Robert Cowley (judge)

Robert Cowley, or Colley (c. 1470-1546) was an English-born judge in sixteenth-century Ireland who held the office of Master of the Rolls in Ireland. He is now chiefly remembered as a possible ancestor of the 1st Duke of Wellington.

Early life

Despite his family's later eminence, Robert's background and early life are poorly recorded. He is generally thought to have been the brother or the son of Walter Colley of Glaston in Rutland; the Colley family is recorded there from about 1400. Robert is said to have seen military service with Garret Mor, the "Great" Earl of Kildare, but the first definite trace of him is when he entered Lincoln's Inn in 1502.^[1] He then decided on a business career, and moved to Dublin where he became a successful merchant. He was made Bailiff of Dublin in 1515.^[2]

Political and judicial career

From about 1520 Cowley played an increasing role in Irish politics. He was in the retinue of the Earl of Surrey when he was appointed Lord Lieutenant of Ireland. In 1522 when Piers Butler, 8th Earl of Ormond replaced Surrey as Lieutenant, Cowley became his legal adviser and Clerk to the Council in 1525; thereafter the Cowley family were regarded as strong Ormond partisans.^[3] Robert also sought to gain influence by becoming a regular correspondent of Cardinal Wolsey and later of Thomas Cromwell. James Bathe, later Chief Baron of the Irish Exchequer and a trusted Crown servant for thirty years, faced Cowley's hostility from early in his career.^[4] In 1525 Bathe, then a very young lawyer, presented the English Government with a book setting out his proposals for reform of the Irish administration: Cowley ridiculed it, writing to Wolsey that Bathe knew as much about the government of Ireland as Cowley did about that of Italy.^[5]

Feud with Patrick Barnewall

In the 1530s Robert and his son Walter Cowley engaged in a power struggle with Patrick Barnewall, the Irish Solicitor General, who also had considerable influence with Cromwell. The Cowleys, who had the reputation for being entirely unscrupulous in advancing their careers, kept up a flow of letters to Cromwell attempting to undermine Barnewall,^[6] alleging in particular that he had challenged the Royal authority in religious matters, a very serious charge in the political climate of the time. For a time it seemed the Cowleys would oust Barnewall: Cowley obtained the offices of Clerk of the Crown and Receiver of Customs of the port of Dublin, and Cromwell praised him as a man of long established fidelity and truth, an opinion with which few others, then or since, have ever agreed.^[7] Barnewall at one point offered to surrender the office of Solicitor General for Ireland to Walter Cowley. In the event Cromwell seems to have made peace between the rivals: Barnewall remained Solicitor General and a new post of Principal Solicitor for Ireland was created for Walter. Robert became Master of the Rolls in 1539. He served on the commission for suppression of the religious houses and received as his reward the priory of Holmpatrick, near Dublin.

Last years

Cowley's influence declined after the downfall and death of Cromwell in 1540: Henry VIII distrusted him, and like many leading political figures of the Pale he quarreled with Sir Anthony St. Leger, the Lord Deputy of Ireland. His efforts to block the rise to power of Chief Baron Bathe were entirely unsuccessful, even though he pointed out, with some justice, that many of Bathe's friends and relatives had been deeply involved in the Rebellion of Silken Thomas. In 1541 Cowley unwisely went to London without official leave: he was promptly denounced for sedition, imprisoned in the Fleet Prison and deprived of office. He was released from the Fleet in 1543 and died in England three years later.^[8] His son Walter was also deprived of office and imprisoned in the Tower of London - several letters from him to the King pleading for clemency still exist.^[9]

Character

Cowley was a gifted man who rose from obscurity to found one of the great Anglo-Irish families; but as a man he was not highly regarded by his contemporaries, or by later historians. His letters to Cromwell, particularly those which detail his efforts to destroy Patrick Barnewall, show him in an unattractive light, and historians have described both Robert and Walter as "ambitious mischief-makers".^[10]

Descendants

Although Walter Cowley, Principal Solicitor for Ireland, is recorded as Robert's brother, there is some evidence that he was Robert's son. Records show that two brothers Walter and Robert Colley originated from Glaston in Rutland, England, and that Walter's son was the distinguished soldier Sir Henry Colley of Carbury Castle. Henry was an ancestor of Richard Colley, who adopted the surname Wesley, was created Baron Mornington and was grandfather of the 1st Duke of Wellington.

References

1. Kenny, Colum The Kings Inns and the Kingdom of Ireland Irish Academic Press Dublin, 1992 p.19
2. Ball F. Elrington The Judges in Ireland 1221-1921 John Murray London 1926 Vol.1 p.203
3. Ball p.203
4. Ó Mathúna, Sean P. William Bathe 1564-1614- a Pioneer in Linguistics John Benjamins 1986 p.9
5. Ó Mathúna p.9
6. Hart, A.C., The History of the King's Serjeants-at-Law in Ireland Four Court Press Dublin 2000 p.34
7. Ball, p.203
8. Ball p. 203
9. State Papers for the Reign of Henry VIII Vol. III published 1834
10. Hart p.30