List of examples of convergent evolution

Convergent evolution — the repeated evolution of similar traits in multiple lineages which all ancestrally lack the trait — is rife in nature, as illustrated by the examples below. The ultimate cause of convergence is usually a similar evolutionary biome, as similar environments will select for similar traits in any species occupying the same ecological niche, even if those species are only distantly related. In the case of cryptic species, it can create species which are only distinguishable by analysing their genetics. Unrelated organisms often develop analogous structures by adapting to similar environments.

In Animals

The skulls of the thylacine (left) and the grey wolf, Canis lupus, are similar, although the species are only very distantly related (different infraclasses). The skull shape of the red fox, Vulpes vulpes, is even closer to that of the thylacine.^[1]

Mammals

• Dugongs and whales have very similar-looking tail flukes.
• Several groups of ungulates have independently reduced or lost side digits on their feet, often leaving one or two digits for walking. That name comes from their hooves, which have evolved from claws several times. Among familiar animals, horses have one walking digit and domestic bovines two on each foot. Various other land vertebrates have also reduced or lost digits.^[2]
• The pronghorn of North America, while not a true antelope and only distantly related to them, closely resembles the true antelopes of the Old World, both behaviorally and morphologically. It also fills a similar ecological niche and is found in the same biomes.^[3]
• Members of the two clades Australosphenida and Theria evolved tribosphenic molars independently.^[4]
• The marsupial thylacine (Tasmanian tiger) had many resemblances to the placental canids.^[5]
• Several mammal groups have independently evolved prickly protrusions of the skin – echidnas (monotremes), the insectivorous hedgehogs, some tenrecs (a diverse group of shrew-like Madagascan mammals), Old World porcupines (rodents) and New World porcupines (another biological family of rodents). In this case, because the two groups of porcupines are closely related, they would be considered to be examples of parallel evolution; however, neither echidnas, nor hedgehogs, nor tenrecs are close relatives of the Rodentia. In fact, the last common ancestor of all of these groups was a contemporary of the dinosaurs.^[6]
• Cat-like sabre-toothed predators evolved in three distinct lineages of mammals – sabre-toothed cats, nimravids ("false" sabre-tooths), and the marsupial "lion" Thylacosmilus. Gorgonopsids and creodonts also developed long canine teeth, but with no other particular physical similarities.^[7]
• A number of mammals have developed powerful fore claws and long, sticky tongues that allow them to open the homes of social insects (e.g., ants and termites) and consume them (myrmecophagy). These include the four species of anteater, more than a dozen armadillos, eight species of pangolin (plus fossil species), the African aardvark, one echidna (an egg-laying monotreme), the enigmatic Fruitafossor, the singular Australian marsupial known as the numbat, the aberrant aardwolf, and possibly also the sloth bear of South Asia, all not related.^[8]
• Koalas of Australasia have evolved fingerprints, indistinguishable from those of humans.^[9]
• The Australian honey possums acquired a long tongue for taking nectar from flowers, a structure similar to that of butterflies, some moths, and hummingbirds, and used to accomplish the very same task.^[10]
• Marsupial sugar glider and squirrel glider of Australia are like the placental flying squirrel. Both lineages have independently developed wing-like flaps (patagia) for leaping from trees, and big eyes for foraging at night.^[11]
• The North American kangaroo rat, Australian hopping mouse, and North African and Asian jerboa have developed convergent adaptations for hot desert environments; these include a small rounded body shape with very large hind legs and long thin tails, a characteristic bipedal hop, and nocturnal, burrowing and seed-eating behaviours. These rodent groups fill similar niches in their respective ecosystems.^[12]
• Opossums have evolved an opposable thumb, a feature which is also commonly found in the non-related primates.^[13]
• Marsupial mole has many resemblances to the placental mole.^[14]
• Marsupial mulgara has many resemblances to the placental mouse.^[15]
• Planigale has many resemblances to the deer mouse.^[16]
• Marsupial Tasmanian devil has many resemblances to the placental hyena. Similar skull morphology, large canines and crushing carnasial molars.^[17]
• Kangaroo and Wallaby (marsupials) have many resemblances to the Patagonian cavy (a large rodent) and hares (a Lagomorpha).^[18]
• The marsupial lion had retractable claws, the same way the placental felines (cats) do today.^[19]
• Microbats, toothed whales and shrews developed sonar-like echolocation systems used for orientation, obstacle avoidance and for locating prey. Modern DNA phylogenies of bats have shown that the traditional suborder of echolocating bats (Microchiroptera) is not a true clade, and instead some echolocating bats are more related to non-echolocating Old World fruit bats than to other echolocating species. The implication is that echolocation in at least two lineages of bats, Megachiroptera and Microchiroptera has evolved independently or been lost in Old World fruit bats.^[20][21]
• Echolocation in bats and whales also both necessitate high frequency hearing. The protein prestin, which confers high hearing sensitivity in mammals, shows molecular convergence between the two main clades of echolocating bats, and also between bats and dolphins.^[22][23] Other hearing genes also show convergence between echolocating taxa.^[24] Recently the first genome-wide study of convergence was published, this study analysed 22 mammal genomes and revealed that tens of genes have undergone the same replacements in echolocating bats and ceteaceans, with many of these genes encoding proteins that function in hearing and vision.^[25]
• Both the aye-aye lemur and the striped possum have an elongated finger used to get invertebrates from trees. There are no woodpeckers in Madagascar or Australia where the species evolved, so the supply of invertebrates in trees was large.^[26]
• Castorocauda (Jurassic period mammal) and beaver both have webbed feet and a flattened tail, but are not related.^[27]
• Prehensile tails came in to a number of unrelated species New World monkeys, kinkajous, porcupines, tree-anteaters, marsupial opossums, and the salamander Bolitoglossa pangolins, treerats, skinks and chameleons.^[28]
• Pig form, large-headed, pig-snouted and hoofs are independent in true pigs in Eurasia, peccary and the extinct entelodonts.^[29]
• Tapirs and pigs look much alike, but tapirs are perissodactyls (odd-toed ungulates) and pigs are artiodactyls (even-toed ungulates).^[30]
• Filter feeding: baleen whales like the humpback and blue whale (mammals), the whale shark and the basking shark separately, the manta ray, the Mesozoic bony fish Leedsichthys, and the early Paleozoic anomalocaridid Aegirocassis have separately evolved ways of sifting plankton from marine waters.^[31]
• Platypus have what looks like a bird's beak (hence its scientific name Ornithorhynchus), but is a mammal.^[32] It was thought that somebody had sewn a duck's beak onto the body of a beaver-like animal. Shaw even took a pair of scissors to the dried skin to check for stitches.^[33]
• Red blood cells in mammals lack a cell nucleus. In comparison, the red blood cells of other vertebrates have nuclei; the only known exceptions are salamanders of the Batrachoseps genus and fish of the Maurolicus genus.^[34]
• Caniforms like skunks and raccoons in North and South America and Feliforms such as mongoose and civets in Asia and Africa have both evolved to fill the nich of small to medium omnivore/insectivore on their side of the world. Some species of mongoose and civet can even spray their attacker with musk similar to the skunk and some civets have also independently evolved similar markings to the raccoon such as the African civet.^[35]
• River Dolphins of the three species that live exclusively in freshwater, live in different rivers: Ganges and Brahmaputra Rivers of India, the Yangtze River of China, and the Amazon River. Mitochondrial and nuclear DNA sequence analysis demonstrates the three are not related.^[36]
• Mangabey have three different genera of Old World monkeys. The Lophocebus and Cercocebus were once thought to be very closely related, so much so that all the species were in one genus. However, it is now known that the species within genus Lophocebus are more closely related to the baboons. While the species within genus Cercocebus are more closely related to the Mandrill, yet both are alike.^[37]
• Sperm whale and the microscopic copepods both use the same buoyancy control system.^[38]
• Wombat is a marsupial has many resemblances to the Groundhog a placental^[39]
• Fossa looks like a large cat. Fossa have semiretractable claws. Fossa also has flexible ankles that allow it to climb up and down trees head-first, and also support jumping from tree to tree. Its classification has been controversial because its physical traits resemble those of cats, but is more closely related to the mongoose family, (Herpestidae).^[40][41]

Prehistoric reptiles

• Pterosaurian pycnofibrils strongly resemble mammalian hair, but are thought to have evolved independently.^[42]
• Ornithischian (bird-hipped) dinosaurs had a pelvis shape similar to that of birds, or avian dinosaurs, which evolved from saurischian (lizard-hipped) dinosaurs.^[43]
• The Heterodontosauridae evolved a tibiotarsus which is also found in modern birds. These groups aren't closely related.^[44]
• Ankylosaurs and glyptodont mammals both had spiked tails.^[45]
• The sauropods and giraffes independently evolved long necks.^[46]
• The horned snouts of ceratopsian dinosaurs like Triceratops have also evolved several times in Cenozoic mammals: rhinos, brontotheres, Arsinoitherium, and Uintatherium.^[47]
• Billed snouts on the duck-billed dinosaurs hadrosaurs strikingly convergent with ducks and duck-billed platypus.^[48]
• Ichthyosaurs a marine reptile of the Mesozoic era looked strikingly like dolphins.^[49]
• Beaks are independent in ceratopsian dinosaurs like Triceratops, birds, turtles, and cephalopods like squid and octopus.^[50]
• The Pelycosauria and the Ctenosauriscidae bore striking resemblance to each other because they both had a sail-like fin on their back. The pelycosaurs are more closely related to mammals while the ctenosauriscids are closely related to pterosaurs and dinosaurs. Also, the spinosaurids had sail-like fins on their backs, when they were not closely related to either.^[51][52]
  • Also, Acrocanthosaurus and Ouranosaurus, which are not closely related to either pelycosaurs, ctenosauriscids or spinosaurids, also had similar, but thicker, spines on their vertebrae, and thus have humps, like the unrelated, mammalian camels and bison.^[53]
• Noasaurus, Baryonyx, and Megaraptor, all unrelated, all had an enlarged hand claw that were originally thought to be placed on the foot, as in dromaeosaurs. A similarly modified claw (or in this case, finger) is on the hand of Iguanodon.^[54]
• The Ornithopods had feet and beaks that resembled that of birds, but are only distantly related.^[55]
• Three groups of dinosaurs, the Tyrannosauridae, Ornithomimosauria, and the Troodontidae, all evolved an arctometatarsus, independently.^[56]
• Some Placodonts (like Cyamodus, Psephoderma, Henodus and especially Placochelys) bear striking resemblance to sea turtles (and turtles in general) in terms of size, shell, beak, mostly toothless jaws, paddle-shaped limbs and possibly other adaptations for aquatic lifestyle.^[57]

• 

  Henodus chelyops (Late Triassic), a placodont

• 

  Proganochelys quenstedti (Late Triassic), a turtle

Extant reptiles

• The thorny devil (Moloch horridus) is similar in diet and activity patterns to the Texas horned lizard (Phrynosoma cornutum), although the two are not particularly closely related.^[58]
• Modern crocodilians resemble prehistoric phytosaurs, champsosaurs, certain labyrinthodont amphibians, and perhaps even the early whale Ambulocetus. The resemblance between the crocodilians and phytosaurs in particular is quite striking; even to the point of having evolved the graduation between narrow- and broad-snouted forms, due to differences in diet between particular species in both groups.^[59]
• The body shape of the prehistoric fish-like reptile Ophthalmosaurus is similar to those of other ichthyosaurians, dolphins (aquatic mammals), and tuna (scombrid fish).^[60]
• Death adders strongly resemble true vipers, but are elapids.^[61]
• The glass snake is actually a lizard but is mistaken as a snake .^[62]
• Large tegu lizards of South America have converged in form and ecology with monitor lizards, which are not present in the Americas.^[63]
• Legless lizards such as Pygopodidae are snake-like lizards that are much like true snakes.^[64]
• Anolis lizards, with populations on isolated islands, are one of the best examples of both adaptive radiation and convergent evolution.^[65]
• Tuataras resemble lizards but in fact are in an order of their own, the Rhynchocephalia. The tuatara has the sockets behind the eyes and has jagged extensions of the jaws instead of teeth.^[66]
• Asian sea snake, Enhydrina schistosa (beaked sea snake) look just like the Australian sea snake Enhydrina zweifeli, but in fact are not related.^[67]
• Emerald tree boa and the green tree python are two different species from two different genera, yet are very much alike.^[39]

Avian

• The little auk of the north Atlantic (Charadriiformes) and the diving-petrels of the southern oceans (Procellariiformes) are remarkably similar in appearance and habits.^[68]
• The Eurasian magpie is a corvid, the Australian magpie is not.^[69]
• Penguins in the Southern Hemisphere evolved similarly to flightless wing-propelled diving auks in the Northern Hemisphere: the Atlantic great auk and the Pacific mancallines.^[70]
• Vultures are a result of convergent evolution: both Old World vultures and New World vultures eat carrion, but Old World vultures are in the eagle and hawk family (Accipitridae) and use mainly eyesight for discovering food; the New World vultures are of obscure ancestry, and some use the sense of smell as well as sight in hunting. Birds of both families are very big, search for food by soaring, circle over sighted carrion, flock in trees, and have unfeathered heads and necks.^[71]

• 

  Nubian vulture, an Old World vulture

• 

  Turkey vulture, a New World vulture

• 

  Hummingbird, a New World bird, with a sunbird, an Old World bird

• Hummingbirds resemble sunbirds. The former live in the Americas and belong to an order or superorder including the swifts, while the latter live in Africa and Asia and are a family in the order Passeriformes.^[72]
• In an odd cross-phyla example, an insect, the hummingbird hawk-moth (Macroglossum stellatarum), also feeds by hovering in front of flowers and drinking their nectar in the same way as the above-mentioned birds.^[73]
• Flightlessness has evolved in many different birds independently. However, taking this to a greater extreme, the terror birds, Gastornithiformes and dromornithids (ironically all extinct) all evolved the similar body shape (flightlessness, long legs, long necks, big heads), yet none of them were closely related. They also share the trait of being giant, flightless birds with vestigial wings, long legs, and long necks with the ratites, although they are not related.^[74][75]
• Certain longclaws (Macronyx) and meadowlarks (Sturnella) have essentially the same striking plumage pattern. The former inhabit Africa and the latter the Americas, and they belong to different lineages of Passerida. While they are ecologically quite similar, no satisfying explanation exists for the convergent plumage; it is best explained by sheer chance.^[76]
• Resemblances between swifts and swallows is due to convergent evolution. The chimney swift was originally identified as chimney swallow (Hirundo pelagica) by Carl Linnaeus in 1758, before being moved to the swift genus Chaetura by James Francis Stephens in 1825.^[77]
• Downy woodpecker and hairy woodpecker look almost the same, as do some 'Chrysocolaptes and Dinopium flamebacks, the smoky-brown woodpecker and some Veniliornis species, and other Veniliornis species and certain "Picoides" and Piculus. In neither case are the similar species particularly close relatives.^[78]
• Many birds of Australia, like wrens and robins, look like northern hemisphere birds but are not related.^[79]
• Oilbird like microbats and toothed whales developed sonar-like echolocation systems used for locating prey.^[80]
• The brain structure, forebrain, of hummingbirds, songbirds, and parrots responsible for vocal learning (not by instinct) is very similar. These types of birds are not closely related.^[81]
• Seriemas and Secretary Birds very closely resemble the ancient dromaeosaurid and troodontid dinosaurs. Both have evolved a retractable sickle-shaped claw on the second toe of each foot, both have feathers, and both are very similar in their overall physical appearance and lifestyle.^[82]
• Migrating birds like, Swainson's thrushes can have half the brain sleep with the other half awake. Dolphins, whales, Amazonian manatee and pinnipeds can do the same. Giving them the advantage of 24 alertness. Called Unihemispheric slow-wave sleep.^[83]

Fish

• Fish that swim by using an elongated fin along the dorsum, ventrum, or in pairs on their lateral margins (such as Oarfish, Knifefish, Cephalopods) have all come to the same ratio of amplitude to wavelength of fin undulation to maximize speed, 20:1.^[84]
• Mudskippers exhibit a number of adaptations to semi-terrestrial lifestyle which are also usually attributed to Tiktaalik: breathing surface air, having eyes positioned on top of the head, propping up and moving on land using strong fins.^[85]

• 

  Tiktaalik roseae - artistic interpretation. Neil Shubin, suggests the animal could prop up on its fins to venture onto land, though many palaeonthologists reject this idea as outdated

• 

  Boleophthalmus boddarti - a mudskipper which is believed to share some features with extinct fishapods in terms of adaptations to terrestrial habitats

• 

  A group of mudskippers coming ashore - they use pectoral fins to prop up and move on land. Some scientists believe Tiktaalik to have acted likewise

• Goby dorsal finned like the lumpsuckers, yet they are not related.
• The Rhenanids became extinct over 200 million years before the first stingrays evolved, yet they share quite a similar appearance.
• Sandlance fish and chameleons have independent eye movements and focusing by use of the cornea.^[86]
• Acanthurids and mbuna are both aggressive, brightly colored fish that feed principally on aufwuchs, although the former is found only in marine environments, while the latter is only found in freshwater Lake Malawi.
• Cichlids of South America and the "sunfish" of North America are strikingly similar in morphology, ecology and behavior.^[87]
• The peacock bass and largemouth bass are excellent examples. The two fishes are not related, yet are very similar. Peacock bass are native of South America and is a Cichla. While largemouth bass are native to Southern USA states and is a sunfish.^[88] others will surely be described (but see the results based on DNA data^[89]).
• The antifreeze protein of fish in the arctic and Antarctic, came about independently.^[90] AFGPs evolved separately in notothenioids and northern cod. In notothenioids, the AFGP gene arose from an ancestral trypsinogen-like serine protease gene.^[91]
• Electric fish: electric organs and electrosensory systems evolved independently in South American Gymnotiformes and African Mormyridae.^[92]
• Eel form are independent in the North American brook lamprey, neotropical eels, and the African spiny eel.^[93]
• Stickleback fish, there is widespread convergent evolution in sticklebacks.^[94]
• Flying fish can fly up to 400 m (1,300 ft) at speeds of more than 70 kilometres per hour (43 mph) at a maximum altitude of more than 6 m (20 ft), much like other flying birds, bats and other gliders.^[95]
• Extinct fish of the family Thoracopteridae, like Thoracopterus or Potanichthys, were similar to modern flying fish (gliding ability thanks to enlarged pair of pectoral fins and a deeply forked tail fin) which is not, however, considered to be their descendant.^[96]
• The Cleaner Wrasse Labroides dimidiatus of the Indian Ocean is a small, longitudinally-striped black and bright blue cleaner fish, just like the Cleaner Goby Elacatinus evelynae of the Western Atlantic.^[97]
• The fish of the discredited genus Stylophthalmus, which are in fact only distantly related, but their larvae of s Stomiiformes and Myctophiformes have all developed stalked eyes.^[98] (see: Stylophthalmine trait)
• Sawfish, a ray and unrelated Sawshark have sharp transverse teeth for hunting.^[99]

• 

  Cleaner wrasse Labroides dimidiatus servicing a Bigeye squirrelfish

• 

  Caribbean cleaning goby Elacatinus evelynae

Amphibians

• Plethodontid salamanders and chameleons have evolved a harpoon-like tongue to catch insects.^[100]
• The Neotropical poison dart frog and the Mantella of Madagascar have independently developed similar mechanisms for obtaining alkaloids from a diet of mites and storing the toxic chemicals in skin glands. They have also independently evolved similar bright skin colors that warn predators of their toxicity (by the opposite of crypsis, namely aposematism).^[101]
• Caecilians are lissamphibians that secondarily lost their limbs, superficially resembling snakes and Legless lizards.^[102]
• Oldest known tetrapods (semi-aquatic Ichthyostegalia) resembled giant salamanders (body plan, lifestyle), though they are considered to be only distantly related.^[103]
• Lungless salamanders are found in two genus, not related, one set in Lineatriton and one set in Oedipina.^[104]

• 

  Elginerpeton pacheni, the oldest known tetrapod

• 

  Andrias japonicus, a giant salamander which resembles first tetrapods

• Ambystoma mexicanum, an extant species, is difficult to tell apart from Permian Branchiosaurus^[105]

• 

  Branchiosaurus, a Permian genus

• 

  Mexican salamander (axolotl), extant

Arthropods

Pill bugs look like pill millipedes, but are actually wood lice that have converged on the same defenses, until they are difficult to tell apart

• Assassin spiders comprise two lineages that evolved independently. They have very long necks and fangs proportionately larger than those of any other spider, and they hunt other spiders by snagging them from a distance.^[106]
• The smelling organs of the terrestrial coconut crab are similar to those of insects.^[107]
• Pill bugs and pill millipedes have evolved not only identical defenses, but are even difficult tell apart at a glance.^[108] There is also a large ocean version the Giant isopod.^[109][110]
• Silk: Spiders, silk moths, larval caddis flies, and the weaver ant all produce silken threads.^[111]
• The praying mantis body type – raptorial forelimb, prehensile neck, and extraordinary snatching speed - has evolved not only in mantid insects but also independently in neuropteran insects Mantispidae.^[112]
• Gripping limb ends have evolved separately in scorpions and in some decapod crustaceans, like lobsters and crabs. These chelae or claws have a similar architecture: the next-to-last segment grows a projection that fits against the last segment.^[113]
• Agriculture: Some kinds of ants, termites, and ambrosia beetles have for a long time cultivated and tend fungi for food. These insects sow, fertilize, and weed their crops. A damselfish also takes care of red algae carpets on its piece of reef; the damselfish actively weeds out invading species of algae by nipping out the newcomer.^[114]
• Slave-making behavior has evolved several times independently in the ant subfamilies Myrmicinae and Formicinae,^[115][116] and more than ten times in total in ants.^[117]
• Proleg a fleshy leg on many larval of insects is found in all the orders in which they appear, formed independently of each order by convergent evolution.^[118]

Molluscs

• Bivalves and the gastropods in the family Juliidae have very similar shells.^[119]
• There are limpet-like forms in several lines of gastropods: "true" limpets, pulmonate siphonariid limpets and several lineages of pulmonate freshwater limpets.^[120][121]
• Cephalopod (like in octopuses & squid) and vertebrate eyes are both lens-camera eyes with much overall similarity, yet are very unrelated species. A closer examination reveals some differences like: embryonic development, extraocular muscles, how many lens parts, etc.^[122] to mice to fruit flies.^[123]
• Swim bladders: Buoyant bladders independently evolved in fishes, the tuberculate pelagic octopus, and siphonophores such as the Portuguese man o' war.^[124]
• Bivalves and brachiopods independently evolved paired hinged shells for protection. However, the anatomy of their soft parts is very dissimilar, which is why molluscs and brachiopods are put into different phyla.^[125]
• Jet propulsion in squids and in scallops: these two groups of mollusks have very different ways of squeezing water through their bodies in order to power rapid movement through a fluid. (Dragonfly larvae in the aquatic stage also use an anal jet to propel them, and jellyfish have used jet propulsion for a very long time.). Sea hares (gastropod molluscs) employ a similar means of jet propulsion, but without the sophisticated neurological machinery of cephalopods they navigate somewhat more clumsily.^[126][127] tunicates (such as salps),^[128][129] and some jellyfish^{[130][131][132]} also employ jet propulsion. The most efficient jet-propelled organisms are the salps,^[128] which use an order of magnitude less energy (per kilogram per metre) than squid.^[133]

Other

• The notochords in chordates are like the stomochords in hemichordates.^[134]
• Elvis taxon in the fossil record developed a similar morphology through convergent evolution.^[135]
• Venomous sting: To inject poison with a hypodermic needle, a sharppointed tube, has shown up independently 10+ times: jellyfish, spiders, scorpions, centipedes, various insects, cone shell, snakes, some Catfish, stingrays, stonefish, the male duckbill platypus, Siphonophorae and stinging nettles plant.^[136]
• Bioluminescence: A symbiotic partnerships with light-emitting bacteria developed many times independently in deep-sea fish, jellyfish, fireflies, rhagophthalmidae&Pyrophorus beetles, pyrosome, Mycena&Omphalotus nidiformis mushrooms, Vargula hilgendorfii, Quantula striata snail, Googly-Eyed Glass Squid, Stiptic fungus, Noctiluca scintillans, Pyrocystis fusiformis, Vargulin, Sea pen, Ostracod, Siphonophorae and glow worms.^[137][138]
• Parthenogenesis: Some lizards and insects have independent the capacity for females to produce live young from unfertilized eggs. Some species are entirely female.^[139]
• Extremely halophile archaeal family Halobacteriaceae and the extremely halophilic bacterium Salinibacter ruber both can live in high salt environment.^[140]
• In the evolution of sexual reproduction and origin of the sex chromosome: Mammals, females have two copies of the X chromosome (XX) and males have one copy of the X and one copy of the Y chromosome (XY). In birds it is the opposite, with males have two copies of the Z chromosome (ZZ) and females have one copy of the Z and one copy of the W chromosome (ZW).^[141]
• Multicellular organisms arose independently in brown algae (seaweed and kelp), plants, and animals.^[142]
• Origins of teeth have happened at least two times.^[143]
• Winged flight is found in unrelated species: birds, bats (mammal), insects, Pterosaur and Pterodactylus (reptiles). Flying fish do not fly, but are very good at Glided flight.^[144]
• Hummingbird, Dragonfly and Hummingbird hawk-moth can hover and fly backwards.^[145]
• Neuroglobins are found in vertebrate neurons, (deuterostomes), and are found in the neurons of unrelated protostomes, like photosynthesis acoel and jelly fish.^[146]
• Siphonophorae and Praya dubia resemble and act like jellyfish, but are Hydrozoa, a colony of specialized minute individuals called zooids.^[147][148] Salp, a Chordata, also is very much like jellyfish, yet completely different.^[149]

In plants

• Leaves have evolved multiple times - see Evolutionary history of plants. They have evolved not only in land plants, but also in various algae, like kelp.^[150]
• Prickles, thorns and spines are all modified plant tissues that have evolved to prevent or limit herbivory, these structures have evolved independently a number of times.^[151]
• Stimulant toxins: Plants which are only distantly related to each other, such as coffee and tea, produce caffeine to deter predators.^[152]
• The aerial rootlets found in ivy (Hedera) are similar to those of the climbing hydrangea (Hydrangea petiolaris) and some other vines. These rootlets are not derived from a common ancestor but have the same function of clinging to whatever support is available.^[153]
• Flowering plants (Delphinium, Aerangis, Tropaeolum and others) from different regions form tube-like spurs that contain nectar. This is why insects from one place sometimes can feed on plants from another place that have a structure like the flower, which is the traditional source of food for the animal.^[154]
• Some dicots (Anemone) and monocots (Trillium) in inhospitable environments are able to form underground organs such as corms, bulbs and rhizomes for reserving of nutrition and water until the conditions become better.
• Carnivorous plants: Nitrogen-deficient plants have in at least 7 distinct times become carnivorous, like: flypaper traps such as sundews and butterworts, spring traps-Venus fly trap, and pitcher traps in order to capture and digest insects to obtain scarce nitrogen.^[155][156]
• Pitcher plants: The pitcher trap evolved independently in three eudicot lineages and one monocot lineage.^[157][158]
• Similar-looking rosette succulents have arisen separately among plants in the families Asphodelaceae (formerly Liliaceae) and Crassulaceae.^[159]
• The orchids, the Birthwort family and Stylidiaceae have evolved independently the specific organ known as gynostemium, more popular as column.^[160]
• The Euphorbia of deserts in Africa and southern Asia, and the Cactaceae of the New World deserts have similar modifications (see picture below for one of many possible examples).^[161]
• Sunflower: some types of sunflower and Pericallis are due to convergent evolution.^[162]
• Crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM), a carbon fixation pathway that evolved in multiple plants as an adaptation to arid conditions.^[163]
• C4 photosynthesis is estimated to have evolved over 60 times within plants,^[164] via multiple different sequences of evolutionary events.^[165] C4 plants use a different metabolic pathway to capture carbon dioxide but also have differences in leaf anatomy and cell biology compared to most other plants.

• 

  Euphorbia obesa

• 

  Astrophytum asterias

In fungi

There are a variety of saprophytic and parasitic organisms that have evolved the habit of growing into their substrates as thin strands for extracellular digestion. This is most typical of the "true" fungi, but it has also evolved in Actinobacteria (bacteria), oomycetes (which are part of the stramenopile grouping, as are kelp), parasitic plants, and rhizocephalans (parasitic barnacles).^{[166][167][168]}

In proteins, enzymes and biochemical pathways

Functional convergence

Evolutionary convergence of serine and cysteine protease towards the same catalytic triads organisation of acid-base-nucleophile in different protease superfamilies. Shown are the triads of subtilisin, prolyl oligopeptidase, TEV protease, and papain.

Evolutionary convergence of threonine proteases towards the same N-terminal active site organisation. Shown are the catalytic threonine of the proteasome and ornithine acetyltransferase.

Here is a list of examples in which unrelated proteins have similar functions with different structure.

• The convergent orientation of the catalytic triad in the active site of serine and cysteine proteases independently in over 20 enzyme superfamilies.^[169]
• The use of an N-terminal threonine for proteolysis.
• The existence of distinct families of carbonic anhydrase is believed to illustrate convergent evolution.
• The use of (Z)-7-dodecen-1-yl acetate as a sex pheromone by the Asian elephant (Elephas maximus) and by more than 100 species of Lepidoptera.
• The biosynthesis of plant hormones such as gibberellin and abscisic acid by different biochemical pathways in plants and fungi.^[170][171]
• The protein prestin that drives the cochlea amplifier and confers high auditory sensitivity in mammals, shows numerous convergent amino acid replacements in bats and dolphins, both of which have independently evolved high frequency hearing for echolocation.^[22][23] This same signature of convergence has also been found in other genes expressed in the mammalian cochlea^[24]
• The repeated independent evolution of nylonase in two different strains of Flavobacterium and one strain of Pseudomonas.
• The myoglobin from the abalone Sulculus diversicolor has a different structure from normal myoglobin but serves a similar function — binding oxygen reversibly. “The molecular weight of Sulculus myoglobin is 41kD, 2.5 times larger than other myoglobins.” Moreover, its amino acid sequence has no homology with other invertebrate myoglobins or with hemoglobins, but is 35% homologous with human indoleamine dioxygenase (IDO), a vertebrate tryptophan-degrading enzyme. Interestingly, it does not share similar function with IDO. “The IDO-like myoglobin is unexpectedly widely distributed among gastropodic molluscs, such as Sulculus, Nordotis, Battilus, Omphalius and Chlorostoma.”^[172]
• The hemocyanin from arthropods and molluscs evolved from different ancestors, tyrosinase and insect storage proteins, respectively. They have different molecular weight and structure. However, the proteins both use copper binding sites to transport oxygen.^[173]
• The hexokinase, ribokinase, and galactokinase families of sugar kinases have similar enzymatic functions of sugar phosphorylation, but they evolved from three distinct nonhomologous families since they all have distinct three-dimensional folding and their conserved sequence patterns are strikingly different.^[174]
• Hemoglobins in jawed vertebrates and jawless fish evolved independently. The oxygen-binding hemoglobins of jawless fish evolved from an ancestor of cytoglobin which has no oxygen transport function and is expressed in fibroblast cells.^[175]
• Toxic agent, serine protease BLTX, in the venom produced by two distinct species, the North American short-tailed shrew Blarina brevicauda and the Mexican beaded lizard, undergo convergent evolution. Although their structures are similar, it turns out that they increased the enzyme activity and toxicity through different way of structure changes. These changes are not found in the other non-venomous reptiles or mammals.^[176]
• Another toxin BgK, a K+ channel-blocking toxin from the sea anemone Bunodosoma granulifera and scorpions adopt distinct scaffolds and unrelated structures, however, they have similar functions.^[177]
• Antifreeze proteins are a perfect example of convergent evolution. Different small proteins with a flat surface which is rich in threonine from different organisms are selected to bind to the surface of ice crystals. "These include two proteins from fish, the ocean pout and the winter flounder, and three very active proteins from insects, the yellow mealworm beetle, the spruce budworm moth, and the snow flea."^[178]
• RNA-binding proteins which contain RNA-binding domain(RBD) and the cold-shock domain (CSD) protein family are also an interesting example of convergent evolution. Except that they both have conserved RNP motifs, other protein sequence are totally different. However, they have a similar function.^[179]
• Blue-light-receptive cryptochrome expressed in the sponge eyes likely evolved convergently in the absence of opsins and nervous systems. The fully sequenced genome of Amphimedon queenslandica, a demosponge larvae, lacks one vital visual component: opsin-a gene for a light-sensitive opsin pigment which is essential for vision in other animals.^[180]
• The structure of immunoglobulin G-binding bacterial proteins A and H do not contain any sequences homologous to the constant repeats of IgG antibodies, but they have similar functions. Both protein G, A, H are inhibited in the interactions with IgG antibodies (IgGFc) by a synthetic peptide corresponding to an 11-amino-acid-long sequence in the COOH-terminal region of the repeats.^[181]

Structural convergence

Here is a list of examples in which unrelated proteins have similar tertiary structures but different functions. Whole protein structural convergence is not thought to occur but some convergence of pockets and secondary structural elements have been documented.

• Some secondary structure convergence occurs due to some residues favouring being in α-helix (helical propensity) and for hydrophobic patches or pocket to be formed at the ends of the parallel sheets.^[182]
• ABAC is a database of convergently evolved protein interaction interfaces. Examples comprise fibronectin/long chain cytokines, NEF/SH2, cyclophilin/capsid proteins.^[183]

See also

• McGhee, G.R. (2011) Convergent Evolution: Limited Forms Most Beautiful. Vienna Series in Theoretical Biology: Massachusetts Institute of Technology Press, Cambridge (MA). 322 pp.

References

1. L Werdelin (1986). "Comparison of Skull Shape in Marsupial and Placental Carnivores". Australian Journal of Zoology 34 (2): 109–117. doi:10.1071/ZO9860109.
2. The phylogeny of the ungulates - Donald Prothero
3. tcnj.edu, ANTELOPE Vs. PRONGHORN
4. Luo, Zhe-Xi; Cifelli, Richard L.; Kielan-Jaworowska, Zofia (2001). "Dual origin of tribosphenic mammals". Nature 409 (6816): 53–57. doi:10.1038/35051023. PMID 11343108.
5. The Curious Evolutionary History of the ‘Marsupial Wolf’ by Kyle Taitt
6. An Introduction to Zoology, Page 102, by Joseph Springer, Dennis Holley, 2012
7. Convergent Evolution: Limited Forms Most Beautiful, page 158, by George R. McGhee, 2011
8. When Nature Discovers The Same Design Over and Over, By NATALIE ANGIER, Published: December 15, 1998
9. BBC, Koalas' Fingerprints
10. Convergent EVOLUTION: "Are Dolphins and Bats more related than we think?" by Cariosa Switzer, October 16, 2013
11. "Analogy: Squirrels and Sugar Gliders". Understanding Evolution. The University of California Museum of Paleontology. Retrieved 28 September 2012.
12. /jerboa.html desertusa.com, The Jerboa, by Jay Sharp
13. johnabbott.qc.ca, COMPARATIVE ANATOMY OF VERTEBRATE SKELETA
14. The Encyclopedia of Applied Animal Behaviour and Welfare, page 137, D. S. Mills and Jeremy N. Marchant-Forde
15. weebly.com, Marsupials
16. 91st Annual Meeting, The American Society of Mammalogists, A Joint Meeting With The Australian Mammal Society Portland State University, 28 June 2011
17. devilsatcradle.com, Tasmanian Devil - Sarcophilus harrisii Taxonomy
18. Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History, Volume 27, page 382, By Joel Asaph Allen
19. nationaldinosaurmuseum.com.au Thylacoleo
20. Yoon, Carol Kaesuk. "Donald R. Griffin, 88, Dies; Argued Animals Can Think", The New York Times, November 14, 2003. Accessed July 16, 2010.
21. D. R. Griffin (1958). Listening in the dark. Yale Univ. Press, New York.
22. Liu Y, Cotton JA, Shen B, Han X, Rossiter SJ, Zhang S (2010). "Convergent sequence evolution between echolocating bats and dolphins.". Current Biology 20 (2): R53–54. doi:10.1016/j.cub.2009.11.058.
23. Liu, Y, Rossiter SJ, Han X, Cotton JA, Zhang S (2010). "Cetaceans on a molecular fast track to ultrasonic hearing". Current Biology 20 (20): 1834–1839. doi:10.1016/j.cub.2010.09.008. PMID 20933423.
24. Davies KTJ, Cotton JA, Kirwan J, Teeling EC, Rossiter SJ (2011). "Parallel signatures of sequence evolution among hearing genes in echolocating mammals: an emerging model of genetic convergence". Heredity 108 (5): 480–489. doi:10.1038/hdy.2011.119.
25. Parker, J; Tsagkogeorga, G; Cotton, JA; Liu, Y; Provero, P; Stupka, E; Rossiter, SJ (2013). "Genome-wide signatures of convergent evolution in echolocating mammals". Nature 502 (7470): , 228–231. Bibcode:2013Natur.502..228P. doi:10.1038/nature12511.
26. Rawlins, D. R; Handasyde, K. A. (2002). "The feeding ecology of the striped possum Dactylopsila trivirgata (Marsupialia: Petauridae) in far north Queensland, Australia". J. Zool., Lond. (Zoological Society of London) 257: 195–206. 2010-04-09.
27. Ji, Q.; Luo, Z.-X.; Yuan, C.-X.; Tabrum, A. R. (2006). "A swimming mammaliaform from the Middle Jurassic and ecomorphological diversification of early mammals". Science 311 (5764): 1123–1127. doi:10.1126/science.1123026. PMID 16497926.
28. Organ, J. M. (2008). The Functional Anatomy of Prehensile and Nonprehensile Tails of the Platyrrhini (Primates) and Procyonidae (Carnivora). Johns Hopkins University. ISBN 9780549312260.
29. "Entelodont General Evidence". BBC Worldwide. 2002. Retrieved 2007-11-21.
30. Dawkins, Richard (2005). The Ancestor's Tale. Boston: Mariner Books. p. 195. ISBN 978-0-618-61916-0.
31. whalefacts.org, Whale Shark Facts
32. "Duck-billed Platypus". Museum of hoaxes. Retrieved 2010-07-21.
33. "Platypus facts file". Australian Platypus Conservancy. Retrieved 2006-09-13.
34. http://people.eku.edu/ritchisong/birdcirculatory.html, Eastern Kentucky University, Ornithology, Avian Circulatory System
35. The Behavior Guide to African Mammals: Including Hoofed Mammals, Carnivores, By Richard Estes
36. Encyclopedia of Marine Mammals, by William F. Perrin, Bernd Wursig, J. G.M. Thewissen
37. http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2005/05/0519_050519_newmonkey_2.html nationalgeographic.com, New Monkey Species Discovered in East Africa, Genus Identification
38. planetearth.nerc.ac.uk, Copepods and whales share weight belt tactic, 16 June 2011, by Tom Marshall
39. theroamingnaturalist.com, Evolution Awesomeness Series #3: Convergent Evolution
40. edgeofexistence.org Fossa
41. a-z-animals.com Fossa
42. Witton, Mark (2013). Pterosaurs: Natural History, Evolution, Anatomy. Princeton University Press. p. 51.
43. Sereno, P.C. 1986. Phylogeny of the bird-hipped dinosaurs (order Ornithischia). National Geographic Research 2(2):234–256.
44. Proctor, Nobel S. Manual of Ornithology: Avian Structure and Function. Yale University Press. (1993) ISBN 0-300-05746-6
45. David Lambert and the Diagram Group. The Field Guide to Prehistoric Life. New York: Facts on File Publications, 1985. pp. 196. ISBN 0-8160-1125-7
46. Bujor, Mara. "Did sauropods walk with their necks upright?". ZME Science.
47. Holtz, Thomas R. Jr. (2011) Dinosaurs: The Most Complete, Up-to-Date Encyclopedia for Dinosaur Lovers of All Ages, Winter 2010 Appendix.
48. Boyle, Alan (2009-06-29). "How dinosaurs chewed". MSNBC. Retrieved 2009-06-03.
49. Southampton, University of. "Fossil Saved from Mule Track Revolutionizes Understanding of Ancient Dolphin-Like Marine Reptile". Science Daily. Retrieved 15 May 2013.
50. Marsh, O.C. (1890). "Additional characters of the Ceratopsidae, with notice of new Cretaceous dinosaurs". American Journal of Science 39: 418–429.
51. Botha-Brink, J.; Modesto, S.P. (2007). "A mixed-age classed 'pelycosaur' aggregation from South Africa: earliest evidence of parental care in amniotes?". Proceedings of the Royal Society B 274 (1627): 2829–2834. doi:10.1098/rspb.2007.0803. PMC 2288685. PMID 17848370.
52. Carroll, R.L. (1969). "Problems of the origin of reptiles". Biological Reviews 44 (3): 393–432. doi:10.1111/j.1469-185x.1969.tb01218.x.
53. palaeos.com, Ornithischia: Hadrosauroidea
54. Agnolin, F.L.; Chiarelli, P. (2010). "The position of the claws in Noasauridae (Dinosauria: Abelisauroidea) and its implications for abelisauroid manus evolution". Paläontologische Zeitschrift 84 (2): 293–300. doi:10.1007/s12542-009-0044-2.
55. Zheng, Xiao-Ting; You, Hai-Lu; Xu, Xing; Dong, Zhi-Ming (2009). "An Early Cretaceous heterodontosaurid dinosaur with filamentous integumentary structures". Nature 458 (7236): 333–336. doi:10.1038/nature07856. PMID 19295609.
56. The Dinosauria: Second Edition, Page 193, David B. Weishampel, Peter Dodson, Halszka Osmólska, 2004
57. Dixon, Dougal. "The Complete Book of Dinosaurs." Hermes House, 2006.
58. genesispark.com, The Thorny Devil and Horned Lizards
59. berkeley.edu, Phytosauria, The phytosaurs
60. Fischer, V.; A. Clement; M. Guiomar; P. Godefroit (2011). "The first definite record of a Valanginian ichthyosaur and its implications on the evolution of post-Liassic Ichthyosauria". Cretaceous Research 32 (2): 155–163. doi:10.1016/j.cretres.2010.11.005.
61. Hoser, R. (1998). "Death adders (genus Acanthophis): an overview, including descriptions of five new species and one subspecies". Monitor 9 (2): 20–30, 33–41.
62. Ophisaurus at Life is Short, but Snakes are Long
63. Sheffield, K. Megan; Butcher, Michael T.; Shugart, S. Katharine; Gander, Jennifer C.; Blob, Richard W. (2011). "Locomotor loading mechanics in the hindlimbs of tegu lizards (Tupinambis merianae): Comparative and evolutionary implications". The Journal of Experimental Biology 214 (15): 2616–2630. doi:10.1242/jeb.048801.
64. Gamble T, Greenbaum E, Jackman TR, Russell AP, Bauer AM (2012). "Repeated origin and loss of adhesive toepads in geckos". PLOS ONE 7 (6): e39429. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0039429. PMC 3384654. PMID 22761794.
65. Losos, Jonathan B. (2007). "Detective Work in the West Indies: Integrating Historical and Experimental Approaches to Study Island Lizard Evolution". BioScience 57 (7): 585–97. doi:10.1641/B570712.
66. "Tuatara". New Zealand Ecology: Living Fossils. TerraNature Trust. 2004. Retrieved 10 November 2006.
67. fox News, Deadliest sea snake splits in two, By Douglas Main, December 11, 2012
68. Christidis, Les; Boles, Walter (2008). Systematics and taxonomy of Australian Birds. Collingwood, Vic: CSIRO Publishing. pp. 81–82. ISBN 978-0-643-06511-6.
69. Christidis L, Boles WE (2008). Systematics and Taxonomy of Australian Birds. Canberra: CSIRO Publishing. p. 196. ISBN 978-0-643-06511-6.
70. The Origin and Evolution of Birds, Page 185, by Alan Feduccia, 1999
71. Vulture, By Thom van Dooren, page 20, 2011
72. Prinzinger, R.; Schafer T. & Schuchmann K. L. (1992). "Energy metabolism, respiratory quotient and breathing parameters in two convergent small bird species : the fork-tailed sunbird Aethopyga christinae (Nectariniidae) and the Chilean hummingbird Sephanoides sephanoides (Trochilidae)". Journal of thermal biology 17.
73. Herrera, Carlos M. (1992). "Activity pattern and thermal biology of a day-flying hawkmoth (Macroglossum stellatarum) under Mediterranean summer conditions". Ecological Entomology 17
74. Harshman J, Braun EL, Braun MJ, et al. (September 2008). "Phylogenomic evidence for multiple losses of flight in ratite birds". Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 105 (36): 13462–7. doi:10.1073/pnas.0803242105. PMC 2533212. PMID 18765814.
75. Holmes, Bob (2008-06-26). "Bird evolutionary tree given a shake by DNA study". New Scientist.
76. theguardian.com, Mystery bird: yellow-throated longclaw, Macronyx croceus, Dec. 2011
77. Cory, Charles B. (March 1918). "Catalogue of Birds of the Americas". Fieldiana Zoology. 197 (Chicago, IL, USA: Field Museum of Natural History) 13 (Part 2): 13. Retrieved 28 September 2012.
78. beautyofbirds.com, Hairywoodpeckers, by Species account by Jeannine Miesle
79. Australian Birds by Donald Trounson, Molly Trounson, National Book Distributors and Publishers, 1996
80. University of North Carolina, Animal Bioacoustics: Communication and echolocation among aquatic and terrestrial animals
81. Evolution of brain structures for vocal learning in birds, by Erich D. JARVIS
82. Birn-Jeffery AV, Miller CE, Naish D, Rayfield EJ, Hone DW (2012). "Pedal claw curvature in birds, lizards and mesozoic dinosaurs--complicated categories and compensating for mass-specific and phylogenetic control". PLOS ONE 7 (12): e50555. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0050555. PMC 3515613. PMID 23227184.
83. Walter, Timothy J.; Marar, Uma (2007). "Sleeping With One Eye Open" (PDF). Capitol Sleep Medicine Newsletter. pp. 3621–3628.
84. Bale R and Neveln ID, Bhalla AP, MacIver MA, Patankar NA" (April 2015). "Convergent evolution of mechanically optimal locomotion in aquatic invertebrates and vertebrates". PLOS Biology 13 (4): e1002123. doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.1002123. PMID 25919026.
85. Daeschler EB, Shubin NH, Jenkins FA (April 2006). "A Devonian tetrapod-like fish and the evolution of the tetrapod body plan". Nature 440 (7085): 757–63. doi:10.1038/nature04639. PMID 16598249.
86. mapoflife.org, Independent eye movement in fish, chameleons and frogmouths
87. .oscarfish.com, Cichlids and Sunfish: A Comparison, By Sandtiger
88. Kullander, Sven; Efrem Ferreira (2006). "A review of the South American cichlid genus Cichla, with descriptions of nine new species (Teleostei: Cichlidae)" (PDF). Ichthyological Explorations of Freshwaters 17 (4).
89. Willis SC, Macrander J, Farias IP, Ortí G (2012). "Simultaneous delimitation of species and quantification of interspecific hybridization in Amazonian peacock cichlids (genus cichla) using multi-locus data". BMC Evolutionary Biology 12 (1): 96. doi:10.1186/1471-2148-12-96. PMC 3563476. PMID 22727018.
90. Crevel RW, Fedyk JK, Spurgeon MJ (July 2002). "Antifreeze proteins: characteristics, occurrence and human exposure". Food and Chemical Toxicology 40 (7): 899–903. doi:10.1016/S0278-6915(02)00042-X. PMID 12065210.
91. Chen L, DeVries AL, Cheng CH (April 1997). "Evolution of antifreeze glycoprotein gene from a trypsinogen gene in Antarctic notothenioid fish". Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 94 (8): 3811–6. doi:10.1073/pnas.94.8.3811. PMC 20523. PMID 9108060.
92. Hopkins CD (December 1995). "Convergent designs for electrogenesis and electroreception". Current Opinion in Neurobiology 5 (6): 769–77. doi:10.1016/0959-4388(95)80105-7. PMID 8805421.
93. Hopkins, C. D. (1995). "Convergent designs for electrogenesis and electroreception". Current Opinion in Neurobiology 5 (6): 769–777. doi:10.1016/0959-4388(95)80105-7. PMID 8805421.
94. Froese, Rainer, and Daniel Pauly, eds. (2012). "Gasterosteidae" in FishBase. October 2012 version.
95. Fish, F. E. (1990). "Wing design and scaling of flying fish with regard to flight performance" (PDF). Journal of Zoology 221 (3): 391–403. doi:10.1111/j.1469-7998.1990.tb04009.x.
96. The Rise of Fishes: 500 Million Years of Evolution by John A. Long
97. Cheney KL, Grutter AS, Blomberg SP, Marshall NJ (August 2009). "Blue and yellow signal cleaning behavior in coral reef fishes". Current Biology 19 (15): 1283–7. doi:10.1016/j.cub.2009.06.028. PMID 19592250.
98. Why are the eyes of larval Black Dragonfish on stalks? - Australian Museum
99. realmonstrosities.com, What's the Difference Between a Sawfish and a Sawshark? Sunday, 26 June 2011
100. mapoflife.org, Tongues of chameleons and amphibians
101. mongabay.com, Study discovers why poison dart frogs are toxic, by Rhett Butler, August 9, 2005
102. Nussbaum, Ronald A. (1998). Cogger, H.G. & Zweifel, R.G., ed. Encyclopedia of Reptiles and Amphibians. San Diego: Academic Press. pp. 52–59.
103. Niedźwiedzki (2010). "Tetrapod trackways from the early Middle Devonian period of Poland". Nature 463 (7277): 43–48. doi:10.1038/nature08623. PMID 20054388.
104. Parra-Olea G, Wake DB (July 2001). "Extreme morphological and ecological homoplasy in tropical salamanders". Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 98 (14): 7888–91. doi:10.1073/pnas.131203598. PMC 35438. PMID 11427707.
105. Milner, Andrew R. (1980). "The Tetrapod Assemblage from Nýrany, Czechoslovakia". In Panchen, A. L. The Terrestrial Environment and the Origin of Land Vertebrates. London and New York: Academic Press. pp. 439–96.
106. Platnick, Norman I. (2008): The world spider catalog, version 8.5. American Museum of Natural History.
107. wired.com, Absurd Creature of the Week: Enormous Hermit Crab Tears Through Coconuts, Eats Kittens, By Matt Simon, 12.20.13
108. "Defining Features of Nominal Clades of Diplopoda" (PDF). Field Museum of Natural History. Retrieved June 24, 2007.
109. Briones-Fourzán, Patricia; Lozano-Alvarez, Enrique (1991). "Aspects of the biology of the giant isopod Bathynomus giganteus A. Milne Edwards, 1879 (Flabellifera: Cirolanidae), off the Yucatan Peninsula". Journal of Crustacean Biology 11 (3): 375–385. doi:10.2307/1548464. JSTOR 1548464.
110. "Monster of the deep: Shocked oil workers catch TWO-AND-A-HALF-FOOT 'woodlouse'". The Daily Mail (London). April 3, 2010.
111. Sutherland TD, Young JH, Weisman S, Hayashi CY, Merritt DJ (2010). "Insect silk: one name, many materials". Annual Review of Entomology 55 (1): 171–88. doi:10.1146/annurev-ento-112408-085401. PMID 19728833.
112. The Praying Mantids, Page 341, by Frederick R. Prete
113. Insects, pt. 1-4. History of the zoophytes. By Oliver Goldsmith, page 39
114. Fungal Biology, By J. W. Deacon, page 278
115. King, JR; Trager, JC.; Pérez-Lachaud, G. (2007), "Natural history of the slave making ant, Polyergus lucidus, sensu lato in northern Florida and its three Formica pallidefulva group hosts.", Journal of Insect Science 7 (42): 1–14, doi:10.1673/031.007.4201
116. Goropashnaya, A. V.; Fedorov, V. B.; Seifert, B.; Pamilo, P. (2012), Chaline, Nicolas, ed., "Phylogenetic Relationships of Palaearctic Formica Species (Hymenoptera, Formicidae) Based on Mitochondrial Cytochrome b Sequences", PLoS ONE 7 (7): 1–7, doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0041697, PMC 3402446, PMID 22911845
117. D'Ettorre, Patrizia; Heinze, Jürgen (2001), "Sociobiology of slave-making ants", Acta Ethologica 3: 67–82, doi:10.1007/s102110100038
118. Suzuki, Y.; Palopoli, M. (2001). "Evolution of insect abdominal appendages: Are prolegs homologous or convergent traits?". Development Genes and Evolution 211 (10): 486–492. doi:10.1007/s00427-001-0182-3. PMID 11702198.
119. maryland.gov, MOLLUSCS
120. University of Hawaii Educational page from Christopher F. Bird, Dep't of Botany. Photos and detailed information distinguishing the different varieties.
121. Lottia gigantea: taxonomy, facts, life cycle, bibliography
122. Yoshida, Masa-aki; Yura, Kei; Ogura, Atsushi (5 March 2014). "Cephalopod eye evolution was modulated by the acquisition of Pax-6 splicing variants". Scientific Reports (nature.com) 4. Bibcode:2014NatSR...4E4256Y. doi:10.1038/srep04256. Retrieved June 30, 2014.
123. Halder, G.; Callaerts, P.; Gehring, W. J. (1995). "New perspectives on eye evolution". Current opinion in genetics & development 5 (5): 602–609. doi:10.1016/0959-437X(95)80029-8. PMID 8664548.
124. "The illustration of the swim bladder in fishes is a good one, because it shows us clearly the highly important fact that an organ originally constructed for one purpose, namely, flotation, may be converted into one for a widely different purpose, namely, respiration. The swim bladder has, also, been worked in as an accessory to the auditory organs of certain fishes. All physiologists admit that the swimbladder is homologous, or "ideally similar" in position and structure with the lungs of the higher vertebrate animals: hence there is no reason to doubt that the swim bladder has actually been converted into lungs, or an organ used exclusively for respiration. According to this view it may be inferred that all vertebrate animals with true lungs are descended by ordinary generation from an ancient and unknown prototype, which was furnished with a floating apparatus or swim bladder." Darwin, Origin of Species.
125. fossilplot.org, Brachiopods and Bivalves: paired shells, with different histories
126. Mill, P. J.; Pickard, R. S. (1975). "Jet-propulsion in anisopteran dragonfly larvae". Journal of Comparative Physiology 97 (4): 329–338. doi:10.1007/BF00631969.
127. Bone, Q.; Trueman, E. R. (2009). "Jet propulsion of the calycophoran siphonophores Chelophyes and Abylopsis". Journal of the Marine Biological Association of the United Kingdom 62: 263. doi:10.1017/S0025315400057271.
128. Bone, Q.; Trueman, E. R. (2009). "Jet propulsion in salps (Tunicata: Thaliacea)". Journal of Zoology 201: 481–506. doi:10.1111/j.1469-7998.1983.tb05071.x.
129. Bone, Q.; Trueman, E. (1984). "Jet propulsion in Doliolum (Tunicata: Thaliacea)". Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology 76: 105–118. doi:10.1016/0022-0981(84)90059-5.
130. Demont, M. Edwin; Gosline, John M. (January 1, 1988). "Mechanics of Jet Propulsion in the Hydromedusan Jellyfish (section I. Mechanical Properties of the Locomotor Structure)". J. Exp. Biol. (134): 313–332.
131. Demont, M. Edwin; Gosline, John M. (January 1, 1988). "Mechanics of Jet Propulsion in the Hydromedusan Jellyfish (section II. Energetics of the Jet Cycle)". J. Exp. Biol. (134): 333–345.
132. Demont, M. Edwin; Gosline, John M. (January 1, 1988). "Mechanics of Jet Propulsion in the Hydromedusan Jellyfish (section III. A Natural Resonating Bell; The Presence and Importance of a Resonant Phenomenon in the Locomotor Structure)". J. Exp. Biol. (134): 347–361.
133. Madin, L. P. (1990). "Aspects of jet propulsion in salps". Canadian Journal of Zoology 68: 765–777. doi:10.1139/z90-111.
134. faculty.vassar.edu, notochor
135. Benton, Michael J.; Harper, David A.T. (2009), Introduction to paleobiology and the fossil record, John Wiley & Sons, p. 77, ISBN 978-1-4051-8646-9
136. Smith WL, Wheeler WC (2006). "Venom evolution widespread in fishes: a phylogenetic road map for the bioprospecting of piscine venoms".
137. Meighen EA (1999). "Autoinduction of light emission in different species of bioluminescent bacteria". Luminescence 14 (1): 3–9. doi:10.1002/(SICI)1522-7243(199901/02)14:1<3::AID-BIO507>3.0.CO;2-4. PMID 10398554.
138. wn.com Bioluminescent
139. Liddell, Scott, Jones. γένεσις A.II, A Greek-English Lexicon, Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1940. q.v..
140. Robinson JL, Pyzyna B, Atrasz RG, et al. (February 2005). "Growth kinetics of extremely halophilic archaea (family halobacteriaceae) as revealed by arrhenius plots". Journal of Bacteriology 187 (3): 923–9. doi:10.1128/JB.187.3.923-929.2005. PMC 545725. PMID 15659670.
141. bio.sunyorange.edu, GENDER AND SEX CHROMOSOMES
142. Strickberger's Evolution, By Brian Keith Hall, Page 188, Benedikt Hallgrímsson, Monroe W. Strickberger
143. sciencemag.org, Separate Evolutionary Origins of Teeth from Evidence in Fossil Jawed Vertebrates, by Moya Meredith Smith1 and Zerina Johanson, 21 February 2003
144. Biology at the University of New Mexico, Vertebrate Adaptations
145. birdsbybent.com, Ruby-throated HummingbirdArchilochus colubris
146. science.gov, Neuroglobins, Pivotal Proteins Associated with Emerging Neural Systems and Precursors of Metazoan Globin Diversity by Lechauve, Christophe; Jager, Muriel; Laguerre, Laurent; Kiger, Laurent; Correc, Gaelle; Leroux, Cedric; Vinogradov, Serge; Czjzek, Mirjam; Marden, Michael C.; Bail
147. Dunn, Casey (2005): Siphonophores. Retrieved 2008-JUL-08.
148. fox.rwu.edu MARINE ECOLOGY PROGRESS SERIES, Dec. 7, 2006 By Sean P. Colin, John H. Costello, Heather Kordula
149. sciencedaily.com, Study sheds light on tunicate evolution, July 5, 2011, Source: Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution
150. scientificamerican.com, How the First Plant Came to Be. A genetic analysis reveals the ancient, complex--and symbiotic--roots of photosynthesis in plants, Feb 16, 2012, By David Biello
151. Simpson, M. G. 2010. "Plant Morphology". In: Plant Systematics, 2nd. edition. Elsevier Academic Press. Chapter 9.
152. medscape.com, Which Plants Contain Caffeine?, by Gayle Nicholas Scott, March 13, 2013
153. "Epiphytes - adaptations to an aerial habitat". Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew.
154. Clarke, C.M. 1997. Nepenthes of Borneo. Natural History Publications (Borneo), Kota Kinabalu.
155. Albert, V.A., Williams, S.E., and Chase, M.W. (1992). "Carnivorous plants: Phylogeny and structural evolution". Science 257 (5076): 1491–1495. doi:10.1126/science.1523408. PMID 1523408.
156. Ellison, A.M., and Gotelli, N.J. (2009). "Energetics and the evolution of carnivorous plants—Darwin's 'most wonderful plants in the world'.". Journal of Experimental Botany 60 (1): 19–42. doi:10.1093/jxb/ern179. PMID 19213724.
157. Albert, V.A.; Williams, S.E.; Chase, M.W. (1992). "Carnivorous Plants: Phylogeny and Structural Evolution". Science 257 (5076): 1491–1495. doi:10.1126/science.1523408. PMID 1523408.
158. Owen Jr, T.P.; Lennon, K.A. (1999). "Structure and Development of Pitchers from the Carnivorous Plant Nepenthes alta (Nepenthaceae)". American Journal of Botany 86 (10): 1382–1390. doi:10.2307/2656921. PMID 10523280.
159. mapoflife.org, Desert plants with succulent leaves
160. science.gov, orchid functional genomics
161. mapoflife.org, Desert plants with succulent stems
162. Indiana University, The Origin of Dendrosenecio
163. Keeley, Jon E. & Rundel, Philip W. (2003), "Evolution of CAM and C4 Carbon‐Concentrating Mechanisms" (PDF), International Journal of Plant Sciences 164 (S3): S55, doi:10.1086/374192, retrieved 2012-02-19
164. Sage, R. F.; Christin, P. -A.; Edwards, E. J. (2011). "The C4 plant lineages of planet Earth". Journal of Experimental Botany 62 (9): 3155–3169. doi:10.1093/jxb/err048. PMID 21414957.
165. Williams BP, Johnston IG, Covshoff S, Hibberd JM (September 2013). "Phenotypic landscape inference reveals multiple evolutionary paths to C₄ photosynthesis". eLife 2: e00961. doi:10.7554/eLife.00961. PMID 24082995.
166. Advanced Biology Principles, p296, fig 14.16—Diagram detailing the re-absorption of substrates within the hypha.
167. Advanced biology principles, p 296—states the purpose of saprotrophs and their internal nutrition, as well as the main two types of fungi that are most often referred to, as well as describes, visually, the process of saprotrophic nutrition through a diagram of hyphae, referring to the Rhizobium on damp, stale whole-meal bread or rotting fruit.
168. Clegg, C. J.; Mackean, D. G. (2006). Advanced Biology: Principles and Applications, 2nd ed. Hodder Publishing
169. Buller, AR; Townsend, CA (Feb 19, 2013). "Intrinsic evolutionary constraints on protease structure, enzyme acylation, and the identity of the catalytic triad.". Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 110 (8): E653–61. doi:10.1073/pnas.1221050110. PMID 23382230.
170. Tudzynski B. (2005). "Gibberellin biosynthesis in fungi: genes, enzymes, evolution, and impact on biotechnology". Appl Microbiol Biotechnol. 66 (6): 597–611. doi:10.1007/s00253-004-1805-1. PMID 15578178.
171. Siewers V, Smedsgaard J, Tudzynski P (July 2004). "The P450 monooxygenase BcABA1 is essential for abscisic acid biosynthesis in Botrytis cinerea". Applied and Environmental Microbiology 70 (7): 3868–76. doi:10.1128/AEM.70.7.3868-3876.2004. PMC 444755. PMID 15240257.
172. Suzuki T, Yuasa H, Imai K (July 1996). "Convergent evolution. The gene structure of Sulculus 41 kDa myoglobin is homologous with that of human indoleamine dioxygenase". Biochimica et Biophysica Acta 1308 (1): 41–8. doi:10.1016/0167-4781(96)00059-0. PMID 8765749.
173. Anupam N&am, Jimmy Ng and Trustin Ennacheril, "The Molecular Evolution of Arthropod & Molluscan Hemocyanin, Evidence for Apomorphic origin and convergent evolution in O2 hinding sites", December 1, 1997
174. Bork P, Sander C, Valencia A (January 1993). "Convergent evolution of similar enzymatic function on different protein folds: the hexokinase, ribokinase, and galactokinase families of sugar kinases". Protein Science 2 (1): 31–40. doi:10.1002/pro.5560020104. PMC 2142297. PMID 8382990.
175. Hoffmann FG, Opazo JC, Storz JF (August 2010). "Gene cooption and convergent evolution of oxygen transport hemoglobins in jawed and jawless vertebrates". Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 107 (32): 14274–9. doi:10.1073/pnas.1006756107. PMC 2922537. PMID 20660759.
176. Aminetzach YT, Srouji JR, Kong CY, Hoekstra HE (December 2009). "Convergent evolution of novel protein function in shrew and lizard venom". Current Biology 19 (22): 1925–31. doi:10.1016/j.cub.2009.09.022. PMID 19879144.
177. Dauplais M, Lecoq A, Song J, et al. (February 1997). "On the convergent evolution of animal toxins. Conservation of a diad of functional residues in potassium channel-blocking toxins with unrelated structures". The Journal of Biological Chemistry 272 (7): 4302–9. doi:10.1074/jbc.272.7.4302. PMID 9020148.
178. Venketesh S, Dayananda C (2008). "Properties, potentials, and prospects of antifreeze proteins". Critical Reviews in Biotechnology 28 (1): 57–82. doi:10.1080/07388550801891152. PMID 18322856.
179. Graumann P, Marahiel MA (April 1996). "A case of convergent evolution of nucleic acid binding modules". BioEssays 18 (4): 309–15. doi:10.1002/bies.950180409. PMID 8967899.
180. Ajna S. Rivera, Todd H. Oakley, etc. Blue-light-receptive cryptochrome is expressed in a sponge eye lacking neurons and Opsin, The Journal of Experimental Biology 215, 1278-1286
181. Frick IM, Wikström M, Forsén S, et al. (September 1992). "Convergent evolution among immunoglobulin G-binding bacterial proteins". Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 89 (18): 8532–6. doi:10.1073/pnas.89.18.8532. PMC 49954. PMID 1528858.
182. Rao ST, Rossmann MG (May 1973). "Comparison of super-secondary structures in proteins". Journal of Molecular Biology 76 (2): 241–56. doi:10.1016/0022-2836(73)90388-4. PMID 4737475.
183. Henschel A, Kim WK, Schroeder M (March 2006). "Equivalent binding sites reveal convergently evolved interaction motifs". Bioinformatics 22 (5): 550–5. doi:10.1093/bioinformatics/bti782. PMID 16287935.