Brinkman v. Long

Brinkman v. Long

No. 2013-CV-32572
Colorado Seventeenth Judicial District Court
Date decided July 9, 2014[1]
Judge sitting C. Scott Crabtree, District Judge
Case history
Prior actions Motion to consolidate with McDaniel-Miccio v. Hickenlooper, No. 14-CV-30731, granted, Order of Colo. Chief Justice (May 8, 2014).
Case holding
Colorado's ban on same-sex marriage violates plaintiffs' guarantees of Due Process and Equal Protection under the Fourteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.

Brinkman v. Long and its companion case, McDaniel-Miccio v. Hickenlooper, are the lead state court cases on same-sex marriage in Colorado. Here, a Colorado district court found on July 9, 2014 that the state's same-sex marriage ban violates same-sex couples' guarantees of equal protection and due process under the Fourteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. Brinkman and McDaniel-Miccio have been appealed to the Colorado Supreme Court, where they were dismissed following the dismissal of similar petitions by the U.S. Supreme Court on October 6, 2014.

Introduction

After being denied a marriage license, a lesbian couple filed a lawsuit on October 30, 2013 in the Seventeenth Judicial District. The case, Brinkman v. Long, seeks to overturn the state's constitutional ban on same-sex marriage.[2][3] The couple was joined on February 18, 2014, by nine other same-sex couples who filed a lawsuit, McDaniel-Miccio v. Hickenlooper, also in state district court, seeking the same outcome.[4][5] Four of the couples are raising children, and five of the couples have married in other states. The suit named Governor John Hickenlooper and Denver City Clerk Debra Johnson as defendants. Hickenlooper responded by noting Colorado's support for civil unions. Johnson said she supported marriage rights for same-sex couples but was obligated to follow the law by denying them marriage licenses. Colorado Attorney General John Suthers, a Republican, announced he would defend the state's ban.[6]

District Court proceedings

Brinkman and McDaniel-Miccio were combined for argument in state district court. Written motions for summary judgment were submitted by May 2, 2014. A court hearing was held on June 16, 2014 in Adams County before state District Judge C. Scott Crabtree, who was reported to be skeptical about the state's position.[7][8]

Ruling

On July 9, 2014, Judge Crabtree ruled that Colorado's same-sex marriage ban violated the plaintiffs' guarantees of equal protection and due process under the Fourteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution:

No state since U.S. v. Windsor has been able to justify its ban under even the rational basis test, much less under the strict scrutiny test.[1]

The judge also noted that because Colorado's civil unions deny same-sex couples federal benefits provided to different-sex couples, "[t]he existence of civil unions [in Colorado] is further evidence of discrimination against same-sex couples and does not ameliorate the discriminatory effect of the Marriage Bans." This argument that civil unions are inherently inferior to marriage had been used successfully before—in Kerrigan v. Commissioner of Public Health, the case that recognized same-sex marriage in Connecticut, a decision which Judge Crabtree references; and in Garden State Equality v. Dow, the New Jersey case that led to marriage equality there. The judge stayed his ruling pending the outcome of appeals.[1]

Effect of Colorado ex rel. Suthers

Colorado District Judge Andrew Hartman's decision in Colorado ex rel. Suthers v. Hall provided legal cover for the Boulder County clerk to issue same-sex marriage licenses as a form of civil disobedience. After Hartman's decision was handed down, the Denver County and Pueblo County clerks began issuing licenses to couples regardless of gender as well, despite Judge Crabtree's stay. When asked to enjoin the Denver County clerk from issuing licenses to same-sex couples, Judge Crabtree refused to take action. On July 14, 2014, Colorado Attorney General Suthers appealed Judge Crabtree's inaction to the Colorado Supreme Court. In a separate filing, and seeking a reversal of Judge Hartman's ruling, the state attorney general also asked the high court for an emergency injunction to stop all state clerks from issuing licenses.[9][10]

Colorado Supreme Court proceedings

In a July 18, 2014 unanimous order issued en banc, the Colorado Supreme Court rejected the attorney general's request for an emergency injunction—one which would have statewide effect. However, in light of the previous stay entered by Judge Crabtree but thereafter left unenforced, the Colorado Supreme Court ordered clerks in Adams and Denver counties stop issuing licenses pursuant to Colorado Appellate Rule 8. That rule grants the high court power to issue a stay where "the trial court … has failed to afford the relief which the applicant requested", Brinkman v. Colorado, No. 2014-SA-212.[11]

On October 6, the U.S. Supreme Court rejected petitions to review decisions of the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals, which comprises Colorado, in Kitchen v. Herbert (Utah) and Bishop v. United States (Oklahoma) that found state bans on same-sex marriage unconstitutional. On October 7, the Colorado Supreme Court lifted its injunction and dismissed the appeal in this case.[12]

References

  1. 1 2 3 C. Scott Crabtree, Colorado District Judge (July 9, 2014). "Summary Judgment Order, Brinkman v. Long, No. 13-CV-32572, and McDaneil-Miccio v. Colorado, No. 14-CV-30731" (PDF). Colorado Seventeenth Judicial District Court, Adams County (courts.state.co.us).
  2. ↑ "Couple files suit against Colorado gay marriage ban". FOX21 News. November 1, 2013. Retrieved April 8, 2014.
  3. ↑ "Brinkman v. Long" (PDF). Retrieved April 3, 2014.
  4. ↑ Verlee, Megan (February 20, 2014). "Same-sex couples file suit to overturn Colorado gay marriage ban". Colorado Public Radio. Retrieved April 8, 2014.
  5. ↑ "McDaniel-Miccio v. Hickenlooper" (PDF). Retrieved April 3, 2014.
  6. ↑ Mitchell, Kirk; Lee, Kurtis (February 19, 2014). "Nine couples seek to overturn Colorado's gay marriage ban". Denver Post. Retrieved April 8, 2014.
  7. ↑ Steffen, Jordan (June 16, 2014). "Colorado Defends Same Sex Marriage Ban in Court". The Denver Post. Retrieved June 17, 2014.
  8. ↑ Riccardi, Nicholas (June 16, 2014). "Colorado judge skeptical of gay marriage ban". Salt Lake Tribune. Associated Press. Retrieved June 17, 2014.
  9. ↑ Ingold, John (July 14, 2014). "Suthers asks Supreme Court to stop clerks from issuing licenses to gay couples". Denver Post. Retrieved July 14, 2014.
  10. ↑ Francisco, Michael (on behalf of Colorado Attorney General John W. Suthers) (14 July 2014). "Emergency Motion for Injunction Pending Appeal, Colorado ex rel. Suthers v. Hall, No. 2014-SA-212". Colorado Supreme Court (Scribd.com).
  11. ↑ Per Curiam (18 July 2014). "Order of Court, Brinkman and Burd v. Colorado, No. 2014-SA-212" (PDF). Colorado Supreme Court, en banc (LGBTQ Nation.com).
  12. ↑ Stanley, Deb (October 7, 2014). "Colorado Attorney General orders all county clerks to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples". 7News Denver. Retrieved January 17, 2015.

See also

This article is issued from Wikipedia - version of the Wednesday, July 01, 2015. The text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution/Share Alike but additional terms may apply for the media files.