William Tankerville Chamberlain

William Tankerville Chamberlain (25 June 1751 – 12 May 1802) was an Irish judge of the late eighteenth century. He was highly praised by contemporaries for his ability and integrity, but his reputation suffered from his conduct as a judge at the trial for treason of William Orr, a trial which is now widely regarded as a grave miscarriage of justice.

Personal life

Chamberlain was born in Dublin, the son of Michael Chamberlain. He attended St.Bees School in West Cumbria, matriculated from the University of Dublin in 1769 and took his degree of Bachelor of Arts there in 1774. He entered the Middle Temple in 1775 and was called to the Bar in 1779.^[1] He married Lucy Boyd of Rosslare House, Rosslare Harbour: their children included Michael, an army officer, Amy, who married the Reverend Crinus Irwin, Archdeacon of Ossory, by whom she had six children, and Sophia, who married Henry Archer.^[2] He lived mainly at Churchtown, Dublin.

Career

To advance his career Chamberlain joined the well-known political club, the Order of St. Patrick or the Screw, whose members called themselves The Monks of the Screw. He sat in the Irish House of Commons as member for Clonmines, but though he was noted for wit and talent, he did not have much reputation as a politician.^[3]

He was appointed a justice of the Court of Common Pleas in 1793 and was transferred to the Court of King's Bench the following year. He sat on the Special Commission to deal with the Rebellion of 1798. His health was poor: he called himself "a martyr to the gout"^[4] and died in 1802, aged only 50. He was buried in St. Ann's Church, Dawson Street.

State trials

As he was an able and conscientious judge, it was natural that Chamberlain should play a large part in the political trials of the mid-1790s, which culminated in the Irish Rebellion of 1798. That he should be attacked by United Irishmen and nationalists generally was understandable; but one notable trial, that of William Orr, damaged his reputation even among his admirers.^[5]

He sat on a commission to try cases of treason in 1795-6, but most of the accused were acquitted.^[6] At the summer assizes in Armagh in 1797, where more than 150 people were tried for sedition, Chamberlain had "the awful and unexampled duty" of sentencing 20 men to death at one sitting.^[7] After the 1798 Rebellion he sat on the special commission to try the rebels, but the results do not suggest great severity: only five people were put on trial and only one hanged.^[8]

Another state trial, that of Patrick Finney in 1798, shows Chamberlain at his best. Finney, a Dublin tobacconist, was charged with treason, largely on the word of one James O'Brien.^[9] He was defended by John Philpot Curran, who in one of his most famous speeches destroyed O'Brien's credit. Chamberlain conducted the trial with notable fairness, and in his summing up cast doubt on the evidence of O'Brien, and virtually directed an acquittal.^[10] The jury found Finney not guilty. Notwithstanding the case of William Orr, there is little evidence that Chamberlain was a political time-server.

William Orr

William Orr, a popular and respected farmer, was charged with administering the United Irishman oath to a soldier called Wheately: this had recently been made a capital offence, and, in contrast to the normal rules of evidence, only one witness was required to swear to the commission of the offence. Orr was tried at the summer assizes in 1797 before Lord Avonmore, the Chief Baron of the Irish Exchequer, and Chamberlain.^[11] John Philpot Curran, defending, exposed Wheately as a liar and man of bad character and argued that the jury had no choice but to acquit. His argument that the judges had misstated the law led to angry exchanges. The circumstances which led to the guilty verdict later caused much comment, two of the jury claiming that they had been made drunk, and two others claiming that they had been threatened. It may be that the judges themselves had doubts, as Avonmore is said to have shed tears as he pronounced the death sentence. Despite numerous pleas for a reprieve, Orr was hanged at Carrickfergus on 14 October.

As it is generally accepted now that Orr was innocent,^[12] Chamberlain clearly shares the responsibility for the miscarriage of justice; on the other hand Avonmore was very much the senior judge and seems to have dominated the proceedings. The Government, aware of the hostile public reaction, praised both judges for "integrity and humanity": but a Dublin newspaper, The Press, was sufficiently concerned by the trial to attack the conduct of both judges, and the editor, Peter Finnerty was prosecuted and convicted for seditious libel as a result.^[13]

Character

Chamberlain was praised as an able and upright judge and a sound lawyer; even his conduct of the Orr trial had its defenders.^[14] When he died in 1802, the newly appointed Lord Chancellor of Ireland, Lord Redesdale, was warned that it would not be easy to find a suitable replacement.^[15] He seems also to have had the gift of friendship: his colleague, later Lord Chief Justice of Ireland, Lord Downes, when he died in 1826 asked to be buried beside Chamberlain. Like most judges of the time he was notably extravagant: they were expected to live and entertain on a scale beyond their salaries, and Chamberlain is said to have died almost penniless.^[16]

References

1. Ball, F. Elrington The Judges in Ireland 1221–1921 John Murray London 1926 Vol.2 p.227
2. Freeman's Journal November 1827
3. Ball, p.181
4. Ball, p.242
5. Ball, p.183
6. Ball, p.184
7. Ball, p. 184
8. Ball, p.185
9. Speeches of John Philpot Curran New York 1811 Vol.1 p.252
10. Speeches of John Philpot Curran pp.276–7
11. Ball, p. 183
12. Ball, p.183
13. Ball, p.183
14. Ball, p.183
15. Ball, p.242
16. Ball, p.250