Oakland County Child Killer

Oakland County Child Killer
Other names	The Babysitter Killer The Babysitter
Criminal penalty	Never sentenced
Killings
Victims	4+
Span of killings	February 15, 1976–March 16, 1977
Country	United States
State(s)	Michigan
Date apprehended	Unapprehended

The Oakland County Child Killer (OCCK) is an unidentified serial killer responsible for the murders of four or more children, two girls and two boys, in Oakland County, Michigan, United States in 1976 and 1977.

Case background

During a 13-month period, four children were abducted and murdered with their bodies left in various locations within the county. The children were each held from 4 to 19 days before being killed. Their deaths triggered a murder investigation which at the time was the largest in US history.^[1] The murders are still unsolved.

Fear and near mass hysteria swept southeastern Michigan as young people were inundated with information on "stranger danger", and parents clogged streets around schools dropping off and picking up their children. The few who did walk, walked in groups and under the watchful eyes of parents in "safe houses", where children could go if they felt uncomfortable. Children even avoided using a playground directly behind the Birmingham police station.^[2] One incident in Livonia involved a tow-truck driver who assaulted a man he had seen asking two boys on the street for directions. He turned out to be a tire salesman on a business trip from Akron, Ohio, who had gotten lost with no knowledge of the slayings. The Detroit News offered a $100,000 reward for the killer's apprehension.^[2]

Detroit's two daily newspapers, as well as the area's numerous radio and television stations, aggressively covered the case. A presentation on WXYT, entitled Winter's Fear: The Children, the Killer, the Search, won a 1977 Peabody Award.

Victims

Confirmed

• Mark Stebbins, 12, of Ferndale, was last seen leaving an American Legion Hall on Sunday afternoon, February 15, 1976. He had told his mother he was going home to watch television. His body was found on February 19, neatly laid out in a snowbank in the parking lot of an office building at Ten Mile Road and Greenfield in Southfield (some reports claim Oak Park; Greenfield is the boundary between the two cities). He had been strangled and sexually assaulted with an object. Rope marks were seen on his wrists. He was fully clothed in the outfit he was wearing when last seen alive.^[2]
• Jill Robinson, 12, of Royal Oak, packed a backpack and ran away from her home on Wednesday, December 22, 1976, following an argument with her mother over dinner preparations. The day after her disappearance, her bicycle was found behind a hobby store on Main Street in that city. Her body was found on the morning of December 26, along the side of Interstate 75 near Big Beaver Road in Troy. She was killed by a single shotgun blast to the face. She was fully clothed and still wearing her backpack. The body was placed within sight of the Troy police station, once again, laid out neatly in the snow.^[2]
• Kristine Mihelich, 10, of Berkley, was last seen Sunday, January 2, 1977 at 3:00 pm at a 7-Eleven store on Twelve Mile Road at Oakshire in Berkley, purchasing a magazine. A mail carrier spotted her fully clothed body 19 days later on the side of a rural road in Franklin Village. She had been smothered. The body was laid within view of nearby homes, eyes closed and arms folded across the chest, once again in the snow.^[2]
• Timothy King, 11, borrowed 30 cents from his older sister and left his home in Birmingham, skateboard in hand, to buy candy at a drugstore on nearby Maple Road on Wednesday, March 16, 1977, at about 8:30 pm. He left the store by the rear entrance, which opened to a parking lot shared with a supermarket, and vanished.^[2] An intensive search was executed that covered the entire Detroit metropolitan area, and there was widespread media coverage, already heavy with coverage on the previous three slayings. In an emotional television appeal, Timothy's father, Barry King, begged the abductor to release his son unharmed. In a letter printed in the Detroit News, Marion King wrote that she hoped Timothy could come home soon so she could serve him his favorite meal, Kentucky Fried Chicken. In the late evening hours of March 22, 1977, two teenagers in a car spotted his body in a shallow ditch alongside Gill Road, about 300 feet south of Eight Mile Road in Livonia, just across the county line in Wayne County. His skateboard was placed next to his body. His clothing had been neatly pressed and washed. He had been suffocated and sexually assaulted with an object. The postmortem showed that Timothy had eaten fried chicken before he was slain.^[2]

Suspected

There were other abductions and murders around the Oakland County area within the same period. These are not specifically tied to the four victims above due to variations in the cases.

• James Davison, 13, was abducted June 22, 1974, around Morris Ave and Porter Ave in Allen Park, Wayne County, Michigan, and was missing for several days; he was strangled and left in an alley face down in Oakland County. He was found on June 26 in the same clothes that he went missing in. He was on his way to a friend's house when he was abducted and his bike was found three blocks away from his home. He survived the attack and it is believed that he may have been a victim of the Oakland County Child Killer.
• Cynthia Cadieux, 16, was abducted and bludgeoned to death on the evening of January 15, 1976. Missing from Roseville, she was discovered nude and battered in Bloomfield Township in the early morning hours of January 16.^[3]

Disproved

• Sheila Srock, 14, was raped and shot dead while babysitting in a home on Villa Street in Birmingham on January 20, 1976. Her assailant had burglarized several homes in the neighborhood earlier in the evening. A neighbor had watched the entire attack in horror from his roof, where he was shoveling snow.^[4] Oliver Rhodes Andrews confessed to, and was convicted of the murder of Srock, and is serving a life sentence in prison.^[5]

Investigation

After the discovery of Kristine Mihelich's body, authorities realized they were dealing with three related cases and evidence that was similar. Reports were released publicly of the possibility a serial killer operating in the Oakland County area. The Michigan State Police led a group of law-enforcement officials from 13 communities in the formation of a task force, devoted solely to the investigation.

Soon after Timothy King was abducted, a composite drawing of the suspected kidnapper, and his vehicle, was released. A woman claimed she had seen a boy with a skateboard talking to a man in a parking lot of the drugstore that Timothy had told his parents he was going to in order to ride his skateboard. The vehicle was reportedly a blue AMC Gremlin with a white side stripe. Authorities would eventually question every Gremlin owner in Oakland County.

Investigators put together a profile of the killer based on witnesses' descriptions of the man seen talking to Timothy King the night he disappeared—a white male with a dark complexion, 25 to 35 years old with shaggy hair and sideburns. Authorities believed that the killer had a job that gave him freedom of movement and may have appeared to be someone that a child might trust, such as a police officer, clergyman or a doctor. He was also believed to be familiar with the area and had the ability to keep children for long periods of time without rousing neighbors' suspicions.

The task force checked out more than 18,000 tips, which resulted in about two dozen arrests on unrelated charges and the busting of a multi-state child pornography ring operating on North Fox Island in Lake Michigan (northwest of the Leelanau Peninsula).^[6] However, task force members were unable to make much headway in the investigation. The task force disbanded in December 1978 and the investigation was turned over to the State Police. The killer never struck again.

Suspects and persons of interest

Allen

A few weeks after the death of Timothy King, Detroit psychiatrist Dr. Bruce Danto, who worked with the task force, received a poorly -spelled guilt-ridden letter. The letter's writer identified himself as "Allen" and claimed that he was a sadomasochist slave of his roommate 'Frank' who is the 'OCCK'.^[7] Allen wrote a pleading, fearful and remorseful letter indicating that he was losing his sanity, endangered, and suicidal, convincing Danto that he was genuine.^[8] Allen wrote that he accompanied Frank on many road trips seeking boys, but he never was present during the abductions for the boys that Frank murdered. Allen confirmed that Frank drove a Gremlin, but he (Frank) 'junked it out in Ohio never to be seen again'.

Allen described that Frank was traumatized by killing children in the Vietnam War where he and Allen served, and was taking revenge on more affluent citizens such as the residents of Birmingham. Allen wrote that Frank wanted rich people to suffer for sending forces to Vietnam, and received nothing in return.^[7]

Allen instructed Danto to respond by printing the code words "weather bureau says trees to bloom in three weeks" published in that Sunday's Free Press edition.^[7] Soon after, Danto got a phone call from Allen, who offered to provide photographic evidence in exchange for a letter from the Governor of Michigan guaranteeing immunity from prosecution. The psychiatrist arranged to meet Allen at a bar called the 'Pony Cart Bar'^[9] near Detroit's exclusive Palmer Woods neighborhood. Allen did not show, and was never heard from again.

Archibald Edward Sloan

Sloan was a pedophile who victimized young boys in his neighborhood^[10] He became a person of interest when hair samples found in his 1966 Pontiac Bonneville, matched hair found on the bodies of Timothy King and Mark Stebbins. However the hair samples did not match other victims. Sloan often lent his car out to his pedophile friends.^[11]

Chris Busch

The case has recently sparked new interest. Timmy King's father, Barry, and brother, Chris, have been trying to get the Michigan State Police to release information about Chris Busch, the son of Harold Lee Busch, a high level General Motors executive. Chris Busch had been in police custody shortly before Timmy's abduction for suspected involvement in child pornography. He committed suicide in 1978. There has been no confirmed activity of the Oakland County Child Killer since his death.^[12] The Michigan State Police have now released 3400 pages of investigative records to Barry King.^[13]

James Vincent Gunnels

As a young teenager, Gunnels was repeatedly sexually assaulted by Chris Busch at their Ess Lake cabin. Busch was convicted of the crime.^[14] Gunnels hair was partially DNA matched with hair found on the blouse of Kristine Mihelich.^[14]

John Wayne Gacy

Authorities in Michigan were investigating the possibility that serial killer John Wayne Gacy could have been the Oakland County Child Killer. A witness to the 1977 abduction of Timothy King, remembered seeing two men with King. The first suspect was described as a young man in his late 20s, the second suspect bore a strong resemblance to Gacy. John Wayne Gacy was also allegedly in Michigan around the time of the murders.^[15] According to DNA tests conducted in 2013, Gacy was not involved in the Oakland County killings.^[16]

Theodore Lamborgine

Police in Parma Heights, Ohio arrested Ted Lamborgine, a retired auto worker believed to have been involved in a child porn ring in the 1970s. On March 27, 2007, investigators told Detroit television station WXYZ that Lamborgine was considered the top suspect in this case. Lamborgine pleaded guilty to 15 sex-related counts involving young boys, rather than accept a plea bargain that would have required him to take a polygraph test on the Oakland County child killings. Lamborgine also rejected an offer of a reduced sentence in exchange for a polygraph on the case.^[17]

In October 2007, the family of Mark Stebbins filed a wrongful death lawsuit against Lamborgine seeking $25,000. The lawsuit alleges Lamborgine, who lived in Metro Detroit in the late 1970s, abducted Mark and held him captive in a Royal Oak house for four days in February 1976 before smothering him to death during a sexual assault. Lamborgine has never been formally linked nor charged in the death of Mark Stebbins. Attorney David A. Binkley seeks compensation, including funeral costs, for Stebbins' brother, Michael, but stressed that money is secondary.^[17]

Resumed investigation and new evidence

Investigation reports released to family of the victims

Police reports obtained by Ken King include new revelations, including DNA testing of new suspects, a sketch found at the scene of Busch's suicide of a boy resembling Mark Stebbins screaming in abject terror and wearing a hooded sweatshirt, and a bloody rope also found at the scene of Busch's suicide.^[18]

Catherine Broad, sister of Timothy King, compiled an archive of investigation material as the case grew.^[19]

Upon researching the case records, the King family produced a documentary entitled 'Decades of Deceit'. The documentary condemns the investigators and prosecutors for alleged shoddy investigations and uncooperative communication, and in particular of disregarding leads the King family discovered in 2006. Funds generated from the sale of the documentary will be donated to the Tim King fund, a fund designated to help abused children and support child activities for Birmingham children.^[20]

DNA tests of hair

According to DNA tests conducted in 2012, samples of hair belonging to an unknown person, were found on the seat of Archibald “Ed” Sloan's 1966 Pontiac Bonneville and bodies of victims Mark Stebbins and Timothy King. The samples are one of the first piece of concrete evidence linking two of the murders.^[21] The samples however exonerate most of the current suspects. DNA tests also confirmed that white hair from the same dog were found on all 4 victims linking the cases.^[14]

A new suspect was discovered, James Vincent Gunnels, when hair found on the blouse of Kristin Mihelich was later tested for DNA. However due to the condition of the hair, an inconclusive match was achievable.^[14] Gunnels, who was convicted in the past for property crimes, was living in a halfway house. He was released in 2011 as the police lacked the evidence to charge him.

Current developments/2012 case reopening

In 2013, an anonymous informant reported a blue AMC Gremlin buried in a farm field now being developed in Grand Blanc. Police are investigating the Gremlin for ties to the crime as Timothy King was last seen in a blue Gremlin.^[22] However, it is common for farmers to dispose of unwanted automobiles in such a method.

"Bob"

In 2005, a unidentified man, who would later emerge to become a common figure in the case and referred to the alias of "Bob" was reminded of a relationship he had in 1977 with an acquaintance. In an interview given to Oakland County investigators in 2010, Bob informed them of atypical observations and actions while driving and conversing with the acquaintance, such as taking him to buildings where satanic rituals were performed according to the acquaintance. The acquaintance navigated through lesser-known routes associated with the case with ease. The acquaintance also spoke of details written in "Allen's" letter (see above).^[23] Bob requested information about the "Allen" letter to help confirm his suspicions, but was denied.^[24]

In 2010, Bob gave a recorded interview to Oakland County investigators and Prosecutor Jessica Cooper to present evidence pertaining to the investigation.^[25] Bob claimed to have tried to approach her with his findings and to convince her to place the case under the jurisdiction of the Department of Justice to expedite the case. The department was already involved as FBI investigators and through resources such as the ViCAP database.^[26] Prosecutor Cooper dismissed his suggestions and, as there was no new evidence presented, his request to inspect the "Allen" letter was denied. Cooper describes the interview on the Oakland County Prosecutor's Office blog as "a rambling statement outlining a theory that the Oakland County Child Killer abductions and murders were related to pagan holidays, the lunar calendar, and Wiccan rituals".^[27]

Bob commenced to correspond with Deborah Jarvis, mother of victim Kristine Mihelich, and investigative journalists such as^[26] Bill Proctor and Heather Catallo in 2010. He claimed that he was among a team of a dozen investigators involved with the case and could identify the perpetrator of the crimes, but refused to indicate which law enforcement division he worked for.^[28][29] He claimed to have invested 10,000 hours into investigations over several years, but was reluctant to release his results as he doubted the competence of Wayne and Oakland county investigators. In a press release email, Bob indicated possible meddling by Jessica Cooper and other reasons as to why he had not made his investigation public.^[30][31][32] According to Paul Hughes, an attorney representing Jarvis, Bob's investigation discovered the murderer. However according to Hughes, Bob refused to identify the culprit unless the authorities divulged crucial information which Bob requested during the initial phone questioning in 2010. Bob wanted to positively confirm the identity of his suspect using the police evidence before proceeding further.^[33]

In 2012, Bob presented his findings to a select group of Detroit journalists on Hughes' cell phone. To preserve his anonymity he insisted that his phone interview with Hughes not be recorded. He theorized that the killers were conducting Wiccan human sacrifice rituals coinciding with pagan celebrations or the lunar calendar.

According to Bob, there were altogether 11-16 victims, significantly more than the four officially confirmed victims.^[29] Bob claimed his team found a number of similarities among the cases that had lottery-like odds to occur compared to other unrelated homicide cases.

Based on this information, Hughes attempted a lawsuit against the Oakland County authorities for $100M citing miscarriage of the investigation and demanding Cooper's resignation. The lawsuit alleged cover-up conspiracies, and obstruction against the victims' families.^[26] Hughes' website solicited donations, and offered a copy of Bob's report for a donation of $1,500. The families of the victims and Cooper claimed that Hughes and Bob are attempting to profit on their distress. The case was dismissed in March 2012 for lack of evidence.

References

1. Martindale, Mike (August 24, 2007). "New DNA evidence surfaces in Oakland child killings". The Detroit News. p. 00.
2. Barfknecht 1993, pp. 123–126
3. McIntyre 1988, p. 11
4. McIntyre 1988, p. 12
5. "Suspect". Ludington Daily News. March 4, 1976. Retrieved June 11, 2011.
6. "Secrets and Lies". True Crime Diary. 2011-06-14. Retrieved 2014-03-12.
7. "Oakland County child killer still a mystery despite letters to the police". Ludington Daily News 28 (264). Associated Press. September 28, 1977. Retrieved December 2, 2013.
8. Tommy McIntyre (January 1, 1988). Great Lakes Books, ed. Wolf in Sheep's Clothing: The Search for a Child Killer. Detroit: Wayne State University Press. pp. 173–174. ISBN 0-8143-1989-0. Retrieved December 3, 2013.
9. Tommy McIntyre (January 1, 1988). Great Lakes Books, ed. Wolf in Sheep's Clothing: The Search for a Child Killer. Detroit: Wayne State University Press. pp. 177–178. ISBN 0-8143-1989-0. Retrieved December 3, 2013.
10. Catallo, Heather (Jul 19, 2012). "Local man says he was assaulted by new Oakland County Child Killer person of interest Arch Sloan". WXZY 7 ABC. Retrieved 12 March 2014.
11. Renner, James (Jul 22, 2012). "Police are REALLY close to identifying Oakland County Child Killer". The Coldest Cases. Archived from the original on May 9, 2013. Retrieved 12 March 2014.
12. Keenan, Marney Rich (October 26, 2009). "Finding Timmy's killer: Family seeks answers 32 years after son's death". The Detroit News. Retrieved November 2, 2009.
13. "Detroit ABC affiliate WXYZ, December 28, 2010"
14. "EXCLUSIVE: New Person Identified In Oakland County Child Killer Case". Clickondetroit.com. Nov 2, 2011. Retrieved 2014-03-12.
15. "Is the Oakland County Child Killer connected to John Wayne Gacy?". Retrieved 02/01/2013. Check date values in: |access-date= (help)
16. Heather Catallo (2013-06-06). "Gacy DNA test results in Oakland County Child Killer case". WXYZ.com. Retrieved 2014-03-12.
17. Martindale, Mike (October 19, 2007). "Victim's family in Oakland child killings sues molester over death". The Detroit news. p. 1B.
18. "EXCLUSIVE: New Person Identified In Oakland County Child Killer Case". Clickondetroit.com. Nov 2, 2011. Retrieved 2014-03-12.
19. Dave Phillips (2013-04-13). "Woman blogs about losing a brother to the Oakland County Child Killer". Theoaklandpress.com. Retrieved 2014-03-12.
20. Heather Catallo (2013-09-12). "Family of Oakland County Child Killer victim takes prosecutor, police to task for unsolved murders". WXYZ.com. Retrieved 2014-03-12.
21. Dave Phillips (2012-07-17). "Prosecutor: DNA presents first link in Oakland County Child Killer case; person of interest named". The News-Herald. Retrieved 2014-03-12.
22. Tammy Stables Battaglia (2013-08-20). "Cops comb blue Gremlin near Grand Blanc for ties to Oakland child killer". Detroit Free Press. Retrieved 2014-03-12.
23. Ashenfelter, David. 'With audio: In Oakland county child killings shadowy figure offers his theories' May 15, 2012. Detroit Free Press. retrieved December 1, 2013 time index: 17:40
24. Ashenfelter, David. 'With audio: In Oakland county child killings shadowy figure offers his theories' May 15, 2012. Detroit Free Press. retrieved December 1, 2013 time index 27:40
25. Ashenfelter, David.'With audio: In Oakland county child killings shadowy figure offers his theories' May 15, 2012. Detroit Free Press. retrieved December 1, 2013
26. Catallo, Heather. 'Detroit lawyer files suit alleging cover-up in Oakland County child killer case'. April 23, 2012. WXYZ ABC 7 Action news. retrieved Dec 1, 2013
27. Cooper, Jessica R. 'The Oakland County children Killings: What about Bob'. Retrieved December 1, 2013
28. Ashenfelter, David. 'Anonymous tipster Bob has become part of the mystery of Oakland Child Killer case'. June 17, 2012. Detroit Free Press. retrieved November 29, 2013
29. Ashenfelter, David. 'Informant says he can connect Oakland County child killings to other deaths'. May 14, 2012. Detroit Free Press. retrieved December 01,2013
30. 'Bob'.'Press release from 'Bob'.'October 16, 2013. Detroit Free Press. December 1, 2013
31. Ashenfelter, David. 'In Oakland county child killing case, man named Bob makes many claims'. May 12, 2013. Detroit Free Press. retrieved December 1, 2013
32. Burns, Gus. 'Anonymous 'Bob' releases secret Oakland country child killer details to select media.' October 16, 2012. Mlive. retrieved November 30, 2013
33. Catallo, Heather.'Source behind $100 Million Child killer is anonymous to even lawyer, family'. April 24, 2012. WXYZ ABC 7 action news. retrieved December 1, 2013

Bibliography

• Barfknecht, Gary (1993). Unexplained Michigan Mysteries: Strange but True Tales from the Michigan Unknown. Davison: Friede Publications. ISBN 0-923756-05-1. OCLC 29187818.
• McIntyre, Tommy (1988). Wolf in Sheep's Clothing: The Search for a Child Killer. Detroit: Wayne State University Press. ISBN 0-8143-1966-1. OCLC 17731672.

External links

• Detectives Revive Infamous Case (2005 Michigan State Police Press Release)