survives Helicopter Crash In River", Spartanburg, SC - Herald-Journal, Jan. 24, 1971
25. Check-Six.com - The 1971 Crash of Gene Cernan's Helo
26. "Jet takeoff aborted, astronaut not hurt", Windsor Star newspaper, Apr 3, 1971
27. "Moon man's jet crashes", Richland, WA - Tri-City Herald newspaper, May 11, 1972
28. "NASA Manned Spacecraft Center - 1972 Press Releases ", Release No: 72-98 Conrad Ejects Safely From T-38, May 10, 1972, PDF page 254; accessed 5 Jan, 2011
29. "NASA Manned Spacecraft Center - 1973 Press Releases ", Release No: 73-91 T-38 Accident Report, July 3, 1973, PDF page 188; accessed 5 Jan, 2011
30. "Astronaut Karl Henize escaped injury in T-38 landing mishap", Florence, Alabama - Times Daily newspaper, Feb 7, 1974
31. "Astronautics and Aeronautics, 1974 A Chronology", NASA SP-4019, pg 28, accessed online, Jan 31, 2011
32. "Disasters and Accidents In Manned Spaceflight, By David Shayler; pg 70", Published by Springer, 2000
33. "Soyuz: a universal spacecraft By Rex Hall, David Shayler; pg 426", Published by Springer, 2003
34. "Biography of Alexander Viktorenko", Russian Federal Space Agency, Jan 2, 2011
35. "Lightning hits plane piloted by astronaut", Spokane Chronicle newspaper, May 22, 1982
36. "Bolt Jolts Fullerton", Milwaukee Sentinel newspaper, May 22, 1982
37. "Astronaut not hurt", Hendersonville, NC - Times-News newspaper, Dec 2, 1982
38. "Bird scraps pre-shuttle flight", Cape Girardeau, MO - Bulletin-Journal newspaper, Apr 5, 1984
39. "Astronaut Avoids Crash In Calif. Neighborhood", Schenectady, NY - Gazette newspaper, Feb 25, 1987
40. "Astronaut flying to Washington has close call with Pan Am Airbus", Fredericksburg, VA - Free Lance Star newspaper, May 17, 1989
41. "Violations ground two veteran shuttle commanders", Eugene Register-Guard newspaper, July 10, 1990
42. "Johnson Space Center Press release - RELEASE NO. 93-032, Astronaut Seddon Injured During Training; May 4, 1993; accessed online 5 Jan, 2010
43. "One astronaut fought frostbite to stay in lineup", Fredericksburg, VA - Free Lance-Star newspaper, Aug 17, 1993
44. "Astronaut collapses", Lodi, CA - News-Sentinel newspaper, Nov 4, 1994
45. "Report: Astronaut Dunbar nearly died from reaction to an experimental drug", Gadsden, Alabama - Times newspaper, July 9, 1995
46. "Sprained ankle causes delay of shuttle launch", Ocala Star-Banner newspaper, Mar 30, 2000
47. "NASA ties bolt to training scare", Florida Today newspaper (article reprinted on the International Aviation Safety Association website), Feb 7, 2004
48. "NASA Jet Sheds Parts Over Florida", AVweb website, February 9, 2004
49. "Private rocket plane goes supersonic in test", Lodi, CA - Sentinel newspaper, Dec 18, 2003