Ergotism

Ergotism
Advanced ergotism with gangrene
Classification and external resources
Specialty	emergency medicine
ICD-10	T62.2
ICD-9-CM	988.2
DiseasesDB	30715
MeSH	D004881

Ergotism (pron. /ˈɜːrɡətˌɪzəm/ UR-gət-iz-əm) is the effect of long term ergot poisoning, traditionally due to the ingestion of the alkaloids produced by the Claviceps purpurea fungus that infects rye and other cereals, and more recently by the action of a number of ergoline-based drugs. It is also known as ergotoxicosis, ergot poisoning and Saint Anthony's Fire. Ergot poisoning is a proposed explanation of bewitchment.

Signs and symptoms

The symptoms can be roughly divided into convulsive symptoms and gangrenous symptoms.

Convulsive

Convulsive symptoms of ergotism

Convulsive symptoms include painful seizures and spasms, diarrhea, paresthesias, itching, mental effects including mania or psychosis, headaches, nausea and vomiting. Usually the gastrointestinal effects precede central nervous system effects.

Gangrenous

The dry gangrene is a result of vasoconstriction induced by the ergotamine-ergocristine alkaloids of the fungus. It affects the more poorly vascularized distal structures, such as the fingers and toes. Symptoms include desquamation or peeling, weak peripheral pulses, loss of peripheral sensation, edema and ultimately the death and loss of affected tissues. Vasoconstriction is treated with vasodilators.^[1]

Causes

Claviceps purpurea fungal sclerotia growing on barley

The toxic ergoline derivatives are found in ergot-based drugs (such as methylergometrine, ergotamine or, previously, ergotoxine). The deleterious side-effects occur either under high dose or when moderate doses interact with potentiators such as erythromycin.

Historically, eating grain products contaminated with the fungus Claviceps purpurea also caused ergotism.

The alkaloids can also pass through lactation from mother to child, causing ergotism in infants.

Identification

Ergot in barley

Dark-purple or black grain kernels, known as ergot bodies, can be identifiable in the heads of cereal or grass just before harvest. In most plants the ergot bodies are larger than normal grain kernels, but can be smaller if the grain is a type of wheat. A larger separation between the bodies and the grain kernels show the removal of ergot bodies during grain cleaning.

Prevention

Removal of ergot bodies is done by placing the yield in a brine solution; the ergot bodies float while the healthy grains sink.^[2] Infested fields need to be deep plowed; ergot cannot germinate if buried more than one inch in soil and therefore won't release its spores into the air. Rotating crops using non-susceptible plants helps reduce infestations since ergot spores only live one year. Crop rotation and deep tillage, such as deep moldboard plowing, are important components in managing ergot, as many cereal crops in the 21st Century are sown with a "no-till" practice (new crops are seeded directly into the stubble from the previous crop to reduce soil erosion.)^[3] Wild and escaped grasses and pastures can be mowed before they flower to help limit the spread of ergot.

Chemical controls can also be used, but are not considered economical especially in commercial operations, and germination of ergot spores can still occur under favorable conditions even with the use of such controls.

History

Painting by Matthias Grünewald of a patient suffering from advanced ergotism from approximately 1512–16 CE

Epidemics of the disease were identified throughout history, though the references in classical writers are inconclusive. Rye, the main vector for transmitting ergotism, was not grown much around the Mediterranean. When Fuchs 1834 separated references to ergotism from erysipelas and other afflictions, he found the earliest reference to ergotism in the Annales Xantenses for the year 857: "a Great plague of swollen blisters consumed the people by a loathsome rot, so that their limbs were loosened and fell off before death."

In the Middle Ages, the gangrenous poisoning was known as "holy fire" or "Saint Anthony's fire", named after monks of the Order of St. Anthony who were particularly successful at treating this ailment. The 12th century chronicler Geoffroy du Breuil of Vigeois recorded the mysterious outbreaks in the Limousin region of France, where the gangrenous form of ergotism was associated with the local Saint Martial. According to Snorri Sturluson, in his Heimskringla, King Magnus, son of King Harald Sigurtharson, who was the half brother of Saint King Olaf Haraldsson, died from ergotism shortly after the Battle of Hastings.

The blight, named from the cock's spur it forms on grasses, was identified and named by Denis Dodart, who reported the relation between ergotized rye and bread poisoning in a letter to the French Royal Academy of Sciences in 1676 (John Ray mentioned ergot for the first time in English the next year). "Ergotism", in this modern sense, was first recorded in 1853; however, Sir Thomas Browne in his Christian Morals (published posthumously in 1716, although penned sometime in the 1670s) also made mention of 'ergotisms'.^[4] Browne in turn, may have been introduced to the word through correspondence with John Ray.

Notable epidemics of ergotism occurred up into the 19th century. Fewer outbreaks have occurred since then due to rye being carefully monitored in developed countries. A severe outbreak of something akin to ergot poisoning occurred, however, in the French village of Pont-Saint-Esprit in 1951, resulting in five deaths.^[5] The outbreak, and the diagnostic confusion surrounding it, are vividly described in John Grant Fuller's book The Day of St Anthony's Fire.^[6]

There is evidence^[7] of ergot poisoning serving a ritual purpose in the ritual killing of certain bog bodies.^[8]

When milled, the ergot is reduced to a red powder,^[9] obvious in lighter grasses but easy to miss in dark rye flour. In less wealthy countries, ergotism still occurs; an outbreak in Ethiopia occurred in mid-2001 from contaminated barley. Whenever there is a combination of moist weather, cool temperatures, delayed harvest in lowland crops and rye consumption, an outbreak is possible.

Poisonings due to consumption of seeds treated with mercury compounds are sometimes misidentified as ergotism.^[10][11] As Dr. Simon Cotton (member of the Chemistry Department of Uppingham School, UK) notes, there have been numerous cases of mass-poisoning due to consumption of mercury-treated seeds.^[12]

Salem witchcraft accusations

The convulsive symptoms from ergot-tainted rye may have been the source of accusations of bewitchment that spurred the Salem witch trials. This medical explanation for the theory of “bewitchment” was first propounded by Linnda R. Caporael in 1976 in an article in Science. In her article, Caporael argues that the convulsive symptoms, such as crawling sensations in the skin, tingling in the fingers, vertigo, tinnitus aurium, headaches, disturbances in sensation, hallucination, painful muscular contractions, vomiting, and diarrhea, as well as psychological symptoms, such as mania, melancholia, psychosis, and delirium, were all symptoms reported in the Salem witchcraft records. Caporael also states there was an abundance of rye in the region as well as climate conditions that could support the tainting of rye.^[13] In 1982, historian Mary Matossian raised Caporael’s theory in an article in American Scientist in which she argued that symptoms of “bewitchment” resemble the ones exhibited in those afflicted with ergot poisoning.^[14]

The hypothesis that ergotism could explain cases of bewitchment has been subject to debate and has been criticized by several scholars. Within a year of Caporael’s article, the historians Spanos and Gottlieb argued against the idea in the same journal. In Spanos and Gottlieb’s rebuttal to Caporael’s article, they concluded that there are several flaws in the explanation. For example, they argued that, if the food supply was contaminated, the symptoms would have occurred on a house-by-house basis, not just in particular individuals. Historian Leon Harrier has rebutted that even if supplies were properly cooked, residents suffering from stomach ulcers had a risk of absorbing the toxin through the stomach lining, offering a direct route to the bloodstream. Being similar to Lysergic acid diethylamide (LSD), the average human's stomach would be too acidic for the ergot to survive, especially if the food was properly cooked. But, if some residents were malnourished and suffering from bleeding stomach ulcers, a minority could be affected by ingesting contaminated grains, leaving the majority unaffected, explaining why ergotism was not previously recognized. Harrier argued that the numbers could have been larger, possibly including the entire town, but due to the trials on bewitchment and heresy, and the fear of being accused and subsequently executed, few could come forward while suffering from legitimate medical conditions.

Spanos and Gottlieb also state that ergot poisoning has additional symptoms not associated with the events in Salem and that the proportion of children afflicted was less than in a typical ergotism epidemic.^[15] The anthropologist H. Sidky noted that ergotism had existed for centuries before the Salem witch trials, and argued that its symptoms would have been recognizable during the time of the Salem witch trials.^[16]

More recently, it has been pointed out that ergots produced by different strains of Claviceps purpurea, and those growing in different soils, may produce different ergot alkaloid compositions. This may explain the different manifestations of ergotism in different outbreaks. For example, an alkaloid, present in high concentrations in ergots from Europe east of the Rhine may have caused convulsive ergotism, while to the west it caused epidemics of gangrenous ergotism.^[17]

See also

• Dancing Plague of 1518

References

1. Piquemal R, Emmerich J, Guilmot JL, Fiessinger JN (June 1998). "Successful treatment of ergotism with Iloprost—a case report". Angiology 49 (6): 493–97. doi:10.1177/000331979804900612. PMID 9631897.
2. http://ianrpubs.unl.edu/live/ec1880/build/ec1880.pdf[]
3. http://www.apsnet.org/edcenter/intropp/lessons/fungi/ascomycetes/Pages/Ergot.aspx
4. 'Natural parts and good Judgement rule the World. States are not governed by ergotisms' Christian Morals pub. 1716 Part 2 Section 4
5. Richards, Ira S (2008). Principles and Practice of Toxicology in Public Health. Sudbury, MA: Jones & Bartlett. p. 64. ISBN 0-7637-3823-9.
6. Fuller, John (1969). The Day of St Anthony's Fire. London: Hutchinson. ISBN 0-09-095460-2.
7. Taylor, Timothy (2003), The Buried Soul: How Humans Invented Death, Fourth Estate.
8. Stødkilde-Jørgensen, Hans; Jacobsen, Niels Otto; Warncke, Esbern; Heinemeier, Jan (March 2008). "The intestines of a more than 2000 years old peat-bog man: microscopy, magnetic resonance imaging and 14C-dating". Journal of Archaeological Science 35 (3): 530–4. doi:10.1016/j.jas.2007.05.010.
9. Cadwick, Ian. "Scripturient: Blog & Commentary." Scripturient Blog Commentary. 9 Nov. 2013. Web. 30 Nov. 2014. <http://ianchadwick.com/blog/bread-madness-and-christianity/>.
10. Ott, Jonathan (1993), Pharmacotheon: Entheogenic Drugs, their Plant Sources and History, Kennewick, WA: Natural Products, p. 145.
11. Hofmann, Albert (1980), "1: How LSD Originated", LSD: My Problem Child, New York, NY: McGraw-Hill, p. 6.
12. Cotton, Simon (October 2003), "Dimethylmercury and Mercury Poisoning", Molecule of the Month, UK: School of Chemistry, University of Bristol, More horrifying than this were epidemics of poisoning, caused by people eating treated seed grains. There was a serious epidemic in Iraq in 1956 and again in 1960, whilst use of seed wheat (which had been treated with a mixture of C₂H₅HgCl and C₆H₅HgOCOCH₃) for food, caused the poisoning of about 100 people in West Pakistan in 1961. Another outbreak happened in Guatemala in 1965. Most serious was the disaster in Iraq in 1971–2, when according to official figures 459 died. Grain had been treated with methyl mercury compounds as a fungicide and should have been planted. Instead it was sold for milling and made into bread. It had been dyed red as a warning and also had warning labels in English and Spanish that no one could understand. .
13. Caporael, Linnda R (April 1976). "Ergotism: The Satan Loose in Salem". Science 192 (4234): 21–6. Bibcode:1976Sci...192...21C. doi:10.1126/science.769159. PMID 769159.
14. Matossian, Mary (July–August 1982). "Ergot and the Salem Witchcraft Affair". American Scientist 70 (4): 355–7. Bibcode:1982AmSci..70..355M. PMID 6756230.
15. Spanos, Nicholas; Gottlieb, John ‘Jack’ (December 1976). "Ergotism and the Salem Village Witch Trials". Science 194 (4272): 1390–4. Bibcode:1976Sci...194.1390S. doi:10.1126/science.795029. PMID 795029.
16. Sidky, H (1997). Witchcraft, Lycanthropy, Drugs and Disease: An Anthropological Study of the European Witch Hunts. Peter Lang. ISBN 0-8204-3354-3.
17. Eadie MJ (July 2003). "Convulsive ergotism: epidemics of the serotonin syndrome?". Lancet Neurology 2 (7): 429–34. doi:10.1016/S1474-4422(03)00439-3. PMID 12849122.