Sir Francis Bernard, 1st Baronet

Sir Francis Bernard, 1st Baronet
10º Governor of the Province of New Jersey
In office 27 January 1758 – 4 July 1760
Monarch	George II
Preceded by	John Reading
Succeeded by	Thomas Boone
Governor of the Province of Massachusetts Bay
In office 2 August 1760 – 1 August 1769
Monarch	George II George III
Preceded by	Thomas Hutchinson (acting)
Succeeded by	Thomas Hutchinson (acting)
Personal details
Born	baptised 12 July 1712 Brightwell-cum-Sotwell, Berkshire, England
Died	16 June 1779 (aged 66) Nether Winchendon, Buckinghamshire, England
Signature

Sir Francis Bernard, 1st Baronet (bapt. 12 July 1712 – 16 June 1779) was a British colonial administrator who served as governor of the provinces of New Jersey and Massachusetts Bay. His uncompromising policies and harsh tactics in Massachusetts angered the colonists and were instrumental in the building of broad-based opposition within the province to the rule of Parliament in the events leading to the American Revolution.

Appointed governor of New Jersey in 1758, he oversaw the province's participation in the later years of the French and Indian War, and had a generally positive relationship with its legislature. In 1760 he was given the governorship of Massachusetts, where he had a stormy relationship with the assembly. Early actions turned the colony's populists against him, and his responses to protests against Parliament's attempts to tax the colonies deepened divisions. After protests against the Townshend Acts in 1768, Bernard sought British Army troops be stationed in Boston to overawe the colonists. He was recalled after the publication of letters in which he was critical of the colony.

After returning to England, he continued to advise the British government on colonial matters, calling for hardline responses to ongoing difficulties in Massachusetts that culminated in the 1773 Boston Tea Party. He suffered a stroke in 1771 and died in 1779, leaving a large family.

Early life

Francis was born in Brightwell-cum-Sotwell, (then in Berkshire, but part of Oxfordshire since 1974), England to the Rev. Francis and Margery (Winslowe) Bernard and was christened on 12 July 1712.^[1] His father died three years later. His mother remarried, but died herself of smallpox in 1718.^[2] He was thereafter probably raised by an aunt for several years, since his stepfather was forced by a failed courtship to flee to Holland.^[3] His stepfather, Anthony Alsop, returned to Berkshire a few years later, and continued to play a role in the boy's upbringing.^[4] Bernard's formal education began at Westminster in 1725, and he then spent seven years at Oxford, where Christ Church granted him a master of arts in 1736. He read law at the Middle Temple and was called to the bar in 1737, after only four years (instead of the typical seven) of study.^[5] He settled in Lincoln, where he practiced law and took on a variety of municipal posts. Among his neighbors in Lincoln were the Pownalls, who had one son (John) serving in the Colonial Office, and another, Thomas, who went to the North American colonies in 1753 and was appointed governor of the Province of Massachusetts Bay in 1757.^[6]

Bernard married Amelia Offley, daughter of the sheriff of Derbyshire, in December 1741, and the couple raised a large family: by 1757 the couple had eight living children.^[7][8] Because his prospects for further income to support this large family were unlikely in Lincoln, he apparently decided to seek a posting in the colonies.^[9] John Adams later described Bernard as "avaricious to a most infamous degree; needy at the same time, having a numerous family to provide for."^[10]

Governor of New Jersey

Proclamation for a General Thanksgiving, issued by Governor Bernard, November 1766

Bernard's wife was cousin to Lord Barrington, who became a Privy Councillor in 1755.^[11][12] Probably through his connections to Barrington and the Pownalls, he secured an appointment as governor of the Province of New Jersey on 27 January 1758, a post that became available upon the death of Jonathan Belcher.^[13][14] Leaving some of his children with relatives, the couple sailed for North America with four of their children, arriving at Perth Amboy on 14 June.^[15]

The colonies were in the middle of the French and Indian War at the time of Bernard's arrival. He established a good working relationship with New Jersey's assembly, and was able to convince the province to raise troops and funds for the ongoing war effort. He signed the Treaty of Easton, an agreement between New Jersey and Pennsylvania on one side, and a group of Indian tribes (the Lenape being of principal concern to New Jersey) fixing boundaries between colonial and Indian lands. This effort was important, for it reduced raiding on the frontiers and made possible the reallocation of provincial military strength to the war with New France.^[16] It and other agreements negotiated by Bernard extinguished all of the remaining Indian titles to New Jersey. Negotiations with the Lenape also resulted in the establishment of the first formal Indian reservation, Brotherton, near present-day Indian Mills. This reservation was only sparsely populated, and was abandoned in 1801 when its remaining inhabitants joined the Stockbridge Indians in upstate New York.^[17]

Governor of Massachusetts

James Otis Jr., portrait by Joseph Blackburn; he was one of Bernard's leading opponents.

Through the influence of his connections in the Colonial Office, Bernard was appointed governor of the Province of Massachusetts Bay in late 1759.^[18] Delays in communications and slow travel were such that Bernard did not arrive in Boston until 2 August 1760. Although initially warmly welcomed, his tenure in Massachusetts was difficult. Bernard sought to vigorously enforce the Navigation Acts, in part because crown officials (including the governor and the customs officials) received shares of the proceeds from the seizure of ships that were caught violating the acts.^[19] The legal actions involving these seizures were heard in a jury-less admiralty court before a Crown-appointed judge, and were extremely unpopular.^[20] Bernard also made an early opponent of James Otis, Jr. by appointing Lieutenant Governor Thomas Hutchinson to be chief justice of the province's highest court, a post that had been promised by several previous governors to Otis' father.^[21] Upset over the snub the younger Otis resigned his post as advocate general (i.e. the Crown's representative, equivalent to a government prosecutor) before the admiralty court, and devoted himself instead to arguing (sometimes pro bono) on behalf of the merchants in defense of their ships.^[22] These early actions during Bernard's tenure drew a clear dividing line between the "popular party" (exemplified by the Otises) opposed to British colonial policy and the "court party" (exemplified by Hutchinson) who supported it.^[19]

Bernard's difficulties were compounded when, after the death in late 1760 of King George II, it became necessary to reissue writs of assistance to customs tax collectors. These writs, which were essentially open-ended search warrants, were judicially controversial and so unpopular that their issuance was later explicitly disallowed by the United States Constitution. Hutchinson, who approved the writs in one of his first acts as chief justice, saw his popularity fall, and Otis, who argued the writs violated the Rights of Englishmen, gained in popularity. He was elected to the provincial legislature in May 1761, where he was well placed to continue his attacks on Bernard's policies.^[23] In the 1761 session of the assembly Otis engineered the gift of Mount Desert Island to Bernard, a partially successful stratagem to divert Bernard's attention from ongoing customs seizures.^[24]

O B[ernard]! Great thy Villainy has been!
Schem'd to destroy our Liberty and Peace:
The publick Eye attentively has seen
Thy base Endeavours, and has watch'd our Ease

— Anonymous pamphlet, 1769^[25]

Bernard's unpopularity continued through other tax measures, including the Sugar Act (1763) and the Stamp Act (1765). While the passage of both acts occasioned protest, the response to the Stamp Act included rioting in the streets, and united many factions in the province against the governor.^[26] In 1767 the passage by Parliament of the Townshend Acts again raised a storm of protest in the colonies.^[27] In Massachusetts the provincial assembly issued a circular letter, calling on the other colonies to join it in a boycott of the goods subject to the Townshend taxes.^[28] Bernard was ordered in April 1768 by Lord Hillsborough, who had recently been appointed to the newly created office of Colonial Secretary, to dissolve the assembly if it failed to retract the letter.^[29] The assembly refused, and Bernard prorogued it in July.

Maier says that his letters to London greatly influenced officials there, but they "distorted" reality. "His misguided conviction that the 'faction' had espoused violence as its primary method of opposition, for example, kept him from recognizing the radicals' peace-keeping efforts....Equally dangerous, Bernard's elaborate accounts were sometimes built on insubstantial evidence."^[30] Warden argues that Bernard was careful not to explicitly ask London for troops, but his exaggerated accounts strongly suggested they were needed. In the fall of 1767 he warned about a possible insurrection in Boston any day, and his exaggerated report of one disturbance in 1768, "certainly had given Lord Hillsboro the impression that troops were the only way to enforce obedience in the town." Warden notes that other key British officials in Boston wrote London with the "same strain of hysteria."^[31] Four thousand British Army troops arrived in Boston in October 1768, further heightening tensions. Bernard was vilified in the local press, and accused of writing letters to the ministry that mischaracterized the situation.^[28] Although he was challenged to release those letters he refused. Opposition agents in London were eventually able to acquire some of his letters, which reached members of the Sons of Liberty in April 1769.^[32] They were promptly published by the radical Boston Gazette, along with deliberations of the governor's council. One letter in particular, in which Bernard called for changes to the Massachusetts charter to increase the governor's power by increasing the council's dependence on him, was the subject of particularly harsh treatment,^[33] and prompted the assembly to formally request that "he might be forever removed from the Government of the Province." He was recalled to England, and Lieutenant Governor Hutchinson became acting governor. When Bernard left Boston on 1 August, the town held an impromptu celebration, decorated the Liberty Tree, and rang church bells.^[34]

His accomplishments in Massachusetts included the design of Harvard Hall at Harvard University and the construction of a summer estate on Pond Street in Jamaica Plain.^[35]

Return to England

British Prime Minister Frederick North, Lord North (portrait by Nathaniel Dance) consulted Bernard on colonial affairs.

Upon his return to England, he asked for and received a hearing concerning the colonial petition against his rule. The Privy Council in February 1770 considered the petition, and after deliberation dismissed all of the charges as "groundless, vexatious, and scandalous."^[36][37] Despite this vindication, Bernard resigned as governor in 1771. He was confirmed in the ownership of Mount Desert Island, a recognition he had been seeking since it was awarded to him in 1761.^[38] Although he had been promised a baronetcy and a pension of £1,000 for his service, he learned after his return that the pension had been reduced to £500 (the baronetcy, of Nettleham, was awarded at crown expense).^[39] His appeals on the matter were at first rejected, but when Lord North became Prime Minister in 1770, the pension was raised, but shortly after replaced by an appointment as commissioner on the Board of Revenue for Ireland, which paid the same amount.^[40]

Bernard became an advisor to the North administration on matters concerning the colonies. He generally took a harder line than his predecessor Thomas Pownall, who advocated for colonial interests in Parliament. Proposals he made in 1771 included ideas central to the 1774 Massachusetts Government Act, which severely constrained colonial political power, including a council appointed by the governor rather than one elected by the assembly.^[38] Bernard may also have played a role in the difficulties Benjamin Franklin had in being recognized as a colonial agent; after Franklin's credentials were refused by the colonial secretary, he encountered Bernard in an antechamber.^[41] Biographer Colin Nicolson observes that Bernard's presence as an advisor to the ministry "cast a shadow over virtually ever American measure regarding Massachusetts" that the ministry considered, because of Bernard's role in breaking trust between the colonists and the London government and the subsequent radicalization of Massachusetts politics.^[42]

In 1774, when the North government was considering how to respond to the Boston Tea Party, Bernard published Select Letters on Trade and Government, containing proposals on how to deal with the ongoing difficulties in the colonies. He proposed to reconcile the constitutional grievances of the British and radical Americans by the possible introduction of American representatives into the Parliament of Great Britain.^[43] In the Select Letters, which included the essay Principles of Law and Polity which he drafted in 1764, he laid out a point-by-point exposition of his viewpoints concerning imperial governance.^[44] Some of his ideas were enacted, notably those enshrined in the Massachusetts Government Act; the outrage in London even sparked the sympathetic colonial advocate Thomas Pownall to propose the closure of Boston's port, which was enacted in the Boston Port Act.^[45]

Decline and death

In late 1771 Bernard was bequeathed the manor at Nether Winchendon upon the death of a cousin to whom he had been close since childhood. Combined with other uncertainties about where various family members would reside after he received the Irish appointment, the stress of the situation led Bernard to suffer a stroke.^[46] His mobility was impaired, but he took the waters at Bath, which appear to have helped his recovery. He applied for permission to resign the Irish post, and settled first at the Nether Winchendon manor; in 1774 his resignation was accepted and his pension restored.^[47] He was well enough in 1772 to travel to Oxford, where he received an honorary Doctor of Civil Law from his alma mater, Christ Church.^[48] Because of his health he moved later in 1772 to a smaller house in nearby Aylesbury. He died on 16 June 1779, after an epileptic seizure, at Nether Winchendon.^[49]

Legacy

Bernard never believed the difficulties he had in Massachusetts were personal: instead of accepting some responsibility, he blamed his problems on the policies emanating from London that he was instructed to implement.^[50] John Adams wrote that Bernard's "antagonistic reports" of matters in Massachusetts were instrumental in turning British government policymakers against colonial interests.^[51] Bernard's name headed a list drawn up in Massachusetts after the American Revolutionary War broke out of "notorious conspirators against the government", and most of his property there was confiscated.^[52] Mount Desert Island was not entirely taken; Bernard's son John, who resided in Maine during the war and sided with the victorious Americans, was able to receive Massachusetts title to half of the island.^[53]

Upon the election of James Bowdoin to be Governor of Massachusetts in 1786, Reverend William Gordon in his sermon warned Bowdoin that he ignored the state's legislature at his peril, as Bernard had.^[53]

Vealtown, New Jersey, a town first settled around 1715 and located in Bernards Township, was renamed Bernardsville in Bernard's honour in 1840.^[54] Bernardston, Massachusetts was incorporated during his Massachusetts administration and is named for him.^[55] Bernard also named Berkshire County, Massachusetts (after his county of birth) and Pittsfield, Massachusetts (after British Prime Minister William Pitt).^[56]

Notes

1. Higgins, p. 1:173
2. Higgins, pp. 1:174–176
3. Higgins, pp. 1:177–178
4. Higgins, pp. 1:178–179
5. Nicolson (2000), p. 25
6. Nicolson (2000), pp. 29–41
7. Higgins, pp. 1:193–219
8. Nicolson (2000), p. 34
9. Higgins, pp. 1:215–217
10. Adams, p. 33
11.  Chisholm, Hugh, ed. (1911). "Barrington, William Wildman Shute, 2nd Viscount". Encyclopædia Britannica (11th ed.). Cambridge University Press.
12. Higgins, p. 1:215
13. Higgins, p. 1:220
14. Nicolson (2000), p. 41
15. Nicolson (2000), pp. 42–45
16. Nicolson (2000), p. 44
17. Martinelli, pp. 70–71
18. Nicolson (2000), p. 45
19. Galvin, p. 25
20. Galvin, pp. 24–25
21. Galvin, pp. 22–23
22. Galvin, pp. 24–32
23. Galvin, pp. 28–34
24. Galvin, p. 42
25. Walett, p. 224
26. Galvin, pp. 74–76, 89–108
27. Walett, p. 217
28. Walett, p. 218
29. Knollenberg, p. 56
30. Pauline Maier (1973). From Resistance to Revolution: Colonial Radicals and the Development of American Opposition to Britain, 1765-1776. W.W. Norton. pp. 151–52.
31. G. B. Warden, Boston 1689-1776 (1970) pp 213-14
32. Walett, p. 219
33. Walett, pp. 220–221
34. Walett, p. 222
35. "A Brief History of Jamaica Plain". Jamaica Plain Historical Society. Retrieved 2012-08-24.
36. Higgins, p. 2:209
37. Nicolson (2000), p. 206
38. Nicolson (2000), p. 210
39. Higgins, pp. 2:205, 210–211
40. Higgins, p. 2:213
41. Nicolson (2000), p. 214
42. Nicolson (2000), p. 215
43. Select Letters on the Trade and Government of America: pages 33-34
44. http://teachingamericanhistory.org/library/index.asp?document=1050
45. Nicolson (2000), p. 221–223
46. Higgins, p. 2:233
47. Higgins, p. 2:234
48. Higgins, p. 2:235
49. Nicolson (2000), p. 236
50. Nicolson (2000), p. 224
51. Nicolson (2000), p. 231
52. Nicolson (2000), pp. 235–236
53. Nicolson (2000), p. 237
54. Lurie, p. 74
55. Nason and Varney, p. 146
56. Smith, p. 132

References

• Adams, John; Carey, George (ed) (2001). The Political Writings of John Adams. Washington, DC: Regnery Publishing. ISBN 9780895262929. OCLC 248150786.
• Barrington, Viscount William Wildman; Bernard, Sir Francis (1912). The Barrington-Bernard Correspondence and Illustrative Matter, 1760–1770. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. OCLC 2433914.
• Galvin, John (1976). Three Men of Boston. New York: Thomas Y. Crowell. ISBN 9780690010183. OCLC 1530708.
• Higgins, Sophia (1903). The Bernards of Abington and Nether Winchendon: a Family History. London and New York: Longmans, Green. OCLC 4277811. (Volume 2)
• Knollenberg, Bernhard (1975). Growth of the American Revolution, 1766–1775. New York: Free Press. ISBN 0-02-917110-5.
• Lurie, Maxine (ed) (2004). Encyclopedia of New Jersey. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press. ISBN 9780813533254. OCLC 53131560.
• Martinelli, Patricia (2012). New Jersey Ghost Towns: Uncovering the Hidden Past. Mechanicsburg, PA: Stackpole Books. ISBN 9780811709101. OCLC 755699329.
• Nason, Elias; Varney, George (1890). A Gazetteer of the State of Massachusetts. Boston, MA: B. B. Russell. OCLC 35077879.
• Nicolson, Colin (2000). The "Infamas Govener" Francis Bernard and the Origins of the American Revolution. Boston, MA: Northeastern University Press. ISBN 978-1-55553-463-9. OCLC 59532824.
• Smith (ed), J. E. A (1869). The History of Pittsfield (Berkshire County), Massachusetts, Volume 1. Boston, MA: Lee and Shepard. OCLC 3578710.
• Walett, Francis (June 1965). "Governor Bernard's Undoing: An Earlier Hutchinson Letters Affair". The New England Quarterly 38 (2): 217–226. JSTOR 363591.
• Nicolson, Colin (1991). "Governor Francis Bernard, the Massachusetts Friends of Government, and the Advent of the Revolution". Proceedings of the Massachusetts Historical Society (Third Series, Volume 103): 24–113. JSTOR 25081034.

Primary sources

• Nicolson, Colin, ed. The Papers of Francis Bernard, Governor of Colonial Massachusetts, 1760-69, 6 vols. Colonial Society of Massachusetts and Univ. of Virginia Press, Boston: 2007-. Vols. 1 to 5 published to date.
  • vol. 5: 1768–1769. (2015). xxvi, 460 pp.