Oregon Ballot Measure 59 (2008)

Measure 59
Creates an unlimited deduction for federal income taxes on individual taxpayers' Oregon income-tax returns.
Results
Votes %
Yes 615,894 36.22%
No 1,084,422 63.78%
Total votes 1,700,316 100.00%
Registered voters/turnout 85.7%
Results by county
  Yes
  No
Source: Oregon Secretary of State [1]

Oregon Ballot Measure 59 was an initiated state statute ballot measure sponsored by Bill Sizemore that appeared on the November 4, 2008 general election ballot in Oregon. If it had passed, Oregon would have join Alabama, Iowa, and Louisiana as the only states to allow federal income taxes to be fully deducted on state income tax returns.

Background

Official Ballot Title

The official ballot title is: Creates an unlimited deduction for federal income taxes on individual taxpayers' Oregon income-tax returns.

History

This is the third time Sizemore has put a similar measure on the ballot. In 2000, he qualified Measure 91, which would have made federal income taxes fully deductible on state taxes. It lost 55–45, but a legislative referral that increased limited state deductions of federal taxes passed. In 2007, the limit on federal deductions was $5,600 — it increases each year indexed to inflation.

In 2006, Sizemore associate Russ Walker introduced Measure 41, which would have allowed "income tax deduction equal to federal exemptions deduction to substitute for state exemption credit." It failed 73–37.

Along with Measures 60 and 64, Measure 59 is one of the three initiatives on the 2008 ballot that Sizemore has brought to the ballot in the past.

Newspaper Endorsements

Here is how Oregon's major newspapers have endorsed on Measure 59:

Newspapers Yes No
The Oregonian No
Medford Mail-Tribune No
Statesman Journal No
Bend Bulletin No
Portland Tribune No
Eugene Register-Guard No
Daily Astorian No
East Oregonian No
Corvallis Gazette Times No
Coos Bay The World No
Willamette Week No
Yamhill Valley News Register No
Gresham Outlook No
Hillsboro Argus No

No Oregon newspapers have endorsed a yes vote on Measure 59.

Specific provisions of the initiative

The ballot title is "An Act to Prohibit Double Taxation". Specific provisions include:

Estimated fiscal impact

The state's Financial Estimate Committee prepares estimated fiscal impact statements for any ballot measures that will appear on the ballot. The estimate prepared by this committee for Measure 58 says:

Other fiscal estimates

The Oregon Center for Public Policy (OCPP) issued a separate financial impact study. Features of their report:

Proponents

Bill Sizemore, Timothy R. Trickey and R. Russell Walker are the measure's chief petitioners.[3]

The committee that put Measure 59 on the ballot was called "Stop the Double Tax".[4] There is no committee currently supporting the ballot measure.

Arguments Supporting Measure 59

Donors supporting Measure 59

The Oregonian reported in September 2007 that Nevada millionaire Loren Parks was the leading contributor to the effort to put Measure 59 and other measures on the ballot.[5] According to the newspaper, Parks gave money directly to the signature gathering firm, rather than to Sizemore directly. A court injunction stemming from a 2000 fraud case prevents Sizemore from spending money directly on politics, although he told Oregon Public Broadcasting in May 2008 that he "found a way to put the measures on the ballot and give voters those choices without me actually handling the money. And so I’m still able to put measures on the ballot, I just have to do it in a sort of round-about way."[6]

Opponents

Measure 59 is opposed by the Defend Oregon, which includes the American Heart Association, 1000 Friends of Oregon, AARP Oregon, Children First for Oregon, and others.

Arguments against Measure 59

Notable arguments that have been made against Measure 59 include:

Donors opposing Measure 59

Defend Oregon, as a committee, is fighting seven different ballot measures, and supporting two others. As a result, it is not possible to discern how much of its campaign spending is going specifically to defeat Measure 58. Altogether, the group has raised $9 million in 2008.[9]

Major donations to the Defend Oregon group as of October 23 include:[10]

Petition drive history

The office of the Oregon Secretary of State announced on June 16, 2008 that its unofficial signature verification process showed that the initiative's supporters had turned in 83,136 valid signatures, versus a requirement of 82,769 signatures. This represented a validity rate of 64.76% calculated over the 128,380 signatures turned in. The measure formally qualified for the ballot on August 2.,[14][15]

A union-funded watchdog group asked the Oregon Secretary of State to conduct an investigation into how some of the signatures on the measure were collected. Bill Bradbury, the Secretary of State has said, ""...most all of the initiatives Oregon voters will decide this fall got there through practices that are now illegal. But those practices were legal at the time most of the signatures were submitted." The state's Election Division is investigating the charges.[16][17][18]

Further reading

Notes

External links

Note:: This article was taken from Ballotpedia's article about Oregon Ballot Measure 59

Basic information

Supporters

Opponents

This article is issued from Wikipedia - version of the Saturday, April 30, 2016. The text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution/Share Alike but additional terms may apply for the media files.