Baby Fae

Baby Fae

Baby Fae, shortly after her transplant. The dark stripe on her torso is the surgical incision.
Born Stephanie Fae Beauclair
(1984-10-14)October 14, 1984
Died November 15, 1984(1984-11-15) (aged &&&&&&&&&&&&&0321 mo 1 day)
Known for first infant subject of a xenotransplant procedure

Stephanie Fae Beauclair[1] (October 14, 1984 – November 15, 1984), better known as Baby Fae, was an American infant born in 1984 with hypoplastic left heart syndrome. She became the first infant subject of a xenotransplant procedure and first successful infant heart transplant, receiving the heart of a baboon. Though she died within a month of the procedure, she had lived weeks longer than any previous recipient of a non-human heart.

Procedure

The procedure, performed by Leonard L. Bailey at Loma Linda University Medical Center, was successful, but Fae died 21 days later of heart failure due to rejection of the transplant. The rejection is thought to have been caused largely by a humoral response against the graft, due to Fae's type O blood creating antibodies against the type AB xenograft.[2] The blood type incompatibility was seen as unavoidable: fewer than 1% of baboons are type O, and Loma Linda only had seven young female baboons – all of which were type AB – available as potential donors.

It was hoped that the transplant could be replaced by an allograft at a later date, before Fae's body began generating isohaemagglutinins, but a suitable donor could not be found in time. Prior to the procedure, no infant heart transplant - even with human hearts - had been successfully performed due to a lack of infant human hearts. [3] To address this issue, Bailey had become a pioneer in the research of cross-species heart transplants, which had included "more than 150 transplants in sheep, goats, and baboons". [3]

A baboon heart was used as there was no time for a suitable human heart to be found. Multiple surgeons had previously experimented with baboon heart implants, leading some to speculate even that baboons could be farmed in the future for such purposes. When asked why he had picked a baboon over a primate more closely related to humans in evolution, he replied, "I don't believe in evolution."[4] Though she died with a month, Baby Fae, at the time of her death, had lived two weeks longer than any previous recipient of a non-human heart.[3]

Ethics

The procedure was subject to a wide ethical and legal debate, but the attention that it generated is thought to have paved the way for Bailey to perform the first successful infant allograft heart transplant a year later. The Baby Fae case, and Bailey's role in it, has been a popular case study in the realm of medical ethics. Bailey did not look for a human heart for Fae. There were questions as to whether parents should be allowed to volunteer children for experimental medical procedures, and whether the parents themselves were properly informed by Bailey. However, because Fae's mother had no medical insurance, she could not afford to pay for the heart transplant procedure. The xenograft, on the other hand, was offered for free.

The case further brought up debates regarding the risk/benefit ratio that should be considered ethical when dealing with experimental procedures on human subjects.[5] Charles Krauthammer, writing in Time, said the Baby Fae case was totally within the realm of experimentation and was "an adventure in medical ethics".[6] Ultimately, the American Medical Association and top medical journals criticized Bailey, concluding that xenografts should be undertaken only as part of a systematic research program with controls in randomized clinical trials.[4] The validity of the consent obtained in the case of Baby Fae has also been largely criticized. Bailey originally alleged that he obtained consent following a long discussion with the mother and father. It was later revealed, however, that the father was not present at the time of consent. The information in the consent form was also changed after the mother originally saw it. The original phrasing stated that the procedure could potentially extend Baby Fae's life 'long term'.[7] Although Fae's full name was not made public at the time of the procedure, her mother chose to reveal herself in 1997.[8]

Popular Culture

The Paul Simon song "The Boy in the Bubble" from the 1986 Graceland album, most likely references her in the lyrics. "Medicine is magical and magical is art / Thinking of the Boy in the Bubble / And the baby with the baboon heart".

References

  1. ↑ The Legacy of Baby Fae, at Loma Linda University; published no later than October 2009; retrieved August 16, 2014
  2. ↑ Bailey, Leonard; Nehlsen-Cannarella SL; Concepcion W; Jolley WB. (December 1985). "Baboon-to-human cardiac xenotransplantation in a neonate.". The Journal of the American Medical Association. 3321-9. 254 (23): 3321–9. doi:10.1001/jama.1985.03360230053022. PMID 2933538.
  3. 1 2 3 http://time.com/4086900/baby-fae-history/. Missing or empty |title= (help)
  4. 1 2 Pence, Gregory E. (2008). Classic Cases in Medical Ethics (PDF) (5th ed.). Retrieved May 28, 2013.
  5. ↑ "Case: Willowbrook Experiments". www.qcc.cuny.edu. Retrieved 2016-01-19.
  6. ↑ Charles Krauthammer, Essay: The Using of Baby Fae, Time, December 3, 1984, accessed May 28, 2013.
  7. ↑ Times, Sandra Blakeslee, Special To The New York (1985-12-20). "BABOON HEART IMPLANT IN BABY FAE IN 1984 ASSAILED AS 'WISHFUL THINKING'". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2016-01-19.
  8. ↑ "Four Corners - 8/25/1997: Animal Transplants. Australian Broadcasting Corp". Abc.net.au. Retrieved 2008-11-26.

Sources

External links

This article is issued from Wikipedia - version of the Saturday, April 23, 2016. The text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution/Share Alike but additional terms may apply for the media files.