Northern Hub

Schematic map showing rail improvements through Manchester city centre as part of the Northern Hub.

Manchester Victoria station was voted the worst station in the UK in 2009. As part of the Northern Hub, the station was modernised with a new roof which was completed in October 2015.

The Northern Hub is a rail project across Northern England to increase train services and reduce journey times between the major cities and towns by electrifying lines and removing a major rail bottleneck in Manchester. It is predicted to stimulate economic growth in the region.^[1] The rail network in Manchester was a bottleneck preventing seamless and fast services between cities and towns in the north of England. There are many points to the project, however the prime point centred on eradicating the Manchester bottleneck allowing trains to travel through Manchester at speed without stopping. The project was announced in 2009 as the Manchester Hub.^[2][3] The project has a steering partnership involving Network Rail, Deutsche Bahn, First TransPennine Express, Northern Rail, East Midlands Trains, CrossCountry, Freightliner, the Department for Transport, Transport for Greater Manchester and Merseytravel.^[4][2]

Services from Liverpool to Leeds and beyond will be diverted from the diesel operated Liverpool to Manchester line southern route via Warrington Central and Manchester Piccadilly to the more direct electrified Liverpool to Manchester northern route via Newton-le-Willows and Manchester Victoria, giving a fast route to and through Manchester. The construction of two through platforms at Manchester Piccadilly will allow 14 trains per hour as against the previous 10. Manchester Victoria station was modernised and completed in October 2015 adopting the role of an east-west rail interchange and through station between Liverpool and Leeds. Trains from the north east of England to Manchester Airport will use a reinstated section of railway, the £85 million Ordsall Chord, between Manchester Victoria and Manchester Oxford Road to access Manchester Piccadilly and continue to the airport without the need to reverse at Piccadilly and without conflicting movements of other trains at the station throat.

The Manchester Hub Study, outlining the project, was released by Network Rail in February 2010. Costs were estimated at £530 million, subsequently reassessed to £560 million.^[2][5] Chancellor George Osborne approved expenditure of £85 million for the new track link in his budget on 23 March 2011,^[6] and other aspects of the scheme were reviewed to ensure best value. A further £130 million was committed in Osborne's budget of March 2012,^[7] and approval for the full scheme was confirmed by the government on 16 July 2012. The first trains are expected to run on the new linking track in 2016 and the project completed by 2018.^[8]

Support for the scheme has been vociferous from civic and business leaders due to the high benefit-to-cost ratio and from politicians such as Chancellor George Osborne but criticised for being incremental and only improving the rail network in Northern England to "where it should have been a decade ago".^[9] The scheme has a benefit-to-cost ratio (BCR) of £4 for every £1 invested - double that of London's Crossrail and the proposed national HS2 network which have a BCR of £2.10 and £2.30 respectively.^[10][11]

The project may be followed by or merged with High Speed 3. In November 2015 Transport for the North (TfN) proposed a four-track trans-Pennine railway line that would link with the HS2 line to London, and a new Liverpool-Manchester airport-Manchester railway line also linked to HS2. A feasibility study of the west to east rail line and its branches into HS2 will be published in March 2016.^[12]

Background

Approximately 90% of Northern Rail's rolling stock was built in the 1980s, including the unpopular "Pacers" (pictured). As of 2014, the last investment in new-built rolling stock for Northern Rail was in 1998.^[13][14]

The Northern Hub was proposed in February 2010 to resolve recurring problems around Manchester city centre which restricted route capacity and frequently caused delays.

• Terminating trains in through platforms as opposed to terminal platforms at Manchester Victoria station removed capacity for trains passing through Manchester. The problem could have been mitigated by an additional terminating platform west of the station but operational efficiencies were achieved by altering route paths to relieve congestion.
• Congestion at Manchester Piccadilly was caused by trains having to reverse to travel on to Manchester Airport and trains between Liverpool and Yorkshire or the East Midlands had to switch lines across the throat of the station temporarily blocking all other services.
• Freight trains pass through Manchester city centre, unusual for a city centre rail network. Currently two freight trains per hour pass through Manchester to Trafford Park and no alternative route exists.^[15] Freight trains using passenger routes through Manchester was raised in Parliament in 2002.^[16]

Network Rail concluded that no single intervention would unlock the bottlenecks but that greater efficiency and enhancement to services was possible. A proposal to use Piccadilly primarily for north-south services and Victoria for east-west services was agreed as the most effective course of action.^[17]

The re-alignment of services commenced in May 2014 when TransPennine Express services between Liverpool Lime Street and Newcastle Central were routed through Manchester Victoria rather than Manchester Piccadilly. It is expected most TransPennine Express services will pass through Victoria by 2018 after the construction of the Ordsall Chord.

Station improvements

The partially complete new roof at Manchester Victoria in July 2014

A number of major stations will be improved to include new platforms, station layout re-configuration and redevelopment. Most improvements will be in Manchester aimed at alleviating the bottlenecks that cause delays to passing services and restricts routes.

Manchester Victoria station will be re-configured as the hub in Northern England for east-west rail services. Once voted the worst station in the United Kingdom, it will receive a £44 million transformation including a £20 million roof covering the entire concourse and four platforms.

Manchester Piccadilly's through platforms, 13 and 14, will be modernised and two new through platforms, 15 and 16, will be built over Fairfield Street to alleviate congestion.^[18]

Manchester Oxford Road's platforms will be lengthened and a footbridge will be built. The Grade II listed timber grid-shell roof will be incorporated into the new station.^[19] The surrounding site around the station could be redeveloped with office, residential and leisure space.^[20][21]

At Leeds Station two platforms will be built at a cost of £13.6 million to alleviate congestion.^[22]

Salford Crescent station will be redeveloped at a cost of £12 million and further development could occur should extra capacity be required.^[23]

At Manchester Airport station a new platform will be built creating extra capacity and access for direct services from other cities in Northern England. Construction of a new platform began in February 2014.^[24] Huyton and Roby will have two new tracks through the stations to allow faster trains to pass and provide two additional platforms. Burnley Manchester Road station will receive a £2.3 million upgrade before the reinstatement of a direct rail service to Manchester Victoria via the re-opened Todmorden Curve in 2015.^[25] Dore and Totley railway station will get a second platform and a footbridge for access to the new platform. The single track will be doubled.^[26]

Infrastructure

A diagram showing the Ordsall Chord.

Northern Hub plans include:^[27]

• Manchester Piccadilly and Manchester Victoria stations linked by the new Ordsall Chord
• Station improvements notably at Manchester Victoria which was rated as the worst station in the United Kingdom in 2009.^[28]
• New platforms at Manchester Piccadilly for trains from/to Oxford Road, enabling traffic from the north and west to access the south side.
• New passing loop on the line from Liverpool to Manchester via Newton-le-Willows, between Roby and Huyton
• Extra capacity on routes through the Pennines between Leeds, Huddersfield, Dewsbury and Manchester
• New passing loops between Sheffield and Manchester at Chinley, Grindleford and Dore

Electrification

Electrification for rail lines out of Manchester are underway or have been approved.^[29] While independent of the Northern Hub scheme, they complement it:

Newly installed overhead electrification into Manchester Victoria station, in October 2015

• Electrification of the Manchester to Liverpool line was announced by the Department for Transport in July 2009. The section from Manchester to Newton-le-Willows was completed in December 2013 and the section to Liverpool should have been completed by December 2014.^[30][31] The 32-mile line between Liverpool Lime Street and Manchester Victoria via Huyton and Newton Le-Willows has a maximum speed limit of 75 mph. Following electrification and the introduction of Class 319 stock, trains will reach 90 mph cutting journey times from 47 to 32 minutes. The Manchester to Newton-le-Willows section was completed on 17 July 2013 marked by a small ceremony at Eccles station at which the Secretary of State for Transport, Rt. Hon. Patrick McLoughlin MP, was present. Electrified Manchester to Edinburgh and Glasgow services have been running since the timetable change in December 2013. Due to delays the target date for completion of the section from Earlestown to Liverpool was missed but electric train services between Liverpool and Manchester Airport commenced in March 2015.
• The Liverpool to Wigan Line is electrified and provides a second connection to the West Coast Main Line at Ince Moss Junction via St. Helens Central. The line was operational by May 2015.
• Electrification of the Manchester to Preston Line via Bolton was announced in December 2009 and is expected to be completed by December 2017.^[29][32] Preparatory work on bridges and tunnels commenced in 2014.
• Electrification of the line from Preston to Blackpool North was scheduled for completion by May 2016.^[29][33] It joins the Manchester to Preston Line providing an electrified route from Blackpool to Manchester and the West Coast Main Line. This stage is now running behind schedule (following a change of engineering contractor and the decision to combine track & signalling alterations with the electrification work)^[34] and is unlikely to be finished until 2018.
• The Huddersfield Line to Leeds and York via Stalybridge was expected to be electrified between 2016 and 2018.^[29][35] Electrification announced in November 2011, but the plan was "paused" by the government in the summer of 2015 due to rising costs and missed targets.^[36] The work is now expected to be completed in 2022, after the DfT gave the go-ahead for work to resume in September 2015.^[37]

Service improvements

A 1900 tiled mural of the rail network in Northern England at Manchester Victoria.

Northern Hub is expected to deliver the following improvements:^[38]

• 14 trains an hour through Manchester compared with 10 currently
• Up to 700 more trains per day with space for 44 million more people to travel by train each year
• Two new fast trains per hour between Manchester Victoria and Liverpool Lime Street
• Six fast trains an hour at peak times between Leeds and Manchester as opposed to five
• New services to Manchester Airport from Bradford via Halifax, and the Calder Valley and from Chester
• A 15-minute service to Manchester Airport from Victoria, Oxford Road and Piccadilly
• An express service between Liverpool Lime Street and Newcastle Central via Manchester Victoria and Leeds commenced in May 2014

The Class 319 will provide faster journey times and greater capacity compared with pacer trains. The refurbished Class 319 entered service in May 2015 between Liverpool and Manchester.

As part of the Northern Hub scheme; electrification of key lines will enable faster electric trains increasing capacity and lowering journey times. Typically, diesel trains that operated between Manchester and Liverpool such as the Class 142 and Class 156 had a maximum speed limit of 75 mph. Following electrification, Class 319 trains reach a top speed of 100 mph with greater acceleration from stations.

Network Rail has published target times from Manchester to be achieved after the completion of the Northern Hub projects.^[2]

• Leeds and Manchester target time: 40 minutes - a reduction of 14 minutes
• Bradford and Manchester target time: 50 minutes - a reduction of 10 minutes
• Manchester and Sheffield target time: 40 minutes - a reduction of 8 minutes
• Chester and Manchester target time: 40 minutes - a reduction of 23 minutes
• Liverpool and Manchester target time: 30 minutes - a reduction of 17 minutes. A reduced journey time of 37 minutes was achieved in May 2014 with the introduction of the new 'express' route and the introduction of Class 319 trains in May 2015 reduced journey times between both cities to 30 minutes.
• Manchester and Preston target time: 30 minutes - a reduction of 9 minutes
• There will be faster journey times to the East Midlands via Sheffield, Chester, Halifax, Hull, Newcastle and the North East

Timeline

Ten new Class 350 were introduced to coincide with Newton-le-Willows to Manchester electrification in 2013. The trains operate on the Edinburgh to Manchester route.

Network Rail's original aim was for all schemes - including electrification, station upgrades and track work - to be completed by the end of 2018, though this timescale will not be met for the Transpennine electrification.

2013

• April - work begins on restoring Manchester Victoria station
• 30 December - Manchester to West Coast Main Line and Newton-le-Willows electrification complete. New four-carriage Class 350s are introduced, reducing journey times and increasing capacity on the Edinburgh-Manchester Airport route.

2014

• 20 May - a new fast service between Liverpool and Newcastle via Manchester Victoria begins delivering journey time reductions
• December - Newton-le-Willows to Liverpool Lime Street and Huyton to Wigan electrification complete - delayed, first services Liverpool to Manchester Airport did not run until March 2015. Four-carriage Class 319s will be introduced increasing capacity between Liverpool and Manchester Airport via Manchester Piccadilly.

2015

• August - Completion of Manchester Victoria station redevelopment

2016

• Early 2016 - work begins on building two new platforms at Manchester Piccadilly and re-configuring Manchester Oxford Road (subject to application approval, expected in late 2015)
• December
  • Manchester Victoria to Preston electrification complete
  • Manchester to Stalybridge electrification complete (TP phase 1)

2017

• December
  • Ordsall Chord operational
  • Preston-Blackpool electrification complete

2018

• Platforms 15 and 16 to be operational at Manchester Piccadilly
• December - Two new platforms at Manchester Piccadilly completed and operational

2022

• Manchester to Leeds and York electrification is complete

Heritage threat

The historic first passenger railway station, Manchester Liverpool Road, a Grade I listed building, is threatened by the plan. After this project is completed, it will no longer be possible to run trains into or out of the station. The Manchester Museum of Science and Industry management objected to the scheme and an inquiry was set up in 2014 to investigate potential damage to the historic structure.^[39]

Future

The Northern Hub may be merged into or superseded by a larger project being called High Speed 3. David Higgins, chairman of the HS2, stated in March 2014 that the Northern Hub scheme is incremental and the benefits of the High Speed 2 will not be fully felt if rail links between Northern cities are not improved.^[40] In June 2014, George Osborne, Chancellor of the Exchequer stated his vision to see improved transport links between Liverpool, Manchester, Sheffield and Leeds to increase economic productivity.^[41] Osborne's proposals were referred to as 'Crossrail of the North' and 'High Speed 3'. In November 2015 Transport for the North (TfN) proposed a four-track trans-Pennine railway line that would link with the HS2 line to London, and a new Liverpool-Manchester airport-Manchester railway line also linked to HS2. A feasibility study of the west to east rail line and its branches into HS2 will be published in March 2016.^[12]

References

1. "Northern Hub". Northern Hub. Retrieved 27 December 2013.
2. "Northern Hub Technical Study" (PDF). Retrieved 13 April 2013.
3. "The Northern Way - Manchester Hub Phase 1" (PDF). Northern Way. April 2009. Retrieved 16 February 2013.
4. "Partners". Northern Hub. Retrieved 6 May 2012.
5. "Rail investment proposed for North England cities". Network Rail. 16 February 2010.
6. Rentoul, John (24 March 2011). "The speech: What Osborne said - and what he really meant". The Independent.
7. "Budget boost for Northern Hub project as George Osborne pledges £130m to improve rail services | Manchester Evening News". menmedia.co.uk. 21 March 2012. Retrieved 6 May 2012.
8. £560m Northern Hub rail scheme approved, Insider News North West, 16 July 2012
9. "The Northern Hub. What is it and is it any use?". The Information Daily. 6 March 2014. Retrieved 5 July 2014.
10. "HS2: Predicted benefits lowered in new government report". BBC News. 29 October 2013. Retrieved 2014-10-27.
11. "'Risks remain' on multi-billion Crossrail project". BBC News. 23 July 2014. Retrieved 2014-10-27.
12. "Northern rail and road routes as vital as Crossrail 2, TfN says". Financial Times. 15 November 2015. (subscription required (help)).
13. "Rail campaigners call for an end to outdated Northern Rail trains". thejournal.co.uk. 23 June 2014. Retrieved 2014-10-28.
14. "Northern passengers forced to use trains more than 20 YEARS older than in the South". Daily Mirror. 13 June 2014. Retrieved 2014-10-28.
15. "The North of England Programme: Northern Hub plus electrification". railtechnologymagazine.com. 10 September 2014. Retrieved 12 September 2014.
16. "Examination of Witnesses (Questions 220-229)". gov.uk. 19 June 2002. Retrieved 2014-11-13.
17. "Greater Manchester Integrated Transport Authority - Report for Resolution". GMPTE. 19 March 2010.
18. "Our plans: Manchester Piccadilly". Network Rail. Retrieved 19 May 2014.
19. "Our plans: Manchester Oxford Road". Network Rail. Retrieved 19 May 2014.
20. "DTZ to head development contest at Oxford Road Station". Place North West. 6 August 2014. Retrieved 10 August 2014.
21. "Former Cornerhouse site set for redevelopment as office, hotel and leisure complex". Manchester Evening News. 7 August 2014. Retrieved 10 August 2014.
22. "Northern Hub among £37.5bn rail spending plan". Insider Media. 8 January 2013. Retrieved 16 April 2013.
23. "A major upgrade for Salford Crescent station". Network Rail. 15 October 2012. Retrieved 16 April 2013.
24. "George Osborne launches £600m Northern Hub rail project". The Guardian. 7 February 2014. Retrieved 31 March 2014.
25. "Work starts on £2.3m Burnley railway station revamp". BBC News. 15 August 2013. Retrieved 14 September 2013.
26. "Consultation on Sheffield rail upgrade plan". Sheffield Star. 25 October 2013. Retrieved 28 October 2013.
27. "The Northern Hub". Transport for Greater Manchester (TfGM). Retrieved 8 July 2012.
28. "Is Victoria UK's worst station?". BBC News. 17 November 2009. Retrieved 8 July 2012.
29. "Electrification in the North". Network Rail.
30. North West Electrification, Network Rail. Accessed 16 July 2012
31. "Rail Electrification - July 2009" (PDF). p. 22.
32. https://www.greatermanchester-ca.gov.uk/download/meetings/id/461/item_14
33. "North-West Electrification". Network Rail.
34. Balfour Beatty pulls out of Lancashire rail electrificationBBC News 21 August 2015; Retrieved 18 December 2015
35. Electrification: Leeds-York is in, and more could follow, Rail News, 16 December 2011
36. Network Rail upgrade delayed by GovernmentBBC News article 25 June 2015; Retrieved 18 December 2015
37. TransPennine and Midland Mainline electrification works to resume DfT; Retrieved 18 December 2015
38. "The Northern Hub". Network Rail. Retrieved 6 May 2012.
39. Merrick, Jay (11 May 2014). "‘Oldest railway station in the world’ threatened by Network Rail plans". The Independent on Sunday. Retrieved 12 May 2014.
40. "Higgins ditches High Speed 2 link to HS1 and Continent". nce.co.uk. 18 March 2014. Retrieved 22 June 2014.
41. "New high-speed rail link needed to boost north of England, Osborne to say". BBC News. 23 June 2014. Retrieved 22 June 2014.

External links

• Northern Hub website