John 2

John 2
← chapter 1 chapter 3 →
John 2:11-22 on Uncial 0162 (P.Oxy. 847), ca. 300.
Book	Gospel of John
Bible part	New Testament
Order in the Bible part	4
Category	Gospel

John 2 is the second chapter of the Gospel of John in the New Testament of the Christian Bible. It contains the famous stories of the miracle of Jesus turning water into wine and Jesus expelling the money changers from the Temple.

Context

The events recorded in chapter one of John's Gospel take place in Bethabara (or Bethany), but in John 1:43 it is reported that "Jesus wanted to go to Galilee". Chapter two opens with Jesus, his mother and his disciples present in Galilee, in the village of Cana. Four "days" have been mentioned in John 1;^[1] John 2 opens on the "third day".^[2] The second/third century theologian Origen suggested this was the third day from the last-named day in John 1:44 ^[3] and the Jamieson-Fausset-Brown Bible Commentary argues that it would take Jesus three days to travel from Bethabara in Perea to Cana in Galilee ^[4][5] whereas the 19th century theologian Heinrich Ewald suggested the third day would be reckoned from Jesus' arrival in Cana.^[6]

Water into Wine

Marriage at Cana

The second chapter of John begins at a wedding celebration in Cana attended by the mother of Jesus (she is not named in John's Gospel), Jesus himself and his disciples. The hosts run out of wine and Jesus' mother asks him to help. Jesus replies "What [is that] to me and to you?" (Greek: τι εμοι και σοι). Some interpretations suggest that Jesus is annoyed that she would ask him for a miracle, and he replies that it is not his "time" yet. The Holman Christian Standard Bible presents two interpretations, either "“What has this concern of yours to do with Me?" or "You and I see things differently" ^[7] whereas in the Weymouth New Testament, Jesus' words are "Leave the matter in my hands".^[8] The Orthodox Jewish Bible highlights a connection with the narrative of the fall in Genesis 3:15: [God] "will put enmity between you (Adam) and the woman, and between your offspring and her offspring".

Nevertheless, Jesus' mother still tells the servants to do whatever he asks, so he tells them to fill up the empty wine containers with water. Afterwards, the head waiter of the wedding tastes it and remarks to the groom that they have saved the best wine for last. John tells his audience that the water was there for the Jewish rite of purification.

According to John, this was his first sign or miracle (in Cana). It occurs immediately after Jesus has told Nathanael in chapter 1:50 that "You shall see greater things than that." According to the hypothesis of the Signs Gospel, this miracle was originally in that document. John uses the Greek word semeion meaning sign, or ergon meaning work, instead of the term the synoptics use, dynamis or act of power, for miracle.^[9]

This miracle only occurs in John's Gospel, not in any of the synoptics. The story can be understood as John's fulfillments of prophecies in the Old Testament, such as in Amos 9:13-14 and Genesis 49:10-11 about the abundance of wine that there will be in the time of the messiah (Brown 340). Messianic wedding festivals are mentioned in Isaiah 62:4-5.^[10] One can also perhaps see this in the synoptics in for instance Mark 2:21-22 where Jesus speaks about "new wineskins". Jesus' mother, not named in the gospel, appears again in John 19:25-27 at Jesus' crucifixion. This begins a series of stories about Jesus's role as the new way that last until his second miracle or sign, the healing of the official's son in John 4.

Interlude

John 2:12 then says that Jesus went with his mother and brothers and disciples to Capernaum for a "not many days", but does not relate what went on there. Cana is about 25 miles from Capernaum using modern roads. ^[11] The synoptic gospels make no mention of Jesus attending the wedding before going to Capernaum, nor that his mother or brothers went there with him. Luke 4 and Matthew 4 report Jesus going to Nazareth and then Capernaum after Jesus's baptism and temptation. Mark 1 has him going to Galilee from the wilderness (where he had been tempted by Satan) ^[12] and visiting several places in Galilee before reaching Capernaum (Mark 1:25, 31, 34). After the authority and power of Jesus had been demonstrated, He and His disciples went throughout Galilee preaching and casting out demons (Mark 1:38-39). Mark later records that they return to Capernaum, after going throughout the neighboring lands.

Jesus cleanses the Temple

Jesus vertreibt die Händler aus dem Tempel by Giovanni Paolo Pannini

Christ drives the Usurers out of the Temple, a woodcut by Lucas Cranach the Elder in Passionary of Christ and Antichrist.^[13]

The story of Jesus overturning the tables of the money changers in the Temple is related next. Jesus and his disciples go to Jerusalem for the Passover, the first of three visits to Jerusalem recounted in this gospel, the others being John 7, where he goes for the Feast of Tabernacles, and the final Passover during which he is crucified. He enters the Temple courts and sees people selling livestock and exchanging money. He explodes:

So he made a whip out of cords, and drove all from the temple area, both sheep and cattle; he scattered the coins of the money changers and overturned their tables. To those who sold doves he said, "Get these out of here! How dare you turn my Father's house into a market! (15-16)

"It is worth remembering that on the eve of the Passover the head of every family carefully collected all the leaven in the house, and there was a general cleansing. Jesus was doing in His Father’s house, it may be, what was then being done in every house in Jerusalem".^[14]

John says that Jesus' disciples remembered the words of Psalm 69:9, "zeal for your house will consume me", perhaps a bit of wordplay interposing the ideas of "'demanding all my attention' and 'leading to my destruction'".^[15] Whether the disciples remembered this during the incident or afterward is not clear: theologian Hermann Olshausen suggested that the recollection took place afterwards, but Heinrich Meyer disagreed: this saying was remembered "at the very time of the occurrence", in contrast to their recollection about Jesus' foretelling of his resurrection (John 2:22), which happened afterwards.^[16]

Jesus is asked for "a sign" to prove that he has authority to expel the money changers. He replies "Destroy this temple, and I will raise it again in three days". The people believe he is talking about the official Temple building, but John states that Jesus meant his body, and that this is what his disciples came to believe after his resurrection. John then says that during the Passover Feast Jesus performed miraculous signs, but does not list them, that caused people to believe in him, but that he would "not entrust himself to them, for he knew all men". Perhaps John included this statement to show Jesus possesses a knowledge of people's hearts and minds, an attribute of God.^[17]

This introduces the antagonism between Jesus and "the Jews", as John calls them, a sign perhaps of a non-Jewish audience. This is over the nature of the Temple. The Temple is already destroyed by the time of the writing of John, and John is trying to show right from the start that the old Temple has been replaced by the new Temple, Jesus' resurrected body and the new Christian and Johannine community. This shows to most scholars the split between John's community and Judaism in general. Some of the Dead Sea scrolls also speak of the community as the temple.^[10]

John mentions the incident with the money changers as occurring at the start of Jesus's ministry, while the synoptic gospels have it occurring shortly before his crucifixion. Some scholars suggest that this shows that Jesus fought with the money changers twice, once at the beginning and once at the end of his ministry. The incident in the synoptics occurs in Mark 11:12-19, Matthew 21:12-17, and Luke 19:45-48. Perhaps John has relocated the story to the beginning to show that Jesus' arrest was for the raising of Lazarus in John 11, not the incident in the Temple.^[10]

The discerner of hearts

The chapter ends with a brief section which the New King James Version sub-titles "The Discerner of Hearts" (verses 23 to 25). Whilst Jesus stayed in Jerusalem for the Passover feast, he performed various unrecorded ^[18] signs, and many "believed in His name". This theme is continued into chapter 3, where the Pharisee Nicodemus acknowledges that "no one can do these signs that You do unless God is with him" (John 3:2).

Notes

1. Bengel's Gnomon of the New Testament on John 1, accessed 31 January 2016
2. John 2:1
3. Referred to in Meyer's New Testament Commentary on John 2, accessed 4 February 2016
4. Jamieson-Fausset-Brown Bible Commentary on John 2, accessed 4 February 2016
5. This journey would be 86 miles on modern roads using Highway 90 - source: Google Maps, accessed 4 February 2016
6. Meyer's New Testament Commentary on John 2, accessed 4 February 2016
7. 2:3-5&version=HCSB Holman Christian Standard Bible at John 2:4
8. John 2:4 in the Weymouth New Testament
9. Brown, page 339
10. Brown et al. page 954
11. Highway 77 and Highway 90 - source: Google Maps, accessed 6 February 2016
12. Mark 1:14
13. The references cited in the Passionary for this woodcut: 1 John 2:14-16, Matthew 10:8, and The Apology of the Augsburg Confession, Article 8, Of the Church
14. Charles Ellicott, Ellicott's Commentary for English Readers on John 2, accessed 8 February 2016
15. Miller, page 204
16. Meyer's NT Commentary on John 2, accessed 8 February 2016
17. Brown et al. page 955
18. "Of these we have no record: Jamieson-Fausset-Brown Bible Commentary on John 2:23, accessed 9 February 2016

References

• Brown, Raymond E. (1997). An Introduction to the New Testament. Doubleday. ISBN 0-385-24767-2.
• Brown, Raymond E.; et al. (1990). The New Jerome Biblical Commentary. Prentice Hall. ISBN 0-13-614934-0.
• "John 2". NIV at biblegateway.com. Retrieved September 5, 2005.
• "John 2". KJV at etext.lib.virginia.edu. Retrieved September 5, 2005.
• Miller, Robert J. (1994). The Complete Gospels. Polebridge Press. ISBN 0-06-065587-9.