Grand Theft Auto clone

Grand Theft Auto III is credited with popularizing a game genre based on driving and shooting in an open world setting.

Grand Theft Auto clone is a subgenre of open world action-adventure video games, characterized by their likeness to the Grand Theft Auto series in either gameplay, or overall design. These types of open world games are games in which players may find and use a variety of vehicles and weapons while roaming freely in an open world setting. The objective of such games is to complete a sequence of core missions involving driving and shooting, but often side-missions and minigames are added to improve replay value. The storylines of games in this subgenre typically have strong themes of crime and violence.

The subgenre has its origins in open-world action adventure games popularized in Europe (and particularly the United Kingdom) throughout the 1980s and 1990s. The release of Grand Theft Auto (1997) marked a major commercial success for open-ended game design in North America, and featured a more marketable crime theme. But it was the popularity of its 3D sequel Grand Theft Auto III in 2001 that led to the widespread propagation of a more specific set of gameplay conventions consistent with a subgenre. The subgenre now includes many games from different developers all over the world where the player can control wide ranges of vehicles and weapons. The subgenre has evolved with greater levels of environmental detail and more realistic behaviors.

Since calling a game a "clone" usually has a negative connotation, reviewers have come up with other names for the subgenre. Names such as "sandbox games", however, are applied to a wider range of games that do not share key features of the Grand Theft Auto series.

Definition

A Grand Theft Auto clone^[1] is a video game that falls within the genre popularized by the 2001 title Grand Theft Auto III,^[2] where players are given the ability to drive any vehicle or fire any weapon as they explore an open world.^[3] These games are sometimes treated as a 3D action-adventure game,^[4] or third-person shooter.^[5] They are noted for frequently bearing strong violent or criminal themes,^[6] though exceptions like American McGee Presents: Scrapland have copied its gameplay and structure with a Teen rating.^[7]

Other terminology

Calling a game a "Grand Theft Auto clone" is sometimes considered unfair or insulting.^[8] This is because reviewers sometimes use this term to suggest that the "clone" is a mere imitation, which commonly occurs in the video game industry, designed for the sole purpose of capitalizing on the success of the Grand Theft Auto series.^[9] However, this term can also be used as a neutral description of a game,^[10] which can range from good to bad.^[11] Reviewers have used "Grand Theft Auto clone" to describe games that rest on their own merits, and do not necessarily dismiss the entire class of games as mere imitators.^[12]

Games of this type are sometimes defined under the broader terminology "open world games" or "sandbox games".^[3] However, many games that predate Grand Theft Auto III, such as Metroid from 1986, are also called open world games.^[13] Conflictingly, games such as Grand Theft Auto III and Body Harvest are credited with inventing this genre more than a decade later.^[14][15] Furthermore, reviewers have stated that this genre does not include every game with a freely explorable world and that this genre is much more specific, thus excluding the free-roaming titles Spider-Man 2 and The Incredible Hulk: Ultimate Destruction from this class of games.^[6] The terminology is inconsistent, sometimes including any game with open level design,^[13] while other times focusing on a specific genre created at the turn of the century.^[16]

Without clear classifications to describe the genre popularized by Grand Theft Auto, reviewers have created a number of alternate names for this genre. Some reviewers have focused on the pervasive criminal themes and content in the genre, using terminology such as "crime games", "crime-based action games",^[17] and what CNN called the "gangsta genre".^[18] Other journalists have emphasized gameplay by describing the genre as "free roaming action adventure games",^[19] "driving-and-shooting games",^[20] and "driving action hybrids".^[21]

Game design

Driving and shooting

Grand Theft Auto clones offer players the ability to steal and drive a number of vehicles.^[22][23] Games have included all kinds of vehicles, such as cars, helicopters, boats, jet-skis, fixed-wing aircraft, and military vehicles.^[6] Reviewers have compared these games based on the number of vehicles they offer, with greater choice resulting in better reviews.^[6] Players can also use vehicles as weapons, either by driving into enemies, or by damaging the vehicle until it explodes.^[16] Some games allow vehicles to perform stunts.^[6] Games in the genre thus incorporate elements of driving simulation games.^[24] Some games even allow players to customize their vehicles.^[25]

Players can engage in combat using range of weapons depending on the game setting, such as assault weapons, sniper rifles, explosives, rocket launchers, and close-range melee weapons.^[6] As such, several reviewers have stated that games in this genre are partially third person shooters.^[5] Players can find weapons scattered throughout the game world, and may buy weapons in shops or take them from dead enemies.^[3] Virtually anyone in the game world can be attacked by the player. In many games, excessive violent behavior will provoke a reaction by police authorities, who the player may then choose to fight or evade.^[26] Players must also keep track of their health and ammunition in order to succeed in combat.^[16]

These games have employed a variety of aiming mechanisms, such as free look aiming or a "lock-on" button.^[27] Several games have been criticized for difficult or burdensome controls when it comes to shooting,^[22][27] and thus video game designers have tried refine the aiming and shooting controls in these games.^[6]

Open world and missions

Grand Theft Auto clones allow players to freely explore the game world,^[6] which is typically on the scale of an entire city. Some games base their level design on real world cities, such as London, New York City, and Los Angeles.^[6] Players are usually able to navigate by vehicle or on foot.^[28][29] Some games put greater emphasis on leaping, climbing,^[6] and even swimming.^[30] Exploring the world is not just necessary to complete objectives, but also to gain valuable items, weapons, and vehicles. Different parts of the game world may be controlled by different enemy factions, who will attempt to stop the player in a variety of ways.^[16] However, more recent games in this genre allow players to acquire their own territory.^[8][31] The freedom of navigating a huge game world may be overwhelming or confusing for new players.^[16] Game designers have come up with a variety of navigational aids to solve this problem. A mini-map feature is common,^[32] while Saints Row and Grand Theft Auto IV go so far as to offer a GPS service.^[24] Games without these navigation tools are sometimes criticized as confusing.^[6]

The player's freedom to explore may be limited until they complete certain objectives and advance the game plot.^[16] Players must visit specific locations and complete specific missions in order to win the game,^[33] such as racing, tailing, couriering, robbing,^[29] stealing,^[22] shooting, assassinating, and driving to specific checkpoints.^[34] There may be multiple ways to complete these missions as the game environment is designed to facilitate shortcuts, experimentation, and creative ways to kill enemies.^[16] Completing a core mission will unlock further missions and advance the storyline,^[8] and if the player fails a mission they will be able to resume the game from before the mission began.^[22] In addition, these games usually offer optional side missions, which allow players to gain other rewards. These side missions improve the game's replay value.^[16] These games are also known for incorporating numerous minigames into the game world,^[35] such as circuit races.^[25] Ultimately, this allows the player to follow or ignore the game's storyline as they see fit.^[23]

History

Origin

Body Harvest (1998) is credited with making Grand Theft Auto III possible.

Open-world, 3D action-adventure games existed for years prior to the release of any similar game from the Scottish developer DMA Design.^[36] Mercenary (1985) has been described as a major ancestor to the Grand Theft Auto series, because it featured an open world which the player could explore freely.^[13] The Terminator, released in 1990, was a free-form, open-world game that set its action in a modern-day city that extended for miles, and included the ability to fire at civilians and steal cars. This game was also among the first American-developed games to feature these elements.^[37]

Hunter (1991) has been described as the first sandbox game featuring full 3D, third-person graphics, thus making it an important precursor to the Grand Theft Auto series.^[38] The game consisted of a large, open world in which there were numerous possibilities to complete different missions.^[38] The character could travel on foot, or steal different vehicles such as cars, tanks, or even bicycles, boats, helicopters and hovercrafts.^[38] Moreover, Hunter also had many unique features such as day and night lighting, fuel modelling, a log book, aerial observation units, tank traps, land mines and computer-controlled rocket batteries and tracer guns.^[39] It was also possible to ride a bicycle, swim, windsurf or even make a parachute jump from a helicopter.^[38][39]

DMA Design began pursuing open-world game design with the first Grand Theft Auto,^[14] which allowed players to commandeer various automobiles and shoot various weapons within a mission-based structure.^[40] Unlike later games in the series, and indeed many earlier influences, the first two GTA games were 2D. In 1998, DMA moved many of these design concepts into a 3D world, with Body Harvest, a Nintendo 64 game developed by DMA Design (which eventually became Rockstar North when it was acquired by Rockstar Games).^[14] This title featured an open world with nonlinear missions and side-quests, as well as the ability to commandeer and drive a variety of vehicles.^[14] As such, it has been retroactively called "GTA in space" (despite the fact that the entire game takes place in various settings on earth),^[14] and is credited with making Grand Theft Auto III possible.^[41] Dan Houser has also cited the 3D Mario and Zelda games on the Nintendo 64 as major influences.^[42] Another important influence came from the Driver series, which was created in 1999, with its open city environments and being cited as the first driving game to allow the player to go anywhere in the map.^[43][44]

Grand Theft Auto III took the gameplay foundation of the first two Grand Theft Auto games and expanded it into a 3D world,^[45] and offered an unprecedented variety of minigames and side-missions.^[35] The title was a much greater commercial success than its direct precursors,^[14] and its influence was profound.^[45] As such, Grand Theft Auto III is credited with popularizing this genre,^[14] let alone inventing it.^[15] Its release is sometimes treated as a revolutionary event in the history of video games, much like the release of Doom nearly a decade earlier.^[46] GamePro called it the most important game of all time, and claimed that every genre was influenced to rethink their conventional level design.^[47] IGN similarly praised it as one of the top ten most influential games of all time.^[35] Subsequent games that follow this formula of driving and shooting in a free-roaming level have been called Grand Theft Auto clones.^[43]

Other critics, however, likened Grand Theft Auto III to The Legend of Zelda and Metroid,^[13] as well as Shenmue in particular,^{[48][49][50][51]} and noted how GTA III had combined elements from previous games and fused them together into a new immersive experience. For instance, radio stations had been implemented earlier in games such as Sega's Out Run (1986)^[52] and Maxis' SimCopter (1996), open-ended missions based on operating a taxi cab in a sandbox environment were the basis for Sega's Crazy Taxi (1999),^[53] the ability to kill non-player characters dated back to action role-playing games like Hydlide II (1985),^[54] and Final Fantasy Adventure (1991),^[55] and the way in which players run over pedestrians and get chased by police has been compared to Pac-Man (1980).^[56]

Recent history

Rockstar North developed Grand Theft Auto: Vice City in 2002, which expanded on the open world concept by letting players explore the interior of more than sixty buildings.^[31] The game featured an expanded soundtrack and the voice talent of several Hollywood actors, including Ray Liotta. This set a new standard for the genre, making studio talent a pre-requisite for success.^[57] Other game developers entered the field that year, with releases such as The Getaway.^[6] The Simpsons: Hit & Run in 2003 applied the concept to a cartoon world,^[6] while True Crime: Streets of LA reversed the Grand Theft Auto formula by putting the player in the role of a police officer.^[58] Even the Driver series, which influenced Grand Theft Auto III, began to follow this formula by combining driving and shooting in Driv3r.^[43] Some reviewers began warning parents of the growing number of games in this genre, due to the violent themes intended for mature audiences.^[57]

A mural ad for Grand Theft Auto IV, which currently holds numerous sales records.

Ultimately, rival developers were unable to match the reception of the Grand Theft Auto series.^[6] Rockstar North released Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas in 2004, which featured an open world on the scale of three distinct cities.^[31] The game also allowed players to customize the player-character and vehicles, as well as compete for turf by fighting with rival gangs.^[31] The continued success of the Grand Theft Auto series led to successful spin-offs, including Grand Theft Auto: Liberty City Stories in 2005, Grand Theft Auto: Vice City Stories in 2006, and the 2D Grand Theft Auto Advance for the Game Boy Advance handheld game console.^[31] A market analysis in early 2006 found that new games in this genre would have more difficulty than new first-person shooters or racing games, and noted that that overall revenue for this genre declines during periods without a new Grand Theft Auto game.^[17] By 2006, developers were producing fewer games in this space, estimated at half the number seen in 2005.^[18] City Racing developed by EA Group and published by Gametop continues to be wildly popular GTA clone, despite the complete lack of storyline.^[59]

With the arrival of the seventh generation of video game consoles, the first "next-gen" Grand Theft Auto clones were released in 2006, beginning with Saints Row from 2006 and Crackdown from 2007 both introduced online multiplayer to the genre, a feature that had been requested by many fans.^[6] Crackdown attracted attention for being created by David Jones, the developer of the original Grand Theft Auto,^[18][60] and featured the ability to develop the player character's superpowers in a semi-futuristic setting.^[6] Meanwhile, The Godfather: The Game and Scarface: The World Is Yours entered the market in 2006, and attempted to apply the Grand Theft Auto formula to popular movie franchises.^[31] Still, reviewers continued to measure these games against the standard set by the Grand Theft Auto series.^[6] Grand Theft Auto IV was released in April 2008 and featured a large, detailed environment, redefining gameplay ^[61] and even adopted the GPS navigation system seen in Saints Row.^[24] The game broke numerous sales records, including the record for the fastest selling game in its first 24 hours.^[62] Since its inception, this genre has evolved to include larger settings, more missions, and a wider range of vehicles.^[14] In 2010 Rockstar Games published Red Dead Redemption, an open world Western themed game.^[63] On the day of Grand Theft Auto V 's release on September 17, 2013, Volition released a free downloadable content pack for Saints Row IV titled "GATV", purposely playing the similarity in the abbreviated titles to promote their game due to the confusion raised on various social networks.^[64]

References

1. "25+ Games Like GTA (Grand Theft Auto)". Find Me Similar.
2. Sources that refer to Grand Theft Auto popularizing or inventing a genre include:
   i. Reparaz, Mikel (2007-03-27). "Battle of the GTA clones". GamesRadar. Retrieved 2008-07-21.;
   ii. Cifaldi, Frank (2006-02-21). "Analysts: FPS 'Most Attractive' Genre for Publishers". Gamasutra. Retrieved 2008-08-21.;
   iii. "Hunt for Grand Theft Auto pirates". BBC News. 2004-10-21. Retrieved 2008-08-26.
3. Bramwell, Tom (2007-03-27). "Crackdown Community Q&A". Eurogamer. Retrieved 2008-07-25.
4. Sources that refer to games similar to Grand Theft Auto as action-adventure games include:
   i. Parkyn, Jonathan (2006-04-18). "Review: The Godfather 3D action game". Personal Computer World. Retrieved 2008-07-25.
   ii. Steve Tilley (2007-04-01). "Wii 'Godfather' for newbies only". CANOE. Retrieved 2008-07-25.;
   iii. Bishop, Sam (2003-05-16). "E3 2003: True Crime: Streets of L.A. Update". IGN. Retrieved 2008-07-25.
   iv. Will Tuttle (2006-08-30). "GameSpy Review – Saints Row". GameSpy. Retrieved 2008-07-25.;
   v. Snow, Blake (2008-01-30). "Just Cause 2 announced for Xbox 360, PS3, PC". GamePro. Archived from the original on 2008-02-01. Retrieved 2008-07-24.
5. For examples of reviewers who have called these kinds of games third person shooters, see:
   i. Tilly, Steve (2005-01-23). "Mercenaries". Canadian Online Explorer. Retrieved 2008-08-26.
   ii. Gerstmann, Jeff (2006-03-14). "Driver: Parallel Lines". CNET Networks. Retrieved 2008-08-26.
6. Reparaz, Mikel (2007-03-27). "Battle of the GTA clones". GamesRadar. Retrieved 2008-07-21.
7. Navarro, Alex (2004-11-11). http://www.gamespot.com/pc/action/scrapland/review.html Scrapland Review], GameSpot, Retrieved on 2009-6-17
8. Price, Tom (2008-03-04). "Saints Row 2 Preview (Xbox 360)". TeamXbox. Retrieved 2008-07-24.
9. Filmer, Jay (2006-08-03). "Saints Row – Preview". 360 Gamer. Archived from the original on October 7, 2007. Retrieved 2008-11-07.
10. Chick,Tom (2006-10-17). "Bully – Review". gamesquad.com. Retrieved 2008-11-07.
11. "Crackdown: Review". GameTrailers. 2007-02-20. Retrieved 2008-11-07.
12. Smith, Ken (2007-04-12). "Top 5 'Grand Theft Auto' clones". MSNBC. Retrieved 2008-11-07.
13. i. Harris, John (September 26, 2007). "Game Design Essentials: 20 Open World Games". Gamasutra. Retrieved 2008-07-25.
    ii. Whitehead, Dan (February 4, 2008). "Born Free: the History of the Openworld Game". Eurogamer. Retrieved 2008-07-25.
14. "Backwards Compatible – Rockstar North". Australian Broadcasting Corporation. 2008-04-28. Retrieved 2008-08-26.
15. i. Thompson, Clive (2008-05-02). "Grand Theft Auto IV Delivers Deft Satire of Street Life". Wired News. Retrieved 2008-07-21.
    ii. "Greatest Games of All Time – Grand Theft Auto III". GameSpot. 2007-06-01. Retrieved 2008-08-26.
16. Treit, Ryan. "Xbox Novice Guide – Sandbox". Xbox.com. Archived from the original on 2008-06-18. Retrieved 2008-08-26.
17. Cifaldi, Frank (2006-02-21). "Analysts: FPS 'Most Attractive' Genre for Publishers". Gamasutra. Retrieved 2008-08-21.
18. Morris, Chris (2006-05-11). "At E3, crime pays a lot less". CNN Money.
19. Parkyn, Jonathan (2006-04-18). "Review: The Godfather 3D action game". Personal Computer World. Retrieved 2008-07-25.
20. "Hunt for Grand Theft Auto pirates". BBC News. 2004-10-21. Retrieved 2008-08-26.
21. Polak, Steve (2004-04-22). "Mafia fun for all the 'family'". The Daily Telegraph.
22. Mikal, Hassan (2008-04-17). "Grand Theft Auto: A Retrospective". Something Awful. Retrieved 2008-07-24.
23. Tilley, Steven (2006-09-10). "Clone Stars; these saints march to the beat of a familiar drum, but they get it right". The Toronto Sun.
24. Thompson, Clive (2008-05-02). "Grand Theft Auto IV Delivers Deft Satire of Street Life". Wired News. Retrieved 2008-07-21.
25. Gaudiosi, John (2006-05-12). "'Parallel Lines': Put It in Drive". The Washington Post. Retrieved 2008-10-20.
26. Gerstmann, Jeff (2006-10-10). "Review – Scarface: The World Is Yours". GameSpot. Retrieved 2008-07-24.
27. Perry, Douglass (2007-02-12). "Crackdown Review". IGN. Retrieved 2008-02-22.
28. Gaudiosi, John (2006-05-12). "'Parallel Lines': Put It in Drive". The Washington Post. Retrieved 2008-07-24.
29. Navarro, Alex (2006-07-26). "GameSpot Review – Outlaw Chopper". GameSpot. Retrieved 2008-07-24.
30. Leeper, Justin (2005-05-23). "GameSpy: Just Cause Review". GameSpy. Retrieved 2008-08-26.
31. CVG UK (2008-04-24). "The complete history of Grand Theft Auto". GamesRadar. Retrieved 2008-08-26.
32. Navarro, Alex (2003-09-15). "Review – Simpsons Hit and Run". GameSpot. Retrieved 2008-07-24.
33. i. Downie, Alan (2006-07-25). "Australian Gamer Preview – Saints Row". Australian Gamer. Retrieved 2008-07-24.
    ii. Wilson, Mark (2006-08-28). "We Visit Volition to Talk Saints Row". Kotaku. Retrieved 2008-07-24.
    iii. Navarro, Alex (2003-09-15). "Review – Simpsons Hit and Run". GameSpot. Retrieved 2008-07-24.
34. Guzman, Hector (2005-11-04). "GameSpy Review – Total Overdose: A Gunslinger's Tale in Mexico (PS2)". GameSpy. Retrieved 2008-07-24.
35. Geddes, Ryan; Daemon Hatfield (2007-12-10). "IGN's Top 10 Most Influential Games". IGN. Retrieved 2008-10-01.
36. Whitehead, Dan (February 4, 2008). "Born Free: the History of the Openworld Game". Eurogamer. Retrieved on 2008-07-25.
37. Fahs, Travis (2009-05-20). IGN Presents the History of Terminator, IGN, Retrieved on 2009-06-17
38. Fahs, Travis (2008-03-24). The Leif Ericson Awards, IGN, Retrieved on 2009-07-16
39. Patterson, Mark (August 1991). Amiga Reviews: Hunter, CU Amiga, Retrieved on 2009-07-16 Archived July 2, 2008, at the Wayback Machine.
40. Mac Donald, Ryan (1998-05-06). "GTA: Grand Theft Auto: European Version Review". GameSpot. Retrieved 2009-04-04.
41. Casamassina, Matt (2007-01-30). "Top 10 Tuesday: Underrated and Underappreciated Games". IGN. Retrieved 2008-11-08.
42. http://www.nytimes.com/2012/11/10/arts/video-games/q-and-a-rockstars-dan-houser-on-grand-theft-auto-v.html
43. Gerstmann, Jeff (2006-03-14). "Driver: Parallel Lines Review". GameSpot. Retrieved 2008-07-24.
44. Guzman, Hector (2006-03-20). "GameSpy: Driver: Parallel Lines – Page 1". GameSpy. Retrieved 2009-04-12.
45. "Greatest Games of All Time – Grand Theft Auto III". GameSpot. 2007-06-01. Retrieved 2008-08-26.
46. "The game treated as much like the release of Doom nearly a decade earlier.". Game Informer 1 (138): 73.
47. Boba Fatt and the GamePros (2007-04-25). "The 52 Most Important Video Games of All Time (page 8 of 8)". GamePro. Archived from the original on 2008-09-05. Retrieved 2008-10-01.
48. Brendan Main, Lost in Yokosuka, The Escapist
49. Shenmue: Creator Yu Suzuki Speaks Out, GamesTM
50. Yu Suzuki, IGN
51. The Disappearance of Yu Suzuki: Part 1, 1UP
52. Brian Gazza. "Outrun". Hardcore Gaming 101. Retrieved 2011-03-17.
53. "Top 25 Racing Games... Ever! Part 1". Retro Gamer. 16 September 2009. Retrieved 2011-03-17.
54. Kurt Kalata & Robert Greene, Hydlide, Hardcore Gaming 101
55. Andrew Vestal (1998-11-02). "Other Game Boy RPGs". GameSpot. Retrieved 2009-11-18.
56. Brian Ashcraft (July 16, 2009). "Grand Theft Auto And Pac-Man? "The Same"". Retrieved 2011-03-08.
57. Snider, Mike (2002-12-27). "Video games: Grand Theft Auto: Vice City". USA Today.
58. Fischer, Russ (2003-11-14). "Review – True Crime: Streets of LA". GameSpy. Retrieved 2008-08-26.
59. "Gametop". Gametop. Gametop Pte Ltd.
60. Brightman, James (2008-03-31). "Report: Crackdown Developer Gets $50M in Funding". GameDaily. Retrieved 2009-04-04.
61. Goldstein, Hillary (2008-04-25). "Grand Theft Auto IV Review". IGN. Retrieved 2009-04-30.
62. "Confirmed: Grand Theft Auto IV Breaks Guinness World Records With Biggest Entertainment Release Of All-Time". Guinness World Records. 2008-05-13. Retrieved 2008-05-13.
63. "Red Dead Redemption Review". IGN.
64. Schreier, Jason (2013-09-17). "GTA V Gets Trolled Hard". Kotaku. Retrieved 2013-09-18.