MAGIC criteria

The MAGIC criteria are a set of guidelines put forth by Robert Abelson in his book Statistics as Principled Argument. In this book he posits that the goal of statistical analysis should be to make compelling claims about the world ^[1] and he presents the MAGIC criteria as a way to do that.

What are the MAGIC criteria?

MAGIC is an acronym for:

Magnitude - How big is the effect? Large effects are more compelling than small ones.
Articulation - How specific is it? ^[2] Precise statements are more compelling than imprecise ones.
Generality - How generally does it apply? ^[1] More general effects are more compelling than less general ones. Claims that would interest a more general audience are more compelling. ^[2]
Interestingness - interesting effects are those that "have the potential, through empirical analysis, to change what people believe about an important issue". ^[1] More interesting effects are more compelling than less interesting ones. In addition, more surprising effects are more compelling than ones that merely confirm what is already known. ^[2]
Credibility - Credible claims are more compelling than incredible ones. The researcher must show that the claims made are credible. ^[1] Results that contradict previously established ones are less credible ^[2]

Reviews and applications of the MAGIC criteria

Song Qian noted that the MAGIC criteria could be of use to ecologists. ^[3] Claudia Stanny discussed them in a course on psychology ^[4] Anne Boomsma noted that they are useful when presenting results of complex statistical methods such as structural equation modelling ^[5] WorldCat called the book "illuminating" ^[6]

References

1 2 3 4 "The MAGIC Criteria". jsvine.com.
1 2 3 4 http://www.cs.sfu.ca/CourseCentral/376/ted/376-08-1/MAGIC-criteria.pdf
↑ Qian, Song (2014). "Statistics in ecology is for making a "principled argument"". Landscape Ecology 29: 42. doi:10.1007/s10980-014-0042-y.
↑ http://uwf.edu/cstanny/website/ResearchDsgn/statistical%20claims%20abelson%201&2%20-%203%20slides.pdf
↑ Boomsma, Anne (2000). "Reporting Analysis of Covariance Studies". Structural Equation Modeling 7: 461–483.
↑ "Statistics As Principled Argument". worldcat.org.

Statistics

Descriptive statistics

Continuous data

Location	Mean arithmetic geometric harmonic Median Mode

Dispersion	Range Standard deviation Coefficient of variation Percentile Interquartile range

Shape	Variance Skewness Kurtosis Moments L-moments

Count data

Index of dispersion

Summary tables

Dependence

Statistical graphics

Data collection

Study design	Effect size Standard error Statistical power Sample size determination

Survey methodology	Sampling stratified cluster Opinion poll Questionnaire

Controlled experiments	Design control optimal Controlled trial Randomized Random assignment Replication Blocking Factorial experiment

Uncontrolled studies	Observational study Natural experiment Quasi-experiment

Statistical inference

Statistical theory

Frequentist inference

Confidence interval Testing hypotheses Power

Unbiased estimators	Mean unbiased minimum-variance Median unbiased

Biased estimators	Maximum likelihood Method of moments Minimum distance Density estimation

Parametric tests	Likelihood-ratio Wald Score

Specific tests

Z (normal) Student's t-test F Shapiro–Wilk Kolmogorov–Smirnov

Goodness of fit	Chi-squared G Sample source (Anderson–Darling) Sample normality (Shapiro–Wilk) Skewness / kurtosis normality (Jarque-Bera) Model comparison (Likelihood-ratio) Model quality (Akaike criterion)

Signed-rank	1-sample (Wilcoxon) 2-sample (Mann–Whitney U) 1-way anova (Kruskal–Wallis)

Bayesian inference

Correlation	Pearson product–moment Partial correlation Confounding variable Coefficient of determination

Regression analysis	Errors and residuals Regression model validation Mixed effects models Simultaneous equations models Multivariate adaptive regression splines (MARS)

Linear regression	Simple linear regression Ordinary least squares General linear model Bayesian regression

Non-standard predictors	Nonlinear regression Nonparametric Semiparametric Isotonic Robust Heteroscedasticity Homoscedasticity

Generalized linear model	Exponential families Logistic (Bernoulli) / Binomial / Poisson regressions

Partition of variance	Analysis of variance (ANOVA, anova) Analysis of covariance Multivariate ANOVA Degrees of freedom

Categorical / Multivariate / Time-series / Survival analysis

Categorical

Multivariate

Time-series

General	Decomposition Trend Stationarity Seasonal adjustment Exponential smoothing Cointegration Structural break Granger causality

Specific tests	Dickey–Fuller Johansen Q-statistic (Ljung–Box) Durbin–Watson Breusch–Godfrey

Time domain	Autocorrelation (ACF) partial (PACF) Cross-correlation (XCF) ARMA model ARIMA model (Box–Jenkins) Autoregressive conditional heteroskedasticity (ARCH) Vector autoregression (VAR)

Frequency domain	Spectral density estimation Fourier analysis Wavelet

Survival

Survival function	Kaplan–Meier estimator (product limit) Proportional hazards models Accelerated failure time (AFT) model First hitting time

Hazard function	Nelson–Aalen estimator

Test	Log-rank test

Applications

Biostatistics	Bioinformatics Clinical trials / studies Epidemiology Medical statistics

Engineering statistics	Chemometrics Methods engineering Probabilistic design Process / quality control Reliability System identification

Social statistics	Actuarial science Census Crime statistics Demography Econometrics National accounts Official statistics Population Psychometrics

Spatial statistics	Cartography Environmental statistics Geographic information system Geostatistics Kriging

Category
Portal
Commons
WikiProject

This article is issued from Wikipedia - version of the Sunday, November 29, 2015. The text is available under the Creative Commons Attribution/Share Alike but additional terms may apply for the media files.