Trams in Turku

Turku tramway network

Overview
Locale	Turku, Finland
Transit type	Tramway
Number of lines	4
Operation
Began operation	1890 (horse tram), 1908 (electric tram)
Ended operation	1892 (horse tram), 1972 (electric tram)
Technical
Track gauge	1908–1972: 1,000 mm (3 ft 3 ^3⁄8 in)
Old gauge	1890–1892: 1,435 mm (4 ft 8 ^1⁄2 in)
Turku tram network in its most extensive form after expansion in 1956.

The Turku tramway network was the first—and as of 2008, second to last—tram system to be operated in Finland. It was operated as horse tramway from 1890 until 1892, and as an electrified tramway from 1908 until 1972. Prior to 1919 the tram system was owned by private interests, and from that year onwards by the City of Turku until closure of the system.^[1]

The possible recreation of the tram network and/or a creation of a light rail network have been discussed since the (second) closure of the tram system in 1972.^[2] In December 2009 the Turku City Council made the decision that a light rail system (Finnish: pikaraitiotie, "fast tramway") system would be realised in the city after an intermediate phase of bus rapid transit.^[3]

History

The only known photograph of a horse-drawn tram in Turku.

1890–1892: Horse tramway

In 1889 Spårvägsaktiebolaget i Åbo ("Tramway Company in Turku"), led by Count August Armfelt applied for the right to construct a horse-drawn tram line in Turku. The application was positively received in the city council,^[4] and already on 4 May 1890 the company opened a tram line between Turku Castle and the city centre. This was the first tram system in Finland, then an autonomous part of Russia. Unusually for a tramway system in Finland, the line was built with a track gauge of 1,435 mm (4 ft 8 ¹⁄₂ in), instead of the Russian broad gauge standard of 1,524 mm (5 ft) or the 1,000 mm (3 ft 3 ³⁄₈ in) gauge used on all subsequent Finnish tramways.^[5] Although passenger numbers were relatively high, high maintenance costs led to the horse tramway being unprofitable, and it was closed down already on 31 October 1892.^[4][5] The five tramcars owned by Spårvägsaktiebolaget i Åbo were sold to Stockholms Nya Spårvägsaktiebolag, Sweden in 1894.^[6]

1908–1919: Privately owned electric tramway

ASEA/AEG-built tram number 4 from 1908, photographed 1952.

Due to the city's population increase, the idea of building a tramway in Turku resurfaced during the first years of the 20th century. Building an electrically powered tramway for the city was first proposed in 1905, but due to the lack of local experience in constructing such a system, foreign companies were selected to construct the service. Germany-based AEG, who also owned the electricity plant in Turku, eventually reached an agreement with the city for building a tram network and operating it for forty years, the city having an option to buy the operations after ten years and thereon between five-year intervals.^[7]

The new tram network was built to the 1,000 mm (3 ft 3 ³⁄₈ in) used on the Helsinki tram network, and it was opened on 22 December 1908. From the start the new network was much more extensive than the horse tram network, with two lines initially operated; a circular line in the centre of the city and a harbour line connecting the city centre to the Port of Turku. In 1909 the two lines were combined into a single one—this rather complex route arrangement was retained until 1932.^[8] The first generation of electric trams in Turku were built by the Swedish ASEA.^[9] The new traffic form gained high popularity, and passenger numbers grew steadily until the beginning of World War I.^[7]

During World War I the Grand Duke of Finland (aka Tsar Nicholas II of Russia) ordered all German-owned possessions within Finland to be confiscated. Therefore between 18 August 1914 and 15 June 1918 the Turku tramway was under control of the Turku and Pori County under the name Turun Sähkölaitos.^[8] The war resulted in unprecedented growth in passenger numbers, to the extent that there was not enough capacity to carry all potential passengers.^[7] Following the end of the war and the subsequent Finnish independence, control of the tramway was returned to Electricitätswerk Åbo AG. However, already on 15 April 1919 the City of Turku purchased the highly profitable tram operations for itself.^[7][8]

1919–1943: Expansion

In 1920, soon after the city took over the tram operations, an explosion at the electric plant resulted in the death of seven people, as well as large-scale damage to the plant itself. As a result the distribution of electricity was disturbed, and the tram network was inoperative due to lack of power for 87 days. Plans were made during the earlier half of the 1920s for expansion of the tram network, but the poor post-war financial situation meant these could not be realised.^[10]

ASEA/AEG built tram 18 from 1933. The last trams of this type were retained in use until the close of the system in 1972.

The first privately owned bus lines appeared in Turku in 1923. During the rest of the decade the number of bus lines grew, resulting in dropping passenger numbers for the tram system. By the end of the decade the tram system was operating at a loss. A committee was set in 1931 to investigate the future of city-maintained public transport in Turku, which recommended that the tram network be expanded and the city should not, for the time being, start its own bus operations. Following the committee's recommendations, plans were drawn to convert the entire tram network to double track and expand it to various directions, doubling the track lineage. This also meant the creation of three separate lines. The construction of the expansions started in 1932,^[11] when two new extensions of the network were opened, resulting in the creation of three separate lines.^[8] A fourth line is also said to have existed at some point during the first half of the 1930s, but reports about it are fragmentary and conflicting.^[12] Further expansions to the network were built during 1933 and 1934.^[11][13] The expansion of the tram network resulted in higher passenger numbers, which necessitated the acquisition of new rolling stock. Prior to acquisition of the new trams a poll was held amongst tram passengers to decide the colour of the new trams. The traditional yellow colour won the vote, scoring 724 votes against the second favourite, dark blue with 208 votes. To cover for a temporary shortage of rolling stock before new trams were delivered, five trams were rented from Helsinki during the years 1931-1938.^[11][14]

Further expansion of the network occurred in 1938 and 1940. The 1940 expansion resulted in the combination of lines 2 and 3 into a single line, which changed numbers halfway though the route. The two-designation system was necessitated by the fact that the new 2/3 line spooled back into itself, with the end of the line stop for "line 3" being located along the route of "line 2".^[13] Tram operations continued throughout World War II, with passenger numbers greatly exceeding those during peace-time.^[15]

1944–1959: Decline

Trams number 34–37 were built while wartime restrictions were still in place and the quality of this tram type was poor.

While the war still continued, new trams were built for Turku in 1944.^[16] Following the end of the war passenger numbers started declining rapidly, which meant the tram operations were making loss by the end of the decade.^[17] In 1950 an experiment was carried out to give up having separate conductors in trams and have the driver sell tickets in order to cut costs. Although the city transport department was pleased with the experiment, it was terminated within the same year partially due to pressure from the tram staff. During the same year the city decided to start its own bus operations. Despite this the city continued to be committed to the tram operations, and during the early 1950s the rail lineage was improved and new trams were acquired. In 1951 lines 2 and 3 were split, resulting in the creation of a circular line 3.^[18][19]

As the 1950s progressed the general opinion started turning against tram traffic, following the general trend of the time. The termination of tram traffic by 1980 was first proposed in 1952 by architect Olavi Laisaari of the city planning department in a proposal for general guidelines for city planning. The proposal was at the time rejected. In 1954 a committee led by vice-city executive Öyvind Stadius came to the conclusion that trams were an impractical solution for a city of Turku's size, but nevertheless recommended maintaining the tram network as large investment were made to it. During the 1950s and 60s the decisions for the future of the tram network were largely a struggle between Laisaari and Stadius for termination of tram traffic on one side, and the leader of the traffic department Pentti Savolainen (Stadius' subordinate) for development of tram traffic on the other side.^[20] Despite the statements against the tram network, the city traffic department made large-scale plans for expansion of the tram network during the 1950s, including light rail lines connecting Turku with neighbouring cities Raisio and Kaarina, which would have greatly increased the profitability of the tram system. Unfortunately these were not realised,^[20][21] apart from a short expansion of line 2 completed in 1956 with a light rail -type track entirely separated from street traffic.^[19][20] Also in 1956 the traffic department acquired new RM 2 -type four-axle trams. Although the city had decided not to build the proposed light rail lines, these so-called "ghost cars" were designed to be usable on light rail lines.^[20]

A Valmet RM 2 tram photographed in Turku market square in 1959.

During the latter part of the 50s passenger numbers started declining again, and a committee formed in 1959 found that under the current financial circumstances the expansion of the tram network was impossible to realise. However, the committee also stated the expansion of the network was necessary in the long run, and the needs of light rail lines should be taken into account in city planning. Additionally the committee suggested, again, ceasing the usage of conductors in trams in favour of ticket-selling by the driver in order to cut costs. By this time the city decision-makers were uninterested in developing or even maintaining the tram network, and as a result the committee's recommendations were not acted on.^[20]

1960–1972: Termination

By the beginning of the 1960s it was clear that the tram network could become profitable again only if it was expanded to the more lucrative suburban routes dominated by the private bus operators. Additionally most of the rolling stock dated from before or during the World War II, and were nearing the end of their lifespan, which meant that sizeable investment would be needed to keep the trams operational. In 1961 the traffic department proposed the acquisitions of new four-axle trams, but the proposal was left untreated by the technical committee until the traffic department would make a proposal for the future of the tram system. As a result Pentti Savolainen proposed the gradual closure of the tram system by 1980, synchronising the closure of different lines with the retirement of the then-current tram staff. Six new four-axle trams would have been required for this plan to be realised. No actual reason was given why the tram system should be closed.^[22]

Savolainen's closure plan was eagerly accepted by the technical committee and forwarded to the city council. The council however turned down the proposal. At the same time the requests for funds for even the most basic maintenance of the tram network were also turned down.^[21][22] Subsequently Savolainen submitted a proposal for termination of tram traffic by 1972, as continuing traffic after that time was not viable without some investment in track maintenance and the rolling stock. However, earlier closure would not be possible due to the need to find new jobs for the tram staff. Additionally the closure of the tram system would require investment in 75–80 diesel-powered buses. None of the preceding or subsequent proposals for replacement of the tram system with buses included an objective comparison between the expenses of tram and bus operations. Each proposal simply presumed that buses were cheaper, without looking further into the matter.^[22]

A SAT/AEG -built tram from 1934 serving as an ice cream bar in Turku Market Square is one of the surviving Turku trams. The livery of the tram when photographed does not correspond with the original.

Starting from 1962, several committees were formed to plan the termination of tram traffic, most of which simply followed Savolainen's second termination proposal. At the same time the future of city-maintained public transport was a source of conflict in the city council, where the rightist parties wanted to leave public transport entirely for private operators, while the leftist parties wanted the city to continue operating public transport lines with buses. Even though the city council on the whole agreed that tram traffic should be terminated, it wasn't until 1965 that the decision was made to terminate line 1 on 11 March 1967, due to the "life-threatening" condition of its tracks.^[19][23] No decision was made about the future of other lines however.^[24]

Following the termination of line 1 in 1967, two additional committees was set to investigate the future of the city's public transport department, but neither arrived at any new conclusions.^[25] In 1969 the decision was made to terminate traffic on line 3 in 1970, but due to delays in delivering the new buses and other difficulties, in the end only line 3A (the inner circle on circular line 3) was terminated, a year behind schedule on 24 April 1971.^[19][26] During the same year the decision was made to convert line 2 into bus traffic in 1972 and line 3B in 1973.^[27] Traffic on line 2 ended on 31 May 1972 and finally line 3B (the outer circle on line 3) was closed ahead of schedule on 1 October 1972.^[19] During the last day of operations all trams in traffic were full with passengers wishing to give their farewells – some even decorated the trams with flowers. The last tram—carrying nearly two hundred passengers although certified for only 50—departed from the terminus stop on 23:30 Eastern European Time, and completed its circle at 23:54, marking the end of tram service in Turku.^[28]

Although the conversion into bus traffic was believed to be an answer to making the city-operated public transport system profitable again, this was not in fact the case and the operations continued making even larger losses until the city's public transport system was reorganised in the 1990s.^[29] The termination of tram traffic also led to a drop in passenger numbers on the city-operated public transport network, despite the growth of the city that took place at the same time.^[30]

Rolling stock

Apart from the last tram type acquired in 1956, the trams used in Turku had no official type designations, possibly owing to the uniformity of the rolling stock.^[31]

Motor trams

Numbers	Builder	Type	In service	Notes	Surviving trams
1–13	ASEA/AEG	–	1908–1953	Five additional trams were rented from Helsinki 1931-1938.[14]	1[32]
14, 15	NWF/AEG	–	1921–1954		None[33]
16–23	ASEA/AEG	–	1933–1972	[34]	2[32]
24–33	Suomen Autoteollisuus/AEG	–	1934–1972	First trams ever to be built in Finland.[16]	2[32]
34–37	Suomen Autoteollisuus/AEG	–	1944–1967		None[16]
38–47	Karia/Strömberg	–	1951–1972		1[35]
48–55	Valmet/Tampella/Strömberg	RM 2	1956–1972	Built with usage on light rail lines in mind. Nicknamed "ghost car"s.	None[36]

Possible future rail systems

The closure of the Turku tram system has been subsequently widely regarded as a mistake.^[37] The recreation of a rail-based public transport system in the city, either in the form of another tram system or a light rail one, has been discussed since the closure of the previous tram system in 1972.^[2][9][21] The Turku city council approved the future construction of a light rail system on 15 December 2009. In the interim the city's public transport system will be rearranged as a bus rapid transport system.^[3]

Light rail

Turku light rail planned route map[38]

Legend Raisio Kuloinen Mälikkälä Runosmäki Turku harbour Nättinummi Linnakaupunki Iso-Heikkilä To Naantali/Uusikaupunki Kähäri Central Railway Station To Loimaa Market Square Aura River Aura River Korppolaismäki Majakkaranta TYKS Kurjenmäki Kupittaa Koivula To Salo Harittu Itäharju Auvainen Pääskyvuori Kaarina Varissuo Light rail line, phase 1 Major stop, phase 1 Light rail line, phase 2 Major stop, phase 2 Existing railroad line Interchange station

The possibility of creating a light rail system into Turku and the neighbouring cities has been discussed since the 1990s. On 4 December 2000 the Turku municipal executive committee ordered a preliminary study to be made about the possible construction of a light rail system in the city, replacing the most popular bus connections that are already running at maximal capacity. The study was completed in 2002.^[2] This study recommended the creation of a light rail system with a track gauge of 1,524 mm (5 ft) to facilitate the usage of train tracks in parts of the system. Two main lines were proposed in the study, one with the route Naantali–Raisio–Turku–Kaarina and another with the route Runosmäki–Turku city center–Varissuo. The cost of the proposed 43.1 km (26.8 mi) system was at the time of the study's completion projected at over €320 million.^[2][21]

In 2008 the city of Turku ordered a more detailed study to be made about the way public transport systems are developed in the City Region of Turku in the future, comparing light rail- and bus-based alternatives. The goal is to present a solution for the creation of an efficient, attractive and uniform public transport system for Turku and the neighbouring cities.^[39] An intermediary report for this study was completed in December 2008, which recommended a somewhat different light rail system from the 2002 study. In the 2008 study the line to Naantali was abandoned but a more extensive network within central Turku was proposed, including the recreation of tracks that had been used by the old Turku tram system.^[38]

The 2008 report recommended for the construction of the light rail network to take place in two phases: phase 1 would be completed by 2020 and would include the lines Runosmäki–Majakkaranta (in Korppolaismäki) and Varissuo–Turku Central railway station. The total length of these lines would be 17.7 km (11.0 mi).^[38][40] Phase 2 would be completed after 2020, coinciding with new residential development in Raisio and Kaarina, and would include a third line Kaarina–central Turku–Raisio and an extension of the Varissuo–Central railway station to the Port of Turku. Total length of the system following phase 2 would be 37.7 km (23.4 mi). As the new proposal does not feature any running on train tracks, rail gauges of 1,000 mm (3 ft 3 ³⁄₈ in), 1,435 mm (4 ft 8 ¹⁄₂ in) and 1,524 mm (5 ft) were presented as alternatives. No preference was given to any of the listed gauges, although the benefits of the 1,435 mm (4 ft 8 ¹⁄₂ in) standard gauge were stated to be the highest of the three alternatives.^[38]

The final report on the recommended future development of public transport in Turku was delivered in April 2009.^[40] Based on this report, the city council of Turku decided on 15 December 2009 that in the short run the city's public transport system would be rearranged to allow the establishment of a bus rapid transit line. In the long run the usage of trolleybuses will be studied, while the most heavily trafficked core bus lines are to be converted into light rail lines.^[3]

Museum tramway

The creation of a museum tramway utilising the remaining trams in the possession of the City of Turku was first proposed in 1985, and has since then been the subject of debate in the city.^[9][21][41]

References

1. "Turun raitiotiet / Tramways of Turku" (in Finnish and English). Finnish Tramway Society. Retrieved 14 July 2008.
2. Laaksonen, Mikko. "Raitiovaunulla Naantaliin, Kaarinaan, Runosmäkeen, Varissuolle?" (in Finnish). Finnish Tramway Society. Retrieved 14 July 2008.
3. "Raitiovaunut palaavat Turkuun" (in Finnish). YLE. 15 December 2009. Retrieved 14 July 2010.
4. Sirkiä, Hanna (2003) [2003]. Hyvästi ny sitt – Raitsikat: Turun raitiovaunuliikenteen lakkautus 1961–1972 (PDF) (in Finnish). Turku: University of Turku. p. 10. Retrieved 16 July 2008.
5. "Turun raitiotielinjat, sivu 2" (in Finnish). Finnish Tramway Society. Retrieved 14 July 2008.
6. "Turku: hevosvaunut / Horse Trams" (in Finnish and English). Finnish Tramway Society. Retrieved 14 July 2008.
7. Sirkiä [2003]. pp. 12–14.
8. "Turun raitiotielinjat, sivu 3" (in Finnish). Finnish Tramway Society. Retrieved 14 July 2008.
9. Nummelin, Markku (2001). Raitiotiet / Tramways (in Finnish and English). Jyväskylä: Kustantaja Laaksonen. pp. 79–82. ISBN 951-98475-2-9.
10. Sirkiä [2003]. p. 15.
11. Sirkiä [2003]. pp. 16–18.
12. "Linja 4" (TXT) (in Finnish). Finnish Tramway Society. Retrieved 14 July 2008.
13. "Turun raitiotielinjat, sivu 4" (in Finnish). Finnish Tramway Society. Retrieved 14 July 2008.
14. "TKL: Moottorivaunut 1–13 / Motor Trams 1–13" (in Finnish and English). Finnish Tramway Society. Retrieved 15 July 2008.
15. Sirkiä [2003]. p. 19.
16. "TKL: Moottorivaunut 24-33 / Motor Trams 24-33" (in Finnish and English). Finnish Tramway Society. Retrieved 15 July 2008.
17. Sirkiä [2003]. p. 21.
18. Sirkiä [2003]. pp. 22–24.
19. "Turun raitiotielinjat, sivu 5" (in Finnish). Finnish Tramway Society. Retrieved 14 July 2008.
20. Sirkiä [2003]. pp. 24–29.
21. Alku, Antero (19 October 2002). "Turku". Kaupunkiliikenne.net (in Finnish). Retrieved 15 July 2008.
22. Sirkiä [2003]. pp. 31–37.
23. Sirkiä [2003]. pp. 37–60.
24. Sirkiä [2003]. p. 72.
25. Sirkiä [2003]. pp. 74–79.
26. Sirkiä [2003]. pp. 79–81
27. Sirkiä [2003]. p. 82.
28. Raitio, Lasse (1 October 2002). "Turun viimeisestä ratikkakyydistä tänään 30 vuotta" (in Finnish). Turun Sanomat. Retrieved 16 September 2008.
29. Sirkiä [2003]. p. 126.
30. Laaksonen, Mikko (2 April 2008). "Matkustajamenetykset kun raitiovaunu korvataan bussilla". kaupunkiliikenne.ner (in Finnish). Retrieved 12 September 2008.
31. "Turun raitiovaunut: sisällysluettelo / Trams in Turku: index" (in Finnish and English). Finnish Tramway Society. Retrieved 15 July 2008.
32. "Turku: Museovaunut ja muut olemassaolevat vaunut / Museum Trams and Other Trams that Exist" (in Finnish and English). Finnish Tramway Society. Retrieved 15 July 2008.
33. "TKL: Moottorivaunut 14, 15 / Motor Trams 14, 15" (in Finnish and English). Finnish Tramway Society. Retrieved 15 July 2008.
34. "TKL: Moottorivaunut 16–23 / Motor Trams 16–23" (in Finnish and English). Finnish Tramway Society. Retrieved 15 July 2008.
35. "TKL: Moottorivaunut 38–47 / Motor Trams 38–47" (in Finnish and English). Finnish Tramway Society. Retrieved 15 July 2008.
36. "TKL: Moottorivaunut 48–55 / Motor Trams 48–55" (in Finnish and English). Finnish Tramway Society. Retrieved 15 July 2008.
37. "Rahat eivät riitä ratikkaan" (in Finnish). Turun Sanomat. 16 September 2008. Retrieved 16 September 2008.
38. "Turun seudun joukkoliikenne 2020 – Pikaraitiotievaihtoehdon väliraportti" (in Finnish). WSP Finland Oy. 1 December 2008. pp. 18–24. Retrieved 5 December 2008.
39. "Turun seudulle halutaan yhteinen tehokas joukkoliikennejärjestelmä". City of Turku press release (in Finnish). City of Turku. 1 July 2008. Retrieved 14 July 2008.
40. "Pikaraitiotien väliraportti menossa valtuustoon" (in Finnish). Radio Sata. 5 December 2008. Retrieved 5 December 2008.
41. Sirkiä [2003]. p. 121.