Lympne light aircraft trials

The Lympne Light Aircraft Trials were held to encourage the development of practical light aircraft for private ownership, with a strong but not exclusive emphasis on fuel economy. They were held in 1923, 1924 and 1926. Each year saw different restrictions on engine size, framed initially in terms of capacity and then weight. The Daily Mail newspaper provided cash prizes throughout though the initiating donation came from the Duke of Sutherland. The Air Ministry were prize givers in the 1924 event. The trials were held at Lympne in Kent, England.

The background

The Lympne events had their origin in the post-World War I state of aviation in Britain and in Germany. Military aircraft production stopped immediately the war ended. In Britain there were large stocks of surplus aircraft available at low prices, making it hard for manufacturers to develop new models. Airlines were only slowly emerging, largely using converted military aeroplanes and having not found a certain economic model. The old fighters, though effective for barnstorming were not economical or practical enough for the private owner.

In Germany the manufacture of powered aircraft was forbidden under the terms of the Treaty of Versailles, but glider development was allowed. In 1921 a glider competitions was held in the Rhön mountains, and in mid-August 1922 the another was held at the Wasserkuppe. The 1922 prize of 100,000 marks was won by a flight of 66 minutes, demonstrating the possibilities of engineless flight. In response, the Daily Mail offered a prize of £1,000 to the pilot making the longest flight in England. The Royal Aero Club chose Itford Hill on the South Downs just east of Brighton as a venue and the event was arranged for 16–21 October 1922. This gave contestants just six weeks to design and build their gliders, or to bring them from Europe. Thirteen gliders competed with each other and the autumn weather. The best flight by an Englishman was that made by Fred Raynham in a Handasyde aircraft, lasting 113 minutes, but the Frenchman Alexis Maneyrol did better in his Peyret tandem monoplane, staying up for a world record 201 minutes to win the prize. Given this demonstration of long duration unpowered flight it is not surprising that people began to consider the possibilities of glider-like aircraft, fitted with small engines, as sports aircraft for the private flyer. The first Lympne meeting the following year and its slightly earlier counterpart in Vauville near Cherbourg, France were the result both of these ideas and a desire to build an aircraft which would satisfy the needs of private fliers and foster private aviation. Unfortunately, in the opinion of many, both at the time and later, the restrictions imposed resulted in aircraft that had too-small engines, wheels that were too thin and of small diameter and engines which, though under powered, were too heavy relative to the often fragile, light-weight frames in which they were housed.^[1] C. G. Grey, editor of 'The Aeroplane' at the time devoted two issues to "a four-page long diatribe" to the failures of the 1924 event and the author of 'The Lympne Trials' speaks of "a clear failure to understand what a private pilot or a flying club might need as a training aeroplane".^[1] Nevertheless the trials did serve to stimulate public and industry interest in private aviation after the first world war and certainly exercised the ingenuity of designers to the maximum in complying with the restrictions placed upon them.

Venue and organisation

Lympne Aerodrome is just west of the village of Lympne, on top of old sea cliffs near the coast and about 3 miles (5 km) WNW of the Kent port of Hythe. The events were organised and administrated by the Royal Aero Club.

1923

The first trial was held 8–13 October 1923.^[2][3] The official proper name was the motor-glider competition.^[4] The Duke of Sutherland, at that time Under-Secretary of State for Air got the competition moving, offering a prize of £500 for the most economical British aircraft. The Daily Mail offered a similar economy prize of £1000 for a flight of more than 50 miles over a 12.5-mile triangular course, powered by an engine of less than 750 cc capacity but for an aircraft from any nation. As a result, the competition began to be referred to as the Daily Mail Motor Glider Competition. Rules were few, but the newspaper's inclusion of a capacity limit with its generous prize was adopted by all entrants. Since a single-seat aircraft was bound to be lighter and more economical than a two-seater, all entrants were single-seaters.

The original intention was to fill the aircraft with one gallon of fuel and see how far they got. Seeing that this would lead to aircraft retrieval problems, the organisers decided that all flights must begin and end at Lypmne. Instead, each was fuelled over a gallon by a standard amount, landing when they judged they had insufficient fuel for another 12.5 miles. If they had used more than one gallon, the calculated consumption was pro rata; if they had used less than one gallon the consumption was nevertheless based on one gallon used.^[5]

Before an aircraft could enter the fuel economy test it was required to pass a demonstration of portability, called the transport test.^[6] Each aircraft had to prove it was capable of going through a standard field gate and then be wheeled along a country road for a mile using not more than two men.^[6] Because this limited the width of the aircraft to 7 ft 6in then the designs all featured either detachable or folding wings.^[6]

Also competed for were the £500 Abdulla Prize, donated by the Abdulla Tobacco Co. for the greatest speed over two laps of the same circuit and £150 each from the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders and the British Cycle and Motor Cycle Manufacturers and Trade Unions for the greatest number of completed circuits during the whole competition.^[7] Sir Charles Wakefield of Wakefield Oil (Castrol) offered £100 for the machine that attained the greatest altitude. These were large sums of money at a time when £80 would buy a sailplane in Germany. The object of the competition was to produce a motor glider that cost no more than £100.

The 1923 entrants were:^[8]

Competition Number	Registration	Type	Engine*	Pilot	Notes
No. 1		Avro 558 biplane		B&H (Grigg)	entered by Grigg Motor & Engineering Company[6][9][10] Probably did not attend
No. 2	G-EBGN	Gnosspelius Gull	Tomtit	John Lankester Parker	Entered by Major O.T. Gnosspelius and J.L. Parker[6]
No. 3	G-EBNV	English Electric Wren	ABC flat twin	Maurice Wright	Entered by the English Electric Company[6]
No. 4	None	English Electric Wren	ABC flat twin	Walter H. Longton	Entered by the English Electric Company[6]
No. 5	None	Avro 558	B&H V-twin	Bert Hinkler	Entered by A.V.Roe & Co.[11]
No. 6	None	Avro 560	Tomtit	Bert Hinkler	[12] Entered by A.V.Roe & Co.[6]
No. 7	G-EBHU	Gloster Gannet	Carden	Larry Carter	Entered by the Gloster Aircraft Company.[6]
No. 8	G-EBHX	de Havilland DH.53	750cc Douglas	Capt Geoffrey de Havilland and Capt Hubert Broad	Entered by the de Havilland Aircraft Company.[6]
No. 9	G-EBKM	Parnall Pixie I	500cc Douglas	Norman Macmillan	[13] Entered by George Parnall and Company.[6]
No. 10	G-EBHN	Vickers Viget	750cc Douglas	Stan Cockerell	Entered by Vickers Limited.[6]
No. 11	G-EBHW	Avro 558	500cc Douglas	Harold Hamersley	Entered by G.S. Bush and H.A. Hammersley.[6]
No. 12	G-EBHZ	de Havilland DH.53	750cc Douglas	Harold Hemming	Entered by A.S. Butler.[6]
No. 13		Handasyde Monoplane	750cc Douglas	Fred Raynham	Entered by the pilot.[6]
No. 14	G-EBHS	RAE Aero Club Hurricane	600cc Douglas	George Bulman	Entered by the Royal Aircraft Establishment Aero Club.[6]
No. 15		Peyret Monoplane	4-cylinder Sergant	Alexis Maneyrol	French, entered by Louis Peyret.[6]
No. 16	O-BAFH	Poncelot Vivette Monoplane	16 hp 4-cylinder Sergant	Baron Georges Kervyn de Letttenhove	[14] Belgian. As No. 21, but mahogany covered fuselage and larger area wings, entered by Jean B. Richard.[6]
No. 17	G-EBIL	ANEC I	Tomtit	"Jimmy" J.H. James	[15] Entered by the Addlestone Aeronautical Association.[6]
No. 18	G-EBHR	ANEC I	Tomtit	Maurice Piercy	Entered by Hubert Blundell.[6]
No. 19	None	Gnosspelius Gull	Tomtit	Rex Stocken	Entered by Major O.T. Gnosspelius and J.L. Parker[6]
No. 20		Kingwell Tandem Monoplane	ABC	H. Sykes	[16] did not attend, entered by P.W. Kingwell.[6]
No. 21	O-BAFG	Poncelot Castar Monoplane	16 hp 4-cylinder Sergant	V. Simonet	[14] Belgian. As No. 16 but fabric covered fuselage and smaller area wings, entered by G.A. de Ro.[6]
No. 22		Peyret Monoplane	Douglas	Alexis Maneyrol	probably did not attend, entered by Louis Peyret.[6]
No. 23	J7233	Sayers-Handley Page H.P.22	500cc Douglas	A.G. Pointing and J.T. Jeyes	[16] entered by pilots.[6]
No. 24	G-EBKN	Parnall Pixie II	750cc Douglas	Norman Macmillan	[13] the same aircraft as No.9 with shorter span wings and a more powerful engine. Entered by the George Parnall and Company.[6]
No. 25	None	Sayers-Handley Page H.P.22	400cc ABC engine	C. Barnard	like No. 23 with a different nose shape and engine Entered by Vernon Bradshaw.[6]
No. 26	J7265	Sayers-Handley Page H.P.23	Tomtit	Gordon Olley	[16] Entered by the Handley Page company.[6]
No. 27	G-EBHQ	Salmon Tandem Monoplane	3 ^1⁄2hp Bradshaw motorcycle engine	Cecil Bouchier	[16] did not attend, entered by Percy Salmon.[6]
No. 28		Falcon Monoplane	JAP		[16] not completed

• The engine referred to here as the Tomtit was the early, crudely adapted motorcycle engine. The Tomtit was a more refined aeronautical adaptation.^[17]

Prize winners^[18] The Duke of Sutherland's prize of £500 and the Daily Mail prize of £1,000 were put together and divided between the English Electric Wren (No. 4) flown by Flt Lt Longton and the ANEC Monoplane (No. 17) flown by Mr Jimmy James. Despite very different engine capacities (398 cc on the Wren and 700 cc on the ANEC), both returned 87.5 mpg (31.0 km/litre).

Joint winner in 1923, this Wren contains parts from both of those competing at Lympne. It still flies.

The Parnall Pixie II (No. 24), flown by Capt Macmillan won the Abdulla speed prize of £500 with a speed of 76.1 mph (122.5 km/h). ANEC No.17, flown this time by Mr Maurice Piercey also won the £200 altitude prize from Sir Charles Wakefield with a height of 14,400 feet (4,390 m).

The two £150 prizes for maximum distance covered went to the Avro 560 (No.6) flown by Bert Hinkler, which completed 80 laps or 1,000 miles (1,609 km). A take-off and landing competition with a £100 prize was frustrated by the gusty conditions and the prize went instead to Avro 558 No.11 flown by Harold Hamersley to an altitude of 13,850 ft (4,221 m).

However Alexis Maneyrol died on the final day during his second attempt on the altitude record, when his Peyret monoplane suffered lift strut failure. The banquet, which was to have concluded the Lympne event, was cancelled as a mark of respect.^[3][19]

The Wren No. 4 still flies with The Shuttleworth Collection, with the help of some parts from No. 3. The Vivette No. 16 hangs from the roof in the Brussels Air Museum, configured as a glider.^[20]

1924

The 1924 trial, properly called the Two-Seater Dual Control Light Aeroplane Competition was held from 27 September to 4 October 1924 also at Lympne Aerodrome.^[21] The rules, issued in February 1924 required^[22] competing aircraft to have engines with a capacity of no more than 1,100 cc, to have full dual controls and one or two airspeed visible from either cockpit. All tests were to be flown with a load of 340 lb (154 kg), excluding fuel but including the pilot's weight.

The elimination trials, held on Sunday 28 September were not expected to be as challenging as they turned out.^[22] There was a transport, store and reassemble test which involved folding or dismantling the wings, moving the aircraft a short distance and housing in a shed 10 ft (3 m) wide, then reversing the process. This had to be done by only two people. A flying test followed, a flight of one lap plus a figure of eight to be made from each cockpit in turn.

The competition proper, starting the next day awarded points on performance in four different tests: high speed, low speed, distance required to take off and clear an obstacle and length of landing run.^[22] The total time in the air during the competition was also logged.

The Air Ministry offered a £2,000 prize for the winner and £1,000 for the runner-up.^[23] In addition, there was a £500 prize for the best combined take-off and landing performance from the Duke of Sutherland, with £100 for the runner-up and a £300 reliability prize from the Society of Motor Manufacturers and the British Cycle and Motor-cycle Manufacturers' and Traders' Union, awarded to the aircraft that flew the most laps during the week.

The 1924 entrants were:^[24]

Competition Number	Registration	Type	Engine	Pilot	Notes
No. 1	G-EBJK	Bristol Brownie	Cherub	Cyril Uwins
No. 2	G-EBJL	Bristol Brownie	Cherub		did not attend
No. 3	G-EBKC	Cranwell CLA.2	Cherub	Nicholas Comper
No. 4	G-EBJJ	Beardmore Wee Bee	Cherub	Maurice Piercey
No. 5	G-EBIY	Westland Woodpigeon	Cherub		did not attend
No. 6	G-EBJV	Westland Woodpigeon	Cherub	Gaskell
No. 7	G-EBJO	ANEC II	Anzani
No. 8	G-EBJU	Short Satellite	Cherub	John Lankester Parker
No. 9	G-EBJP	Supermarine Sparrow[25]	Thrush	Henry Biard
No. 10	G-EBKP	Avro Avis	Cherub	Bert Hinkler
No. 11	G-EBKP	Avro Avis	Thrush	Bert Hinkler	Avro entered the same Avis twice to have a choice of engines. No.10 flew in the trials.
No. 12	G-EBKD	Blackburn Bluebird	Thrush		did not attend
No. 14	G-EBMB	Hawker Cygnet I	Anzani	Walter Longton
No. 15	G-EBJH	Hawker Cygnet II	Scorpion	Fred Raynham
No. 16	G-EBJF	Vickers Vagabond	Cherub	H.J. Payn
No. 17	G-EBJG	Parnall Pixie III biplane [13]	Cherub		Not flown in competition
No. 18	G-EBJG	Parnall Pixie III monoplane [13]	Cherub	Frank Courtney	Same aircraft as No. 17, without upper second wing, flown in competition
No. 19	G-EBKK	Parnall Pixie IIIa biplane [13]	Cherub	Sholto Douglas	Given Type No.IIIa, flown in competition

Only eight of these survived the elimination trials to proceed to the trials proper.^[23] The unexpectedly high loss rate was broadly due to underdeveloped engines and a rushed preparation of airframes.^[26] The Vickers Vagabond, for example arrived by road unflown. The successful machines were No.s 1, 3, 4, 5, 14, 15, 18 and 19. Pixies No.s 17 and 18 were the same aircraft, configurable as either a monoplane or a biplane, but only flown as No.18, in monoplane configuration. This dropped out of the trials on Tuesday 30 September,^[27] leaving only seven aircraft to end with officially recognised performances.^[28]

Prize winners^[23] The Air Ministry first prize was won by Maurice Piercey flying the Beardmore "Wee Bee" (No. 4). The runner up was the Bristol Brownie (No. 1) flown by Cyril Unwins. These were the only two aircraft reliable enough to complete the high speed tests, reaching 70.1 mph (112.8 km/h) and 65.2 mph (104.9 km/h) respectively. The Brownie also won the £500 take-off and landing prize, with the Cygnet II (No.15) running up. The slow Cranwell CLA.2 (No.3) went the furthest and flew for longest, winning the £300 reliability prize. It covered 762.5 miles (1,227 km) in almost 18 hours flying.

Cynet No. 14 is exhibited in non-flying condition at the RAF Museum, Cosford, Shropshire.^[29]

1926

Supermarine Sparrow II, G-EBJP; marked as number "7" for the 1926 trials

The 1926 trials were held at Lympne in September 1926. The aim of the competition was to encourage the design of practical two seaters, which as in 1924 were to have full dual control. Rather than limit engine capacity, the rules set a maximum engine weight of 170 lb (77.1 kg). For the first time in the Lympne trials, all aircraft had to be all British. This requirement, together with the weight limit severely limited the choice of engines. Air Ministry interest had waned and they put up no prize money, but the Daily Mail offered £5,000 in all, £3,000 to the winner, £1,500 to the runner-up and £500 for third place. A single "figure of merit" determined position, the ratio of the useful load carried, unchanged throughout the trials to the mass of petrol used over the total 1,994 miles (3,208 km) flown. The preliminary eliminating trials began on Friday 10th, and the trial proper on Sunday 12th.

The 1926 entrants were:^[30][31]

Competition Number	Registration	Type	Engine	Pilot	Notes
No. 1	G-EBKD	Blackburn Bluebird	Genet	Walter Longton	entered by Blackburn
No. 2	G-EBOU	de Havilland DH.60 Moth	Genet	Hubert Broad	entered by de Havilland
No. 3	G-EBJK	Bristol Brownie	Cherub	Cyril Uwins	entered by Bristol Aeroplane Company
No. 4	G-EBJH	Hawker Cygnet	Cherub	J.S. Chick	entered by the Aero Club of the RAE
No. 5	G-EBNL	RAE Sirocco			never completed
No. 6	G-EBMB	Hawker Cygnet	Cherub	George Bulman	entered by T.O.M. Sopwith & F. Sigrist
No. 7	G-EBJP	Supermarine Sparrow II[25]	Cherub	Henry Biard	entered by Supermarine
No. 8	G-EBOO	Halton Mayfly	Cherub		entered by Halton Aero Club; not completed until 1927
No. 9	G-EBOV	Avro Avian	Genet	Bert Hinkler	entered by Avro
No. 10	G-EBKP	Avro Avis	Cherub	Sholto Douglas	entered by Avro
No. 11	G-EBPB	Cranwell CLA.4	Pobjoy P		entered by the Aero Club of the RAE; Pobjoy P failed tests
No. 12	G-EBPC	Cranwell CLA.4	Cherub	Nicholas Comper	entered by the Aero Club of the RAE
No. 13	G-EBPI	ANEC Missel Thrush	Thrush	G.L.P. Henderson	entered by H.W. Martin
No. 14	G-EBJG	Parnall Pixie III[13]	Cherub	Frank Courtney	entered by Parnall
No. 15	G-EBJU	Short Satellite	Scorpion	John Lankester Parker	entered by the Severn Aero Club
No. 16	G-EBJV	Westland Woodpigeon	Scorpion	Ritchie and Park	entered by the Severn Aero Club

Competitors No.s 5, 8 and 11 did not arrive in time for the elimination trials.^[32] The Missel Thrush did, but was out even before the start of the elimination test, badly damaged in an accident begun with undercarriage failure. The elimination trials did not reduce the field as severely as in 1924, but three aircraft (No.1, 12 and 15) were disqualified after suffering undercarriage failures in the flying tests. These tests involved a pair of five-minute flights over the airfield, including a figure of eight, the first flown from one cockpit and the second from the other. All the entrants passed the weight checks, the dismantle-house-reassemble test, similar the that undertaken in 1924 and the more demanding take off test.

So on Sunday, nine machines started the trials proper.^[33][34] On each of the six days, competitors flew several laps of courses mostly involving towns or landmarks along or near the Kent and Sussex coastline, and usually involving either three or six laps totalling between 300–400 miles. Friday's course was an exception, a two lap flight on a 106-mile circuit from Lympne to the south London airport at Croydon. By Thursday morning the field had been reduced to four, the two Cygnets with No.6 leading, followed by the Brownie and then the Pixie. Two days more flying left this order unchanged; final figures of merit were 1.105, 0.907, 0.850 and 0.773 respectively.

The 1926 winner, Hawker Cygnet G-EBMB, in 2008

Prize winners^[35] So the factory entered Hawker Cygnet, flown by Paul Bulman took the £3,000 winner's prize, the RAE Aero Club Cygnet flown by J.S. Chick the £1,500 for second place and the Bristol Brownie £500 for third. All three aircraft used the Cherub engine. If placings had been determined by fuel consumed rather than the figure of merit, the order would have been unchanged, and Bulman flew his Cygnet significantly faster (68.36 mph or 101.0 km/h) over the 1,994 miles of the course than anyone else.^[36]

References

Notes

1. Ord-Hume, Arthur W. J. G. (2012). The Lympne Trials. Catrine, Ayrshire: Stenlake Publishing. pp. 3–7. ISBN 978-1-84033-573-6.
2. The Shuttleworth Aircraft Collection
3. Hastingleigh, Kent: Those Magnificent Men in their Flying Machines: 1923
4. Ord-Hume 2000, pp. 45–6
5. Flight 4 October 1923 p.602-3
6. "Lympne Avietta Competition - Entries for Duke of Sutherland's Prize" The Times (London). Tuesday, 2 October 1923. (43461), col D, p. 9.
7. Flight 11 October 1923 p.626
8. Flight 18 October 1923 p.636 Lympne 1923 entrants p.149
9. Ord-Hume 2000, pp. 565
10. Grigg Motor & Engineering Company of Twickenham.
11. Ord-Hume 2000, pp. 545
12. Ord-Hume 2000, pp. 246
13. Jackson 1974, pp. 278-279
14. Flight 6 December 1923 p.748
15. Ord-Hume 2000, pp. 225
16. Ord-Hume 2000, pp. 459
17. Flight 29 May 1924 p.338
18. Flight 18 October 1923 p.648
19. Ord-Hume 2000, pp. 47
20. Vivette
21. "Two-Seater Light Plane Competitions at Lympne". Flight: 634–40. 2 October 1924.
22. Ord-Hume 2000, pp. 49–50
23. Flight 9 October 1924 p.650
24. Flight 25 September 1924 p.586-624 Lympne 1924 entrants (list p.588)
25. Jackson 1974, p. 316
26. Ord-Hume 2000, pp. 51–52
27. Flight 1924-10-02 p. 631 incorrectly reported that both Pixies went out early with engine trouble. A correction was made the following week, p.656
28. Flight 9 October 1924 p.650 Lympne 1924 qualifiers p.650
29. Hawker Cygnet airplane pictures & aircraft photos - RAF Museums
30. Flight 29 July 1926 p.462 Lympne 1924 Entrant's list
31. Flight 16 September 1926 p.593
32. Flight 16 September 1926 p.592-8
33. Flight 16 September 1926 p.599-603
34. Flight 23 September 1926 p.612-8
35. Flight 23 September 1926 p.618
36. Flight 23 September 1926 p.613

Bibliography

• Jackson, A.J. (1974). British Civil Aircraft since 1919 Volume 3. London: Putnam. ISBN 0-370-10014-X.
• Ord-Hume, Arthur W.J.G. (2000). British Light Aeroplanes. Peterborough: GMS Enterprises. ISBN 978-1-870384-76-6.

Coordinates: 51°4.8′N 1°1′E / 51.0800°N 1.017°E