Lawton Chiles

Lawton Chiles
41st Governor of Florida
In office January 8, 1991 – December 12, 1998
Lieutenant	Buddy MacKay
Preceded by	Bob Martinez
Succeeded by	Buddy MacKay
United States Senator from Florida
In office January 3, 1971 – January 3, 1989
Preceded by	Spessard Holland
Succeeded by	Connie Mack III
Chairman of the Senate Committee on the Budget
In office January 3, 1987 – January 3, 1989
Preceded by	Pete Domenici
Succeeded by	Jim Sasser
Chairman of the Senate Special Committee on Aging
In office January 3, 1979 – January 3, 1981
Preceded by	Frank Church
Succeeded by	H. John Heinz III
Member of the Florida Senate
In office 1966-1970
Member of the Florida House of Representatives
In office 1958-1966
Personal details
Born	Lawton Mainor Chiles, Jr. April 3, 1930 Lakeland, Florida, U.S.
Died	December 12, 1998 (aged 68) Tallahassee, Florida, U.S.
Resting place	Chiles Family Estate Lakeland, Florida
Political party	Democratic
Spouse(s)	Rhea May Grafton (m. 1951–1998; his death); 4 children
Alma mater	University of Florida
Religion	Presbyterianism
Military service
Allegiance	United States of America
Service/branch	United States Army
Years of service	1953–1954
Battles/wars	Korean War

Pair of Lawton Chiles' walking shoes on display at the Florida State Capitol.

Lawton Mainor Chiles, Jr. (April 3, 1930 – December 12, 1998) was an American politician from the U.S. state of Florida. A Korean War veteran, Chiles later returned to Florida for law school and eventually opened his own private practice in 1955. Three years later, Chiles entered politics with a successful bid for the Florida House of Representatives in 1958, as a member of Democratic Party.

By 1966, Chiles left the Florida House to run for the Florida Senate. Despite 12 years in the Florida Legislature, Chiles was relatively unknown when he decided to bid for United States Senate in 1970. He embarked on a 1,003-mile walk from Pensacola to Key West for his campaign, earning him the nickname "Walkin' Lawton". It was successful and Chiles defeated his opponent William C. Cramer by a 53.9%-46.1% margin. Chiles retired from the United States Senate and from politics entirely in 1989.

However, supporters convinced him to run for Governor of Florida in 1990 against the unpopular incumbent Bob Martinez, and Chiles defeated Martinez by a 13-point margin (56.5% to 43.5%). During his first term as Governor of Florida, Lawton Chiles brought reform to health care in the state and oversaw recovery efforts from Hurricane Andrew in 1992. Chiles faced a tough re-election bid in 1994 against Jeb Bush, who was a businessman and son of former President of the United States George H. W. Bush. Chiles prevailed over Bush by fewer than 64,000 votes. In his second term, Chiles was known for his reforms to education in Florida. On December 12, 1998, he suffered a heart attack and died at the Florida Governor's Mansion, leaving Lieutenant Governor Buddy MacKay to serve the remaining 23 days of Chiles' unexpired term.

Early life

Chiles was born in Polk County, Florida near Lakeland, the son of Margaret Kate (née Patterson) and Lawton Mainor Chiles. He attended public school at Lakeland High School, then the University of Florida at Gainesville. At the University of Florida, he was active in student politics, and was inducted into both the university Hall of Fame (the most prestigious honor a student can receive at UF) and Florida Blue Key.

He was a member of the Alpha Tau Omega fraternity. He graduated in 1952. Following his college years, Chiles entered the Korean War, commissionied as an artillery officer in the United States Army. After the war, Chiles returned to the University of Florida for law school, from which he graduated in 1955; he passed the state bar exam that year and went into private practice in Lakeland. He married Rhea Grafton.

Early career

In 1958, Chiles, a Democrat, was elected to the Florida House of Representatives.^[1] It was essentially still a one-party state, as most African Americans were disfranchised by a constitution and laws passed since the turn of the century.^[2] Chiles served in the House until 1966, when he was elected to a seat in the state senate, which he held until 1970.^[3] While in the State Senate, Chiles served on the 1968 Florida Law Revision Commission. During his time in the state legislature, Chiles continued to work as a lawyer and developer in Lakeland. He was one of the initial investors in the Red Lobster restaurant chain.^[4] He was a member of the Florida Society of the Sons of the American Revolution.^[5]

The 1,003-mile walk

In 1970, Chiles decided to run for a seat in the United States Senate. At the time, despite his 12 years in the state legislature, he was largely unknown outside his Lakeland-based district. To generate some media coverage and meet people across the state, Chiles embarked upon a 1,003-mile, 91-day walk across Florida from Pensacola to Key West. The walk earned him the recognition he sought, as well as the nickname that would follow him throughout his political career– "Walkin' Lawton". In his journal Chiles wrote that sometimes he walked alone, while other times he met ordinary Floridians along the way. In later years, Chiles would recall the walk allowed him to see Florida's natural beauty, as well as the state's problems, with fresh eyes. Some Florida reporters said that Chiles enjoyed campaigning much more than governing.^[6]

Chiles v. Cramer

In the general election campaign, Chiles faced U.S. Representative William C. Cramer of St. Petersburg, the first Republican to have served in Congress from Florida since Reconstruction. Cramer, a graduate of Harvard Law School, questioned Chiles's votes as a state senator on several matters regarding insurance. One law increased automobile liability rates by 50 percent over two years, and another raised premiums for school bus insurance, at a time that Chiles's insurance agency in Lakeland held the policy on the Polk County School Board, but such "conflict-of-interest" accusations seemed to have little political effect.^[7]

The self-made Cramer depicted Chiles as coming from a "silver spoon" background with a then net worth of $300,000, but the media ignored questions about the candidates' personal wealth.^[8] Instead, reporters focused on the walk, often termed a "public relations stroke of genius." Prior to the walk, Chiles was identified by only 5 percent of voters; afterwards, he had widespread positive recognition.^[9]

The Tallahassee Democrat forecast correctly that Chiles's "weary feet and comfortable hiking boots" would carry the 40-year-old "slow-country country lawyer" with "boyish amiability", and "back-country common sense and methodical urbane political savvy" to victory.^[10] Chiles's "Huck Finn" image was contrasted one night in Miami when he held a fried chicken picnic while the Republicans showcased a black-tie $1,000-a-plate dinner.^[11]

Cramer could not match Chiles's public appeal. An observer described Cramer's "charisma" as "a speech in the Congressional Record." A Cramer aide said it was difficult "selling experience. It's not a sexy thing."^[12] A Chiles advertisement urged that voters "Vote for yourself. Chiles walked our streets and highways to hear what you have to say. That's why a vote for Chiles is like a vote for yourself."^[13] With "shoe leather and a shoestring budget", Chiles presented himself as a "problem solver who doesn't automatically vote 'No' on every issue."^[14]

Cramer said that he should have demanded more debates and rebuffed the walking tactic: "I never could get that turned around. He was walking, and I was running. But the press was enamored with the walk ... Every time he was asked a question about where he stood, he would quote somebody that he met on the campaign trail to state what he was to do when he got to the Senate consistent with what that constituent had said. The basic approach gave him more credibility to his walk, which had nothing to do with his qualifications for the Senate but gave him free publicity and appealed to the 'little man.'"^[15]

With ecology a national concern by 1970, Chiles announced his opposition to the Cross Florida Barge Canal, which had originally been supported by every member of the Florida congressional delegation. The project, one-third completed, was cancelled early in 1971 and is now a protected green belt corridor. Chiles endorsed federal funding to remove waste from the bass-teeming Lake Apopka in central Florida. By contrast, Cramer received little credit from environmentalists although he had drafted the Water Pollution Control Act of 1956 and had sponsored legislation to protect alligators, stop beach erosion, dredge harbors, and remove oil spills. Instead, Cramer's critics accused him of having weakened anti-pollution laws. Cramer questioned Chiles's opposition to a proposed severance tax on phosphate mining, which particularly impacted Tampa Bay. Cramer declared that "Liberal Lawton has protected the phosphate industry -- the state's single largest polluter."^[16]

By 1974, a survey showed Floridians favored limits on development, and 60 percent urged more government funding for conservation.^[17]

Only three newspapers—in Orlando, Fort Myers, and Pasco County—supported Cramer in the race against Chiles.^[18] In the face of media opposition, Cramer failed to pin the "liberal" label on Chiles, who called himself by the rare hybrid term "progressive conservative."^[19] Explaining Cramer's inability to make "liberalism" an issue in 1970, The New York Times observed that Chiles and his successful gubernatorial running mate, Reubin Askew of Pensacola "convey amiable good ol' boy qualities with moderate-to-liberal aspirations that do not strike fear into the hearts of conservatives."^[20]

Chiles relied heavily on his support from the retiring Senator Spessard Holland. He noted that Cramer had expected to face former Governor Farris Bryant, who like LeRoy Collins in 1968, Gurney's foe, had ties to the administration of U.S. President Lyndon B. Johnson. Bryant lost the senatorial primary to Chiles. "I'm not anything Cramer thought he would be running against. So he's reduced to telling lies about me," Chiles quipped.^[21] Chiles said that Cramer can bring Nixon, Agnew, Reagan, and anybody else he wants. ... I'll take Holland on my side against all of them."^[22]

Cramer said a Republican-majority Senate would lead to the removal of controversial Senator J. William Fulbright of Arkansas, the chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee who had long opposed the Vietnam War. Chiles, however, retorted that if Republicans controlled the Senate other southern Democrats would also forfeit committee chairmanships earned through their seniority.^[23]

The Senate

Sen. Lawton Chiles.

Chiles was twice re-elected to the U.S. Senate -- 1976 and 1982, both heavily Democratic years. Chiles, never flashy, was considered a moderate lawmaker who rarely made waves. He served as the chairman of the Special Committee on Aging of the 96th Congress (1979–81), and in the 100th Congress (1987–89) served as chairman of the influential Senate Budget Committee. While heading the Budget Committee, he played a key role in the 1987 revision of the Gramm-Rudman-Hollings Act.

In 1985, Chiles underwent quadruple-bypass heart surgery. After his recovery, he became increasingly frustrated with the slow pace of work in the Senate, complaining that it was too difficult to get anything done. He hence announced in December 1987 that he would not seek re-election the next year.^[24] Chiles was succeeded by Republican Connie Mack.

Governor of Florida

After the surgery, Chiles developed clinical depression,^[25] and was treated with Prozac. He retired from the Senate in 1989 and intended to retire from politics entirely. However, several supporters convinced him to enter the 1990 Florida Governor's race against Republican incumbent Bob Martinez. During the Democratic Party primary, his opponent Bill Nelson attempted to make an issue of Chiles' age and health, a strategy that backfired badly in a state with a large retiree population.

Chiles ran a campaign to "reinvent" the state's government, and defeated Martinez to take office in 1991. During his first term as Governor, Chiles managed to accomplish very little. Although he developed ambitious health-care and tax reform packages, neither passed in the hostile state legislature. The early years of his term were troubled by a national economic recession that severely damaged Florida's tourism-based economy, and by Hurricane Andrew, which struck near Homestead in August, 1992.

Chiles ran for re-election in 1994 against Jeb Bush. Republican candidate Bush ran a television advertisement which featured the mother of a teenage girl who had been abducted and murdered many years before. The mother stated that "Her killer is still on death row, and we're still waiting for justice. We won't get it from Lawton Chiles because he's too liberal on crime", referring to Chiles not signing the convicted killer's death warrant. Chiles, then governor, responded that he did not sign a death warrant because the case was still on appeal. The Democratic governor further claimed a record of support for the death penalty, having presided over 18 executions during his two terms (among them the first Floridian woman executed since 1848). Moreover, after the botched electrocution of Pedro Medina in 1997, and despite significant public criticism, Chiles refused to endorse the use of lethal injection as a lawful form of execution. The new method was introduced under Bush's administration in 1999 after the execution of Allen Lee Davis.

Chiles' second term as Governor was notable as the first time in state history that a Democratic Governor had a legislature controlled by the Republican Party. Despite this, he had some successes, including a successful lawsuit he and state Attorney General Bob Butterworth filed against the tobacco industry, which resulted in an $11.3 billion settlement for the state. He also won approval for a $2.7 billion statewide school construction program. In 1995 Chiles sought treatment for a neurological problem, after he awoke with nausea, slurred speech and loss of coordination. He recovered fully.

Death

Ineligible to run a third time, Chiles supported the Lieutenant Governor, Kenneth H. "Buddy" MacKay, in the 1998 Florida governor's race against Jeb Bush. Bush, however, scored an easy victory over MacKay. On December 12 that year, just three weeks before his long-awaited retirement was to begin, Chiles suffered a fatal heart attack while exercising on a cycling machine in the Governor's mansion gymnasium.

Funeral services were held at Faith Presbyterian Church in Tallahassee, following a funeral procession that traced part of his walk from the 1970 Senate campaign, from the panhandle town of Century to Tallahassee. Chiles was initially buried in a church cemetery in Tallahassee; however, within a year his wife had the body moved to a 200-acre tract 15 miles east of Tallahassee, a place they named Jubilee.^[26] He was succeeded in office by MacKay, who served until Bush's term began on January 5, 1999.

Legacy

Legislative and executive programs

Chiles was known as a health care and children's advocate throughout his career. He emphasized health coverage for the uninsured and led a campaign to create the National Commission for Prevention of Infant Mortality in the late 1980s. In 1994 he fought for the creation of regional health care alliances throughout the state, which allow small businesses to pool their health care dollars and broaden coverage while saving money. He also created the Florida Department of Elder Affairs.

In 1992, Chiles created the Florida Healthy Start program to provide a comprehensive prenatal and infant care program available to all pregnant women and infants across the state; since the program's inception the state's infant mortality rate has dropped 18%. In 1996, Chiles appointed a Governor's Commission on Education to examine the state's school system. One of the significant recommendations that came from that commission eventually led to the highly controversial 2002 state constitutional amendment restricting Florida's school class sizes.

In 1997, pro-life advocacy group Choose Life collected 10,000 signatures and filed the $30,000 fee required under Florida law at the time to submit an application for a new specialty plate. State Senator Tom Lee sponsored a bill in support of the tag's creation. The bill passed both houses of the Florida State Legislature in early 1998, but was vetoed by Chiles, who stated that license plates are not the "proper forum for debate" on political issues.^[27][28]

Judicial appointments

Perhaps his greatest legacy was his impact on the Florida Supreme Court, where his appointments continued to have a major impact on state and national events long after Chiles' death. Chiles appointed Justice Major B. Harding in 1991, Justice Charles T. Wells in 1994, Justice Harry Lee Anstead in 1994, Justice Barbara J. Pariente in 1997, and Justice R. Fred Lewis in 1998. Chiles and incoming Gov. Jeb Bush jointly appointed Justice Peggy A. Quince in 1998 just a few days before Chiles' death. Quince was jointly appointed because her term as Justice would begin the exact moment that Bush's first term as Governor began, so there was a legal question which Governor had the authority to appoint her. Bush and Chiles agreed to make a joint appointment to avoid a lawsuit over the question.

Thus, at one point, Chiles had appointed five of the seven Justices and had jointly appointed the sixth. Chiles' appointments formed the Supreme Court majorities that decided the following major cases:

• In 2006, the Court struck down a law passed by the Florida State Legislature that had created the United States' first statewide education voucher program. The majority in this case consisted of Wells, Anstead, Pariente, Lewis, and Quince. Bush appointees Raoul G. Cantero and Kenneth B. Bell dissented.
• In 2004, the court struck down another piece of legislation from the Florida legislature designed to reverse a lower court decision in the Terri Schiavo case. This decision was unanimous and included Bush appointees Cantero and Bell. By this time, Harding had retired.
• In the 2000 presidential election controversy, the Florida Supreme Court ordered a statewide recount in the disputed election pitting George W. Bush against Al Gore. The United States Supreme Court later reversed that ruling. The Florida Supreme Court majority in this case consisted of Anstead, Pariente, Lewis, and Quince. Dissenting Justices were Wells, Harding, and Leander J. Shaw, Jr., an appointee of Gov. Bob Graham. Shaw retired in early 2003 and was replaced by Bell.

Relatives

Chiles' niece is former US Senator Kay Hagan of North Carolina, a Democrat elected in 2008. Hagan is the daughter of Chiles' sister Jeannette. Chiles' son, "Bud" Chiles, ran for the position of Governor of Florida without party affiliation in a grassroots campaign. Like his father, Bud embarked on a walking tour of the state, listening and visiting with local communities in Florida.^[29] On September 2, 2010, Chiles dropped out of the race citing "continuing down this road could have unintended consequences, dividing those who hold common goals..." Chiles threw his support behind Alex Sink.^[30]

Electoral history

Democratic primary for United States Senator from Florida, 1970

• C. Farris Bryant – 240,222 (32.90%)
• Lawton Chiles – 188,300 (25.79%)
• Fred Schultz – 175,745 (24.07%)
• Alcee Hastings – 91,948 (12.59%)
• Joel Daves – 33,939 (4.65%)

Democratic runoff for United States Senator from Florida, 1970

• Lawton Chiles – 474,420 (65.74%)
• C. Farris Bryant – 247,211 (34.26%)

Florida United States Senate election, 1970

• Lawton Chiles (D) – 902,438 (53.87%)
• William C. Cramer (R) – 772,817 (46.13%)

Florida United States Senate election, 1976

• Lawton Chiles (D, Inc.) – 1,799,518 (62.98%)
• John Grady (R) – 1,057,886 (37.02%)

Florida United States Senate election, 1982

• Lawton Chiles (D, Inc.) – 1,637,667 (61.72%)
• Van B. Poole (R) – 1,015,330 (38.27%)

Democratic primary for Governor of Florida, 1990

• Lawton Chiles – 746,325 (69.49%)
• Bill Nelson – 327,731 (30.51%)

Florida gubernatorial election, 1990

• Lawton Chiles/Buddy MacKay (D) – 1,995,206 (56.51%)
• Bob Martinez (Inc.)/J. Allison DeFoor (R) – 1,535,068 (43.48%)

Democratic primary for Governor of Florida, 1994

• Lawton Chiles (Inc.) – 603,657 (72.17%)
• Jack Gargan – 232,757 (27.83%)

Florida gubernatorial election, 1994

• Lawton Chiles/Buddy MacKay (D, Inc.) – 2,135,008 (50.75%)
• Jeb Bush/Tom Feeney (R) – 2,071,068 (49.23%)

See also

• The Florida Wildlife Corridor Expedition
• Lawton Chiles High School
• Lawton Chiles Legal Information Center

References

1. http://bioguide.congress.gov/scripts/biodisplay.pl?index=c000356
2. Richard M. Valelly, The Two Reconstructions: The Struggle for Black Enfranchisement University of Chicago Press, 2009, pp. 146-147
3. http://bioguide.congress.gov/scripts/biodisplay.pl?index=c000356
4. http://www.theledger.com/article/20140516/newschief/140519390
5. http://connecticutsar.org/about/what-sar-means/
6. Pearson, Richard (December 13, 1998). "Florida Gov. Lawton Chiles Dies". Washington Post. Retrieved October 9, 2014.
7. Miami Herald, October 10, 1970; Tallahassee Democrat, October 10, 18, 1970
8. Miami Herald, October 23, 1970; Tallahassee Democrat, November 1, 1970
9. Alexander P Lamis, The Two-Party South, p. 185; Miami Herald, September 9, 1970; Tallahassee Democrat, September 6 and November 1, 1970.
10. Tallahassee Democrat, November 1, 1970
11. Miami Herald, September 27, 1970
12. Tallahassee Democrat, November 1, 1970; Miami Herald, September 4, 1970
13. Miami Herald, September 27, 1970
14. Miami Herald, September 9 and October 29, 1970
15. Billy Hathorn, "Cramer v. Kirk: The Florida Republican Schism of 1970", Florida Historical Quarterly (April 1990), p. 418
16. "Cramer v. Kirk" p. 418; "Bill Cramer ... Who Else?", campaign brochure of Cramer senatorial campaign, 1970
17. Jack Bass and Walter DeVries, The Transformation of Southern Politics: Social Change and Political Consequence Since 1945 (New York, 1976), p. 116
18. "Cramer v. Kirk", p. 419
19. Numan V. Bartley and Hugh D. Graham, Southern Politics and the Second Reconstruction (Baltimore, Maryland, 1975), pp. 146-147; Miami Herald, October 27, 1970
20. The New York Times, October 11, 1970
21. Cramer v. Kirk," p. 419
22. Tallahassee Democrat, September 30, 1970
23. "Cramer v. Kirk", p. 420
24. , New York Times, December 25, 1987; retrieved on May 5, 2009.
25. "Ex-Senator Ends Retirement And Faces an Election Issue". Associated Press. April 14, 1990. Retrieved October 21, 2007.
26. "Grave Site Has Feel of State's Bygone Days". Orlando Sentinel. December 14, 2003.
27. Gielow-Jacobs, Leslie: "Free Speech and the Limits of Legislative Discretion: The Example of Specialty License Plates" Florida Law Review, 53(3) pages 419–432
28. Lithwick, Dahlia: "Poetic Licenses", Slate.com, February 6, 2003; retrieved June 23, 2007.
29. Bud's campaign website
30. "Chiles throws support to Sink in Fla. gov's race", miamiherald.com, September 2, 2010.

External links

• Official Governor's portrait and biography from the State of Florida
• St. Petersburg Times article on the death of Gov. Chiles
• Biographical Directory of the US Congress
• Chiles' electoral results