William Downes Griffith

William Downes Griffith (18 July 1829 – 1908) was an Attorney General of the Cape Colony (1866–72), the last British Attorney General there before the country attained self-government.

Early life

Born in Kildare, Ireland, on 18 July 1829, he studied at Trinity College, Dublin, and was called to the bar at the Inner Temple, London, in 1855. He married Harriet Stokes on 1 October 1861.

Attorney General (1866–1872)

Griffith, "literally saturated with law", emigrated to the Cape of Good Hope and served as Attorney General, succeeding the conciliatory and liberal William Porter on 20 March 1866, when that fellow Irishman retired.^[1]

Griffith was reputedly a highly pugnacious and imperious personality, with little tolerance of the locally elected parliamentary representatives and a "somewhat disagreeable manner" that alienated his colleagues.^[2] He was also repeatedly accused of knowing very little about the state and affairs of southern Africa. His term was therefore characterised by fierce antagonism with the spectrum of political interests in southern Africa. While his relationship with the local electorate and their representatives soon became largely unworkable, much of his day-to-day labour was delegated to the quiet but over-worked Mr Simeon Jacobs, who also ended up having to serve as acting Attorney General while Griffith traveled.^[3]

The rise of the "Responsible Government" movement

A movement supportive of self-government and local democracy was growing in the Cape, in response to what was perceived to be the ineptitude and injustice of British Imperial control. This "Responsible Government" movement was fiercely opposed by Griffith, who unsuccessfully worked to obstruct their bills in parliament.^[4]

Griffith drafted the most famous and prominent set of objections that were presented against the establishment of self-government in southern Africa. Among these, he pointed to the predicted effects of the Cape's multi-racial franchise and the "preponderance of the coloured races". He underlined the fact that the Responsible Government movement had strong support from the small but growing "coloured" electorate, which he predicted would soon mobilise in its entirety, and eventually comprise at least half of the Cape's voters. Without direct British control, he could see no easy way in which this political change could be thwarted.^[5]

After a long and bitter political struggle, the parliamentary majority of the local "Responsibles" caused the British Governor to authorise a Bill for self-government to be drafted. Griffith flatly refused to draft it, and took a strategic "leave of absence" to London. As the Attorney General was required for such a bill, Griffith's disappearance caused a serious hitch. However parliament sent for Mr Jacobs, who had long been Griffith's long-suffering right-hand man, and who was consequently very happy to travel from Grahamstown to draft the bill, outmanoeuvring the hated attorney general.^[6]

Later life

After the Responsible Government movement of John Molteno gained power and instituted self-government, Griffith was quietly retired, given a pension, and replaced by the popular and locally born John De Villiers.^[7]

Griffith returned to Britain and became a county court judge (circuit no. 25) in 1877. He was the author of various legal papers, such as The Law of Bankruptcy 1868 and Practice under Judicature Acts 1875, 1877.^[8]

References

1. https://archive.org/stream/lifetimesofsirri00wilm/lifetimesofsirri00wilm_djvu.txt
2. Hon Mr Justice Cole: Reminiscences of my Life and of the Cape Bench and Bar. Juta & Co. 1896. p.59.
3. Kilpin, R.: The Old Cape House, being pages from the history of a legislative assembly. Cape Town: T.M. Miller, 1918.
4. P. A. Molteno: The life and times of Sir John Charles Molteno, K. C. M. G., First Premier of Cape Colony, Comprising a History of Representative Institutions and Responsible Government at the Cape. London: Smith, Elder & Co. 1900
5. George McCall Theal: History of South Africa Since September 1795. Cambridge University Press, 2010. p. 118
6. https://archive.org/stream/reminiscencesofm00coleiala/reminiscencesofm00coleiala_djvu.txt
7. Theal, George McCall, 1837-1919: History of South Africa, from 1873 to 1884. London: Allan. 1919.
8. Wikisource:Page:Men-at-the-Bar.djvu/227