Operation Black Thunderstorm

Operation Black Thunderstorm Part of the War in North-West Pakistan After the operation, the personnel of Pakistan Armed Forces hoist the Pakistan flag at the highest point of the Valley. Date 26 April 2009 – 14 June 2009 [1] (1 month, 2 weeks and 5 days) Location Swat Valley, Buner, Lower Dir, Shangla District, Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa Province Result Decisive Pakistani victory Districts returned to government control Many Taliban commanders captured or killed Failure to capture or kill Maulana Fazlullah Belligerents State of Pakistan  Pakistan Army  Pakistan Air Force  Pakistan Navy TTP TNSM Commanders and leaders LGen. Masood Aslam Air-Mshl. Hifazat Khan MGen. Ijaz Awan MGen. Haroon Aslam MGen. Sajjad Ghani MGen. Tariq Khan Maulana Fazlullah Sufi Muhammad  (POW) Maulana Ameer Izzat (POW) (KIA)[2] Syed Wahab (POW)[3] Maulana Muhammad Alam (POW) (KIA) [2] Units involved 9th Infantry Division Pakistan Navy Northern Command Pakistan Marines 50th Airborne Division SSG Division No. 25th Squadron Night Strike Eagles Army Rangers Division[4] Pro-government tribes[5] Strength 30,000 - 45,000 Regular and Airborne Forces 500+ SSG Division 5,000 Casualties and losses 150 + killed, 95 captured (18 rescued), 317 wounded (Military claim) 1,475 killed (23 foreign militants), 114 captured (Military claim) Unknown number of civilians killed 3.4 million displaced

Operation Black Thunderstorm^[6] was an aggressive military operation that commenced on April 26, 2009 conducted by the Pakistan Army, with the aim of retaking Buner, Lower Dir, Swat and Shangla districts from the Taliban after the militants took control of them since the start of the year.^[7]

Background

A temporary ceasefire was called in the Malakand region on February 16, 2009.^[8] The provincial government agreed to allow the implementation of Sharia in the region once violence had stopped.^[8][9][10] Sufi Muhammad traveled to Swat to discuss peace with Fazlullah and his followers,^[11] who agreed to observe the ceasefire.^[9][10][12] On February 24, 2009 Muslim Khan, spokesperson of the Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) publicly announced that his group would observe an indefinite ceasefire.^[13] The ANP, the governing party of the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa sent the bill to President Asif Ali Zardari, who delayed signing it into law until "the writ of the government [had] been established."^[14] Soon after that the militants expanded their territory into other districts and by mid-April they took Buner, Lower Dir and Shangla. With the Taliban takeover the militants came within 60 miles (97 km) of the capital of Pakistan, Islamabad.^[15] It was the closest that Taliban forces ever got to capturing the Pakistan capital, Islamabad. This raised the alarm among western countries, particularly the United States, that a collapse of the country and a Taliban takeover was playing out. The government was highly criticized for making peace deals with the militants. Therefore, the Pakistani government launched an operation in late April to retake all territory lost in the previous months.

Operation

Attack on Lower Dir

Operation Toar Tander-I (Black Thunderstorm-I) began in Lower Dir as the Frontier Corps (FC) killed 26 Taliban, including key commanders Maulana Shahid and Qari Quraish.

The operation was launched on April 26, after the Taliban, in violation of the peace agreement, attacked security forces and government officials and closed roads for the movement of government and FC convoys. In some villages, the Taliban had looted shops and tortured villagers to gain their support, adding that a jirga had also been forced to back them.

Officials said the forces were gaining ground against the Taliban and their hideouts in Kalkot, Islam Dara and Hoshyari Dara were targeted. Paramilitary troops and helicopter gunships bombed suspected Taliban bases during the operation. Eight soldiers and around 50 militants were killed in two days of fighting. The operation mostly cleared the Lower Dir district of Taliban forces by April 28. However, the military was still fighting with pockets of militant resistance in the coming weeks.^[16][16]

Buner Assault

The second phase of the operation started the same day as fighting in Lower Dir was dying down. The Pakistan Army's push to retake control of Buner, which was only 100 kilometres (62 mi) away from the capital city Islamabad, started. Special Forces members belonging to Pakistan Army's 50th Airborne Division and the Pakistan Army's Special Services Group swarmed down ropes from helicopters to enter the town of Daggar, which lies in the strategically important Buna valley to the northwest of Islamabad, killing nearly 50 militants.^[17] Pakistan Army leaders hoped to trap about 500 militants in between the 50th Airborne forces and SSG Division's teams that is advancing on the ground towards Taliban positions at the valley's entrance. The fate of 75 police officers taken hostage by the Taliban in Buner the previous night remained unclear. 18 were rescued the next day but the others were still prisoners. The troops belonging to 50th Airborne Division jumped first on April 30 in Buner City between 00:48 and 01:40. The Pakistan Air Force's SS Wing's 1st SOS Squadron flown the No. 6 Squadron Globe Trotters transport aircraft where hundreds of additional members of 50th Airborne Division, Special Services Group - Navy, 4th SOS Squadron, 140th Expeditionary Marines Battalion and the 1st Commando Yildiram Battalion, SSG jumped off in the dark night of April 31, and landed in different areas of Buner where they had taken the strategic positions. The battle between Airborne Forces and Taliban Forces ended when Taliban had lost large number of their men and suffered heavy human casualties caused by Airborne Forces of Pakistan Armed Forces.

The operation in Daggar came on the third day of the Army's offensive to roll back the Taliban advance that had caused concern not just in Islamabad – which is just 65 miles away – but also in Washington. Major General Athar Abbas, a military spokesman, told reporters in Rawalpindi that the Army and Frontier Corps paramilitary units launched the operation in Buner district, building on a several-day offensive in the region. Abbas said an estimated 450 to 500 Taliban are believed active in Buner, many believed to be engaged in "criminal activities."

The US had been repeatedly pressing the Pakistan government to take action, fearful that the militants were gaining too much ground and might even use Buner as a bridgehead for an attack on the capital city.^[18][19]

On May 2, another 10 soldiers were captured in Buner. The military confirmed that some 87 militants and four soldiers had been killed in fighting in the district between April 28 and May 4. The military also stated that its troops were confronted during the fighting with wave attacks of suicide car-bombers. At least 27 suicide bombers were killed in the fighting. By May 5, troops started to push back the Taliban militants in Buner.^[20][21]

Operation Rah-e-Rast

Airborne paratroopers took active participation in the war and pushed Taliban back to areas adjacent to Afghanistan.

On May 5, the third phase of the operation started as airborne troops boarded on C-130 transport aircraft, jumped off and stormed the militant-held valley of Swat. The name of this sub-operation of Black Thunderstorm has been referred to as Operation Rah-e-Rast in Urdu . In more than a month of fighting, by June 15, 106 soldiers and 1,040 militants were killed. Militant fighters were holed up in the emerald mines and in the main town of Swat district, Mingora. The emerald mines were secured by the Army's 50th Airborne division by May 7, but the militants were still holding their positions in Mingora and on a strategic hilltop overlooking the town. Meanwhile, on May 7, in Lower Dir, which was previously declared clear of the Taliban by the military, militants overran a paramilitary fort, killing three paramilitary soldiers and capturing 10 policemen. On the midnight of May 10, additional airborne troops with small teams of Pakistan Navy SEALs jumped off from C-130 transport aircraft, and attacked a Taliban hidden training camp at Banai Baba in Shangla district, which is just east from Swat. In the fighting at Banai Baba the military reported killing 150 militants for the loss of two soldiers. At the same time as the fighting in Shangla, some sporadic fighting was still continuing in Lower Dir where, over four days, 109 more militants were killed. Also, further west, in the Mohmand agency, a group of 300 militants attacked a military outpost; in the fighting that ensued 26 militants were killed and 14 soldiers were wounded. On May 12, Pakistani SSG commandos were inserted by helicopters into the Piochar area, a rear-support base for the militants in the northern part of the Swat valley, to conduct search-and-destroy operations.^{[22][23][24][25][26][27][28]}

By May 15, the Army claimed that Buner was finally completely cleared of Taliban forces, however artillery bombardment of Taliban positions in the hills was still ongoing. And it was reported that the Taliban were more dug in and in larger numbers in Buner than the military previously assumed. Meanwhile, the Pakistani military continued with their push up the Swat valley. As the military approached Mingora, the Taliban were digging in for a "bloody urban battle" against the Pakistani army's airborne forces in a hotly disputed city in the north-western part of the country. The Taliban began concentrating forces in Mingora - digging trenches, laying mines and taking positions on rooftops.

Stratfor, a private firm that describes itself as a global intelligence company, mentioned that it is not clear if the Pakistani military is trained and even equipped to go into a situation like that, adding that even the United States military "would have to think twice" about such an offensive. Pakistani military spokesman Major General Athar Abbas, who is the spokesman for Pakistan's military said "the military intends to drive the Taliban out of the contested area, even if the kind of fighting resembles that of the Battle of Stalingrad". He said that the whole resolve of the government and the military is to once and for all finish the Taliban from the Swat valley. The army has about 15,000 troops on the ground and is estimated that there are still over 5,000 Taliban fighters in the area.^[29]

On May 17, heavy street fighting started in the towns of Kanju and Matta and the Army was slowly advancing towards Mingora. Also, a few days later fighting started in the area of the Takhtaband bridge for control of this crossing point.^[30] On May 20, a key town in Buner was captured by the Army. The Army captured Sultanwas in fighting which, according to the military, killed one soldier and 80 militants, another nine soldiers were wounded.^[31] By May 23, Kanju, Matta and the Takhtaband bridge had been secured by the military, but fighting was still going on in Takhtaband itself and the Buner and Dir districts, where nine more militants were killed. Meanwhile, the military was surrounding the main militant base in the Peochar Valley.^[32]

Battle for Mingora

Military personnel observing the city and the valley of Swat after the successful capture.

On May 23, the battle for the capital of Swat, Mingora, started as the small teams belonging to SSG Division accompanied with Army Rangers stormed the city. The Ranger and SSG Division's teams entered in the city from two different phases. The SSG Division's team at first entered the city from the air as they were parachuted. At the same time, the Army Rangers and additional SSG Division's teams entered the city as they were boarded on M113C and the APC Talha-B. Combat here was heavy, intense, and occurred in the streets. Taliban Fighters had dug themselves into bunkers built into hotels and government buildings. Pakistan's SSG and Army Rangers had fought the Taliban fighters hand-to-hand inside the buildings and hotels. On the first day of the tiring and long battle, fighting was mainly in the center of the city, at the central bus terminal and along the main road near the city's primary gateway.^[33] By the next day's early morning, the military captured several intersections and three squares; including Green Square, which had been known as "Bloody Intersection", because the Taliban were dumping bodies of people who they executed at that location. Intense fighting was going on in the Nawa Kilay neighbourhood and the western suburb of Qambar.^[34]

By May 27, the military took control of 70 percent of the city, including the city's airport, and Taliban forces across Swat were in retreat, but fighting was still continuing. At the same time, in continuing battles in Lower Dir and Shangla, three more soldiers and eight militants were killed.^[35]

On May 29, the Army cleared Aman Kot and the Technical Institute College on the Mingora-Kokarai road in Mingora. On the same day, the village of Peochar in the Peochar Valley, as well as the town of Bahrain in the north of Swat, had been taken by the military.^[36]

On May 30, the Pakistani military had taken back the city of Mingora from the Taliban, calling it a significant victory in its offensive against the Taliban. However, some sporadic fighting was still continuing on the city's outskirts. Also, sporadic fighting was continuing in the rest of Swat and in the Shangla district where on June 2, two soldiers and five militants were killed.^[37][38][39]

In the battle for Mingora 286 militants were killed.^[40]

Alleged capture of Sufi Muhammad and other leaders

On June 4, it was reported that Sufi Muhammad, the founder of Tehreek-e-Nafaz-e-Shariat-e-Mohammadi or TNSM, was arrested in Amandarra along with other militant leaders.^[41] In the coming days there was confusion over this claim since the Taliban themselves said that Muhammad was missing. However, several days later it was confirmed that Muhammad was not captured and was in hiding, while two of his aides were captured by the Army. Those two aides, Muhammad Maulana Alam and Ameer Izzat Khan, were killed when militants attacked the prison transport they were in on June 7. On 26 July 2009, the government confirmed the arrest of Sufi Mohammad for encouraging violence and terrorism.^[42][43]

Sporadic fighting

By this point, the Pakistan Military was in control of much of Swat, however sporadic fighting still continued, especially in the Upper Dir District.^[44] After a bomb explosion in Hayagai Sharki village's masjid in Dir, which killed 38 civilians,^[44] local tribesmen, between 1,000 and 1,500, formed a lashkar (citizen's militia) and retaliated against the Taliban and TNSM by taking up arms and surrounding almost 300 militants.^[44] In support of the Lashkars, the Pakistan Military sent its helicopter gunships to the villages of Shatkas and Ghazi Gai where the heaviest fighting was ongoing.^[45][46] Paramilitary soldiers also set up mortars on high ground above the villages.^[45][46]

On June 12, troops captured the town of Chuprial in Swat in a major battle that left 39 militants and 10 soldiers dead. This was the last major battle, and one of the most bloody, of the operation.^[47]

On June 14, the operation ended with Pakistani troops consolidating their positions in the four districts and going after the remaining pockets of resistance, primarily in the Swat valley.^[1]

Casualties

In all, according to the military, 128 soldiers and at least 1,475 militants were killed and 317 soldiers were wounded during operation Black Thunderstorm. 95 soldiers and policemen were captured by the militants, 18 of them were rescued while the fate of the others remained undetermined. 114 militants were captured, including some local commanders.^{[47][48][49][50][51][52]} At least 23 of the militants killed were foreigners.^[53]

Later revelations about the Swat deal

On May 13, 2009, Pakistan's ambassador to the United States Husain Haqqani revealed on The Daily Show to Jon Stewart that Pakistan's decision to strike a peace deal with Taliban militants earlier, which effectively ceded control of large swathes of the country's northwest, was all part of a cunning plan to fool the Taliban, which is now coming to fruition with the commencement of Operation Black Thunderstorm. The ambassador mentioned to Jon Stewart that President Asif Ali Zardari's signing of the Nizam-e-Adl Regulation, which was the Swat peace deal, was nothing more than a trick to lure the Taliban from the mountains and countryside to the main towns where it would be much easier for the Pakistani military to kill or capture them.

"[President Zardari] did something very smart. When he was with President Obama recently, he explained it. He actually told the American government that I'm going to do this deal to try and prove to those within Pakistan, and in Pakistan's state apparatus, who think that these guys can be negotiated with — I will negotiate with them only to prove that you can't negotiate with them, because they will break the deal. And as soon as they broke the deal, the army is back in, the fighting is going on, and you can see the results."^[54]

The Swat peace-deal was heavily criticised by Hillary Clinton when she accused Pakistan's government of abdicating to the Taliban in agreeing to impose Islamic law in the Swat valley.^[55] However, Clinton was unaware that the Pakistani Government was simply using "reverse psychology," as Jon Stewart phrased it, on the Taliban.^[54][56][57]

Foreign involvement and aftermath

Pakistan's foreign office spokesman had confirmed that there was a heavy influx of foreigners aiding the Taliban and that weapons were coming from the adjacent country of Afghanistan. Many Pakistani defence analysts and experts had publicly accused India and Afghanistan of aiding the Taliban to destabilize Pakistan. On May 19, 2009, the Pakistan Army captured three foreign fighters from Mingora District. According to the Pakistani Army, all these foreign fighters were Libyan nationals. The Pakistani Army also captured five Saudi nationals during the search operation.

In Khybar Pass, a police raid on a local house resulted in the arrest of 20 Tajik nationals. In heavy fighting in Malakand Division, Pakistani commandos killed five Uzbek fighters. Many Pakistani political parties, such as PML-N, accused India, of providing economic and financial support to the Taliban. According to a White house press release, the United States and NATO were working with Pakistan to find out who's providing the financial support and what routes were they using to smuggle the weapons. According to the Daily Jang's investigative report, a large amount of Afghan National Army's weapons was stolen by the Taliban, and also the report claimed that there is no formal security for their weapons depots. Daily Jang also cited that a large number of Uzbeks and Tajiks were freely crossing Afghanistan's border into Pakistan to fight against Pakistan.

The airborne troops standing at the end of the valley.

Parliamentarian Khawaja Muhammad Asif of Pakistan Muslim League-N held a press conference in the Parliament media lounge, where he warned Afghan President Hamid Karzai. He said that "Karzai became President with the support of Pakistan". He also warned him that Afghanistan should not play with Pakistan's security. After the convincing evidence, Pakistan, along with United States and NATO, found out the significant routes that were using to supply heavy weaponry to Talibans. Pakistan blocked the routes successfully. On May 17, M.I. learnt that a large numbers of Taliban fighters with a number of foreign fighters, were presented in Khyber Pass, and possibly, were planning to re-take the Swat from the Army.

On May 20, 2009, in Khyber Pass, Pakistan Army sent a small teams of Special Service Group (SSG) Commandos, along with small teams of Army Rangers's Ninth Wing Company. As the teams progressed, the Pakistani commandos had confronted a large numbers of foreign fighters with a full-backing support of Taliban militant fighters. The battle was day long and an intensified heavy fighting, outnumbered Pakistani Black Storks Commandos (Special Service Group) and Ranger's Ninth Wing Company, killed a large number of Taliban and foreign fighters and Taliban leadership had repeatedly suffered heavy human casualties as well as Taliban had lost large number of their fighters.

The various media reports stated that foreign fighters were Uzbek and Tajik nationals. Pakistani Commandos also recovered a large amount of weaponry in trucks. During the battle, Pakistani special forces also successfully secured NATO's supply-line trucks that were constantly targeted by the Taliban fighters. After a day long battle, Taliban began to flee from the area at night, but while trying to escape, the SSG and the Ranger teams had intercepted their hiding locations. An ambush led by the Pakistani special forces, the SSG and Ranger's Ninth Wing Company, killed large number of the remaining Taliban fighters. After weeks of heavy fighting, the Taliban had suffered heavy losses and lost many key leaders and territories in Swat and Khyber Pass. The final battle concluded as Pakistan Army as victorious and eliminating the major Taliban leadership from the war theater.

In this operation Brig. Hussain Abbas also embraced martyrdom, He participated in a rescue mission to bring back the bodies of a heli crash.

See also

• War in North-West Pakistan
• Operation Zarb-e-Azb
• Operation Rah-e-Nijat
• Operation Rah-e-Rast
• Tehreek-i-Taliban Pakistan
• Fazlullah

References

1. Archived August 17, 2011, at the Wayback Machine.
3. "Militants kill aides of cleric captured by Pak military". The Daily Star. Bangladesh. 7 June 2009. Retrieved 19 February 2015.
4. Roggio, Bill (24 April 2009). "Rangers deployed to secure Islamabad outskirts". The Long War Journal. Retrieved 19 February 2015.
5. https://web.archive.org/20090611222034/http://news.yahoo.com:80/s/ap/20090608/ap_on_re_as/as_pakistan. Archived from the original on June 11, 2009. Retrieved June 10, 2009. Missing or empty |title= (help)
6. "26 killed as troops hit Taliban hideouts in Dir". Daily Times. 28 April 2009.
7. "Obama's foreign policy". Cosmopolis.ch. 2 June 2009. Retrieved 19 February 2015.
8. Jan, Delawar (2009-02-17). "Nizam-e-Adl Regulation for Malakand, Kohistan announced". The News International. Retrieved 2009-04-30.
9. "Pakistan agrees Sharia law deal". BBC News. 2009-02-16. Retrieved 2009-04-27.
10. Ali, Zulfiqar; Laura King (2009-02-17). "Pakistan officials allow Sharia in volatile region". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved 2009-04-22.
11. "Pakistan Blasted for Creating Taliban Safe Haven With Islamic Law Deal". Fox News. 2009-02-17. Retrieved 2009-04-22.
12. "Top Pakistani militant released". BBC News. 2008-04-21. Retrieved 2009-04-22.
13. Perlez, Jane (2009-02-24). "Taliban Accepts Pakistan Cease-Fire". New York Times. Retrieved 2009-04-22.
14. Khan, M Ilyas (2009-04-15). "Doubts remain as Sharia bill signed". Islamabad: BBC News. Retrieved 2009-04-27.
15. Constable, Pamela (2009-04-22). "Defiant Taliban Forces Advance To Within 60 Miles of Islamabad". Washington Post. Retrieved 2009-10-19.
16. Yusuf, Huma (28 April 2009). "Pakistan intensifies fight against Taliban". The Christian Science Monitor. Retrieved 14 December 2014.
18. Hussain, Zahid; Booth, Jenny (April 29, 2009). "Pakistan army retakes main town in Buna from Taleban militants". The Times (London). Retrieved May 20, 2010.
19. Stobart, Janet (April 29, 2009). "Jurors acquit 3 in transit attack". Chicago Tribune.
20. "7 more militants killed in NW Pakistan operation". People's Daily Online. 4 May 2009. Retrieved 14 December 2014.
21. "80 militants killed in Buner operation in Pakistan". People's Daily Online. 4 May 2009. Retrieved 14 December 2014.
22. "Thousands flee amid deadly Pakistan clashes". ABC News. 7 May 2009. Retrieved 14 December 2014.
23. "Troops killed in Pakistan clashes". BBC News. May 7, 2009. Retrieved May 20, 2010.
24. https://web.archive.org/20090618035607/http://www.kwqc.com:80/Global/story.asp?S=10327270. Archived from the original on June 18, 2009. Retrieved May 16, 2009. Missing or empty |title= (help)
25. "Unknown".
26. "Pakistan: 200 Taliban die in 24 hours". CNN. May 10, 2009. Retrieved May 20, 2010.
27. "Fighting flares in northwest Pakistan, 230 Taliban killed". The Times of India. May 10, 2009.
28. "Pakistan: Up to 700 militants killed in offensive". USA Today. May 11, 2009. Retrieved May 20, 2010.
29. "Analyst: 'Bloody urban battle' looms between Taliban, Pakistan". CNN. May 14, 2009. Retrieved May 20, 2010.
30. "Pakistan troops in Taliban urban warfare". Bigpondnews.com. 2009-05-19. Retrieved 2015-02-19.
31. "Pakistan: 80 militants killed; U.S. says 1 soldier dead". USA Today. May 20, 2009. Retrieved May 20, 2010.
32. "Pakistan military confronts Taliban in key Swat city". CNN. May 23, 2009. Retrieved May 20, 2010.
33. Witte, Griff (May 24, 2009). "Pakistan Intensifies Effort With Thrust Into Swat's Main City". The Washington Post. Retrieved May 20, 2010.
35. "Six troops, 29 Taliban killed in Pakistan's Swat Valley". Earth Times. Retrieved 14 December 2014.
36. https://web.archive.org/20090530202153/http://www.dawn.com:80/wps/wcm/connect/dawn-content-library/dawn/news/pakistan/04-army-clears-militant-stronghold-of-peochar-qs-06. Archived from the original on May 30, 2009. Retrieved May 29, 2009. Missing or empty |title= (help)
37. "Pakistan secures key Swat Valley city". CNN. May 30, 2009. Retrieved May 20, 2010.
38. "Pakistan army 'regains' Swat city". BBC News. May 30, 2009. Retrieved May 20, 2010.
39. "Pakistan Army Rescues Scores of Cadets, Others Missing". Earth Times. Retrieved 14 December 2014.
40. "Ghost town of Pakistan's Swat". ReliefWeb. 28 May 2009. Retrieved 19 February 2015.
41. "Banned NSM confirms Maulana Sufi's arrest". Geo TV. 4 June 2009. Retrieved 19 February 2015.
42. "Pakistan holds pro-Taliban cleric". BBC News. 2009-07-26. Retrieved 2009-09-19.
43. "Sufi Mohammad arrested: NWFP Information Minister". Dawn Media Group. 2009-07-26. Retrieved 2009-09-19.
44. "Pakistan tribesmen battle Taliban". BBC News. June 8, 2009. Retrieved May 20, 2010.
45. "Gunship backing for Taliban fight". BBC News. June 9, 2009. Retrieved May 20, 2010.
46. Shah, Farzana (10 June 2009). "Pak military sends gunships to support Upper Dir tribesmen against militants". Asian Tribune. Retrieved 19 February 2015.
47. "Premier, 1st Div club officials to meet BCB boss". Daily Star. Retrieved 14 December 2014.
49. "Pakistan pounds militants after moderate clerics murder". Earth Times. Retrieved 14 December 2014.
50. "Press Release No PR198/2009-ISPR". ispr.gov.pk. 14 June 2009. Retrieved 19 February 2015.
51. "Over 1,240 militants killed in ongoing operation in NW Pakistan". People's Daily Online. 2 June 2009. Retrieved 14 December 2014.
52. "Pakistani security forces kill 27 Taliban". webindia123. 9 June 2009. Retrieved 14 December 2014.
54. Mackey, Robert (May 14, 2009). "Sifting Through ‘Debris of the Past' to Make Sense of Pakistan's Taliban Problem". The New York Times. Retrieved May 20, 2010.
55. "Clinton says Pakistan abdicating to the Taliban". Reuters. April 22, 2009.
56. "Today's Newspaper - The News International". The News International, Pakistan. Retrieved 14 December 2014.
57. "Pakistan's 'Reverse Psychology' Peace Accords". Retrieved 14 December 2014.