European Stability Mechanism

European Stability Mechanism

Logo of the ESM
ESM member states   Other EU member states
Formation	27 September 2012
Type	IGO
Legal status	Treaty Establishing the European Stability Mechanism
Headquarters	Luxembourg City, Luxembourg 49°38′07″N 6°10′06″E / 49.63529°N 6.1684°ECoordinates: 49°38′07″N 6°10′06″E / 49.63529°N 6.1684°E
Membership	19 (all Member States of the eurozone)
Managing Director	Klaus Regling[1]
President of the Board of Governors	Jeroen Dijsselbloem
Organs	Board of Governors Board of Directors
Staff	122 by 31 December 2014[1]
Website	esm.europa.eu

The European Stability Mechanism (ESM) is an intergovernmental organization located in Luxembourg City, which operate under public international law for all eurozone Member States having ratified a special ESM intergovernmental treaty. It was established on 27 September 2012 as a permanent firewall for the eurozone, to safeguard and provide instant access to financial assistance programmes for member states of the eurozone in financial difficulty, with a maximum lending capacity of €500 billion.

It replaces two earlier temporary EU funding programmes: the European Financial Stability Facility (EFSF) and the European Financial Stabilisation Mechanism (EFSM). All new bailouts for any eurozone member state will now be covered by ESM, while the EFSF and EFSM will continue to handle money transfers and programme monitoring for the previously approved bailout loans to Ireland, Portugal and Greece.

The Treaty Establishing the European Stability Mechanism stipulated that the organization would be established if member states representing 90% of its capital requirements ratified the founding treaty.^[2] This threshold was surpassed with Germany's completion of the ratification process on 27 September 2012, which brought the treaty into force on that date for sixteen of the seventeen members of the eurozone. The remaining state, Estonia, which had only committed 0.19% of the capital, completed its ratification on 4 October 2012.^[3] A separate treaty, amending Article 136 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU) to authorize the establishment of the ESM under EU law, was planned to enter into force on 1 January 2013. However, the last of the then-27 European Union member states to complete their ratification of this amendment, the Czech Republic, did not do so until 23 April 2013, postponing its entry into force until 1 May 2013.^[4]

The ESM commenced its operations after an inaugural meeting on 8 October 2012.^[5][6] The first 40% of the paid-in capital was transferred by all ESM member states ahead of a treaty regulated deadline of 12 October 2012.^[7] ESM member states can apply for a bailout if they are in financial difficulty or their financial sector is a stability threat in need of recapitalization. ESM bailouts are conditional on member states first signing a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU), outlining a programme for the needed reforms or fiscal consolidation to be implemented in order to restore the financial stability. Another precondition for receiving an ESM bailout is that the member state must have ratified the European Fiscal Compact. When applying for ESM support, the country in concern is analyzed and evaluated on all relevant financial stability matters by the so-called Troika (European Commission, ECB and IMF) in order to decide which of its five different kinds of support programmes should be offered.^[8] As of April 2013, the ESM has approved two Financial Assistance Facility Agreement (FAFA) programmes, with up till €100bn earmarked for recapitalization of Spanish Banks,^[9] and €9bn in disbursements for Cyprus for a sovereign state bailout programme. The Cyprus bank recapitalization was funded by converting bank deposits into equity.^[10][11]

History

Following the European sovereign debt crisis that resulted in the lending of money to EU states, there has been a drive to reform the functioning of the eurozone in the event of a crisis. This led to the creation, amongst other things, of a loan (pejoratively called "bailout" in the media) mechanism: the European Financial Stability Facility (EFSF) and the European Financial Stability Mechanism (EFSM). These, together with the International Monetary Fund, would lend money to EU states in trouble, in the same way that the European Central Bank can lend money to European banks. However, the EFSF and EFSM were intended only as a temporary measure (to expire in 2013), in part due to the lack of a legal basis in the EU treaties.

In order to resolve the issue, the German government felt a treaty amendment would be required. After the difficult ratification of the Treaty of Lisbon, many states and statesmen opposed reopening treaty amendment and the British government opposes changes affecting the United Kingdom.^[12][13] However, after winning the support of French President Nicolas Sarkozy^[14] Germany won support from the European Council in October 2010 for a new treaty. It would be a minimal amendment to strengthen sanctions and create a permanent lending-out mechanism. It would not fulfil the German demand to have the removal of voting rights as a sanction as that would require deeper treaty amendment. The treaty would be designed so there would be no need for referendums, providing the basis for a speedy ratification process, with the aim to have it completely ratified and come into force in July 2012. In that case, it was to co-exist with the temporary lending-out mechanism (EFSF) for one year, as EFSF was set only to expire as a rescue facility at 1 July 2013.^[2]

Treaty basis

Article 136 amendment of TFEU

On 16 December 2010 the European Council agreed a two line amendment to Article 136 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU),^[15] that would give the ESM legal legitimacy^[16] and was designed to avoid any referendums. The amendment simply changes the EU treaties to allow for a permanent mechanism to be established.^[17] In March of the following year leaders also agreed to a separate eurozone-only treaty that would create the ESM itself.^[18]

In March 2011, the European Parliament approved the treaty amendment after receiving assurances that the European Commission, rather than EU states, would play 'a central role' in running the ESM, despite wishing it had been more involved earlier,^[19][20] and it was signed by all 27 EU member states on 25 March 2011. The amendment reads:

“

The member states whose currency is the euro may establish a stability mechanism to be activated if indispensable to safeguard the stability of the euro area as a whole. The granting of any required financial assistance under the mechanism will be made subject to strict conditionality.

”

The amendment authorises the eurozone countries to establish a stability mechanism to protect the common currency, within EU law. This mean, that the existing intergovernmental treaty having established ESM outside of the EU framework with entry into force 27 September 2012, might subsequently be transposed to become part of the EU framework once this TFEU article 136 amendment enters into force. The ESM established by the intergovernmental treaty was designed to be fully compatible with existing EU law, and the European Court of Justice ruled in November 2012 - that "the right of a Member State to conclude and ratify the ESM Treaty is not subject to the entry into force" of the TFEU amendment.^[21] The TFEU amendment came into force on 1 May 2013, after the Czech Republic became the last member state to ratify the agreement according to its respective constitutional requirements.^[4]

In June 2015, an updated EMU reform plan was released which envisaged that in the medium-term (between July 2017 and 2025) the ESM should be transposed from being an intergovernmental agreement to become fully integrated into the EU law framework applying to all eurozone member states under the competence provided for by the amended article 136 of the TFEU.^[22]

Treaty Establishing the European Stability Mechanism

In addition to the "TFEU amendment" treaty, the European Stability Mechanism itself was established by a treaty among the eurozone states, named the Treaty Establishing the European Stability Mechanism, which sets out the details of how the ESM would operate. Formally, two treaties with this name were signed: one on 11 July 2011 and one on 2 February 2012, after the first turned out not to be substantial enough the second version was produced to "make it more effective".^[23] The 2012 version was signed by all 17 Eurozone members on 2 February 2012, and was planned to be ratified and enter force by mid-2012, when the EFSF and EFSM were set to expire. The treaty was concluded exclusively by eurozone states, amongst others because the UK refused to participate in any fiscal integration.^[24][25]

The Treaty establishing the ESM entered into force on 27 September 2012 for 16 signatories.^[3] Estonia completed their ratification on 3 October 2012, six days after the treaty entered into force. However, the inaugural meeting of the ESM didn't occur until 8 October, after the treaty's entry into force for Estonia.^[3] Latvia's adoption of the euro on 1 January 2014 was given final approval by the Economic and Financial Affairs Council on 9 July,^[26][27] making them eligible to apply for ESM membership.^[28] Following Latvia's government giving their consent to joining to the ESM in November 2013,^[29] the acceded on 21 February 2014.^[3] The treaty entered into force for them on 13 March 2014.^[3] Latvia's contribution to the ESM will be €325 million.^[30] Lithuania adopted the euro on 1 January 2015, and acceded to the ESM on 14 January 2015. They became a member on 3 February 2015.^[3]

Organization

The ESM is an intergovernmental organization established under public international law, and located in Luxembourg City. It has about 145 personnel, who are also responsible for the EFSF. The organization is led by a managing director appointed for a 5-year term. The first managing director Klaus Regling was appointed in 2012.

Each member state appoints a governor (and alternate) for the board of governors, which can either be chaired by the President of the Euro Group or by a separate elected chair from amongst the governors themselves.^[7][18] In 2012, Jean-Claude Juncker (Luxembourg) was appointed to this position.^[31] The board consists of Ministers of Finance of the member states. The Board of Directors consists 17 members "of high competence in economic and financial matters". Each member state appoints one Director and an alternate.^[31]

Financial support instruments

ESM member states can apply for an ESM bailout if they are in financial difficulty or their financial sector is a stability threat in need of recapitalization. ESM bailouts are conditional on member states first signing a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU), outlining a programme for the needed reforms or fiscal consolidation to be implemented in order to restore the financial stability. Another precondition for receiving an ESM bailout, starting from 1 March 2013, will be that the member state must have fully ratified the European Fiscal Compact. When applying for ESM support, the country in concern will be analyzed and evaluated on all relevant financial stability matters by the so-called Troika (European Commission, ECB and IMF) in order to decide if one/several of these 5 different kind of support programmes should be offered:^[32]

1. Stability support loan within a macro-economic adjustment programme (Sovereign Bailout Loan):
   "To be granted if it is no longer sustainable for the state to draw on capital markets, when seeking to cover the states financial needs. The signed conditional MoU agreement will focus on requirements for fiscal consolidation and structural reforms to improve the sovereign financial stability."
2. Bank recapitalisation programme:
   "To be granted if the roots of a crisis situation are primarily located in the financial sector and not directly related to fiscal or structural policies at the state level, with the government seeking to finance a recapitalisation at sustainable borrowing costs. ESM will only offer a bank recapitalisation support package, if it can be established that neither the private market nor the member state will be able to conduct the needed recapitalisation on their own, without causing increased financial stress/instability. The size of the needed recapitalisation shall be determined by a stress test, calculating the amount needed for a complete financial sector repair to eliminate all vulnerabilities. Support from this ESM package is earmarked for bank recapitalisation, and can not be used for any other purpose. The signed conditional MoU agreement will likewise only cover requirements for reform/changes to the financial sector, within the domains of financial supervision, corporate governance and domestic laws relating to restructuring/resolution."
3. Precautionary financial assistance (PCCL/ECCL):
   "Comprise support in the form of setting up available "credit lines" the ESM member state can draw on if suddenly needed. This support shall be offered to ESM members whose economic conditions are currently sound enough to maintain continuous access to market financing, but being in a fragile situation calling for the setup of an adequate safety-net (financial guarantee), to help ensure a continued access to market financing. The signed conditional MoU agreement will focus on requirements for fiscal consolidation and structural reforms to improve the sovereign financial stability."
4. Primary Market Support Facility (PMSF):
   "Bond purchase operations in the primary market could be made by ESM, in complement to offering regular loans under a macro-economic adjustment programme or to drawdown of funds under a precautionary programme. This instrument would be used primarily towards the end of an adjustment programme to facilitate a country’s return to draw on the market, and reduce the risk of a failed bond auction. The aim is for the private market to subscribe to 50% of the bond auction while ESM cover the remaining 50%. If the participation of the private market proves to be insignificant the PMSF will be cancelled, and replaced by an extra transfer of funds from the macro-economic/precautionary programme. There will be no additional MoU agreement for this support package, as the conditions will be identical to the pre-existing Sovereign bailout loan / Precautionary programme."
5. Secondary Market Support Facility (SMSF):
   "This facility aims to support the good functioning of the government debt markets of ESM Members in exceptional circumstances where the lack of market liquidity threatens financial stability, with a risk of pushing sovereign interest rates towards unsustainable levels and creating refinancing problems for the banking system of the ESM Member concerned. An ESM secondary market intervention is intended to enable market-making that would ensure some debt market liquidity and incentivise investors to further participate in the financing of ESM Members. The instrument can be offered either as a stand alone support, or in combination with support from any of the other 4 instruments. No additional MoU agreement will be needed for ESM members already receiving a Sovereign bailout loan/Precautionary programme; but a non-programme country (being sound in regards of financial stability; except for thef liquidity issue), will obviously need to sign a MoU agreement with the policy conditions outlined by the European Commission in liaison with the ECB."

In order to further help increase the financial stability of the eurozone, the ECB decided on 6 September 2012 to automatically run a free unlimited amount of yield-lowering bond purchases (OMT support programme) for all eurozone countries involved in a sovereign state bailout or precautionary programme from EFSF/ESM, if -and for as long as- the country is found to suffer from stressed bond yields at excessive levels; but only at the point of time where the country possesses/regain a complete market funding access -and only if the country still complies with all terms in the signed MoU-agreement.^[33][34] Countries receiving a precautionary programme rather than a sovereign bailout, will per definition have complete market access and thus qualify for OMT support if also suffering from stressed interest rates on its government bonds. In regards of countries receiving a sovereign bailout (Ireland, Portugal and Greece), they will on the other hand not qualify for OMT support before they have regained complete market access, which the ECB define as the moment when the state succeeds to issue a new ten-year government bond series at the private capital market.^[33][35]

Initially, EFSF and ESM were only allowed to offer financial stability loans directly to sovereign states, meaning that offered bank recapitalisation packages were first paid to the state and then transferred to the suffering financial sector; and thus these type of loans were accounted for as national debt of the sovereign state - adversely impacting its gross debt-to-GDP ratio and credit rating. In example, this regime was utilized when ESM established a bank recapitalization support programme for Spain in 2012-13. On the EU summit on 19 October 2012, it was decided that ESM bank recapitalisation packages in the future (starting from the date when ECBs new supervision unit for the financial sector has been set to commence operations: 4 November 2014^[36]), instead only shall by paid directly to the financial sector, so that it no longer counts as state debt in the statistics.^[37][38] ESM made the decided "direct bank recapitalization" framework operational starting from December 2014, as a new novel ultimate backstop instrument to apply for systemic banks in their recovery/resolution phase, if such banks will be found in need to receive additional recapitalization funds after conducted bail-in by private creditors and regulated payment by the Single Resolution Fund.^[39] In this way, the primary backstop to patch future uncovered recapitalization needs of a failing systemic bank will be provided by bail-in of private creditors along with contributions from the Single Resolution Fund (as regulated by the Bank Recovery and Resolution Directive), while the ESM "direct bank recapitalization" instrument only will be needed as an "ultimate backstop" for the most extreme cases where the primary backstop funds are found to be insufficient.

Contributions

Distribution of contributions

  Germany (27.1464%)

  France (20.3859%)

  Italy (17.9137%)

  Spain (11.9037%)

  Netherlands (5.7170%)

  Belgium (3.4771%)

  Greece (2.8167%)

  Austria (2.7834%)

  Portugal (2.5092%)

  Finland (1.7974%)

  Ireland (1.5922%)

  Slovakia (0.8240%)

  Slovenia (0.4276%)

  Luxemburg (0.2504%)

  Cyprus (0.1962%)

  Other (0.2591%)

The ESM is expected to have an authorised capital of 700 billion euros of which 80 billion is paid-in capital, and the remaining 620 billion -if needed- will be loaned through the issuance of some special ESM obligations at the capital markets.^[7] The ESM treaty foresees a payment of the capital in five annual instalments, but the Eurogroup decided on 30 March 2012 that capital payments shall be accelerated and all the capital paid by the first half of 2014.^[40] The following table shows the part each member state has to pay following the ESM treaty.

ESM member state	Percentage of contributions	Paid-in capital (million €)	Number of shares	Capital subscription (million €)	Nominal GDP 2010 (million US$)
Germany	27.1464	21,717.1	1,900,248	190,024.8	3,315,643
France	20.3859	16,308.7	1,427,013	142,701.3	2,582,527
Italy	17.9137	14,331.0	1,253,959	125,395.9	2,055,114
Spain	11.9037	9,523.0	833,259	83,325.9	1,409,946
Netherlands	5.7170	4,573.6	400,190	40,019.0	783,293
Belgium	3.4771	2,781.7	243,397	24,339.7	465,676
Greece	2.8167	2,253.4	197,169	19,716.9	305,415
Austria	2.7834	2,226.7	194,838	19,483.8	376,841
Portugal	2.5092	2,007.4	175,644	17,564.4	229,336
Finland	1.7974	1,437.9	125,818	12,581.8	239,232
Ireland	1.5922	1,273.8	111,454	11,145.4	204,261
Slovakia	0.8240	659.2	57,680	5,768.0	86,262
Slovenia	0.4276	342.1	29,932	2,993.2	46,442
Luxembourg	0.2504	200.3	17,528	1,752.8	52,433
Cyprus	0.1962	157.0	13,734	1,373.4	22,752
Estonia	0.1860	148.8	13,020	1,302.0	19,220
Malta	0.0731	58.5	5,117	511.7	7,801
Total	100.0	80,000	7,000,000	700,000	12,202,194

At the moment when ESM has received all its paid-in capital from the eurozone countries, the ESM will be authorized to approve bailout deals for a maximum amount of €500 billion, with the remaining €200 billion of the fund being earmarked as safely invested capital reserve, in order to guarantee the issuance of ESM bonds will always get the highest AAA credit rating, with the lowest possible interest rate at the current time.^[7] 40% of the paid-in capital shall be transferred on 12 October 2012, with the remaining three times of 20% transfers scheduled for Q2-2013, Q4-2013 and Q2-2014. As the ESM lending capacity depends on the amount of paid-in capital, it will start out only to be €200bn in Q4-2012, and then be increased with €100bn each time one of the remaining three capital transfers ticks in. If needed, a majority of the ESM board can also decide to accelerate the payment schedule.^[41] On 1 May 2013, ESM has reconfirmed the schedule for receiving paid-in capital, with the third tranch already received in April 2013 followed by the fourth in October 2013, with the final fifth tranch scheduled for April 2014.^[42]

Lending activities

The Troika currently negotiates with Spain and Cyprus, about setting up an economic recovery programme in return of providing support with financial loans from ESM. Cyprus so far applied both for a €6bn sovereign bailout loan and a €5bn bank recapitalisation package.^[43] Cyprus could however perhaps also be interested in additional support packages from instrument 3/4/5. Reportedly Spain beside of applying for a €100bn bank recapitalisation package in June 2012,^[7] now also follow a path of negotiations to get financial support from a Precautionary Conditioned Credit Line (PCCL) package.^[44] If Spain will apply and receive a PCCL package, irrespectively to what extent it subsequently decides to draw on this established credit line, this would at the same time immediately qualify the country also to receive "free" additional financial support from ECB, in the form of some yield-lowering bond purchases (OMT).^[45][46]

Bailout programmes for EU members since 2008

The table below provides an overview of the financial composition of all bailout programs being initiated for EU member states, since the Global Financial Crisis erupted in September 2008. EU member states outside the eurozone (marked with yellow in the table) have no access to the funds provided by EFSF/ESM, but can be covered with rescue loans from EU's Balance of Payments programme (BoP), IMF and bilateral loans (with an extra possible assistance from the Worldbank/EIB/EBRD if classified as a development country). Since October 2012, the ESM as a permanent new financial stability fund to cover any future potential bailout packages within the eurozone, has effectively replaced the now defunct GLF + EFSM + EFSF funds. Whenever pledged funds in a scheduled bailout program were not transferred in full, the table has noted this by writing "Y out of X".

EU member	Time span	IMF[7][47] (billion €)	World Bank[47] (billion €)	EIB / EBRD (billion €)	Bilateral[7] (billion €)	BoP[47] (billion €)	GLF[48] (billion €)	EFSM[7] (billion €)	EFSF[7] (billion €)	ESM[7] (billion €)	Bailout in total (billion €)
Cyprus I^1	Dec.2011-Dec.2012	-	-	-	2.5	-	-	-	-	-	002.5^1
Cyprus II^2	May 2013-Mar.2016	001.0	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	009.0	010.0^2
Greece I+II^3	May 2010-Jun.2015	032.1 out of 48.1	-	-	-	-	52.9	-	130.9 out of 144.6	-	215.9 out of 245.6^3
Greece III^4	Aug.2015-Aug.2018	0(proportion of 86, to be decided Oct.2015)	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	(up till 86)	086^4
Hungary^5	Nov.2008-Oct.2010	009.1 out of 12.5	1.0	-	-	5.5 out of 6.5	-	-	-	-	015.6 out of 20.0^5
Ireland^6	Nov.2010-Dec.2013	022.5	-	-	4.8	-	-	022.5	018.4	-	068.2^6
Latvia^7	Dec.2008-Dec.2011	001.1 out of 1.7	0.4	0.1	0.0 out of 2.2	2.9 out of 3.1	-	-	-	-	004.5 out of 7.5^7
Portugal^8	May 2011-Jun 2014	026.5 out of 27.4	-	-	-	-	-	024.3 out of 25.6	026.0	-	076.8 out of 79.0^8
Romania I^9	May 2009-Jun 2011	012.6 out of 13.6	1.0	1.0	-	5.0	-	-	-	-	019.6 out of 20.6^9
Romania II^10	Mar 2011-Jun 2013	000.0 out of 3.6	1.15	-	-	0.0 out of 1.4	-	-	-	-	001.15 out of 6.15^10
Romania III^11	Oct 2013-Sep 2015	000.0 out of 2.0	2.5	-	-	0.0 out of 2.0	-	-	-	-	002.5 out of 6.5^11
Spain^12	July 2012-Dec.2013	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	041.3 out of 100	041.3 out of 100^12
Total payment	Nov.2008-Aug.2018	104.9	6.05	1.1	7.3	13.4	52.9	46.8	175.3	136.3	544.05

^1 Cyprus received in late December 2011 a €2.5bn bilateral emergency bailout loan from Russia, to cover its governmental budget deficits and a refinancing of maturing governmental debts until 31 December 2012.[49][50][51] Initially the bailout loan was supposed to be fully repaid in 2016, but as part of establishment of the later following second Cypriot bailout programme, Russia accepted a delayed repayment in eight biannual tranches throughout 2018-2021 - while also lowering its requested interest rate from 4.5% to 2.5%.[52]

^2 When it became evident Cyprus needed an additional bailout loan to cover the government's fiscal operations throughout 2013-2015, on top of additional funding needs for recapitalization of the Cypriot financial sector, negotiations for such an extra bailout package started with the Troika in June 2012.[53][54][55] In December 2012 a preliminary estimate indicated, that the needed overall bailout package should have a size of €17.5bn, comprising €10bn for bank recapitalisation and €6.0bn for refinancing maturing debt plus €1.5bn to cover budget deficits in 2013+2014+2015, which in total would have increased the Cypriot debt-to-GDP ratio to around 140%.[56] The final agreed package however only entailed a €10bn support package, financed partly by IMF (€1bn) and ESM (€9bn),[11] because it was possible to reach a fund saving agreement with the Cypriot authorities, featuring a direct closure of the most troubled Laiki Bank and a forced bail-in recapitalisation plan for Bank of Cyprus.[57][58] The final conditions for activation of the bailout package was outlined by the Troika's MoU agreement in April 2013, and include: 1) Recapitalisation of the entire financial sector while accepting a closure of the Laiki bank, 2) Implementation of the anti-money laundering framework in Cypriot financial institutions, 3) Fiscal consolidation to help bring down the Cypriot governmental budget deficit, 4) Structural reforms to restore competitiveness and macroeconomic imbalances, 5) Privatization programme. The Cypriot debt-to-GDP ratio is on this background now forecasted only to peak at 126% in 2015 and subsequently decline to 105% in 2020, and thus considered to remain within sustainable territory. The €10bn bailout comprise €4.1bn spend on debt liabilities (refinancing and amortization), 3.4bn to cover fiscal deficits, and €2.5bn for the bank recapitalization. These amounts will be paid to Cyprus through regular tranches from 13 May 2013 until 31 March 2016. According to the programme this will be sufficient, as Cyprus during the programme period in addition will: Receive €1.0bn extraordinary revenue from privatization of government assets, ensure an automatic roll-over of €1.0bn maturing Treasury Bills and €1.0bn of maturing bonds held by domestic creditors, bring down the funding need for bank recapitalization with €8.7bn - of which 0.4bn is reinjection of future profit earned by the Cyprus Central Bank (injected in advance at the short term by selling its gold reserve) and €8.3bn origin from the bail-in of creditors in Laiki bank and Bank of Cyprus.[59] The forced automatic rollover of maturing bonds held by domestic creditors were conducted in 2013, and equaled according to some credit rating agencies a "selective default" or "restrictive default", mainly because of the fact that the fixed yields of the new bonds did not reflect the market rates - while maturities at the same time automatically were extended.[52]

^3 Many sources list the first bailout was €110bn followed by the second on €130bn. When you deduct €2.7bn due to Ireland+Portugal+Slovakia opting out as creditors for the first bailout, and add the extra €8.2bn IMF has promised to pay Greece for the years in 2015-16 (through a programme extension implemented in December 2012), the total amount of bailout funds sums up to €245.6bn.[48][60] The first bailout resulted in a payout of €20.1bn from IMF and €52.9bn from GLF, during the course of May 2010 until December 2011,[48] and then it was technically replaced by a second bailout package for 2012-2016, which had a size of €172.6bn (€28bn from IMF and €144.6bn from EFSF), as it included the remaining committed amounts from the first bailout package.[61] All committed IMF amounts were made available to the Greek government for financing its continued operation of public budget deficits and to refinance maturing public debt held by private creditors and IMF. The payments from EFSF were earmarked to finance €35.6bn of PSI restructured government debt (as part of a deal where private investors in return accepted a nominal haircut, lower interest rates and longer maturities for their remaining principal), €48.2bn for bank recapitalization,[60] €11.3bn for a second PSI debt buy-back,[62] while the remaining €49.5bn were made available to cover continued operation of public budget deficits.[63] The combined programme was scheduled to expire in March 2016, after IMF had extended their programme period with extra loan tranches from January 2015 to March 2016 (as a mean to help Greece service the total sum of interests accruing during the lifespan of already issued IMF loans), while the Eurogroup at the same time opted to conduct their reimbursement and deferral of interests outside their bailout programme framework - with the EFSF programme still being planned to end in December 2014.[64] Due to the refusal by the Greek government to comply with the agreed conditional terms for receiving a continued flow of bailout transfers, both IMF and the Eurogroup opted to freeze their programmes since August 2014. To avoid a technical expiry, the Eurogroup postponed the expiry date for its frozen programme to 30 June 2015, paving the way within this new deadline for the possibility of transfer terms first to be renegotiated and then finally complied with to ensure completion of the programme.[64] As Greece withdrew unilaterally from the process of settling renegotiated terms and time extension for the completion of the programme, it expired uncompleted on 30 June 2015. Hereby, Greece lost the possibility to extract €13.7bn of remaining funds from the EFSF (€1.0bn unused PSI and Bond Interest facilities, €10.9bn unused bank recapitalization funds and a €1.8bn frozen tranche of macroeconomic support),[65][66] and also lost the remaining SDR 13.561bn of IMF funds[67] (being equal to €16.0bn as per the SDR exchange rate on 5 Jan 2012[68]), although those lost IMF funds might be recouped if Greece settles an agreement for a new third bailout programme with ESM - and passes the first review of such programme.

^4 A new third bailout programme worth €86bn in total, jointly covered by funds from IMF and ESM, will be disbursed in tranches from August 2015 until August 2018.[69] The programme was approved to be negotiated on 17 July 2015,[70] and approved in full detail by the publication of an ESM facility agreement on 19 August 2015.[71][72] IMF's transfer of the "remainder of its frozen I+II programme" and their new commitment also to contribute with a part of the funds for the third bailout, depends on a successful prior completion of the first review of the new third programme in October 2015.[73] Due to a matter of urgency, EFSM immediately conducted a temporary €7.16bn emergency transfer to Greece on 20 July 2015,[74][75] which was fully overtaken by ESM when the first tranche of the third program was conducted 20 August 2015.[72] Due to being temporary bridge financing and not part of an official bailout programme, the table do not display this special type of EFSM transfer. The loans of the program has an average maturity of 32.5 years and carry a variable interest rate (currently at 1%). The program has earmarked transfer of up till €25bn for bank recapitalization purposes (to be used to the extent deemed needed by the annual stress tests of the SSM), and also include establishment of a new privatization fund to conduct sale of Greek public assets - of which the first generated €25bn will be used for early repayment of the bailout loans earmarked for bank recapitalizations. Potential debt relief for Greece, in the form of longer grace and payment periods, will be considered by the European public creditors after the first review of the new programme, by October/November 2015.[72]

^5 Hungary recovered faster than expected, and thus did not receive the remaining €4.4bn bailout support scheduled for October 2009-October 2010.[47][76] IMF paid in total 7.6 out of 10.5 billion SDR,[77] equal to €9.1bn out of €12.5bn at current exchange rates.[78]

^6 In Ireland the National Treasury Management Agency also paid €17.5bn for the program on behalf of the Irish government, of which €10bn were injected by the National Pensions Reserve Fund and the remaining €7.5bn paid by "domestic cash resources",[79] which helped increase the program total to €85bn.[7] As this extra amount by technical terms is an internal bail-in, it has not been added to the bailout total. As of 31 March 2014 all committed funds had been transferred, with EFSF even paing €0.7bn more, so that the total amount of funds had been marginally increased from €67.5bn to €68.2bn.[80]

^7 Latvia recovered faster than expected, and thus did not receive the remaining €3.0bn bailout support originally scheduled for 2011.[81][82]

^8 Portugal completed its support programme as scheduled in June 2014, one month later than initially planned due to awaiting a verdict by its constitutional court, but without asking for establishment of any subsequent precautionary credit line facility.[83] By the end of the programme all committed amounts had been transferred, except for the last tranche of €2.6bn (1.7bn from EFSM and 0.9bn from IMF),[84] which the Portuguese government declined to receive.[85][86] The reason why the IMF transfers still mounted to slightly more than the initially committed €26bn, was due to its payment with SDR's instead of euro - and some favorable developments in the EUR-SDR exchange rate compared to the beginning of the programme.[87] In November 2014, Portugal received its last delayed €0.4bn tranche from EFSM (post programme),[88] hereby bringing its total drawn bailout amount up at €76.8bn out of €79.0bn.

^9 Romania recovered faster than expected, and thus did not receive the remaining €1.0bn bailout support originally scheduled for 2011.[89][90]

^10 Romania had a precautionary credit line with €5.0bn available to draw money from if needed, during the period March 2011-June 2013; but entirely avoided to draw on it.[91][92][47][93] During the period, the World Bank however supported with a transfer of €0.4bn as a DPL3 development loan programme and €0.75bn as results based financing for social assistance and health.[94]

^11 Romania had a second €4bn precautionary credit line established jointly by IMF and EU, of which IMF accounts for SDR 1.75134bn = €2bn, which is available to draw money from if needed during the period from October 2013 to 30 September 2015. In addition the World Bank also made €1bn available under a Development Policy Loan with a deferred drawdown option valid from January 2013 through December 2015.[95] The World Bank will throughout the period also continue providing earlier committed development programme support of €0.891bn,[96][97] but this extra transfer is not accounted for as "bailout support" in the third programme due to being "earlier committed amounts". In April 2014, the World Bank increased their support by adding the transfer of a first €0.75bn Fiscal Effectiveness and Growth Development Policy Loan,[98] with the final second FEG-DPL tranch on €0.75bn (worth about $1bn) to be contracted in the first part of 2015.[99] No money had been drawn from the precautionary credit line, as of May 2014.

^12 Spain's €100bn support package has been earmarked only for recapitalisation of the financial sector.[100] Initially an EFSF emergency account with €30bn was available, but nothing was drawn, and it was cancelled again in November 2012 after being superseded by the regular ESM recapitalisation programme.[101] The first ESM recapitalisation tranch of €39.47bn was approved 28 November,[102][103] and transferred to the bank recapitalisation fund of the Spanish government (FROB) on 11 December 2012.[101] A second tranch for "category 2" banks on €1.86n was approved by the Commission on 20 December,[104] and finally transferred by ESM on 5 February 2013.[105] "Category 3" banks were also subject for a possible third tranch in June 2013, in case they failed before then to acquire sufficient additional capital funding from private markets.[106] During January 2013, all "category 3" banks however managed to fully recapitalise through private markets and thus will not be in need for any State aid. The remaining €58.7bn of the initial support package is thus not expected to be activated, but will stay available as a fund with precautionary capital reserves to possibly draw upon if unexpected things happen - until 31 December 2013.[100][107] In total €41.3bn out of the available €100bn was transferred.[108] Upon the scheduled exit of the programme, no follow-up assistance was requested.[109]

Critics

Critics have noted that the ESM severely confines the economic sovereignty of its member states and criticise that it provides extensive powers and immunity to the board of ESM Governors without parliamentary influence or control.^[110] Think-tanks such as the World Pensions Council (WPC) have argued that the European Stability Mechanism is the product of a short-term political consensus, and thus won't be conductive of a durable, cohesive institutional solution. In their perspective, a profound revision of the Lisbon Treaty itself is unavoidable if Germany is to succeed in imposing its economic views, as stringent orthodoxy across the budgetary, fiscal and regulatory fronts will necessarily have to go beyond the treaty in its current form, thus further reducing the individual prerogatives of national governments.^{[111][112][113]}

Estonia

In Estonia a group of MPs have called for a referendum on the treaty.^[114] On 8 August, during the first reading of the bill ratifying the ESM in Riigikogu, the Estonian Centre Party put forward a motion to reject the bill. However, this motion was defeated in parliament by 56 votes against, with 33 voting for.^[115]

Germany

In Germany some members of FDP (liberal party) and CSU (conservative Bavarian party), both minor parties of the previous government coalition, were against the European Stability Mechanism.^[116] The Left, Pirate Party Germany and NPD also oppose the ESM, the latter comparing it with the Enabling Act of 1933.

Finland

Both opposition parties the True Finns and the Centre Party oppose the ESM.

France

Left Front and left wing presidential candidate Jean-Luc Mélenchon^[117] oppose the ESM.

Netherlands

The Socialist Party opposes the ESM. Geert Wilders' Party for Freedom opposes any increase or systematisation of transfer payments, from the Netherlands to other EU countries, through means such as the ESM.

Slovakia

An opposition liberal party Freedom and Solidarity is a staunch opponent of the ESM.

See also

• European Financial Stability Facility
• European Financial Stabilisation Mechanism
• European Fiscal Compact
• Maiden Lane Transactions
• Term Asset-Backed Securities Loan Facility
• Treaties of the European Union
• Troubled Assets Relief Program
• List of acronyms: European sovereign-debt crisis

References

1. "ESM Annual Report 2014" (PDF).
2. "European Council Press releases". European Council. 9 December 2011. Retrieved 9 December 2011.
3. ESM Treaty details
4. "a136 Amendment details". Retrieved 2013-04-23.
5. "Germany Finally Ratifies ESM Bailout Fund". HispanicBusiness. 27 September 2012. Retrieved 27 September 2012.
6. "Permanent bailout fund". 8 October 2012. Retrieved 2 June 2014.
7. "FAQ about European Financial Stability Facility (EFSF) and the new ESM" (PDF). EFSF. 3 August 2012. Retrieved 19 August 2012.
8. "FAQ on European Stability Mechanism (ESM)" (PDF). ESM. 8 October 2012. Retrieved 11 October 2012.
9. "Financial assistance: Spain". ESM. 5 February 2013. Retrieved 16 April 2013.
10. "Press conference: Klaus Regling at Informal Eurogroup meeting on 12/04/2013". ESM. 12 April 2013. Retrieved 16 April 2013.
11. "Eurogroup Statement on Cyprus" (PDF). Eurogroup. 12 April 2013. Retrieved 20 April 2013.
12. Van Rompuy wants clearer 'hierarchy' to deal with future crises, by Honor Mahony, EUobserver, 25.05.2010
13. Don't expect Britain to back a new EU treaty, Cameron tells Merkel, by Tony Paterson, The Independent, 22.05.2010
14. Battle over treaty change divides Europe ahead of summit, by Leigh Phillips, EUobserver, 28.10.2010
15. EUROPEAN COUNCIL 16–17 DECEMBER 2010 CONCLUSIONS, European Council 17 December 2010
16. Phillips, Leigh (17 December 2010) EU leaders agree to tweak treaty, keep bail-out fund unchanged, EU Observer
17. EUROPEAN COUNCIL 16-17 DECEMBER 2010 CONCLUSIONS, European Council 17 December 2010
18. EUROPEAN COUNCIL 24/25 MARCH 2011 CONCLUSIONS
19. Parliament approves Treaty change to allow stability mechanism, European Parliament
20. Retrieved 22 March 2011 Published 22 March 2011
21. "Judgment of the Court (27 November 2012, Pringle, Case C-370/12)". EUR-Lex. 27 November 2012. Retrieved 27 November 2012.
22. "Completing Europe's Economic and Monetary Union: Report by Jean-Claude Juncker in close cooperation with Donald Tusk, Jeroen Dijsselbloem, Mario Draghi and Martin Schulz" (PDF). European Commission. 21 June 2015.
23. "European Stability Mechanism Treaty signed". European Council. Retrieved 4 February 2012.
24. Van Rompuy wants clearer 'hierarchy' to deal with future crises, by Honor Mahony, EUobserver, 25 May 2010
25. Don't expect Britain to back a new EU treaty, Cameron tells Merkel, by Tony Paterson, The Independent, 22 May 2010
26. "Latvia Wins Final EU Approval to Adopt Euro on Jan. 1 Next Year". Bloomberg. 2013-07-09. Retrieved 2013-07-09.
27. "Commission: Latvia meets the conditions for adopting the euro". European Commission. 2013-06-05. Retrieved 2013-06-16.
28. "Latvia ready to adopt euro in 2014 - EC convergence report". 2013-06-05. Retrieved 2013-07-06.
29. "Government approves bill on Latvia's ESM membership". 2013-11-12-. Retrieved 2013-11-12. Check date values in: |date= (help)
30. "Latvian Prime Minister: 'We Have Learned From Our Mistakes'". Der Spiegel. 2013-06-29. Retrieved 2013-07-06.
31. "Board of Governors". ESM. Retrieved 27 January 2013.
32. "FAQ on European Stability Mechanism (ESM)" (PDF). ESM. 19 April 2013.
33. "Technical features of Outright Monetary Transactions", ECB Press Release, 6 September 2012
34. Stephen Castle and Melissa Eddy (7 Sep 2012). "Bond Plan Lowers Debt Costs, but Germany Grumbles". New York Times.
35. "Press conference (4 October 2012): Introductory statement to the press conference (with Q&A)". ECB. 4 October 2012. Retrieved 10 October 2012.
36. "COUNCIL REGULATION (EU) No 1024/2013 of 15 October 2013 conferring specific tasks on the European Central Bank concerning policies relating to the prudential supervision of credit institutions". Official Journal of the European Union (European Union) L (287): 63–89. 2013-10-29.
37. "Merkel stands tough on Spanish bank aid". Financial Times. 19 October 2012. Retrieved 27 October 2012.
38. "Rajoy takes long view over summit outcome". Financial Times. 19 October 2012. Retrieved 27 October 2012.
39. "ESM direct bank recapitalisation instrument adopted". ESM. 8 December 2014.
40. Statement of the Eurogroup
41. "EFSF newsletter September 2012" (PDF). EFSF. September 2012. Retrieved 3 October 2012.
42. "Euro area Member States transfer third tranche of paid-in capital to ESM" (PDF). ESM. 1 May 2013. Retrieved 6 May 2013.
43. "Cyprus Said to Seek $14 Billion in Fifth European Bailout". Bloomberg. 4 October 2012. Retrieved 4 October 2012.
44. "Spain to ask for bailout next month". The Telegraph. 15 October 2012. Retrieved 15 October 2012.
45. "Opposition wanes to Spanish aid request". Financial Times. 16 October 2012. Retrieved 16 October 2012.
46. "Spain prepares to make rescue request". Financial Times. 24 October 2012. Retrieved 27 October 2012.
47. "Balance of Payments - European Commission". Ec.europa.eu. 2013-01-31. Retrieved 2013-09-27.
48. http://ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/assistance_eu_ms/greek_loan_facility/index_en.htm
49. "Cyprus Gets Second 1.32 Bln Euro Russian Loan Tranche". RiaNovosti. 26 January 2012. Retrieved 24 April 2013.
50. "Russia loans Cyprus 2.5 billion". The Guardian. 10 October 2011. Archived from the original on 21 July 2012. Retrieved 13 March 2012.
51. Hadjipapas, Andreas; Hope, Kerin (14 September 2011). "Cyprus nears €2.5bn Russian loan deal". Financial Times. Retrieved 13 March 2012.
52. "Public Debt Management Annual Report 2013" (PDF). Cypriot Ministry of Finance. 22 May 2014.
53. "Eurogroup statement on a possible macro-financial assistance programme for Cyprus" (PDF). Eurogroup. 13 December 2012. Retrieved 14 December 2012.
54. "European Commission statement on Cyprus". European Commission. 20 March 2013. Retrieved 24 March 2013.
55. "Speech: Statement on Cyprus in the European Parliament (SPEECH/13/325 by Olli Rehn)". European Commission. 17 April 2013. Retrieved 23 April 2013.
56. "Cyprus could lower debt post-bailout with ESM". Kathimerini (English edition). 12 December 2012. Retrieved 13 December 2012.
57. "Eurogroup Statement on Cyprus". Eurozone Portal. 16 March 2013. Retrieved 24 March 2013.
58. "Eurogroup Statement on Cyprus" (PDF). Eurogroup. 25 March 2013. Retrieved 25 March 2013.
59. "The Economic Adjustment Programme for Cyprus" (PDF). Occasional Papers 149 (yield spreads displayed by graph 19). European Commission. 17 May 2013. Retrieved 19 May 2013.
60. "The Second Economic Adjustment Programme for Greece" (PDF). European Commission. March 2012. Retrieved 3 August 2012.
61. "EFSF Head: Fund to contribute 109.1b euros to Greece's second bailout". Marketall. 16 March 2012.
62. "FAQ – New disbursement of financial assistance to Greece" (PDF). EFSF. 22 January 2013.
63. "The Second Economic Adjustment Programme for Greece (Third review July 2013)" (PDF). European Commission. 29 July 2013. Retrieved 22 January 2014.
64. "Frequently Asked Questions on the EFSF: Section E – The programme for Greece" (PDF). European Financial Stability Facility. 19 March 2015.
65. "EFSF programme for Greece expires today". ESM. 30 June 2015.
66. "FAQ document on Greece" (PDF). ESM. 13 July 2015.
67. "Greece: Financial Position in the Fund as of June 30, 2015". IMF. 18 July 2015.
68. "FIFTH REVIEW UNDER THE EXTENDED ARRANGEMENT UNDER THE EXTENDED FUND FACILITY, AND REQUEST FOR WAIVER OF NONOBSERVANCE OF PERFORMANCE CRITERION AND REPHASING OF ACCESS; STAFF REPORT; PRESS RELEASE; AND STATEMENT BY THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR GREECE" (PDF). Table 13. Greece: Schedule of Proposed Purchases under the Extended Arrangement, 2012–16. IMF. 10 June 2014.
69. "Greece: An Update of IMF Staff’s Preliminary Public Debt Sustainability Analysis". IMF. 14 July 2015.
70. "ESM Board of Governors approves decision to grant, in principle, stability support to Greece". ESM. 17 July 2015.
71. "Eurogroup statement on the ESM programme for Greece". Council of the European Union. 14 August 2015.
72. "FAQ on ESM/EFSF financial assistance for Greece" (PDF). ESM. 19 August 2015.
73. "Angela Merkel sees IMF joining Greek bailout, floats debt relief". National Post (Financial Post). 17 August 2015.
74. "Council implementing decision (EU) 2015/1181 of 17 July 2015: on granting short-term Union financial assistance to Greece". Official Journal of the EU. 18 July 2015.
75. "EFSM: Council approves €7bn bridge loan to Greece". Concil of the EU. 17 July 2015.
76. "Third supplemental memorandum of understanding" (PDF). Retrieved 2013-09-27.
77. "IMF Financial Activities - Update September 30, 2010". Imf.org. Retrieved 2013-09-27.
78. "Convert Euros (EUR) and Special Drawing Rights (SDR): Currency Exchange Rate Conversion Calculator". Coinmill.com. Retrieved 2013-09-27.
79. "Dáil Éireann Debate (Vol.733 No.1): Written Answers - National Cash Reserves". Houses of the Oireachtas. 24 May 2011. Retrieved 26 April 2013.
80. "Ireland's EU/IMF Programme: Programme Summary". National Treasury Management Agency. 31 March 2014.
81. "Balance-of-payments assistance to Latvia". European Commission. 17 May 2013.
82. "International Loan Programme: Questions and Answers". Latvian Finance Ministry.
83. "Statement by Vice-President Siim Kallas on Portugal's decision regarding programme exit". European Commission. 5 May 2014.
84. "Statement by the EC, ECB, and IMF on the Twelfth Review Mission to Portugal". IMF. 2 May 2014.
85. "Portugal to do without final bailout payment". EurActiv. 13 June 2014.
86. "The Economic Adjustment Programme for Portugal 2011-2014" (PDF). European Commission. 17 October 2014.
87. "Occasional Papers 191: The Economic Adjustment Programme for Portugal Eleventh Review" (PDF). ANNEX 3: Indicative Financing Needs and Sources. European Commission. 23 April 2014.
88. "Portugal: Final disbursement made from EU financial assistance programme". European Commission. 12 November 2014.
89. "IMF Financial Activities - Update March 24, 2011". Imf.org. Retrieved 2013-09-27.
90. "Convert Euros (EUR) and Special Drawing Rights (SDR): Currency Exchange Rate Conversion Calculator". Coinmill.com. Retrieved 2013-09-27.
91. "IMF Financial Activities - Update September 27, 2012". Imf.org. Retrieved 2013-09-27.
92. "Convert Euros (EUR) and Special Drawing Rights (SDR): Currency Exchange Rate Conversion Calculator". Coinmill.com. Retrieved 2013-09-27.
93. "Press release: IMF Approves Three-Month Extension of SBA for Romania". IMF. 20 March 2013. Retrieved 26 April 2013.
94. "Occasional Papers 156: Overall assessment of the two balance-of-payments assistance programmes for Romania, 2009-2013" (PDF). ANNEX 1: Financial Assistance Programmes in 2009-2013. European Commission. July 2013.
95. "2013/531/EU: Council Decision of 22 October 2013 providing precautionary Union medium-term financial assistance to Romania" (PDF). Official Journal of the European Union. 29 October 2013.
96. "WORLD BANK GROUP Romania Partnership: COUNTRY PROGRAM SNAPSHOT" (PDF). World Bank. April 2014.
97. "Occasional Papers 165 - Romania: Balance-of-Payments Assistance Programme 2013-2015" (PDF). ANNEX 1: Financial Assistance Programmes in 2009-2013. European Commission. November 2013.
98. "PROGRAM DOCUMENT ON A PROPOSED LOAN IN THE AMOUNT OF €750 MILLION TO ROMANIA: FOR THE FIRST FISCAL EFFECTIVENESS AND GROWTH DEVELOPMENT POLICY LOAN" (PDF). World Bank - IBRD. 29 April 2014.
99. "World Bank launched Romania's Country Partnership Strategy for 2014-2017" (PDF). ACTMedia - Romanian Business News. 29 May 2014.
100. "Financial Assistance Facility Agreement between ESM, Spain, Bank of Spain and FROB" (PDF). European Commission. 29 November 2012. Retrieved 8 December 2012.
101. "FAQ - Financial Assistance for Spain" (PDF). ESM. 7 December 2012. Retrieved 8 December 2012.
102. "State aid: Commission approves restructuring plans of Spanish banks BFA/Bankia, NCG Banco, Catalunya Banc and Banco de Valencia". Europa (European Commission). 28 November 2012. Retrieved 3 December 2012.
103. "Spain requests €39.5bn bank bail-out, but no state rescue". The Telegraph. 3 December 2012. Retrieved 3 December 2012.
104. "State aid: Commission approves restructuring plans of Spanish banks Liberbank, Caja3, Banco Mare Nostrum and Banco CEISS". Europa (European Commission). 20 December 2012. Retrieved 29 December 2012.
105. "ESM financial assistance to Spain". ESM. 5 February 2013. Retrieved 5 February 2013.
106. "European Economy Occasional Papers 118: The Financial Sector Adjustment Programme for Spain" (PDF). European Commission. 16 October 2012. Retrieved 28 October 2012.
107. "European Economy Occasional Papers 130: Financial Assistance Programme for the Recapitalisation of Financial Institutions in Spain - Second Review of the Programme Spring 2013". European Commission. 19 March 2013. Retrieved 24 March 2013.
108. "Spain's exit". ESM. 31 December 2013.
109. "Spain successfully exits ESM financial assistance programme". ESM. 31 December 2013.
110. Common Concerns: Austria: Objections and Reservations to ESM (European Stability Mechanism)
111. M Nicolas Firzli (Jan. 2010), Orthodoxie financière et régulation bancaire: les leçons du Glass-Steagall Act (Bank Regulation and Financial Orthodoxy: the Lessons from the Glass-Steagall Act) (PDF) (in French), retrieved 8 January 2010
112. M. Nicolas J. Firzli, "Greece and the EU Debt Crisis" The Vienna Review, March 2010
113. "see Ionescu Romeo, "Romania and Greece: Together or Alone", AJBM Vol. 4(19), p. 4197, December, 2010 [Quoting Q1 2010 article (in French) by M. Nicolas J. Firzli in Revue Analyse Financière]" (PDF). Retrieved 29 March 2011.
114. Tammik, Ott (1 August 2012). "MPs Suggest Referendum for ESM". Eesti Rahvusringhääling. Retrieved 6 August 2012.
115. "Extraordinary Session of Riigikogu: Bill on Ratification and Implementation of the Treaty Establishing the European Stability Mechanism passed first reading". Riigikogu press service. 8 August 2012. Retrieved 18 August 2012.
116. Welt:Liberale Euro-Rebellen haben fast 900 Unterschriften
117. Contre la ratification du « Mécanisme européen de stabilité financière »

External links

• Official website
• Treaty text
• Treaty draft (german)
• ESM explained