IRT Ninth Avenue Line

The Ninth Avenue El's "suicide curve" at 110th Street, in 1896

The IRT Ninth Avenue Line, often called the Ninth Avenue El,^[1] was the first elevated railway in New York City. It opened on July 1, 1868 as the West Side and Yonkers Patent Railway, as an experimental single-track cable-powered elevated railway from Battery Place, at the south end of Manhattan Island, northward up Greenwich Street to Cortlandt Street. It ceased operation on June 11, 1940,^[2] after it was replaced by the IND Eighth Avenue Line which had opened in 1932.

The last section in use, over the Harlem River, was known as the Polo Grounds Shuttle, and closed on August 31, 1958.^[3] This portion used the now-removed Putnam Bridge swing bridge^[4][5] and went through a tunnel, complete with partially underground stations.^[6]

History

West Side and Yonkers Patent Railway

West Side and Yonkers Patent Railway test run, 1867

On April 20, 1866, the West Side and Yonkers Patent Railway Company was formed by Charles T. Harvey and eventually was awarded the approval to begin construction of an elevated line operating on Greenwich Street, then Ninth Avenue from Battery Place to 30th Street.^[7] His company had been chartered with a subscribed capital of $100,000, to build a 25-mile elevated railroad from the southern extremity of the city northward through the city and thence to the village of Yonkers.^[8]

Construction on the line began on July 1, 1867.^[7] The first column was erected on October 7, 1867 and was tested in December 1867.^[7] The 0.5 miles (0.80 km) line was dubbed the “one-legged railroad,” because the single track ran above the street on a single row of columns.^[8] The cable was a loop, driven by a stationary engine, that ran between the rails for propulsion of the cars, and then returned under the street.^[8] The equipment included three complete passenger cars; four vaults where the machinery was located; and patent rights.^[7]

The line opened for business on July 1, 1868,^[7] and the State Commissioners who authorized the “experiment” declared it a success, and the Governor authorized its completion to Spuyten Duyvil.^[8] The name was later changed to the West Side and Yonkers Patent Elevated Railway Company.^[7] The original northern terminus was 29th Street,^[7] and the southern terminus was Dey Street.^[7] The line used multiple one-mile-long (1.6 km-long) cable loops, driven by steam engines in cellars of buildings adjacent to the track. Each loop was started when a car neared it and stopped when it had passed. The cables were equipped with collars that the car connected to with "claws". As the claws could not be "slipped" the car was jerked each time it moved to the next cable.

The line had ongoing problems. The mechanics of grasping the cable proved less-than-perfect.^[8] Maintaining the mile-long cable was a problem.^[8] Having it “return” under the street was a problem that was soon fixed by having it return at track level, but it still had to be directed off the track and into the building where the stationary engine sat.^[8] Legal problems were constant, largely at the instigation of those who wanted the franchise for themselves.^[8] The line finally shut down altogether and sat idle for a few months,^[7] and its assets were sold at a Sheriff's auction on November 15, 1870 for $960 (about $15,000 in today’s money).^[7][8] The purchasers of this deal were the bondholders, who subsequently reorganized the line as the Westside Patented Elevated Railway Company.^[8]

There were objections from Boss Tweed and his allies, who were pushing for his viaduct scheme as well as injunctions introduced by the horse-car companies which, up until this time, had no competition. On February 9, 1871, the Transit Commissioners granted permission for the elevated railway company to proceed with their plan to discard all previous equipment and replace it with steam locomotives.^[7][8] Repairs were made to strengthen the existing structure and steam operation began on April 20, 1871.^[8] There were only two stations at this time, one at Dey Street, the other at the end of the line at 29th Street. In the summer of 1871, three mortgages were defaulted, and trustees were appointed by the bondholders to reorganize the railroad properties.^[8] In 1872, the property was bought at auction by the newly organized New York Elevated Railroad Company.^[7][8] Thus commenced the world's first successful elevated railway.^[7] Steam power was to be used on all subsequent lines until the advent of electrical operation in 1902.^[7]

Extension

The Putnam Bridge, which took the extended and reguaged line over the Harlem River

On May 6, 1872, the Watts Street station opened, and on June 17, 1872, the Little West 12th Street station opened with a passing track.^[9] On August 15, 1872 the Morris Street station was opened.^[9] On March 19, 1873, the Morris Street station was closed in favor of a terminal at the rear of #7 Broadway, where the Company offices were located.^[9] US Mail was carried on regular passenger trains on the front platform of the first car accompanied by a US Post Office Guard with a limit of 7 bags.^[9] RPO Cars were not used for this service.^[9] The first yard and engine repair shop was located here.^[9] On January 21, 1873, the Franklin Street station opened.^[9] At the time, running time on the line was 28 minutes.^[9] On July 30, 1873, the line was extended to 34th Street on Ninth Avenue.^[9] On October 21, 1873, the 21st Street station opened.^[9] On November 3, 1873, the Houston Street station opened.^[9] On December 13, 1873, a new station opened at 30th Street, which replaced the original terminal at 29th Street.^[9] On May 25, 1874, a new and larger Cortlandt Street station replaced the original Dey Street station.^[9]

In March 1875, the entire structure was strengthened and the track gauge was set to 1,435 mm (4 ft 8 ¹⁄₂ in) to carry standard passenger cars, and interchange freight cars.^[9] The line was closed down a short time while 200 men changed the wheel widths on the rolling stock and laid the rails on cross-ties.^[9] A passing siding at Franklin Street was also installed.^[9] On November 5, 1875, service was extended to 42nd Street at Ninth Avenue, and the Bethune Street station at Greenwich Street was opened.^[9] On January 18, 1876, single-track operation was extended to 61st Street, with stations at 50th Street and 55th Street and an incline was installed at 61st Street for equipment delivery.^[9] The line was now five miles in length.^[9] On April 15, 1877, the first double-track el structure from Morris Street through Battery Park to the South Ferry Terminal station at Whitehall Street was opened.^[9] The Morris Street station was reopened for two years until the line was rebuilt for the junction of the Sixth Ave line at Morris Street.^[9] On June 2, 1878, service to 53rd Street began.^[9] The line now carried 8,500 passengers a day.^[9] The car and engine shops were located behind #7 Broadway.^[9] Passenger cars were lighted by oil candles at this time.^[9] On June 9, 1879, operations were extended to 81st Street and Columbus (Ninth) Avenue, with new stations at 59th, 66th, 72nd and 81st Streets.^[9] The double track structure was built jointly by the New York Elevated Railroad on the West side of the street and the Metropolitan Elevated Railroad on the East side.^[9] On June 21, 1879, service was extended to 104th Street with intermediate stations at 86th, 93rd Street, and 99th Street.^[9]

On September 17, 1879, the line was further extended north from 104th Street and Columbus Avenue, curved east at 110th Street, and then turned north onto Eighth Avenue to 125th Street. A new station at 116th Street, above Eighth Avenue, was opened.^[9] This curve structure from 110th Street to Eighth Avenue was the highest ever built at 100 feet (30 m) above the street and made a 90-degree turn from Ninth Ave on to 110th Street, then another on to Eighth Avenue.^[9] It was dubbed "Suicide Curve" as some people leaped to their death from this location.^[9][10] In October 1879, the rebuilding of the lower portion of the line to from 14th Street to Morris Street began.^[9] The Morris Street station was closed again as the structure there was rebuilt for the junction to the Sixth Avenue line.^[9] The Ninth Ave line narrowed to two tracks and the two tracks of the Sixth Ave Elevated on Trinity Place curved onto Greenwich Street to make a four-track structure, where the Sixth Avenue El ramped two blocks south to the level junction just north of the Battery Place Station.^[9] On September 27, 1879, the 130th and 135th Street stations on Eighth Avenue were opened.^[9]

On December 1, 1879, the 145th Street and 155th Street stations were opened.^[9] A yard was built on the east side of Eighth Avenue at 145th Street.^[9] On May 2, 1880, work was completed on the lower portion of the line and trains began operating over a completely rebuilt structure.^[9] The original track on the east side of Greenwich Street and the west side of Ninth Avenue, as well as the sections reinforced between 1874 and 1876, were torn down section by section and replaced.^[9] During this reconstruction, service was maintained by using the passing sidings, which, in some cases, became center passing tracks.^[9] The Battery Place station replaced the Morris Street station at the junction with the Sixth Avenue line.^[9] In the 1880s and the early 1890s, the El was closed from 8 PM to 5:30 AM and all day on Sundays. In 1880, the fare was raised to 10 cents, but 5 cents during morning and evening rush hours.^[10] In 1885, the first demonstration of an electric traction engine in New York was on the Ninth Avenue El.^[11] In 1886, the fare was cut to 5 cents all the time and it stayed at 5 cents until 1939.^[10] In the earliest years, tickets were sold at stations and collected on the trains by conductors.^[10] After 1886, the tickets were dropped in collecting boxes.^[10]

An 1892 drawing of the el

In 1892, a third track was added from 59th Street to 116th Street.^[10]

On April 11, 1897, bicycle train service was inaugurated and operated each Sunday on the line from Rector Street to 155th Street.^[9][10] The South Ferry platforms were too congested to handle the service.^[9] Seats were removed on one side of cars and bicycle racks installed for 24" bikes.^[9][10] The fare was 15 cents for passenger and bike or 25 cents for two with a tandem.^[9] Thirty-five two car bicycle trains identified by signs on the front of the trains were run until the autumn, when they were discontinued permanently.^[9]

Electric operation

On February 18, 1903, electric operation began on the line from South Ferry to 155th Street.^[7][9][10] A 66th Street Local-Express powered by Locomotive #135 was the last steam operated passenger train on the line.^[9] A few steam locomotives remained in work train service for a number of years afterwards.^[9] On June 3, 1903, the 110th Street station opened, with four elevators to get passengers up from the street to the downtown platform and the mezzanine level for uptown trains.^[9][10] The station could only be built with elevators as it was 63 feet above street level, and was the highest station.^[10] Some say that the tower, which had the elevators, lasted into the early 1970s.^[10]

The Ninth Avenue El and several other lines of the Manhattan Railway company were taken over with a 99-year lease by the Interborough Rapid Transit Company on April 1, 1903.^{[7][9][10][12]} On April 1, 1903, the entire Manhattan Elevated system was leased to the IRT Company for 999 years. Subway system construction was planned to connect with the Els at various points. By June 25, 1903, the last steam-powered elevated train was operated in passenger service on the 9th Ave El.^[7][9][13] In 1905, the storage yard built at 145th Street was replaced with 159th Street Yard and service facility which was north of the Polo Grounds.^[14]40°50′0″N 73°56′12″W / 40.83333°N 73.93667°W The rebuilding project was extended all the way north to 116th Street, creating Manhattan's first three-track elevated, although center-track express service did not begin until 1916.

1905 Ninth Avenue derailment

On September 15, 1904, the US Express Company began less-than-carload and package express service over the Third and Ninth Avenue Els.^[9] The express depot was at the rear of #7 Broadway, where the company offices were.^[9] A spur from the end of the Sixth Avenue El at Morris Street went into the upper level of the building.^[9] Livestock and less-than-carload freight were carried in the El baggage-express center door cars.^[9] The package express cars made five round trips daily to uptown points at the 129th Street and 155th Street Terminals.^[9] Both services were discontinued shortly before WWI.^[9] No interchange railroad freight cars were operated.^[9] On September 11, 1905, the worst accident in the history of New York's elevated railways took place at a curve at 53rd street resulting in 13 deaths and 48 serious injuries.^[15] On November 15, 1917, the last new station was opened at 151st Street on Eighth Ave, where the structure was expanded to 4 tracks and an express fly-over was installed to optimize traffic to the Bronx and 155th St terminal operations.^[9]

On January 6, 1918, the New York & Putnam Railroad terminated its operations over the bridge to the 155th Street Terminal with the Ninth Avenue El.^[9] The bridge and structure at the Polo Grounds was to have been the entrance of the New York & Northern Railroad, which later became the New York & Putnam, via the El structure into downtown and lower Manhattan. The Putnam Railroad bridge was the last of the steam-powered swing type Harlem River drawbridges and was leased to the IRT for 999 years to become part of the IRT Ninth Avenue El, Jerome Ave line extension to the Bronx.^[9]

On July 1, 1918, express service on the line began operating from 125th Street to 155th Street, and trains began using the new express station at 145th Street for the first time.^[9][16] At the same time the line was extended to 162nd street with stops opening at Sedgwick Avenue and at Anderson–Jerome Avenues,^[16] in order to serve the New York Central Putnam Line passengers transferring to the new terminal at 30th Street.^[9] A rise in the Bronx terrain between the Sedgewick Avenue station to the East and the Anderson Ave station to the West necessitated the Jerome Ave Connection to be tunneled for about 5 blocks, making that segment of the El a subway.^[9] The Sedgewick Ave station entrance was above the el structure and serviced both the El and the new Putnam Railroad terminal built there to replace the 155th St Terminal.^[9]

Beginning on July 17, 1918, service was extended to the Kingsbridge Road station on the Jerome Ave Line.^[9] On January 2, 1919, rush hour expresses began running to the Woodlawn station on the IRT Jerome Avenue Line.^[9]

Starting in 1923 there were coin-operated turnstiles.^[10]

Final years

Berenice Abbott photograph of Ninth Avenue El station at 72nd Street, 1936

The line began at South Ferry and ran along Greenwich Street from Battery Place to Gansevoort Street in lower Manhattan, Ninth Avenue in midtown (joining with the Sixth Avenue El at 53rd Street, continuing along Columbus Avenue in upper Manhattan between 59th Street and 110th, turning east on 110th and running north on Eighth Avenue until the Harlem River.^[17]

As of 1934, the following services were being operated:

• 9th Avenue Local - South Ferry to 155th Street all hours, extended Sundays and late nights to Burnside Avenue via Jerome Avenue Line.
• 9th Avenue Express - Rector Street to Burnside Avenue via Jerome Avenue Line weekdays and Saturdays daytime, extended to Fordham Road weekday rush periods, also Saturday morning rush and afternoon thru PM peak. These trains ran express south of 155th Street southbound until noon and northbound after noon, and made all stops in the opposite direction.

After the 6th Avenue Elevated was closed on December 4, 1938, weekday and Saturday evening 9th Avenue locals were extended from 155th Street to Burnside Avenue to replace 6th Avenue Elevated service.

The line was closed June 11, 1940 and dismantled, following the purchase of the IRT by the City of New York.^[2][9] Service from 155th Street to Burnside Avenue in the Bronx was continued as the "Polo Grounds Shuttle" at all hours. A paper transfer issuance was established between the shuttle and the IND Concourse Line station at 155th Street at the Polo Grounds.^[9] IRT composite construction subway cars replaced the wooden el cars on the line, but retained the el third rail shoes.^[9] Dual third rail operation remained in use on the Jerome Avenue Line to the yards at Bedford Park until the Shuttle was discontinued in 1957 and the structure and the bridge were removed in 1962.^[9] The shuttle was cut back to 167th Street on June 1, 1941, and was discontinued on August 31, 1958, as a result of the departure of the Giants and the ending of passenger service on the New York Central's Putnam Division.^[3][9]

Station listing

From north to south, the stations were:

Station	Tracks	Opening date	Closing date	Transfers & Notes
merge with IRT Jerome Avenue Line between 161st Street and 167th Street
Anderson–Jerome Avenues	all	July 1, 1918[16]	August 31, 1958[3]	Still exists in ruins. Service continued north along the Jerome Avenue Line to 167th Street when the new Bronx stations opened. Service was further extended to Woodlawn on January 2, 1919.[7]
Sedgwick Avenue	all	July 1, 1918[16]	August 31, 1958[3]	Still exists in ruins. Transfer point with New York Central Railroad's Putnam Division.[7]
Manhattan – Bronx border, bridge over Harlem River
tracks split to the 159th Street Yard
155th Street	all	1879[7]	August 31, 1958[3]	Station was built next to New York Central Railroad's Putnam Division southern terminus and was a transfer point until the Putnam Division stopped service into Manhattan in 1918.[7]
151st Street	local	November 15, 1917	June 11, 1940[2]
145th Street	all	December 1, 1879	June 11, 1940[2]
140th Street	local	September 27, 1879	June 11, 1940[2]
135th Street	local	September 27, 1879	June 11, 1940[2]
130th Street	local	September 27, 1879	June 11, 1940[2]
125th Street	all	September 17, 1879	June 11, 1940[2]
116th Street	all	September 17, 1879	June 11, 1940[2]
110th Street	local	June 3, 1903	June 11, 1940[2]
104th Street	local	June 21, 1879	June 11, 1940[2]
99th Street	local	June 21, 1879	June 11, 1940[2]
93rd Street	local	June 21, 1879	June 11, 1940[2]
86th Street	local	June 21, 1879	June 11, 1940[2]
81st Street	local	June 9, 1879[18]	June 11, 1940[2]
72nd Street	local	June 9, 1879[18]	June 11, 1940[2]
66th Street	all		June 11, 1940[2]
59th Street	local	June 9, 1879[18]	June 11, 1940[2]	Transfer to Sixth Avenue Elevated
55th Street	local	January 18, 1876	Before 1904
merged at 53rd Street with branch of IRT Sixth Avenue Line
53rd Street	local	June 2, 1878	Before 1904
50th Street	local	January 18, 1876	June 11, 1940[2]
42nd Street	local	November 6, 1875[7]	June 11, 1940[2]
34th Street	all	July 30, 1873[7]	June 11, 1940[2]
30th Street	local	December 13, 1873	June 11, 1940[2]
29th Street		1868[7]	December 13, 1873
23rd Street	local	October 21, 1873	June 11, 1940[2]
21st Street	local	October 21, 1873	June 11, 1940[2]
14th Street	all		June 11, 1940[2]
Little West 12th Street	local	June 17, 1872	Before 1904
Bethune Street	local	November 5, 1875	Before 1904
Christopher Street	all	November 3, 1873	June 11, 1940[2]
Houston Street	local	November 3, 1873	June 11, 1940[2]
Watts Street	local	May 6, 1872	Before 1904
Desbrosses Street	all	November 23, 1873	June 11, 1940[2]
Franklin Street	local	January 21, 1873	June 11, 1940[2]
Warren Street	all	February 14, 1870	June 11, 1940[2]
Barclay Street	local	February 14, 1870	June 11, 1940[2]
Dey Street		1868[7]
Cortlandt Street	all	May 25, 1874	June 11, 1940[2]
Rector Street	local	May 25, 1874	June 11, 1940[2]
Morris Street	local	August 15, 1872 April 15, 1877	March 19, 1873 September 27, 1879
split from IRT Sixth Avenue Line
Battery Place	all	June 13, 1872 for IRT Sixth Avenue Line trains, and May 2, 1880 for Ninth Avenue Line trains	June 11, 1940[2]	Transfer to Sixth Avenue Elevated
South Ferry	all	June 13, 1872 for IRT Sixth Avenue Line trains, and April 5, 1877 for Ninth Avenue Line trains[19]	December 22, 1950, but was no longer used by Ninth Avenue El after June 11, 1940.[2]	Various ferries (see South Ferry.) Transfer to Second, Third and Sixth Avenue Elevated Lines.

References

1. "Remembering the 9th Avenue El". MTA.info. October 26, 2011. Retrieved 2011-10-28.
2. Ninth Avenue Elevated Closure Poster
3. "imagejpg1_zpse1f8a458.jpg Photo by JavierMitty - Photobucket". Photobucket.
4. "Image 8282". nycsubway.org. 1958-06-14. Retrieved 2007-11-27.
5. "Image 8296". nycsubway.org. Retrieved 2007-11-27.
6. Walsh, Kevin. "When Is a Subway Not a Subway?". Forgotten NY. Retrieved 2007-11-27.
7. "The 9th Avenue Elevated-Polo Grounds Shuttle". nycsubway.org. 2012. Retrieved 2014-07-03.
8. "New York Elevated - Charles Harvey". Mid-Continent Railway Museum. 2006-04-08. Retrieved 2015-10-25.
9. "Along the Line". Time Traveling on the NYC Ninth Ave El. 1903-02-18. Retrieved 2015-10-26.
10. History, Bloomingdale (2013-09-13). "The Ninth Avenue El". bloomingdale history. Retrieved 2015-10-25.
11. Sansone, Gene; P. Roess, Roger (August 23, 2012). 9783642304842. Springer Science & Business Media. ISBN 9783642304842.
12. Feinman, Mark S. "Continuing the Story of the 9th Avenue El". Retrieved 2009-08-04.
13. Walker, James Blaine (1918). Fifty Years of Rapid Transit, 1864-1917. pp. 182–186.
14. "Eighth Avenue El". Time Traveling on the NYC Ninth Ave El. Retrieved 2015-10-26.
15. Robert C. Reed, The New York Elevated, South Brunswick, NJ and New York: Barnes, 1978, ISBN 0-498-02138-6, p. 138.
16. "Open New Subway To Regular Traffic: First Train On Seventh Avenue Line Carries Mayor And Other Officials: To Serve Lower West Side: Whitney Predicts An Awakening Of The District–New Extensions Of Elevated Railroad Service". New York Times. July 2, 1918. Retrieved 25 October 2015.
17. The Red Book: New York. New York: Interstate Map Co. 1935.
18. "The Manhattan Company. Opening of the West Side to Eighty-first Street - The Sunday Trains" (PDF). The New York Times Company. 10 June 1879. p. 8. Retrieved 11 February 2009.
19. "The 3rd Avenue Elevated". nycsubway.org. 2012. Retrieved 2014-07-03.

External links

• "Open New Subway to Regular Traffic" (PDF). New York Times. 1918-07-02. p. 11. Retrieved 2007-11-27.
• Beach Pneumatic Transit Co by Joseph Brennan Full of Photographs and information about the line, particularly Chapter 14.
• NYCsubway.org - The 9th Avenue Elevated
• 1939 track map
• Time Traveling on the NYC Ninth Ave El - A History of New York City (Manhattan) Elevated Railways