Two-child policy

A two-child policy is a government-imposed limit of two children allowed per family or the payment of government subsidies only to the first two children. It has previously been used in Vietnam. In British Hong Kong in the 1970s, citizens were also highly encouraged to have two children as a limit (although it was not mandated by law), and it was used as part of the region's family planning strategies.

China

During the 1970s, Chinese citizens were encouraged to have only one child.^[1] The ongoing Cultural Revolution and the strain it placed on the nation were large factors. During this time, the birth rate dropped from nearly 6 children per woman to just under 3.^[2] (The colloquial term "births per woman" is usually formalized as the Total Fertility Rate (TFR), a technical term in demographic analysis meaning the average number of children that would be born to a woman over her lifetime if she were to experience the exact current age-specific fertility rates through her lifetime.)

As China's youngest generation (born under the one-child policy, which first became a requirement for most couples in 1979) came of age for formation of the next generation, a single child would be left with having to provide support for his or her two parents and four grandparents. In response to this issue, by 2009 all provinces allowed couples to have two children if both parents were only children themselves.^[3] After a policy change of the Chinese government in late 2013, most Chinese provinces further relaxed the policy in 2014 by allowing families to have two children if one of the parents is an only child.^[4][5][6]

Moreover, in accordance with PRC's affirmative action policies towards ethnic minorities, all non-Han ethnic groups were subjected to different rules and were usually allowed to have two children in urban areas, and three or four in rural areas. Han Chinese living in rural areas were often permitted to have two children, as exceptions existed if the first child was a daughter.^[7] Because of cases such as these, as well as urban couples who simply paid a fine (or "social maintenance fee") to have more children,^[8] the overall fertility rate of mainland China is, in fact, closer to two children per family than to one child per family (1.8). In addition, since 2012, Han Chinese in southern Xinjiang were allowed to have two children. This, along with incentives and restrictions against higher Muslim Uyghur fertility, was seen as attempt to counter the threat of Uyghur separatism.^[9]

On 29 October 2015, Xinhua reported the change in the existing law to a two-child policy citing a statement from the Communist Party of China.^[10][11] The new policy allowing Chinese couples to have two children was proposed in order to help address the aging issue in China.^[12] On 27 December 2015, the new law was passed in the session of the National People's Congress Standing Committee, which governs country's laws, effective from 1 January 2016.^[13][14][15]

British Hong Kong

In Hong Kong, the Two is Enough campaign in the 1970s encouraged people to have two or fewer children in each family, contributing to the reduced birth rate in the following decades (poster with actress Fung Bo Bo)

In British Hong Kong, the Eugenics League was founded in 1936, which became The Family Planning Association of Hong Kong in 1950.^[16] The organisation provides family planning advice, sex education, birth control services to the general public of Hong Kong. In the 1970s, due to the rapidly rising population, it launched the "Two is Enough" campaign,^[16] which reduced the general birth rate through educational means. The organisation,^[17] founded the International Planned Parenthood Federation with its counterparts in seven other countries.^[17] The total fertility rate in Hong Kong is currently 1.04 children per woman, one of the lowest in the world.

Iran

Iranian authorities encouraged families in Iran not to have more than two children when conducting Family planning in Iran from early 1990s to late 2006. Iran's government "declared that Islam favored families with only two children", as one historian put it.^[18] when the family planning program initiated where Iran's Health Ministry launched a nationwide campaign and introduced contraceptives - pills, condoms, IUDs, implants, tubal ligations, and vasectomies.^[19] Starting in 2006, the government's population control policy changed when Ahmadinejad called for reversal of Iran's existing policy of "two children is enough"^[20] and later in 2012 Ayatollah Khamenei also stated that Iran's contraceptive policy made sense 20 years ago, "but its continuation in later years was wrong ... Scientific and experts studies show that we will face population aging and reduction (in population) if the birth-control policy continues."^[21]

Singapore

In Singapore, the two-child policy until the 1980s was called "Stop at Two".

United Kingdom

In July 2007, the think tank Optimum Population Trust (now Population Matters) advocated what the Daily Mail described as a "'two-child' policy" to combat population increases and climate change in the United Kingdom. The article stated:

"According to the report, published by the Optimum Population Trust, Britain's high birth rate is a major factor in the current level of climate change, which can only be combatted if families voluntarily limit the number of children they have."^[22]

In October 2012, the Conservative Party's proposed policy of only paying child benefit for the first two children of unemployed parents has been described as a 'two-child policy',^[23] and has been fronted by the Secretary of State for Work and Pensions and former leader of the Conservative Party Iain Duncan Smith.^[24]

Vietnam

Vietnam has had a population policy for over 50 years, launched by the Vietnamese government in the early 1960s in North Vietnam and continues in a modified form today throughout united Vietnam.^[25] The policy emphasizes the official family-size goal to be một hoặc hai con, which means "one or two children."^[26]

In 2014, Vietnam has an estimated population of 92.5 million people, which represents 1.28% of the total world population.^[27] Currently, the total fertility rate of Vietnam is 1.8 (births per woman),^[28] which is below the replacement-level fertility of 2.1, the rate "at which a population exactly replaces itself from one generation to the next" according to the World Resources Institute.^[29]

History

From 1954 to 1975, Vietnam was split into North and South Vietnam along the 17th parallel with separate governments and policies in each region. North Vietnam became the Democratic Republic of Vietnam and had a communist government, whereas South Vietnam became the Republic of Vietnam and was more aligned with the United States and other Western nations.^[30] In 1963, North Vietnam began a policy advocating a two-or-three-child norm due to the sharp population increase of the largely poor and rural population.^[26] Vietnam's family planning policy was developed before those of other countries, such as China and India, the government used a system of information, education, communication (IEC) campaign and publicly accessible contraceptives to curb the population.^[31] After the reunification of North and South Vietnam in 1975 under the Communist Party, there was a governmental effort to extend the policies of the North to the rest of Vietnam, which extended into the next decade.^[32] Though the government of the Republic of Vietnam adopted family planning in general as the official state policy, inadequate medical facilities prevented the policy from being effectively implemented.^[33]

In 1982, the Vietnam government practiced various family planning measures, including the allowance of use of abortion and the creation of the National Committee for Population and Family Planning. After 1983, each family was required to limit the number of children to two. In 1985, the government increased incentives, such as contraceptives and abortion acceptors, and disincentives, such as penalties for violations, for family planning.^[33]

In 1986, the Party implemented the Renovation (Đổi Mới) Policy, which completely reversed the Communist Party economy to implement capitalistic market ideals. The aims of the Renovation Policy were to end Vietnam's economic isolation, increase competitiveness, and raise living standards.^[34] In an attempt to effectively develop the population socioeconomically and increase the standard of living within the population, the Vietnam government emphasized the need to contain birth rates.^[35] In 1988, Council of Ministers issued an in-depth family planning policy, adding additional restrictions beyond the previous restriction of keeping the maximum number of children per household to two.^[36] The detailed one-or-two-child policy of Vietnam was established nine years after China's one-child policy was implemented, and elements of China's policy are reflected in Vietnam's, such as the emphasis on marrying later,^[25] postponing childbearing age (22-years of age or older for women and 24-years of age or older for men),^[36] and spacing out birth of children (3–5 years apart).^[25][36] The state was required to supply free birth control devices (such as intrauterine loops, condoms, and birth control pills) and to provide facilities for individuals who are eligible for abortions.^[36] Furthermore, if families did not comply with the two-child policy, they were required to pay high fees and were unable to move into urban centers.^[36]

In 1993, the Vietnamese government issued the first formalization for the unified Vietnam of the one-to-two child policy as a mandatory national policy. The policy combined advertisements and education to promote a smaller family "so people may enjoy a plentiful and happy life."^[37] The Vietnamese government explicitly linked the family planning policy with "historical and cultural traditions, value structures and development objectives," encouraging a collectivist mindset in which individuals honor the needs of the nation above their own.^[35] The goal of the policy was to reduce the Vietnamese fertility rate to the replacement level of 2.1^[29] by 2015, so that the country could have a stable population during mid-21st century. In 1997, the goal was accelerated to reach the replacement level by 2005, and the government subsequently integrated an increased use of abortion as a means to curb population growth.^[38]

In 2003, the Standing Parliamentary Committee of the National Assembly issued the highest legislative document on population titled the Population Ordinance, which restructured the official family planning policy.^[25] According to the ordinance, couples "shall have the right to decide on the time to have babies, the number of children and the duration between child births."^[39] However, shortly after, the government implemented the National Strategy on Population 2001-2010, which again called for decreasing the fertility rate to the replacement level by 2005. This caused controversy as individuals protested the conflicting messages purported by the government in regards to their reproductive rights.^[25] To address this confusion, the government issued Resolution 47 in 2005 which stated that "to sustain high economic growth, Viet Nam needs to pursue a population control policy until it has become an industrialized country." However at this time, the population had already reached the goal of having a total fertility rate below the replacement level.^[25]

In 2009, the Population Ordinance was amended to again restrict the number of children to be one or two children, although individuals were allowed to decide the timing and spacing of their births.^[40] The government is currently drafting a new Law on Population to replace the Population Ordinance in 2015. However, there is disagreement between policy makers and academics on what should be included in the law.^[41]

Administration

The organizational structure of the two-child policy was housed under different governmental units since its conception in the 1960s. As the policy evolved from "Initiation in the 1960s-1970s; Maturity in the 1980s-1990s; and Legalization in the 2000s-2010s,"^[25] the administration of the population policy also changed. From 1961-1983, the population program fell under the Population and Birth Control Unit. From 1984-2002, it was under the control of National Committee for Population and Family Planning. From 2003-2006, it was in the jurisdiction of the Viet Nam Commission for Population, Family, and Children. Since 2007, the population program has been under the General Office for Population and Family Planning.^[25]

Although the policy was advocated on the national level, the central government did not utilize specific fines or incentives, instead delegating implementation responsibilities to local governments.^[31] Each family was required to have at most two children, and local governments were responsible to decide the details of enforcement. Depending on the specific location, district governments charged fines ranging from 60 to 800 kilograms of paddy rice, equivalent to the worth of a month to a year's wages, for each additional child, and additionally, women who agreed to be sterilized were given bonuses of 120 to 400 kilograms of rice. Individuals who did not use contraceptives sometimes had their names announced over the intercom system of the village to shame them into using them, whereas individuals who did could be selected to win the Labor Medal for "good realization of the population-family planning program."^[31] The government and large companies also regularly denied people who violated the policy of their salaries, promotions, and sometimes even their jobs.^[31]

Current status

Currently, the effective population policy is the revised 2009 Population Ordinance which states that "each couple and individual has the right and responsibility to participate in the campaigns on population and family planning, reproductive health care: (i) decide time and birth spacing; (ii) have one or two children, exceptional cases to be determined by the Government."^[40] Thus, individuals have control over the timing and spacing of the births of their children but are still restricted in the number of children they are allowed to have. Furthermore, later that year, Chief Executive Trương Tấn San stressed the need for continued diligence in population control and stated that the population of Vietnam should be 100 million people by 2020, and suggested that a new comprehensive Law on Population be introduced to the government by 2015.^[25]

Effects of this policy

Reduction of the birthrate

The total fertility rate in Vietnam dropped from 5.6 in 1979 to 3.2 by 1993, suggesting the two-child policy was successful in containing the population growth.^[42] According to one demographic model, the Bongaarts' model of components of fertility, high rates of contraceptive use and of induced abortion are plausible explanations for the decreased fertility rate. Furthermore, because of this policy, the population has fundamentally changed their ideas of the family. In 1988, the Inter-Censal Demographic and Health Survey found that parents wanted an average of 3.3 children, and in 1994, they found that the ideal number of children fell to 2.8.^[42]

However, the reported findings differ depending on the fertility model utilized and on the particular research study cited. The United Nations Economic and Social Council for Asia and the Pacific found that the average number in household was 3.1 in 1998.^[43] In another study conducted by the America-based non-profit, non-governmental organization Population Reference Bureau, the number found was lower at 2.3.^[44] Another study, published in the Worldwide State of the Family in 1995 by Tran Xuan Nhi,^[45] found a contrasting finding that the total fertility rate only dropped slightly and the size of nuclear families experienced only a slight change, dipping from 4.8 to 4.7 from 1989 to 1994.^[43]

Sex-based differences

There is evidence that son preference exists in Vietnam.^[46] Traditionally, men oversee and are responsible for household enterprises, managing agriculture, ancestral worship, and carrying on the family name.^[47] However, although the desire for a son is seen in the Vietnamese family's fertility practices, the desire for more than one son is not.^[47] Families with two daughters are twice as likely to have a third child than families with at least one son, presumably with the hopes that this one will be a boy.^[47] Furthermore, women who do not have any sons are around 15% less likely to use contraceptives than families who have at least one.^[46] There were also increased rates of "contraceptive failure" amongst couples who had a son, as families secretly removed an IUD to bypass the policy in hopes of having a son.^[48] This is consistent with findings from other East Asian countries in which son preference corresponds with a demand for fewer children so that families will have at least one son to maintain the ancestral line.^[46]

Despite the evidence for son preference, there is no clear evidence that Vietnam's sex ratio at birth is increasing, as seen in other East Asian countries, notably China, though evidence is conflicting depending on the source.^[48] In fact, according to the Vietnamese census data for 1989 and 1999, the sex ratios of males to females at birth are actually decreasing.^[48] On the other hand, some sources state that the impact of son preference varies by region of Vietnam. In the north, there is a strong relationship between sex bias in fertility decisions and number of male births, while in the south, this relationship is nonexistent.^[47] However, mothers who pursue certain occupations, such as government cadres and farmers, are more likely to want a particular sex of child and have higher sex-ratio differences at birth. This reflects the pressure for government employees to adhere to the two-child limit, and the perceived necessity of males for manual labor in the farm.^[48]

Criticism

Inadequate contraceptives

Although the policy states that "the state will supply, free of charge, birth control devices... to eligible persons who are cadres, manual workers, civil servants or members of the armed forces... and poor persons who register to practice family planning... The widespread sale of birth control devices will be permitted to facilitate their use by everybody that needs them,"^[49] the only modern contraceptive readily available in Vietnam is the IUD.^[50] However, many women choose not to use it due to the side effects, such as increased bleeding, back and abdominal pains, headache, and general weakness.^[51] Thus, contraceptive use is low among women under the age of 25, and experts have speculated that "contraceptive use among young women might increase if temporary, easy-to-use methods, such as the pill and the condom, were more accessible. For the government to achieve its two-child policy, the survey committee recommends increased promotion of the commercial availability of the condom and the pill, and strengthening of the government family planning program."^[50]

Increased abortion

Abortion rates in Vietnam are unusually high by international standards, with a total abortion rate of at least 2.5 abortions per woman.^[52] Generally, the abortion rate for young age groups is higher than older age groups due to a limited awareness of contraceptive methods and availability. Individuals of lower educational levels also have higher abortion rates.^[53] Vietnam also has some of the world's most liberal abortion laws, though the Vietnamese government is aiming to reduce the number of unwanted pregnancies and abortion-related difficulties.^[54] Although sex-selective abortions were banned by the government in 2006,^[54] there is evidence that suggests that son preference is associated with a higher likelihood of repeat abortions, as women with no sons were significantly less likely to have a repeat abortion compared to women with one son.^[55]

There are multiple factors influencing Vietnam's high abortion rates. First, because women do not have access to contraceptive methods besides IUDs, many do not use effective birth control.^[52] Women who have undergone multiple abortions used short-term methods of contraceptives, such as condoms and contraceptive pills, which are less effective than long-acting contraceptives to which many do not have access.^[55] Secondly, due to the higher costs of raising a child in some geographic areas of Vietnam, abortions have become more acceptable.^[52] Furthermore, the era of modernization and development of free-market reforms since the 1980s has led to a rise in premarital and unwanted pregnancy, and subsequently increased abortion services.^[52] Additionally, the Vietnamese government has insufficient alternatives to abortion within the family planning purposes and a lack of post-abortion contraceptive dialogues for families.^[54] Thus, experts have suggested providing more diverse, long-acting contraceptive alternatives and increasing counseling for families that have experienced an abortion as methods to decrease abortion in Vietnam.^[55]

See also

• One-child policy
• Only child
• Family planning
• Pledge two or fewer (family limitation campaign)
• Family planning in India once implemented two-child policy.

References

1. http://www.britannica.com/topic/one-child-policy
2. CIA World Factbook
3. "计生委新闻发言人:11%以上人口可生两个孩子 (English: "Spokesperson of the one-child policy committee: 11% or more of the population may have two children)" (in Chinese). Sina.com. 10 July 2007. Retrieved 7 November 2008.
4. Patti Waldmeir (2013-11-15). "China's 'one-child' rethink marks symbolic shift". FT. Retrieved 2013-11-19.
5. Ouyang, Y. (2013). "China relaxes its one-child policy". The Lancet 382 (9907): e28–e30. doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(13)62544-1.
6. http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2014-07/10/content_17706811.htm
7. Yardley, Jim (11 May 2008). "China Sticking With One-Child Policy". The New York Times. Retrieved 20 November 2008.
8. "New rich challenge family planning policy." Xinhua.
9. "The government in Xinjiang is trying to limit Muslim births". The Economist. 7 November 2015. Retrieved 10 November 2015.
10. "China to end one-child policy and allow two". BBC. 29 October 2015.
11. "China to allow two children for all couples". Xinhua. 29 October 2015.
12. "News Analysis: Two-child policy calls for better public services - Xinhua | English.news.cn". news.xinhuanet.com. Retrieved 2015-10-31.
13. "Top legislature amends law to allow all couples to have two children". Xinhua News Agency. 27 December 2015.
14. "China officially ends one-child policy, signing into law bill allowing married couples to have two children". ABC Online. 27 December 2015.
15. "China: 1 child policy ends officially, bill allowing 2nd child signed". Hindustan Times. 27 December 2015.
16. History of the Family Planning Association of Hong Kong
17. History of International Planned Parenthood Federation
18. Abrahamian, History of Modern Iran, (2008), p.184
19. Sciolino, Elaine, Persian Mirrors : the Elusive Face of Iran, Free Press, 2000, 2005 (p.282)
20. Prospects for Ahmadinejad’s Call for More Rapid Population Growth in Iran Tait, Robert (October 23, 2006). "Ahmadinejad urges Iranian baby boom to challenge west". Guardian Unlimited (London: The Guardian). Retrieved 2010-03-03.
21. "Iran urges baby boom, slashes birth-control programs". usatoday. Retrieved 3 July 2015.
22. Firth, Niall (11 July 2007). "Families should have no more than two children - thinktank". London: The Daily Mail. Retrieved 29 October 2012.
23. Ramesh, Randeep (25 October 2012). "Two-child benefits policy targets the strivers in low-paid jobs". London: The Guardian. Retrieved 29 October 2012.
24. Grice, Andrew (26 October 2012). "What is Iain Duncan Smith's two-child policy?". London: The Independent. Retrieved 29 October 2012.
25. Pham, Bang Nguyen; Hill, Peter S; Hall, Wayne; Rao, Chalapati. "The Evolution of Population Policy in Viet Nam". School of Population Health, University of Queensland. Retrieved 12 March 2015.
26. Goodkind, Daniel (March 1995). "Vietnam's One-or-Two-Child Policy in Action". Population and Development Review 21 (1): 85–111. doi:10.2307/2137414. Retrieved 12 March 2015.
27. "Vietnam Population (Live)". Worldometers. Retrieved 12 March 2015.
28. "Fertility rate, total (births per woman)". World Bank. World Bank. Retrieved 12 March 2015.
29. Searchinger, Tim; Hanson, Craig; Waite, Richard; Lipinski, Brian; Leeson, George; Harper, Sarah. "Achieving Replacement Level Fertility". World Resources Institute. World Resources Institute.
30. Langguth, A.J. (March 12, 2002). Our Vietnam: The War 1954-1975. Simon & Schuster. p. 671. ISBN 0-7432-1231-2.
31. Knudsen, Lara (June 30, 2006). Reproductive Rights in a Global Context: South Africa, Uganda, Peru, Denmark, United States, Vietnam, Jordan (1 ed.). Vanderbilt University Press. pp. 139–168. ISBN 0-8265-1528-2.
32. Allman, James; Vu, Qui Nhan; Nguyen, Minh Thang; Pham, Bich San (September 1991). "Fertility and Family Planning in Vietnam". Studies in Family Planning 22 (5): 308–317. doi:10.2307/1966685.
33. "Viet Nam". United Nations. Retrieved 19 April 2015.
34. Freeman, Donald (April 1996). "Doi Moi Policy and the Small-Enterprise Boom in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam". Geographical Review 86 (2): 178–197. doi:10.2307/215955.
35. Bruun, Ole; Jacobsen, Michael (2 September 2000). Human Rights and Asian Values: Contesting National Identities and Cultural Representations in Asia. Psychology Press. pp. 161–180. ISBN 0-7007-1212-7.
36. "Vietnam's New Fertility Policy". Population and Development Review 15 (1): 169–172. Mar 1989. doi:10.2307/1973424.
37. "Resolution of 1993 on Policy Concerning the Population and Family Planning Work". Hanoi Voice of Vietnam Network. Retrieved 12 March 2015.
38. May, John F. (March 30, 2012). World Population Policies: Their Origin, Evolution, and Impact. Springer. pp. 139–145. ISBN 94-007-2836-0.
39. "Population Ordinance (6/2003)". The Standing Committee of National Assembly.
40. "Ordinance No. 08/2008". Retrieved 12 March 2015.
41. Pham, Bang Nguyen (2014). "The Demographic Transition and Implications for the New Law on Population in Vietnam". Asian Population Studies 10 (3): 237–240. doi:10.1080/17441730.2014.955162.
42. Haughton, Jonathan (1997). "Falling Fertility in Vietnam". Population Studies: A Journal of Demography 51 (2): 203–211. doi:10.1080/0032472031000149916.
43. Wisensale, Steven (2000). "Family Policy in a Changing Vietnam". Journal of Comparative Family Studies 31 (1): 79–90.
44. "An Overview of Population and Development in Vietnam". Population Reference Bureau. Retrieved 19 April 2015.
45. Nhi, Tran Xuan. "Vietnam's families". Worldwide State of the Family.
46. Haughton, Jonathan; Haughton, Dominique (1995). "Son Preference in Vietnam". Studies in Family Planning 26 (6): 325–337. doi:10.2307/2138098.
47. Guilmoto, Christophe Z. (March 2012). "Son Preference, Sex Selection, and Kinship in Vietnam". Population and Development Review 38 (1): 31–54. doi:10.1111/j.1728-4457.2012.00471.x.
48. Belanger, Daniele; Khuat, Thi Hai Oanh; Liu, Jianye; Le, Thanh Thuy; Pham, Viet Thanh (2003). "Are Sex Ratios at Birth Increasing in Vietnam?". Population 58: 231–250. doi:10.2307/3246604.
49. "Vietnam's New Fertility Policy". Population and Development Review 15 (1): 169–172. February 1989. doi:10.2307/1973424.
50. Edwards, S. (September 1992). "In Vietnam, Contraceptive Awareness High, Use Low Despite Two-Child Policy". International Family Planning Perspectives 18 (3): 117–119. doi:10.2307/2133412.
51. Johansson, Annika; Le, Thi Nham Tuyet; Nguyen, Lap; Kajsa, Sundstrom (September 1996). "Abortion in Context: Women's Experience in Two Villages in Thai Binh Province, Vietnam". International Family Planning Perspectives 22 (3): 103–107. doi:10.2307/2950750.
52. Goodkind, Daniel (December 1994). "Abortion in Vietnam: Measurements, Puzzles, and Concerns". Studies in Family Planning 25 (6): 342–352. doi:10.2307/2137878.
53. Nguyen, Thanh Binh (January 2012). "Abortion in Present Day Vietnam". International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences 2 (1): 56–62.
54. Whittaker, Andrea (2012). Abortion in Asia: Local Dilemmas, Global Politics. Berghahn Books. ISBN 0-85745-795-0.
55. Ngo, Thoai D.; Keogh, Sarah; Nguyen, Thang H.; Le, Hoan T.; Pham, Kiet H. T.; Nguyen, Yen B.T. (June 2014). "Risk factors for repeat abortion and implications for addressing unintended pregnancy in Vietnam". International Journal of Gynecology & Obstetrics 125 (3): 241–246. doi:10.1016/j.ijgo.2013.11.014.

Further reading

• Fong, Mei (2015). One Child: The Past And Future Of China’s Most Radical Experiment. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt. ISBN 0-544-27539-X.