Ken Livingstone

Ken Livingstone
Livingstone in 2008
1st Mayor of London
In office 4 May 2000 – 4 May 2008
Deputy	Nicky Gavron (2000–03) Jenny Jones (2003–04) Nicky Gavron (2004–08)
Preceded by	Office created
Succeeded by	Boris Johnson
Leader of the Greater London Council
In office 17 May 1981 – 1 April 1986
Preceded by	Horace Cutler
Succeeded by	Office abolished
Member of Parliament for Brent East
In office 11 June 1987 – 7 June 2001
Preceded by	Reg Freeson
Succeeded by	Paul Daisley
Majority	23,748 (45.0%)
Personal details
Born	Kenneth Robert Livingstone 17 June 1945 London, United Kingdom
Nationality	British
Political party	Labour (1968–2000, 2003–2016 suspended)[1]
Spouse(s)	Christine Chapman (1973–1982) Emma Beal (2009–present)[2]
Children	5
Residence	North London
Alma mater	Tulse Hill School

Kenneth Robert Livingstone (born 17 June 1945) is an English politician who served as the Leader of the Greater London Council (GLC) from 1981 until the Council was abolished in 1986, and as Mayor of London from the creation of the office in 2000 until 2008. He also served as the Member of Parliament (MP) for Brent East from 1987 to 2001. A suspended member of the Labour Party, he was on the party's hard left, ideologically identifying as a democratic socialist.

Born to a working-class family in Lambeth, Livingstone joined Labour in 1968 and was elected to represent Norwood at the GLC in 1973, Hackney North and Stoke Newington in 1977, and Paddington in 1981, when he was elected leader of the GLC by Labour members. Attempting to reduce London Underground fares, his plans were challenged in court and declared unlawful; more successful were his schemes to benefit women and underprivileged minorities, despite stiff opposition. Livingstone was heavily criticised in the mainstream media for supporting controversial issues like republicanism, LGBT rights, and a United Ireland, and given the moniker "Red Ken". Livingstone was a vocal opponent of the Conservative Party government of Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher, which in 1986 abolished the GLC. Elected as MP for Brent East in 1987, he became closely associated with anti-racist campaigns. He unsuccessfully stood for Labour Party leader on a leftist platform in 1992 and 1994, and became a vocal critic of Tony Blair's New Labour project that pushed the party to the centre.

After failing to become Labour's candidate in the 2000 London mayoral election, Livingstone successfully contested the election as an independent candidate. In his first term as Mayor of London, he introduced the congestion charge, Oyster card, and articulated buses, and unsuccessfully opposed the government's privatisation of London Underground. Despite his opposition to Blair's government on issues like the Iraq War, Livingstone was invited to stand for re-election as Labour's candidate and was re-elected in 2004, expanding his transport policies, introducing new environmental regulations, and enacting civil rights policies. Initiating and overseeing London's winning bid to host the 2012 Summer Olympics and ushering in a major redevelopment of the city's East End, his leadership after the 7 July 2005 London bombings was widely praised. He stood unsuccessfully as Labour candidate in London's mayoral elections of 2008 and 2012, losing to Conservative candidate Boris Johnson.

Characterised as "the only truly successful Left-wing British politician of modern times",^[3] Livingstone is a highly controversial figure in British politics. Supporters lauded his efforts to improve rights for women, LGBT people, and ethnic minorities in London, but critics accused him of cronyism and antisemitism and lambasted his connections to Islamists, Marxists, and Irish republicans.

Early life

Childhood and young adulthood: 1945–1967

Livingstone was born in his grandmother's house in Lambeth, south London, on 17 June 1945.^[4] His family was working class; his mother, Ethel Ada (née Kennard, 1915–1997), had been born in Southwark before training as an acrobatic dancer and working on the music hall circuit prior to the Second World War.^[5][6] Ken's Scottish father, Robert "Bob" Moffat Livingstone (1915–1971), had been born in Dunoon before joining the Merchant Navy in 1932 and becoming ship's master.^[7][8] Having met in April 1940 at a music hall in Workington, they married within three months. After the war the couple moved in with Ethel's aggressive mother, Zona Ann (Williams), whom Livingstone considered "tyrannical".^[9] Livingstone's sister Lin was born 2¹⁄₂ years later.^[10] Robert and Ethel went through various jobs in the post-war years, with the former working on fishing trawlers and English Channel ferries, while the latter worked in a bakers, at Freemans catalogue dispatch and as a cinema usherette.^[11] Livingstone's parents were "working class Tories", and unlike many Conservative voters at the time did not hold to socially conservative views on race and sexuality, opposing racism and homophobia.^[12] The family was nominally Anglican, although Livingstone abandoned Christianity when he was 11, becoming an atheist.^[13]

Moving to a Tulse Hill council housing estate, Livingstone attended St. Leonard's Primary School, and after failing his eleven plus exam, in 1956 began secondary education at Tulse Hill Comprehensive School.^[14] In 1957, his family purchased their own property at 66 Wolfington Road, West Norwood.^[15] Rather shy at school, he was bullied, and got into trouble for truancy.^[16] One year, his form master was Philip Hobsbaum, who encouraged his pupils to debate current events, first interesting Livingstone in politics. He related that he became "an argumentative cocky little brat" at home, bringing up topics at the dinner table to enrage his father.^[17] His interest in politics was furthered by the 1958 Papal election of Pope John XXIII – a man who had "a strong impact" on Livingstone – and the United States presidential election, 1960.^[18] At Tulse Hill Comprehensive he gained his interest in amphibians and reptiles, keeping several as pets; his mother worried that rather than focusing on school work all he cared about was "his pet lizard and friends".^[19] At school he attained four O-levels in English Literature, English Language, Geography and Art, subjects he later described as "the easy ones". He started work rather than stay on for the non-compulsory sixth form, which required six O-levels.^[20]

From 1962 through to 1970, Livingstone worked as a technician at the Chester Beatty cancer research laboratory in Fulham, looking after animals used in experimentation.^[21] Most of the technicians were socialists, and Livingstone helped found a branch of the Association of Scientific, Technical and Managerial Staffs to fight redundancies imposed by company bosses.^[22] Livingstone's leftist views solidified upon the election of Labour Prime Minister Harold Wilson in 1964.^[23] With a friend from Chester Beatty, Livingstone toured West Africa in 1966, visiting Algeria, Niger, Nigeria, Lagos, Ghana and Togo. Interested in the region's wildlife, Livingstone rescued an infant ostrich from being eaten, donating it to Lagos children's zoo.^[24] Returning home, he took part in several protest marches as a part of the anti-Vietnam War movement, becoming increasingly interested in politics and briefly subscribing to the publication of a libertarian socialist group, Solidarity.^[25]

Political activism: 1968–1970

"My arrival [at the Norwood Labour Party meetings] had been rather like taking a bottle of gin into a room full of alcoholics. I was immediately passed round and consumed."

Ken Livingstone (1987)^[26]

Livingstone joined the Labour Party in March 1968, when he was 23 years old, later describing it as "one of the few recorded instances of a rat climbing aboard a sinking ship".^[27] At the time, many leftists were leaving in disgust at the Labour government's support for the U.S. in the Vietnam War, cuts to the National Health Service budget, and restrictions on trade unions; many went on to join far-left parties like the International Socialists and the Socialist Labour League, or single-issue groups like the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament and the Child Poverty Action Group.^[27] Suffering mass electoral defeat at the local elections, in London, Labour lost 15 boroughs, including Livingstone's London Borough of Lambeth, which came under Conservative control.^[28] Contrastingly, Livingstone believed that grassroots campaigning – such as the 1968 student protests – were ineffective, joining Labour because he considered it the best chance for implementing progressive political change in the UK.^[29]

Joining his local Labour branch in Norwood, he involved himself in their operations, within a month becoming chair and secretary of the Norwood Young Socialists, gaining a place on the constituency's General Management and Executive Committees, and sitting on the Local Government Committee who prepared Labour's manifesto for the next borough election.^[30] Hoping for better qualifications, he attended night school, gaining O-levels in Human Anatomy, Physiology and Hygiene, and an A-level in Zoology. Leaving his job at Chester Beatty, in September 1970 he began a 3-year course at the Philippa Fawcett Teacher Training College (PFTTC) in Streatham; his attendance was poor, and he considered it "a complete waste" of time. Beginning a romantic relationship with Christine Chapman, president of the PFTTC student's union, the couple married in 1973.^[31] Realising the Conservative governance of Lambeth Borough council was hard to unseat, Livingstone aided Eddie Lopez in reaching out to members of the local populace disenfranchised from the traditional Labour leadership. Associating with the leftist Schools' Action Union (SAU) founded in the wake of the 1968 student protests, he encouraged members of the Brixton branch of the Black Panther Party to join Labour.^[32] His involvement in the SAU led to his dismissal from the PFTCC student's union, who disagreed with politicising secondary school pupils.^[33]

Lambeth Housing Committee: 1971–1973

"It was intoxicating to be at what seemed at the time the centre of events. We were pushing ahead with our schemes. We had honoured our pledge that pensioners should travel free on London Transport buses. We introduced the provision of free contraception for anyone who lived or worked in the borough. When Mrs Thatcher (then Education Secretary) made it illegal for Education Authorities to give children free school milk, Lambeth – which was not an education authority – stepped in to continue paying for the service."

Ken Livingstone on the Labour-run Lambeth Borough Council in the early 1970s (1987).^[34]

In 1971, Livingstone and his comrades developed a new strategy for obtaining political power in Lambeth borough. Focusing on campaigning for the marginal seats in the south of the borough, the safe Labour seats in the north were left to established party members. Public dissatisfaction with the Conservative government of Prime Minister Edward Heath led to Labour's best local government results since the 1940s; Labour leftists gained every marginal seat in Lambeth, and the borough returned to Labour control.^[35] In October 1971, Livingstone's father died of a heart attack; his mother soon moved to Lincoln.^[36] That year, Labour members voted Livingstone Vice-Chairman of the Housing Committee on the Lambeth London Borough Council, his first job in local government.^[37] Reforming the housing system, Livingstone and Committee Chairman Ewan Carr cancelled the proposed rent increase for council housing, temporarily halting the construction of Europe's largest tower blocks, and founded a Family Squatting Group to ensure that homeless families would be immediately rehoused through squatting in empty houses. He increased the number of compulsory purchase orders for private-rented properties, converting them to council housing.^[38] They faced opposition to their reforms, which were cancelled by central government.^[39]

Livingstone and the leftists became embroiled in factional in-fighting within Labour, vying for powerful positions with centrist members. Although never adopting Marxism, Livingstone became involved with a number of Trotskyist groups active within Labour; viewing them as potential allies, he became friends with Chris Knight, Graham Bash and Keith Veness, members of the Socialist Charter, a Trotskyist cell affiliated with the Revolutionary Communist League that had infiltrated the Labour party.^[40] In his struggle against Labour centrists, Livingstone was influenced by Trotskyist Ted Knight, who convinced him to oppose the use of British troops in Northern Ireland, believing they would simply be used to quash nationalist protests against British rule.^[41] Livingstone stood as the leftist candidate for the Chair of the Lambeth Housing Committee in April 1973, but was defeated by David Stimpson, who undid many of Livingston and Carr's reforms.^[42]

Early years on the Greater London Council: 1973–1977

In June 1972, after a campaign orchestrated by Eddie Lopez, Livingstone was selected as the Labour candidate for Norwood in the Greater London Council (GLC). In the 1973 GLC elections, he won the seat with 11,622 votes, a firm lead over his Conservative rival.^[43] Led by Reg Goodwin, the GLC was dominated by Labour, who controlled 57 seats, compared to 33 controlled by the Conservatives and 2 by the Liberal Party. Of the Labour GLC members, around 16, including Livingstone, were staunch leftists.^[44] Representing Norwood in the GLC, Livingstone continued as a Lambeth councillor and Vice Chairman of the Lambeth Housing Committee, criticising Lambeth council's dealings with the borough's homeless. Learning that the council had pursued a racist policy of allocating the best housing to white working-class families, Livingstone went public with the evidence, which was published in the South London Press.^[45] In August 1973, he publicly threatened to resign from the Lambeth Housing Committee if the council failed "to honour longstanding promises" to rehouse 76 homeless families then staying in dilapidated and overcrowded halfway accommodation. Frustrated at the council's failure to achieve this, he resigned from the Housing Committee in December 1973.^[46]

Considered a radical troublemaker by the GLC's Labour management, Livingstone was allocated the relatively unimportant position of Vice Chairman of the Film Viewing Board, monitoring the release of soft pornography. Like most Board members, Livingstone opposed cinematic censorship, a view he changed with the increasing availability of violent pornography.^[47] With growing support from Labour leftists, in March 1974 he was elected onto the executive of the Greater London Labour Party (GLLP), responsible for drawing up the manifesto for the GLC Labour group and the lists of candidates for council and parliamentary seats.^[48] Turning his attention once more to housing, he became Vice Chairman of the GLC's Housing Management Committee, however was sacked in April 1975 for his vocal opposition to the Goodwin administration's decision to cut £50,000,000 from the GLC's house-building budget.^[49] Coming up to the 1977 GLC elections, Livingstone recognised the difficulty of retaining his Norwood seat, instead being selected for Hackney North and Stoke Newington, a Labour safe seat, following the retirement of David Pitt. Accused of being a "carpetbagger", it ensured he was one of the few leftist Labour councillors to remain on the GLC, which fell into Conservative hands under Horace Cutler.^[50]

Hampstead: 1977–1980

Margaret Thatcher, leader (1975–90) of the Conservative Party, prime minister (1979–90) of the United Kingdom

Turning towards the Houses of Parliament, Livingstone and Christine moved to West Hampstead, north London; in June 1977 he was selected by local party members as the Labour parliamentary candidate for the Hampstead constituency, beating Vince Cable.^[51] He gained notoriety in the Hampstead and Highgate Express for publicly reaffirming his support for the controversial issue of LGBT rights, declaring he supported the reduction of the age of consent for male same-sex activity from 21 to 16, in line with the different-sex age of consent.^[52] Becoming active in the politics of the London Borough of Camden, Livingstone was elected Chair of Camden's Housing Committee; putting forward radical reforms, he democratized council housing meetings by welcoming local people, froze rents for a year, reformed the rate collection system, changed rent arrears procedures and implemented further compulsory purchase orders to increase council housing. Criticised by some senior colleagues as incompetent and excessively ambitious, some accused him of encouraging leftists to move into the borough's council housing to increase his local support base.^[53]

In 1979, internal crisis rocked Labour as activist group, the Campaign for Labour Democracy, struggled with the Parliamentary Labour Party for a greater say in party management.^[54] Livingstone joined the activists, on 15 July 1978 helping unify small hard left groups as the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory (SCLV). Producing a sporadically published paper, Socialist Organiser, as a mouthpiece for Livingstone's views,^[55] it criticised Labour Prime Minister James Callaghan as "anti-working class".^[56] In January 1979, Britain was hit by a series of public sector worker strikes that came to be known as the "Winter of Discontent." In Camden Borough, council employees unionised under the National Union of Public Employees (NUPE) went on strike, demanding a 35-hour limit to their working week and a weekly wage increase to £60. Livingstone backed the strikers, urging Camden Council to grant their demands, eventually getting his way. District auditor Ian Pickwell, a government-appointed accountant who monitored council finances, claimed that this move was reckless and illegal, taking Camden Council to court. If found guilty, Livingstone would have been held personally responsible for the measure, forced to pay the massive surcharge, and been disqualified for public office for five years; ultimately the judge threw out the case.^[57]

In May 1979, a general election was held in the United Kingdom. Standing as Labour candidate for Hampstead, Livingstone was defeated by the incumbent Conservative, Geoffrey Finsberg. Weakened by the Winter of Discontent, Callaghan's government lost to the Conservatives, whose leader, Margaret Thatcher, became Prime Minister. A staunch right winger and free market advocate, she became a bitter opponent of the labour movement and Livingstone.^[58] Following the electoral defeat, Livingstone told Socialist Organiser that the blame lay solely with the "Labour government's policies" and the anti-democratic attitude of Callaghan and the Parliamentary Labour Party, calling for greater party democracy and a turn towards a socialist platform. This was a popular message among many Labour activists amassed under the SCLV. The primary figurehead for this leftist trend was Tony Benn, who narrowly missed being elected deputy leader of Labour in September 1981, under new party leader Michael Foot. The head of the "Bennite left", Benn became "an inspiration and a prophet" to Livingstone; the two became the best known left-wingers in Labour.^[59]

Greater London Council leadership

Becoming leader of the GLC: 1979–1981

Inspired by the Bennites, Livingstone planned a GLC take-over; on 18 October 1979, he called a meeting of Labour leftists entitled "Taking over the GLC", beginning publication of monthly newsletter the London Labour Briefing. Focused on increasing leftist power in the London Labour Party, he urged socialists to stand as candidates in the upcoming GLC election. When the time came to choose who would lead London Labour in that election, Livingstone put his name down, but was challenged by the moderate Andrew McIntosh; in the April 1980 vote, McIntosh beat Livingstone by 14 votes to 13.^[60] In September 1980, Livingstone separated from his wife Christine, though they remained amicable. Moving into a small flat at 195 Randolph Avenue, Maida Vale with his pet reptiles and amphibians, he divorced in October 1982 and began a relationship with Kate Allen, chair of Camden Council Women's Committee.^[61]

County Hall in Lambeth, then home of the Greater London Council

Livingstone turned his attention to achieving a GLC Labour victory, exchanging his safe-seat in Hackney North for the marginal Inner London seat at Paddington; in May 1981 he won the seat by 2,397 votes.^[62] Cutler and the Conservatives learned of Livingstone's plans, proclaiming that a GLC Labour victory would lead to a Marxist takeover of London and then Britain; the rightist press picked up the story, with the Daily Express using the headline of "Why We Must Stop These Red Wreckers".^[63] Such scaremongering was ineffective, and the GLC election of May 1981 was a Labour victory, with McIntosh installed as Head of the GLC; within 24 hours he would be deposed by members of his own party, replaced by Livingstone.^[64]

On 7 May, Livingstone called a caucus of his supporters; announcing his intent to challenge McIntosh's leadership, he invited those assembled to stand for other GLC posts. The meeting ended at 4:45pm having agreed on a full slate of candidates. At 5 o'clock, McIntosh held a GLC Labour meeting; the attendees called an immediate leadership election, in which Livingstone defeated him by 30 votes to 20. The entire left caucus slate was then elected. The next day, a leftist coup deposed Sir Ashley Bramall on the Inner London Education Authority (ILEA), replacing him with Bryn Davies; the left group now controlled both the GLC and the ILEA.^[65]

McIntosh proclaimed the GLC coup illegitimate, asserting that Labour was in danger from a leftist take-over.^[66] The mainstream right-wing press criticised the coup; the Daily Mail called Livingstone a "left wing extremist", and The Sun nicknamed him "Red Ken", stating his victory meant "full-steam-ahead red-blooded Socialism for London." The Financial Times issued a "warning" that leftists could use such tactics to take control of the government, when "the erosion of our democracy will surely begin."^[67] Thatcher joined the rallying call, proclaiming that leftists like Livingstone had "no time for parliamentary democracy", but were plotting "To impose upon this nation a tyranny which the peoples of Eastern Europe yearn to cast aside."^[68]

Leader of the GLC: 1981–1983

Entering County Hall as GLC leader on 8 May 1981, Livingstone initiated changes, converting the building's Freemasonic temple into a meeting room and removing many of the privileges enjoyed by GLC members and senior officers.^[69] He initiated an open-door policy allowing citizens to hold meetings in the committee rooms free of charge, with County Hall gaining the nickname of "the People's Palace".^[70] Livingstone took great pleasure watching the disgust expressed by some Conservative GLC members when non-members began using the building's restaurant.^[70] In the London Labour Briefing, Livingstone announced "London's ours! After the most vicious GLC election of all time, the Labour Party has won a working majority on a radical socialist programme." He stated that their job was to "sustain a holding operation until such time as the Tory [Conservative] government can be brought down and replaced by a left-wing Labour government."^[71] There was a perception among Livingstone's allies that they constituted the genuine opposition to Thatcher's government, with Foot's Labour leadership dismissed as ineffectual; they hoped Benn would soon replace him.^[72]

"There is nothing that happens to you at any stage in your life that can prepare you for the British Press in full hue and cry. As a socialist I started out with the lowest possible opinion of Fleet Street and was amazed to discover that they managed to sink even lower than I expected... I would spend hours carefully explaining our policies only to open the paper the next morning and see instead a smear about my sex-life, alleged personality defects or some completely fabricated account of a meeting or a split that never actually happened."

Ken Livingstone, 1987.^[73]

There was a widespread public perception that Livingstone's GLC leadership was illegitimate, while the mainstream British media remained resolutely hostile to the hard left.^[74] Livingstone received the levels of national press attention normally reserved for senior Members of Parliament.^[75] A press interview was arranged with Max Hastings for the Evening Standard, in which Livingstone was portrayed as affable but ruthless.^[76] The Sun's editor Kelvin MacKenzie took a particular interest in Livingstone, establishing a reporting team to 'dig up the dirt' on him; they were unable to uncover any scandalous information, focusing on his love of amphibians, a personality trait mocked by other media sources.^[77] The satirical journal Private Eye referred to him as "Ken Leninspart" after Vladimir Lenin,^[78] proceeding to erroneously claim that Livingstone received funding from the Libyan Jamahiriya; suing them for libel, in November 1983 the journal apologised, awarding Livingstone £15,000 in damages in an out-of-court settlement.^[79]

During 1982, Livingstone made new appointments to the GLC governance, with John McDonnell appointed key chair of finance and Valerie Wise chair of the new Women's Committee, while Sir Ashley Bramall became GLC chairman and Tony McBrearty was appointed chair of housing. Others stayed in their former positions, including Dave Wetzel as transport chair and Mike Ward as chair of industry; thus was created what biographer John Carvel described as "the second Livingstone administration", leading to a "more calm and supportive environment".^[80] Turning his attention once more to Parliament, Livingstone attempted to get selected as the Labour candidate for the constituency of Brent East, a place which he felt an "affinity" for and where several friends lived. At the time, the Brent East Labour Party was in strife as competing factions battled for control, with Livingstone attempting to gain the support of both the hard and soft left. Securing a significant level of support from local party members, he nonetheless failed to apply for candidacy in time, and so the incumbent centrist Reg Freeson was once more selected as Labour candidate for Brent East. A subsequent vote at the council meeting revealed that 52 local Labour members would have voted for Livingstone, with only 2 for Freeson and 3 abstentions. Nevertheless, in the United Kingdom general election, 1983, Freeson went on to win the Brent East constituency for Labour.^[81] In 1983, Livingstone began co-presenting a late night television chat show with Janet Street-Porter for London Weekend Television.^[82]

Fares Fair and transport policy

The Greater London Labour Manifesto for the 1981 elections, although written under McIntosh's leadership, had been determined by a special conference of the London Labour Party in October 1980 in which Livingstone's speech had been decisive on transport policy. The manifesto focused on job creation schemes and cutting London Transport fares, and it was to these issues that Livingstone's administration turned.^[83] One primary manifesto focus had been a pledge known as Fares Fair, which focused on reducing London Underground fares and freezing them at that lower rate. Based on a fare freeze implemented by the South Yorkshire Metropolitan County Council in 1975, it was widely considered to be a moderate and mainstream policy by Labour, which it was hoped would get more Londoners using public transport, thereby reducing congestion. In October 1981, the GLC implemented their policy, cutting London Transport fares by 32%; to fund the move, the GLC planned to increase the London rates.^[84]

The legality of the Fares Fair policy was challenged by Dennis Barkway, Conservative leader of the London Borough of Bromley council, who complained that his constituents were having to pay for cheaper fares on the London Underground when it did not operate in their borough. Although the Divisional Court initially found in favour of the GLC, Bromley Borough took the issue to a court of appeal, where three judges – Lord Denning, Lord Justice Oliver and Lord Justice Watkins – reversed the previous decision, finding in favour of Bromley Borough on 10 November. They proclaimed that the Fares Fair policy was illegal because the GLC was expressly forbidden from choosing to run London Transport at a deficit, even if this was in the perceived interest of Londoners.^[85] The GLC appealed this decision, taking the case to the House of Lords; on 17 December five Law Lords unanimously ruled in favour of Bromley Borough Council, putting a permanent end to the Fares Fair policy.^[86] GLC transport chairman Dave Wetzel labelled the judges "Vandals in Ermine" while Livingstone maintained his belief that the judicial decision was politically motivated.^[87]

Initially presenting a motion to the GLC Labour groups that they refuse to comply with the judicial decision and continue with the policy regardless, but was out-voted by 32–22; many commentators claimed that Livingstone had only been bluffing in order to save face among the Labour Left.^[88] Instead, Livingstone got on board with a campaign known as "Keep Fares Fair" in order to bring about a change in the law that would make the Fares Fair policy legal; an alternate movement, "Can't Pay, Won't Pay", accused Livingstone of being a sell-out and insisted that the GLC proceed with its policies regardless of their legality.^[89] One aspect of the London Transport reforms was however maintained; the new system of flat fares within ticket zones, and the inter-modal Travelcard ticket continues as the basis of the ticketing system.^[90] The GLC then put together new measures in the hope to reduce London Transport fares by a more modest amount, 25%, taking them back to roughly the price that they were when Livingstone's administration took office; it was ruled legal in January 1983, and subsequently implemented.^[91]

GLEB and nuclear disarmament

Livingstone's administration founded the Greater London Enterprise Board (GLEB) to create employment by investing in the industrial regeneration of London, with the funds provided by the council, its workers' pension fund and the financial markets. Livingstone later claimed that GLC bureaucrats obstructed much of what GLEB tried to achieve.^[92] Other policies implemented by the Labour Left also foundered. Attempts to prevent the sale-off of GLC council housing largely failed, in part due to the strong opposition from the Conservative government.^[93] ILEA attempted to carry through with its promise to cut the price of school meals in the capital from 35p to 25p, but was forced to abandon its plans following legal advice that the councillors could be made to pay the surcharge and disqualified from public office.^[94]

The Livingstone administration took a strong stance on the issue of nuclear disarmament, proclaiming London a "nuclear-free zone". On 20 May 1981, the GLC halted its annual spending of £1 million on nuclear war defence plans, with Livingstone's deputy, Illtyd Harrington, proclaiming that "we are challenging... the absurd cosmetic approach to Armageddon." They published the names of the 3000 politicians and administrators who had been earmarked for survival in underground bunkers in the event of a nuclear strike on London. Thatcher's government remained highly critical of these moves, putting out a propaganda campaign explaining their argument for the necessity of Britain's nuclear deterrent to counter the Soviet Union.^[95]

Egalitarian policies

"Arguing that politics had long been the near-exclusive preserve of white middle-aged men, the GLC began an attempt to open itself to representations from other groups, principally from women, the working-class, ethnic minorities and homosexuals but also from children and the elderly. This was a real break from traditional politics as practised centrally by both major parties... and it attracted hostility from all sides."

Historian Alwyn W. Turner, 2010.^[96]

An egalitarian, Livingstone's administration advocated measures to improve the lives of disadvantaged minorities within London, including women, the disabled, homosexuals, and ethnic minorities, who together made up a sizeable percentage of the city's population; what Reg Race called "the Rainbow Coalition".^[97] The GLC allocated a small percentage of its expenditure on funding minority community groups, including the London Gay Teenage Group, English Collective of Prostitutes, Women Against Rape, Lesbian Line, A Woman's Place, and Rights of Women.^[97] Believing these groups could initiate social change, the GLC increased its annual funding of voluntary organisations from £6 million in 1980 to £50 million in 1984.^[98] They also provided loans to such groups, coming under a barrage of press criticism for awarding a loan to the Sheba Feminist Publishers, whose works were widely labelled pornographic.^[99] In July 1981, Livingstone founded the Ethnic Minorities Committee, the Police Committee, and the Gay and Lesbian Working Party, and in June 1982, a Women's Committee was also established.^[98] Believing the Metropolitan Police to be a racist organisation, he appointed Paul Boateng to head the Police Committee and monitor the force's activities.^[100] Considering the police a highly political organisation, he publicly remarked that "When you canvas police flats at election time, you find that they are either Conservatives who think of Thatcher as a bit of a pinko or they are National Front."^[100]

The Conservatives and mainstream rightist press were largely critical of these measures, considering them symptomatic of what they derogatarily termed the "loony left". Claiming that these only served "fringe" interests, their criticisms often exhibited racist, homophobic and sexist sentiment.^[101] A number of journalists fabricated stories designed to discredit Livingstone and the "loony left", for instance claiming that the GLC made its workers drink only Nicaraguan coffee in solidarity with the country's socialist government, and that Haringey Council leader Bernie Grant had banned the use of the term "black bin liner" and the rhyme "Baa Baa Black Sheep" because they were perceived as racially insensitive.^[102] Writing in 2008, BBC reporter Andrew Hosken noted that although most of Livingstone's GLC administration's policies were ultimately a failure, its role in helping change social attitudes towards women and minorities in London remained its "enduring legacy".^[103]

Republicanism and Ireland

Invited to the Wedding of Charles, Prince of Wales, and Lady Diana Spencer at St Paul's Cathedral in July 1981, Livingstone – a republican critical of the monarchy – wished the couple well but turned down the offer. He also permitted Irish republican protesters to hold a vigil on the steps of County Hall throughout the wedding celebrations, both actions that enraged the press.^[104] His administration supported the People's March for Jobs, a demonstration of 500 anti-unemployment protesters who marched to London from Northern England, allowing them to sleep in County Hall and catering for them. Costing £19,000, critics argued that Livingstone was illegally using public money for his own political causes.^[105] The GLC orchestrated a propaganda campaign against Thatcher's government, in January 1982 erecting a sign on the top of County Hall – clearly visible from the Houses of Parliament – stating the number of unemployed in London.^[106]

In September 1981, Livingstone began production of weekly newspaper, the Labour Herald, co-edited with Ted Knight and Matthew Warburton. It was published by a press owned by the Trotskyist Workers Revolutionary Party (WRP), who had financed it with funding from Libya and Iraq. Livingstone's commercial relationship with WRP leader Gerry Healy was controversial among British socialists, many of whom disapproved of Healy's violent nature.^[107] The Labour Herald folded in 1985, when Healy was exposed as a sex offender and ousted from the WRP's leadership.^[108]

"This morning the Sun presents the most odious man in Britain. Take a bow, Mr Livingstone, socialist leader of the Greater London Council. In just a few months since he appeared on the national scene, he has quickly become a joke. But no one can laugh at him any more. The joke has turned sour, sick and obscene. For Mr Livingstone steps forward as the defender and the apologist of the criminal, murderous activities of the IRA."

The Sun lambasts Livingstone after his support for Irish republicanism.^[109]

A supporter of Irish reunification, Livingstone had connections with the left-wing Irish republican party Sinn Féin and in July, met with the mother of an imprisoned Provisional Irish Republican Army (IRA) militant Thomas McElwee, then taking part in the 1981 Irish hunger strike. That day, Livingstone publicly proclaimed his support for those prisoners on hunger strike, claiming that the British government's fight against the IRA was not "some sort of campaign against terrorism" but was "the last colonial war." He was heavily criticised for this meeting and his statements in the mainstream press, while Prime Minister Thatcher claimed that his comments constituted "the most disgraceful statement I have ever heard."^[110] Soon after, he also met with the children of Yvonne Dunlop, an Irish Protestant who had been killed in McElwee's bomb attack.^[111]

On 10 October, the IRA bombed London's Chelsea Barracks, killing 2 and injuring 40. Denouncing the attack, Livingstone informed members of the Cambridge University Tory Reform Group that it was a misunderstanding to view the IRA as "criminals or lunatics" because of their strong political motives and that "violence will recur again and again as long as we are in Ireland." Mainstream press criticised him for these comments, with The Sun labeling him "the most odious man in Britain". In response, Livingstone proclaimed that the press coverage had been "ill-founded, utterly out of context and distorted", reiterating his opposition both to IRA attacks and British rule in Northern Ireland.^[112] Anti-Livingstone pressure mounted and on 15 October he was publicly attacked in the street by members of unionist militia, The Friends of Ulster. In a second incident, Livingstone was attacked by far right skinheads shouting "commie bastard" at the Three Horseshoes Pub in Hampstead.^[113] Known as "Green Ken" among Ulster Unionists, Unionist paramilitary Michael Stone of the Ulster Defence Association plotted to kill Livingstone, only abandoning the plan when he became convinced that the security services were onto him.^{[114][115][116]}

Livingstone's willingness to meet with Irish republican leader Gerry Adams (above, pictured in 2001), caused outrage within his own party and the British press

Livingstone agreed to meet Gerry Adams, Sinn Féin President and IRA-supporter, after Adams was invited to London by Labour members of the Troops Out campaign in December 1982. The same day as the invitation was made, the Irish National Liberation Army (INLA) bombed The Droppin Well bar in Ballykelly, County Londonderry, killing 11 soldiers and 6 civilians; in the aftermath, Livingstone was pressured to cancel the meeting. Expressing his horror at the bombing, Livingstone insisted that the meeting proceed, for Adams had no connection with the INLA, but Conservative Home Secretary Willie Whitelaw banned Adams' entry to Britain with the 1976 Prevention of Terrorism (Temporary Provisions) Act.^[117] In February 1983, Livingstone visited Adams in his constituency of West Belfast, receiving a hero's welcome from local republicans.^[118] In July 1983, Adams finally came to London on the invite of Livingstone and MP Jeremy Corbyn, allowing him to present his views to a mainstream British audience through televised interviews.^[119] In August, Livingstone was interviewed on Irish state radio, proclaiming that Britain's 800-year occupation of Ireland was more destructive than the Holocaust; he was publicly criticised by Labour members and the press.^[119] He also controversially expressed solidarity with the Marxist–Leninist government of Fidel Castro in Cuba against the U.S. economic embargo, in turn receiving an annual Christmas gift of Cuban rum from the Cuban embassy.^[120]

Courting further controversy, in the Falklands War of 1982, during which the United Kingdom battled Argentina for control of the Falkland Islands, Livingstone stated his belief that the islands rightfully belonged to the Argentinian people, but not the military junta then ruling the country.^[121] Upon British victory, he sarcastically remarked that "Britain had finally been able to beat the hell out of a country smaller, weaker and even worse governed than we were."^[122] Challenging the Conservative government's militarism, the GLC proclaimed 1983 to be "Peace Year", solidifying ties with the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament (CND) in order to advocate international nuclear disarmament, a measure opposed by the Thatcher government.^[123] In keeping with this pacifistic outlook, they banned the Territorial Army from marching past County Hall that year.^[124] The GLC then proclaimed 1984 to be "Anti-Racism Year".^[125] In July 1985, the GLC twinned London with the Nicaraguan city of Managua, then under the control of the socialist Sandinista National Liberation Front.^[126] The press also continued to criticise the Livingstone administration's funding of volunteer groups that they perceived represented only "fringe interests". As Livingstone biographer Andrew Hosken remarked, "by far the most contentious grant" was given in February 1983 to a group called Babies Against the Bomb, founded by a group of mothers who had united to campaign against nuclear weapons.^[127]

Members of the London Labour groups chastised Livingstone for his controversial statements, believing them detrimental to the party, leading Labour members and supporters to defect to the Social Democratic Party (SDP).^[128] Many highlighted Labour's failure to secure the seat in the Croydon North West by-election, 1981 as a sign of Labour's prospects under Livingstone.^[129] Some called for Livingstone's removal, but Michael Foot's Trotskyist assistant Una Cooze defended Livingstone's position to her boss.^[130] Television and radio outlets welcomed Livingstone on for interviews; described by biographer John Carvel as having "one of the best television styles of any contemporary politician", Livingstone used this medium to speak to a wider audience, gaining widespread public support, something Carvell attributed to his "directness, self-deprecation, colourful language, complete unflappability under fire and lack of pomposity", coupled with popular policies like Fares Fair.^[131]

Abolition of the GLC: 1983–1986

"Whatever the long-term achievements of Livingstone's administration, there is no question that its aggression towards the government and the Establishment ultimately spelled doom for the GLC. In the eyes of the government and the media, Livingstone started badly and got worse. Within eight months, he was in deep crisis and within two years, Margaret Thatcher had started the wheels in motion for abolition. Such was the backlash by judges, civil servants, politicians and journalists that Livingstone failed not only in the key objective of bringing down Thatcher but also in implementing many of his policies. It would lay Livingstone open to the allegation that he had laid the GLC at the sacrificial altar of his ambition."

Biographer Andrew Hosken (2008).^[132]

The 1983 general election proved disastrous for Labour, as much of their support went to the Social Democrat-Liberal Alliance, and Thatcher entered her second term in office. Foot was replaced by Neil Kinnock, a man Livingstone considered "repellent".^[133] Livingstone publicly attributed Labour's electoral failure to the leading role that the party's capitalist wing had played, arguing that the party should promote a socialist program of "national reconstruction", overseeing the nationalisation of banks and major industry and allowing for the investment in new development.^[134]

Considering it a waste of rate payer's money, Thatcher's government was keen to abolish the GLC and devolve control to the Greater London boroughs, stating its intention to do so in its 1983 electoral manifesto.^[135] Secretary of State for Employment Norman Tebbit lambasted the GLC as "Labour-dominated, high-spending and at odds with the government's view of the world"; Livingstone commented that there was "a huge gulf between the cultural values of the GLC Labour group and everything that Mrs Thatcher considered right and proper."^[136] The government felt confident that there was sufficient opposition to Livingstone's administration that they could abolish the GLC: according to a MORI poll in April 1983, 58% of Londoners were dissatisfied and 26% satisfied with Livingstone.^[137]

Attempting to fight the proposals, the GLC devoted £11 million to a campaign led by Reg Race focusing on press campaigning, advertising, and parliamentary lobbying. The campaign sent Livingstone on a party roadshow conference in which he convinced the Liberal and Social Democratic parties to oppose abolition. Using the slogan "say no to no say", they publicly highlighted that without the GLC, London would be the only capital city in Western Europe without a directly elected body.^[138] The campaign was successful, with polls indicating majority support among Londoners for retaining the Council, and in March 1984, 20,000 public servants held a 24-hour strike in support.^[139] The government nevertheless remained committed to abolition, and in June 1984 the House of Commons passed the Local Government Act 1985 with 237 votes in favour and 217 against.^[140] Livingstone and three senior GLC members resigned their seats in August 1984, to force byelections on the issue of abolition, but the Conservatives declined to contest them and all four were comfortably re-elected on a low turnout.^[141] Labour group chief whip John Wilson was interim council leader during the byelection campaign.

The GLC was formally abolished at midnight on 31 March 1986, with Livingstone marking the occasion by holding a free concert at Festival Hall.^[142] In his capacity as former leader of the GLC, Livingstone was invited to visit Australia, Israel, and Zimbabwe in the following months by leftist groups in those countries, before he and Allen undertook a 5-week Himalayan trek to the base camp of Mount Everest.^[143]

Member of Parliament

The Houses of Parliament, where Livingstone served as MP

Turning his attention to a parliamentary career, Livingstone defeated Reg Freeson to represent Labour for the north-west London constituency of Brent East in the 1987 general election.^[144] When the election came, he narrowly defeated Conservative candidate Harriet Crawley to become Brent East's MP, while Thatcher retained the Premiership for a third term.^[145] Livingstone found the atmosphere of the Houses of Parliament uncomfortable, labeling it "absolutely tribal",^[146] and asserting that "It's like working in the Natural History Museum, except not all the exhibits are stuffed."^[147] There was much hostility between him and the Parliamentary Labour Party, who allocated him a windowless office with fellow leftist MP Harry Barnes.^[148] He took on Maureen Charleson as his personal secretary, who would remain with him for the next 20 years.^[149]

In his maiden speech to Parliament in July 1987, Livingstone used parliamentary privilege to raise a number of allegations made by Fred Holroyd, a former Special Intelligence Service operative in Northern Ireland. Despite the convention of maiden speeches being non-controversial, Livingstone alleged that Holroyd had been mistreated when he tried to expose MI5 collusion with Ulster loyalist paramilitaries in the 1970s. Thatcher denounced his claims as "utterly contemptible".^[150] In September 1987 Livingstone was elected to Labour's National Executive Committee (NEC), although was voted off in October 1989, to be replaced by John Prescott.^[151] As Kinnock tried to pull Labour to the centre, Livingstone worked to strengthen socialist elements in the party.^[152] He continued to make his opinions known, refusing to pay the controversial poll tax until it was revoked, and being one of the 55 Labour MPs to oppose British involvement in the Gulf War in January 1991.^[153] Conversely, he supported NATO intervention in the Balkans, and the bombing of Serbia.^[154]

In the 1992 general election, John Major led the Conservatives to a narrow victory, resulting in Kinnock's resignation as head of Labour. Livingstone put his name forward as a proposed replacement, with Bernie Grant as his deputy, although they were not selected, with John Smith and Margaret Beckett taking the positions instead.^[155] After Smith died in May 1994, Livingstone again put his name down as a potential leader, although withdrew it due to a lack of support. Instead, Tony Blair was selected, with Livingstone predicting that he would be "the most right-wing leader" in Labour history.^[156] Blair and his supporters sought to reform the party by further expunging leftist elements and taking it to the centre ground, thus creating "New Labour", with Blairite Peter Mandelson asserting that hard left figures like Livingstone represented "the enemy" of reform.^[157] Throughout 1995, Livingstone unsuccessfully fought Blair's attempts to remove Clause Four (promoting nationalised industry) from the Labour constitution, which he saw as a betrayal of the party's socialist roots.^[158] In 1996, he warned of the growing influence of spin doctors in the party, and called for Blair to sack Alastair Campbell after a High Court judge criticised him in a libel trial.^[159] Nevertheless, Blair's reforms led Labour to a landslide victory in the 1997 general election, resulting in the formation of the first Labour government since 1979.^[160] In December 1997, Livingstone joined a Labour revolt against Blair's attempts to cut benefits to single mothers, and in March 1998 publicly criticised Gordon Brown for advocating "an awful lot of Thatcherite nonsense" and attempting to privatise the London Underground through the PPP scheme.^[161] However, in 1997 he was re-elected to the NEC, beating Mandelson to the position.^[162]

"I want power. I want to change Britain and I'm not ashamed to say it. Anyone who wants to achieve change would grab at the leadership."

Ken Livingstone on the Labour leadership, 1986.^[163]

Livingstone continued his association with members of Trotskyite group Socialist Action, with the group's leader John Ross became his most important adviser, teaching him about economics.^[164] Investing in an advanced £25,000 computer, he and Ross used the machine to undertake complex economic analysis, on the basis of which they began publishing the Socialist Economic Bulletin in 1990.^[165] Two other members of the group, Redmond O'Neill and Simon Fletcher, also became trusted advisers.^[166] When Socialist Action founded a campaign group, the Anti-Racist Alliance, Livingstone came to be closely associated with it. They campaigned around the racist murder of Stephen Lawrence and the rise of the far right British National Party, but were disadvantaged by an ongoing rivalry with the Anti-Nazi League.^[167]

As his political significance waned, Livingstone gained more work in the media, commenting that the press "started to use me only once they thought I was harmless".^[168] To receive these outside earnings, he founded a company known as Localaction Ltd.^[169] In 1987 he authored an autobiography for HarperCollins, If Voting Changed Anything They'd Abolish It,^[170] conducted journalism for the London Daily News,^[171] stood in for BBC Radio 2 disk-jockey Jimmy Young, and served as a judge for that year's Whitbread Prize.^[172] In 1989, Unwin Hyman published his second book, Livingstone's Labour: A Programme for the 90s, in which he expressed his views on a variety of issues,^[173] while that same year he was employed to promote Red Leicester cheese in adverts for the National Dairy Council and to appear in adverts for British Coal alongside Edwina Currie.^[174] In October 1991 Livingstone began writing a column for Rupert Murdoch's right-wing tabloid The Sun, a controversial move among British socialists.^[175] In his column he often discussed his love of amphibians and campaigned for the protection of the great crested newt, on the basis of which he was appointed vice president of the London Zoological Society in 1996–97.^[176] He subsequently began to write a food column for Esquire and then The Evening Standard, also making regular appearances on the BBC quiz show Have I Got News For You?.^[177] In 1995, Livingstone was invited to appear on the track "Ernold Same" by the band Blur.^[177]

Mayor of London

Mayoral election: 2000

By 1996, various prominent public figures were arguing for the implementation of directly-elected mayors for large UK cities like London.^[178] The idea of a London mayor of a Greater London Authority had been included in Labour's 1997 election manifesto, and after their election a referendum was scheduled for May 1998, in which there was a 72% yes vote with a 34% turnout.^[179] With the first mayoral election scheduled for May 2000, in March 1998 Livingstone stated his intention to stand as a potential Labour candidate for the position.^[180] Blair did not want Livingstone as London Mayor, claiming that he was one of the leftists who "almost knocked [the party] over the edge of the cliff into extinction" during the 1980s.^[181] He and the Labour spin doctors organised a campaign against Livingstone to ensure that he was not selected, with Campbell and Sally Morgan unsuccessfully attempting to get Oona King to denounce Livingstone.^[182] They failed to convince Mo Mowlam to stand for the mayorship, and instead encouraged the reluctant Frank Dobson to stand.^[183] Recognising that a 'one member, one vote' election within the London Labour Party would probably see Livingstone selected over Dobson, Blair ensured that a third of the votes would come from the rank-and-file members, a third from the trade unions, and a third from Labour MPs and MEPs, the latter two of which he could pressure into voting for his own preferred candidate, something that Dobson was deeply uncomfortable with.^[184] Information on the Blairite campaign against Livingstone became public, costing Dobson much support; nevertheless, due to the impact of the MPs and MEPs, Dobson won the candidacy with 51% to Livingstone's 48%.^[185]

Livingstone proclaimed Dobson to be "a tainted candidate" and stated his intention to run for the Mayoralty as an independent candidate. Aware that this would result in his expulsion from Labour, he publicly stated that "I have been forced to choose between the party I love and upholding the democratic rights of Londoners."^[186] The polls indicated clear support for Livingstone among the London electorate, with his campaign being run by his Socialist Action associates.^[187] He gained the support of a wide range of celebrities, from musicians like Fatboy Slim, Pink Floyd, the Chemical Brothers, and Blur, artists like Damian Hirst and Tracey Emin, and those from other fields, among them Ken Loach, Jo Brand, and Chris Evans, the latter of whom donated £200,000 to the campaign; half of what Livingstone required.^[188] In March 2000, Livingstone agreed to make a public apology to the House of Commons, after he was criticised over his failure to properly register outside interests worth more than £150,000.^[189] The election took place in May 2000, at which Livingstone came first with 58% of first and second-preference votes; Conservative candidate Steven Norris came second and Dobson third.^[190] Livingstone tearfully started his acceptance speech with "As I was saying before I was so rudely interrupted 14 years ago..."^[191]

First mayoral term: 2000–04

City Hall, specially built for the GLA

Livingstone now had "the largest and most direct mandate of any politician in British history",^[192] receiving an annual salary of £87,000.^[193] It was the Mayor's job to oversee a number of subordinate bodies, including the Metropolitan Police, Transport for London (TfL), the London Development Agency, and the London Fire Brigade, and in doing so he was granted a number of executive powers.^[194] He would be scrutinised by the elected London Assembly, whose first chairman was Trevor Phillips, a Labour politician with a mutual dislike of Livingstone.^[195] Livingstone was permitted twelve principal advisers, many of whom were members of Socialist Action or people whom he had worked with on the GLC.^[196] Ross and Fletcher became two of his closest confidants, with Livingstone commenting that "They aren't just my closest political advisers... they're also mostly my best friends."^[197] In 2002, he promoted six of his senior aides, resulting in allegations of cronyism from Assembly members.^[198] The Mayoral office was initially based in temporary headquarters at Romney House in Marsham Street, Westminster,^[199] while a purpose-built building was constructed in Southwark; termed City Hall, it was officially opened by Queen Elizabeth II in July 2002, with Livingstone commenting that it resembled a "glass testicle."^[200]

Much of Livingstone's first two years were devoted to setting up the Mayoral system and administration.^[201] He also devoted much time to battling New Labour's plans to upgrade the London Underground system through a public–private partnership (PPP) program, believing it to be too expensive and tantamount to the privatisation of a state-owned service. He furthermore had strong concerns about safety; PPP would divide different parts of the Underground among various companies, something that he argued threatened a holistic safety and maintenance program. These concerns were shared by the National Union of Rail, Maritime and Transport Workers (RMT) and the Associated Society of Locomotive Engineers and Firemen (ASLEF) trade union, who went on strike over the issue, being joined on the picket line by Livingstone.^[202] Appointing Bob Kiley as transport commissioner, the duo argued that the upgrade should be carried out in state hands through a public bond issue, as had been done in the case of the New York City Subway. They launched court cases against the government over PPP in 2001–02, but were ultimately unsuccessful, and the project went ahead, with the Underground being privatised in January 2003.^[202]

Although he had initially stated that he would not do so, Livingstone's administration sought to phase out use of the Routemaster buses, the design for which dated to the 1950s. Although iconic, they were deemed hazardous and responsible for a high number of deaths and serious injuries as passengers climbed onto them, also being non-wheelchair accessible and thus not meeting the requirements of the Disability Discrimination Act 1995. The process was gradual, with the last Routemaster being decommissioned in December 2005.^[203] The Routemasters were replaced by a new fleet of 103 articulated buses, known colloquially as "bendy buses", which were launched in June 2002. While the Routemasters fitted 80 people on at one time, the articulated buses fitted up to 140 passengers, however they were deemed dangerous for cyclists.^[204] Attempting to reduce London's environmental impact, Livingstone created the London Hydrogen Partnership and the London Energy Partnership in his first term as Mayor of London.^[205] The Mayor's Energy Strategy, "green light to clean power," committed London to reducing its emissions of carbon dioxide by 20%, relative to the 1990 level, by 2010.^[205]

Livingstone's administration introduced the fleet of articulated "bendy buses" to replace the Routemasters

Deeming them vermin, Livingstone sought to remove the pigeons from Trafalgar Square; he tried to evict seed sellers and introduced hawks to scare the pigeons off.^[206] He pedestrianised the north side of the Square, transforming it into a public space with a cafe, public toilets, and a lift for the disabled.^[207] He introduced an annual Saint Patrick's Day festival to celebrate the contributions of the Irish to London,^[208] and revived London's free anti-racism music festival, now called Rise: London United, later attributing London's 35% decrease in racist attacks to this and other anti-racist policies.^[209] Continuing his support for LGBT rights, in 2001 he set up Britain's first register for same-sex couples; while falling short of legal marriage rights, the register was seen as a step towards the Civil Partnership Act 2004.^[210]

Livingstone's relationship with Kate Allen ended in November 2001, although they remained friends.^[211] He then started a relationship with Emma Beal, together having two children, Thomas (born December 2002) and Mia (born March 2004).^[212] At a May 2002 party in Tufnell Park, Livingstone got into an argument with Beal's friend Robin Hedges, a reporter for The Evening Standard. Beal subsequently fell off of a wall and bruised his ribs; the press claimed that Livingstone had pushed him, although he insisted that he did not. Liberal Democrats on the London Assembly referred the matter to the Standards Board for England, who ruled that there was no evidence for any wrongdoing on Livingstone's behalf.^[213]

As proposed in their election manifesto, in February 2003 Livingstone's administration introduced a congestion charge covering 8 square miles in central London, charging motorists £5 a day for driving through the area. It was introduced in an attempt to deter traffic and reduce congestion; Livingstone himself took the London Underground to work, and tried to inspire more Londoners to use public transport rather than cars. The policy was highly controversial, and strongly opposed by businesses, resident groups, the roads lobby, and the Labour government; many commentators recognised that if opposition resulted in the policy being abandoned then it could lead to the end of Livingstone's political career.^[214] That year, the Political Studies Association named Livingstone 'Politician of the Year' due to his implementation of the 'bold and imaginative' scheme.^[215] The scheme resulted in a marked reduction on traffic in central London, resulting in improved bus services, and by 2007, TfL could claim that the charge had reduced congestion by 20%.^[216][217] To further encourage the use of public transport, in June 2003, the Oyster card system was introduced,^[218] while bus and Underground journeys were made free for people aged 11 to 18.^[219]

A car rental company's "Red Ken's Tax Paid" car sticker: a negative comment on the congestion charge

In 2002, Livingstone came out in support of a proposal for the 2012 Olympic Games to be held in London. He insisted however that the Games must be held in the East End, and result in an urban regeneration program centred on the Lee Valley. He gained the support of Labour's culture secretary Tessa Jowell, who convinced the government to back the plans in May 2003.^[220] In May 2004, the International Olympic Commission put London on the shortlist of potential locations for the Games, alongside Paris, Madrid, Moscow, and New York City; although Paris was widely expected to be the eventual victor, London would prove successful in its nomination.^[221] Another major development project was launched in February 2004 as the London Plan, in which Livingstone's administration laid out their intentions to deal with the city's major housing shortage by ensuring the construction of 30,000 new homes a year. It stressed that 50% of these should be deemed "affordable housing" although later critics would highlight that in actuality, the amount of "affordable housing" in these new constructions did not exceed 30%.^[222]

Livingstone had no control over government policy regarding immigration, which had resulted in a significant growth in foreign arrivals coming to London during his administration; from 2000 to 2005 London's population grew by 200,000 to reach 7.5 million.^[223] Livingstone did not oppose this, instead encouraging racial equality and celebrating the city's multiculturalism.^[224] Another policy over which Livingstone had no control was the U.K.'s involvement in the Iraq War, a U.S.-led invasion to overthrow Saddam Hussein's Iraqi government; Livingstone was a prominent critic of the conflict and involved himself in the Stop the War campaign.^[225] In November 2003, Livingstone made headlines for referring to US President George W. Bush as "the greatest threat to life on this planet," just before Bush's official visit to the UK. Livingstone also organised an alternative "Peace Reception" at City Hall "for everybody who is not George Bush," with anti-war Vietnam veteran Ron Kovic as the guest of honour.^[226]

Livingstone's success with the congestion charge and rejuvenation of Trafalgar Square led the Labour leadership to reconsider their position on him, with Blair re-admitting him to the party and asking that he stand as their Mayoral candidate for the 2004 election. Livingstone eagerly agreed, and Labour Mayoral candidate Nicky Gavron volunteered to take a subordinate position as his deputy.^[227] In campaigning for the election, Livingstone highlighted his record: the congestion charge, free bus travel for under 11s, 1000 extra buses, and 5000 extra police officers, whereas his main competitor, the Conservative Steve Norris, campaigned primarily on a policy of abolishing the congestion charge.^[228] Livingstone continued to court controversy throughout the campaign; in June 2004 he was quoted on The Guardian's website as saying: "I just long for the day I wake up and find that the Saudi Royal Family are swinging from lamp-posts and they've got a proper government that represents the people of Saudi Arabia", for which he was widely criticised.^{[229][230][231]} That same month he came under criticism from sectors of the left for urging RMT members to cross picket lines in a proposed Underground strike because the latest offer had been "extremely generous", leading RMT general secretary Bob Crow to step down as a TfL board member.^[229] In the London mayoral election, 2004, Livingstone was announced as the winner on 10 June 2004. He won 36% of first preference votes to Norris's 28% and Liberal Democrat Simon Hughes's 15%. When all the candidates except Livingstone and Norris were eliminated and the second preferences of those voters who had picked neither Livingstone or Norris as their first choice were counted, Livingstone won with 55% to Norris's 45%.^[232][233]

Second mayoral term: 2004–08

Livingstone attends the 2007 St Patrick's Day celebrations in London.

Amid the War on Terror and threat from Al Qaeda, Livingstone sought to build closer ties to the London's Muslim community, controversially agreeing to meet with Islamist groups like the Muslim Association of Britain alongside moderate organisations.^[234] In July 2004, he attended a conference discussing France's ban on the burka at which he talked alongside Islamist cleric Yusuf al-Qaradawi. Livingstone described al-Qaradawi as "one of the most authoritative Muslim scholars in the world today" and argued that his influence could help stop the radicalisation of young British Muslims. The move was controversial, with Jewish and LGBT organisations criticising Livingstone, citing al-Qaradawi's record of anti-Semitic and homophobic remarks, with the meeting leading to a publicised argument between Livingstone and his former supporter Peter Tatchell.^[235] Livingstone continued to champion the Palestinian cause in the Israel-Palestine conflict, in March 2005 accusing Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon of being a "war criminal" responsible for the 1982 Sabra and Shatila massacre.^[236]

During his second term, Livingstone continued his support for London's bid to host the 2012 Olympic Games, playing a crucial role in securing vital Russian support for the bid. On 6 July 2005, in a ceremony held in Singapore attended by Livingstone, London was announced as the victor, resulting in widespread celebration.^[237] The following day, British-born Islamist suicide bombers undertook three attacks on the Underground and another on a bus, killing 52 civilians. Livingstone gave a speech from Singapore denouncing the attackers as terrorists, before immediately returning to London.^[238] Informing the BBC that Western foreign policy was largely to blame for the attacks,^[239] his response to the situation was widely praised, even by opponents.^[240] Fearing an Islamophobic backlash against the city's Muslim minority, he initiated an advertising campaign to counter this, holding a rally for inter-community unity in Trafalgar Square.^[241] A second, failed suicide bombing attack took place on 21 July,^[242] and in the aftermath police officers shot dead a Brazilian tourist, Jean Charles de Menezes, whom they mistook for a bomber. Police initially lied about the killing, resulting in widespread condemnation, although Livingstone defended the actions of Metropolitan Police commissioner Ian Blair.^[243]

In the aftermath of the 2005 London bombings, Livingstone initiated a campaign to celebrate London's multiculturalism

After Livingstone left a party in February 2005, Oliver Finegold, a reporter for the Evening Standard, attempted to ask Livingstone a question in the street. Aware that Finegold was Jewish, Livingstone accused him of acting "just like a concentration camp guard" and asserting that he worked for the "reactionary bigots... who supported fascism" at the Daily Mail and General Trust.^[244][245] Although The Evening Standard initially did not deem the comments newsworthy, they were leaked to The Guardian, resulting in accusations of anti-Semitism against Livingstone from the Board of Deputies of British Jews.^[246] There were many calls for Livingstone to apologise, including from Tony Blair, the London Assembly, a Holocaust survivors group and his deputy Gavron (the daughter of a Holocaust survivor), but he refused.^[247][248] The Standards Board for England asked the Adjudication Panel for England to deal with Livingstone on the issue, who in February 2006 found him guilty of bringing his office into disrepute and suspended him from office for a month. The decision was controversial, with Livingstone and many others arguing that an unelected board should not have the power to suspend an elected official.^[249][250] In October 2006 at the High Court of Justice, Justice Collins overturned the decision to suspend Livingstone.^[251][252]

Although he had aggravated much of London's Jewish community, Livingstone denied being anti-semitic, holding regular meetings with the city's Jewish groups and introducing public Hanukkah celebrations in Trafalgar Square in December 2005.^{[253][254][255]} He came under further accusations of anti-semitism in March 2006 for asserting that the businessmen David and Simon Reuben should return to Iran if they did not like Britain; he claimed he had mistakenly believed them to be Iranian Muslims, whereas in reality they were Indian Jews.^[256] Livingstone refused calls for him to apologise to the Reubens, instead offering "a complete apology to the people of Iran for the suggestion that they may be linked in any way to the Reuben brothers".^[257]

In March 2006, Livingstone publicly criticised foreign embassies in London who refused to pay the congestion charge under the conditions of the 1961 Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations. His criticism focused on US diplomat Robert Tuttle, condemning him as a "chiselling little crook" whose embassy was refusing to pay the £1.5 million he believed it owed.^[120] In February 2007, Livingstone's administration doubled the congestion charge zone by extending it westwards into Kensington and Chelsea, despite opposition from resident groups.^[258] In October 2007, the government agreed to go ahead with Crossrail, a £16 billion project to construct a train line under central London, linking Berkshire to Essex.^[259] Meanwhile, Livingstone felt vindicated in his former opposition to public private partnership when one of the companies who now controlled part of the Underground, Metronet, collapsed in July 2007, with the state having to intervene to protect the service.^[260] Livingstone had also welcomed the construction of skyscrapers in London, giving the go ahead for 15 to be constructed during his Mayoralty, including 30 St Mary Axe and The Shard. He considered it necessary to fill the demand for office space, but was criticised by groups and individuals, most notably Charles, Prince of Wales, concerned about the preservation of historic skylines.^[261]

Livingstone's emotional apology for London's role in the transatlantic slave trade

In May 2006, Livingstone welcomed Venezuelan President Hugo Chávez to London, hosting an event for him at City Hall. This was condemned by various Conservatives claiming that Chávez's democratic socialist government had undermined pluralistic democracy.^[262] Livingstone proceeded to accept the presidency of the pro-Chávez Venezuelan Information Centre.^[263] In November 2006, Livingstone travelled to Latin America to visit Chávez, during which he and his entourage stayed in Cuba at a cost of £29,000; many British sources condemned the visit as a waste of tax-payer's money.^[264] In August 2007, it was announced that Livingstone had come to an agreement with oil-rich Venezuela; Chávez's government would supply £16 million a year worth of free oil to TfL, who would use it to subsidise half priced bus fares for 250,000 Londoners on benefits. In return, London would provide expertise in running transport, as well as other services such as CCTV and waste management.^[265][266]

Livingstone helped organise the first "Eid in the Square" event at Trafalgar Square in commemoration of the Islamic Eid ul-Fitr festival in October 2006.^[267] In May 2007, Livingstone travelled to New York City to attend the C40 conference of major world cities to deal with environmentalist issues. One of the leading figures of the conference, he called for other cities to adopt congestion charging as an environmental measure.^[268] In August 2007, he issued a public apology on behalf of London for its role in the transatlantic slave trade. He selected the anniversary of the Haitian Revolution on which to do it, and in his tearful speech asserted that it was the resistance of enslaved persons rather than the philanthropy of wealthy whites that led to the trade's end.^[269] A week later he attended the unveiling of the statue of Nelson Mandela in Parliament Square, where he met with Nelson Mandela.^[270] In June 2007, Livingstone criticised the planned £200 million Thames Water Desalination Plant at Beckton, which will be the United Kingdom's first, calling it "misguided and a retrograde step in UK environmental policy", and that "we should be encouraging people to use less water, not more."^[271] In October 2007, London Councils stated Livingstone had gone back on his promise to chair the developing London Waste and Recycling Board, and to provide £6 million of funding for the project, because "the government had failed to provide him with absolute control of the Board."^[272]

Livingstone was defeated by Conservative candidate Boris Johnson (pictured, 2006)

Livingstone intended to stand again as Labour candidate in the London Mayoral election, 2008, this time against Conservative candidate Boris Johnson.^[273] At the start of the campaign Livingstone took Johnson more seriously than many others were doing, referring to him as "the most formidable opponent I will face in my political career."^[274] Much of Labour's campaign revolved around criticising Johnson for perceived racist and homophobic comments that he had made in the past, although Johnson strenuously denied that he was bigoted.^[275] Livingstone also proposed that if he were to win a third term he would increase the congestion charge fee to £25 for the most polluting vehicles, while removing it for the least, and that he would also introduce a cycling scheme based on the Vélib' system in Paris.^[276] As part of his campaign, Livingstone highlighted that by 2008, the Metropolitan Police had 35,000 officers, 10,000 more than it had had in 2000, also highlighting statistics to indicate falling crime rates across the city during his Mayorship.^[277] Nevertheless, there had been a recent rise in gang killing among young people, with 27 teenagers having been killed in gang warfare during 2007, a statistic used by Johnson's campaign who emphasised the idea that a Johnson administration would be far tougher on youth crime and anti-social behaviour.^[278]

Further controversy rocked Livingstone's campaign in December 2007 when Evening Standard journalist Andrew Gilligan alleged that one of Livingstone's close advisers, Lee Jasper, had siphoned off at least £2.5 million from the London Development Agency to fund black community groups with which he was closely associated. Livingstone stood by Jasper and claimed that the Evening Standard campaign was racist, but ultimately agreed to suspend Jasper while a full investigation took place.^[279] An independent report into the affair by District auditor Michael Haworth-Maden in July 2009 found no evidence of "misappropriation of funds" but noted "significant" gaps in financial paperwork.^[280] The election took place in May 2008, and witnessed a turnout of approximately 45% of eligible voters, with Johnson receiving 43.2% and Livingstone 37% of first-preference votes; when second-preference votes were added, Johnson proved victorious with 53.2% to Livingstone's 46.8%.^[281]

Post-mayoral career

Unsuccessful election: 2008–14

Newly elected, Mayor Johnson paid tribute to Livingstone and his "very considerable achievements", hoping that the new administration could "discover a way in which the mayoralty can continue to benefit from your transparent love of London".^[282] Johnson's administration nevertheless reversed a number of Livingstone's policies, for instance overturning the deal for Venezuelan oil.^{[283][284][285][286]} Intent on giving Venezuela the "advice that we promised",^[283][286] in August 2008 Livingstone announced that he would be advising urban planning in Caracas.^{[283][284][285][286]} Livingstone predicted that in twenty years it could become a "first-world city",^[286] and hoped to help with his "very extensive network of contacts both domestically and internationally".^[285]

"Obviously everyone respects the decision of the electorate. But it is already clear that Boris Johnson's Tory regime is one of decline [in] London: economic decline, social decline, cultural decline and environmental decline. This is the real root of the incompetence [his administration] has shown in its first two months in office. I believe this will become increasingly obvious and therefore I will use the normal methods of democratic debate to convince electors that the previous policies were successful and the new ones will fail."

Ken Livingstone (2008)^[287]

In January 2009, Livingstone responded to the Gaza War by calling for the European Union and the UK to bring home their ambassadors to Israel to express disapproval for the "slaughter and systematic murder of innocent Arabs".^[288][289] From September 2009 to March 2011, Livingstone presented the book review programme Epilogue for the Iranian state-sponsored international news channel Press TV, for which he came under criticism from Iranian exile groups.^[290][291] In July 2010, he spoke at the Durham Miners' Gala, praising working class culture.^[292] He also used the speech to attack spending cuts by the new coalition government, claiming they were not necessary.^[293] In September 2010, Livingstone criticised the public spending cuts announced by the recently elected Conservative-Liberal Democrat coalition government, which he stated amounted to £45 billion a year for London alone, and were "beyond Margaret Thatcher's wildest dreams" as well as threatening to result in widespread division and poverty across the capital.^[294] In May 2011, Livingstone said he was "appalled" that Osama bin Laden had been shot dead by US Special forces "in his pyjamas" and "in front of his kid," and that the values of a western democracy would have been best demonstrated if Bin Laden had been put on trial and his words challenged.^[295]

Livingstone stood for the Labour candidacy as 2012 Mayoral candidate. His campaign attracted criticism when he joked that the election was "a simple choice between good and evil",^[296] and when he was accused of antisemitism by Jewish Labour supporters for suggesting that being largely wealthy, the Jewish community would not vote for him. He denied making the comments, but nevertheless apologised.^{[297][298][299]} Johnson's campaign emphasised the accusation that Livingstone was guilty of tax evasion, for which Livingstone called Johnson a "bare-faced liar".^[300] The political scientist Andrew Crines believed that Livingstone's campaign suffered from its focus on criticising Johnson rather than presenting an alternate and progressive vision of London's future,^[301] also suggesting that after decades in the public eye, Livingstone had come to be seen as an over-familiar and politically tired figure by the London electorate.^[302] On 4 May 2012 Livingstone was defeated in the London 2012 Mayoral Elections by the incumbent Mayor, Boris Johnson. There was only a difference of 62,538 votes between the 2 candidates with Livingstone receiving 992,273 votes and Johnson receiving 1,054,811 votes. Livingstone criticised bias in the media and declared that he would be bowing out of politics.^[303][304]

He remained publicly critical of Johnson over the coming years; in April 2014, he admitted that while he had once feared Johnson as "the most hardline right-wing ideologue since Thatcher", over the course of Johnson's mayoralty, he had instead concluded that he was "a fairly lazy tosser who just wants to be there" but who does very little work.^[305]

Under Corbyn's leadership: 2015–

Livingstone was a supporter of Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn (pictured)

In May 2015, Livingstone endorsed Sadiq Khan to be the Labour candidate for the 2016 London mayoral election,^[306] and in July then endorsed Jeremy Corbyn in the 2015 Labour Party leadership election.^[307] After Corbyn was elected Labour leader, Livingstone was one of his most prominent allies; in November 2015 Corbyn appointed Livingstone to co-convene Labour's defence review alongside Maria Eagle.^[308] This appointment was criticised by shadow defence minister Kevan Jones, who expressed the view that Livingstone knew little about defence and that it would damage the party's reputation. Livingstone responded by claiming that Jones – who has spoken about his own clinical depression – needed "psychiatric help". Jones took offense, and while Livingstone initially refused to apologise, he subsequently did so after Corbyn urged him to.^[309]

Livingstone faced further criticism following a television appearance in which he stated that the perpetrators of the 2005 London bombings carried out their actions as retribution for UK involvement in the Iraq War.^[310][311] In March 2016, Livingstone again courted controversy by comparing a hedge fund's donation to Labour MP Dan Jarvis to "Jimmy Savile funding a children's group"; it subsequently emerged that Livingstone himself had accepted £8,000 from a hedge fund, leading to accusations of hypocrisy.^[312][313]

Suspension from the Labour Party

In April 2016, Livingstone publicly commented on the suspension of Labour MP Naz Shah; she had been removed from the party after it was revealed that she had made comments on Facebook suggesting that Israeli Jews should be relocated to the United States.^[314] Livingstone stated that Shah's postings, which were made before she became an MP at the 2015 general election, were "completely over the top" and "rude",^[315] although he did not deem them antisemitic.^[316] He asserted that there is a "well-orchestrated campaign by the Israel lobby to smear anybody who criticises Israeli policy as antisemitic",^[317] and also stated that Adolf Hitler "was supporting Zionism before he went mad and ended up killing six million Jews".^[315]

He defended his claims by reference to Lenni Brenner's Zionism in the Age of the Dictators,^[318] and many commentators suggested that Livingstone was referring to the Haavara Agreement between Nazi Germany and the Zionist Federation of Germany.^{[319][320][321][322]} Livingstone's statements were criticized by some historians,^[323][324] among them Roger Moorhouse, who claimed that they were historically inaccurate.^[325] He also became involved in a public argument on the subject with the Labour MP John Mann.^[326]

Livingstone was subsequently suspended from Labour Party membership "for bringing the party into disrepute".^[327] Over 20 Labour MPs called for Livingstone's suspension, while Jon Lansman, founder of the pro-Corbyn Momentum group, called for Livingstone to leave politics altogether,^[327] and Khan called for his expulsion from the party.^[318]

In a subsequent interview, Livingstone expressed regret both for mentioning Hitler and for offending Jews but added that "I'm not going to apologise for telling the truth."^[328][329] Corbyn announced that the decision to expel Livingstone would be made by a National Executive Committee internal inquiry, whilst Livingstone insisted that he would be exonerated on the basis of Brenner's book, saying "how can the truth be an offence?"^[330]

Political views

"Ken never had a very clear political philosophy. Ken never read philosophical books from a political point of view. He had a gut feeling; he was always opposed to exploitation and inequalities in a big way. He had a social conscience and wanted to do something about it. But he saw it within the existing parliamentary and political system. He didn't consider taking up arms against anybody as a way forward or dramatically changing the electoral system. He thought you could persuade and change the Labour Party."

Ted Knight on Livingstone.^[331]

Within the Labour Party, Livingstone was aligned with the hard left.^[332] Historian Alwyn W. Turner noted that Livingstone's entire approach to politics revolved not simply around providing public services, but in trying to change society itself; in his words, he wanted to get away from the concept of "old white men coming along to general management committees and talking about rubbish collection."^[333] Biographer John Carvel, a journalist from The Guardian, remarked that Livingstone's political motivation was a "fundamental desire... for a more participative, cooperative society", leading him to oppose "concentrations of power and... exploitation in all its forms – economic, racial and sexual."^[334] However, Livingstone has also described his approach to fiscal policy as "monetarist": "I was a monetarist right from the beginning when I was leader of the GLC. We paid down debt every year. We had an absolutely firm rule."^[335]

Livingstone describes himself as a socialist. In 1987, he stated that "politics is my religion. It's my moral framework. I believe a socialist society is inherently the best thing, and that's like an act of faith."^[336] In 2007, he stated that "I still believe one day that the idea that the main means of production are owned by private individuals... will be considered as anti-democratic as the idea serfs could be tied to the land. But I will not be alive when that day comes."^[337] Livingstone had always worked towards a unified socialist front on the British left, and disliked the tendency towards splintering and forming rival factions, usually over issues of political theory, among the socialist community.^[338] Although rejecting Marxism, throughout his political career he has worked alongside Marxist far-left groups and has become involved with the "politics of the street".^[339] He has however not worked with those Marxist groups, such as the Socialist Workers Party and the Revolutionary Communist Party, who advocate the destruction of the Labour Party as the way forward for socialism, seeing their beliefs as incompatible with his own.^[340] Livingstone has consistently opposed the actions of the Israeli government. In a 2005 interview he said that he was not against the existence of Israel, but rather Ariel Sharon's government; he recalled that on his 1986 visit to the country he got on well with its left-wing politicians.^[341]

Livingstone has consistently rejected being defined under any particular ideological current of socialism.^[342] Recognising this, in 2000, the former Labour Party leader Neil Kinnock asserted that Livingstone could only be defined as a "Kennist".^[331] Livingstone's understanding of politics arises from his studies of animal behaviour and anthropology; rejecting the idea that the human species is naturally progressing (a view advocated by socialists like the Fabian Society), Livingstone instead took the view that human society is still coming to terms with the massive socio-economic changes that it experienced upon the development of agriculture during the Neolithic. Highlighting that a hunter-gatherer mode of subsistence is more natural to the human species, he believes that modern society has to adopt many hunter-gatherer values – namely mutual co-operation and emphasis on human relationships rather than consumerism – in order to survive.^[343]

Personal life

Historian Alwyn W. Turner noted that Livingstone was a "gifted communicator and self-publicist" who was able to stump his opponents using his "mischievous sense of humour".^[333] Biographer John Carvel echoed these comments, highlighting that Livingstone had a "talent for public speaking".^[344] Biographer Andrew Hosken noted that many of those who had worked with Livingstone had commented on him being an excellent boss, who was "a good delegator, decisive and supportive" as well as being "a friendly and modest colleague."^[345] Jenny McCartney, a reporter from The Spectator, expressed the view that "in person he is hard to dislike. There's a notable absence of pomposity in his manner, a propensity to laughter, and his love of an ideological scrap is allied to a calm, sometimes wry style of delivery: it looks fiercer on paper."^[346] In The Guardian, the journalist Hugh Muir described Livingstone as a man who is "happiest in the limelight, discomforted by the periphery" and who also "hates to apologise... especially when called upon [to do so]... by media or political opponents for whom he has no respect".^[347]

On the issue of nationality, Livingstone has expressed the view that he identifies as English rather than British, although his father was Scottish and he supports the continued existence of the United Kingdom.^[346] Although raised into a nominally Christian family, Livingstone renounced religious belief when he was eleven, becoming an atheist. In a 2005 interview he commented that in doing so he had rejected "mumbo-jumbo in favour of rational science."^[13] He is known for his enthusiasm for gardening and keeping and breeding newts. He was the first person to breed the Western Dwarf Clawed Frog Hymenochirus curtipes in captivity.^[348][349] Livingstone is a big fan of The Godfather film franchise, stating that the actions of the criminal organisations within the movies are very much akin to the world of politics.^[350]

Family

Livingstone repeatedly attempted to keep his family life private, commenting that "I expect that my private life is not in the public domain and I'm rude to any journalist who turns up... at home".^[351] It is known that he has five children.^[352] Livingstone married Christine Pamela Chapman in 1973; the marriage ended in divorce in 1982. Around that time he became involved with Kate Allen, now director of Amnesty International in the UK; the couple separated in November 2001.^[353] He then entered a relationship with his office manager, Emma Beal; they have a son and a daughter together.^[354] Livingstone and Beal married on 26 September 2009 in the Mappin Pavilion of London Zoo. They live in North London.^[2]

Livingstone had also fathered three children prior to 2000; a boy by one mother and two girls by another.^[354] The children were born to two different women while Livingstone was involved with Kate Allen, according to an article by Decca Aitkenhead:

In his memoir, he describes how one was an old friend who was keen to have children but feared she was running out of time. "We had never been involved romantically but I knew her well enough to know she would be a wonderful mother and so I said I would like to be the father of her children." A daughter was born in 1990, and another in 1992. Then another friend said she'd like to have children: "And we agreed to have a baby." Their son was born within weeks of his daughter in 1992.^[355]

Legacy and influence

Throughout his career, Livingstone polarised public opinion,^[356] and was widely recognised as a risk-taker.^[277] Supporters described him as the "People's Ken" and an "anti-politician politician", opining that he had the common touch with working-class Londoners that most British politicians lacked.^[357] He was widely recognised for having improved the status of minority groups in London.^[358] He was also deemed a "formidable operator" at City Hall, with an "intimate knowledge" of London.^[359]

He was also widely criticised and denounced during his career. During his Mayorship, he faced repeated accusations of cronyism for favouring his chosen aides over other staff.^[198] One of his supporters, Atma Singh, commented that under Livingstone's leadership, a culture of bullying pervaded at City Hall, although this was denied by many other staff there.^[360] Livingstone has also been criticised by various British far-left groups like the Socialist Workers Party and the Alliance for Workers' Liberty, who have deemed his reformist politics to be insufficiently radical and condemned him for backing the Metropolitan Police and big business while criticising the RMT trade union during his Mayorship.^[361]

Throughout his career, Livingstone was referenced in popular culture. During the 1980s, Spitting Image featured a fictionalised version of Livingstone voiced by Harry Enfield.^[177] In 1990, BBC show The Comic Strip produced an episode entitled "GLC: The Carnage Continues..." in which Robbie Coltrane played a fictionalised portrayal of Charles Bronson playing Livingstone in a Hollywood movie.^[177] Kate Bush wrote the song "Ken" for the episode, which was then released as a B-side to her single "Love and Anger".^[362]

References

Footnotes

1. "Jeremy Corbyn denies crisis as Ken Livingstone suspended". BBC News.
2. BBC News 2009.
3. Moore 2007; Purnell 2011, p. 314; Eaton 2014.
4. Carvel 1984, pp. 26, 28; Hosken 2008, p. 1.
5. Carvel 1984, p. 27; Carvel 1999, p. 17; Hosken 2008, pp. 1–2.
6. "Births England and Wales 1837–1915". Freebmd.org.uk. 21 June 2010. Retrieved 7 July 2010.
7. Carvel 1984, pp. 27–28; Carvel 1999, pp. 18, 36; Hosken 2008, p. 2; Edwards & Isaby 2008, pp. 32–33.
8. Barratt, Nick (7 April 2007). "Family Detective:Ken Livingstone". The Daily Telegraph (London). Retrieved 4 April 2010.
9. Carvel 1984, pp. 27–28; Hosken 2008, pp. 1–2; Livingstone 2011, p. 1.
10. Carvel 1984, p. 28.
11. Carvel 1984, pp. 28–30, 32; Hosken 2008, p. 4.
12. Carvel 1984, p. 32; Hosken 2008, p. 11.
13. Livingstone 2005.
14. Carvel 1984, pp. 31–32; Hosken 2008, pp. 4–6; Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 33.
15. Carvel 1984. pp. 31–32.
16. Carvel 1984, p. 37; Livingstone 1987, p. 14; Hosken 2008, p. 8.
17. Carvel 1984, p. 35.
18. Carvel 1984, p. 37.
19. Carvel 1984, p. 36; Hosken 2008, p. 7; Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 33.
20. Carvel 1984, p. 37; Hosken 2008, p. 9.
21. Carvel 1984, p. 38; Livingstone 1987, p. 13; Hosken 2008, pp. 9–10; Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 33.
22. Carvel 1984, p. 39; Livingstone 1987, p. 14; Hosken 2008, p. 11.
23. Carvel 1984, p. 38; Livingstone 1987, p. 14.
24. Carvel 1984, p. 38; Hosken 2008, p. 11; Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 33.
25. Carvel 1984, p. 39; Livingstone 1987, p. 14.
26. Livingstone 1987, p. 11.
27. Carvel 1984, pp. 39–40; Livingstone 1987, p. 11; Hosken 2008, pp. 13–14.
28. Carvel 1984, p. 41; Hosken 2008, p. 14.
29. Livingstone 1987, pp. 12–13.
30. Carvel 1984, p. 40; Livingstone 1987, p. 13; Hosken 2008, p. 15.
31. Carvel 1984, pp. 44–45; Hosken 2008, pp. 16–18.
32. Livingstone 1987, pp. 16–17.
33. Hosken 2008, p. 18.
34. Livingstone 1987, p. 22.
35. Carvel 1984, p. 41; Livingstone 1987, pp. 18–19; Hosken 2008, p. 20.
36. Carvel 1984, p. 44.
37. Carvel 1984, p. 42; Livingstone 1987, p. 21; Hosken 2008, p. 21.
38. Carvel 1984, p. 42; Livingstone 1987, p. 23.
39. Livingstone 1987. p. 26.
40. Hosken 2008, pp. 27–36.
41. Carvel 1984, pp. 42–43; Livingstone 1987, pp. 26–27; Hosken 2008, pp. 22–23.
42. Livingstone 1987, pp. 28–31, 33.
43. Carvel 1984, p. 45; Livingstone 1987, pp. 40, 42; Hosken 2008, p. 39.
44. Livingstone 1987, p. 42; Hosken 2008, p. 39.
45. Livingstone 1987, p. 38; Hosken 2008, pp. 55–56.
46. Carvel 1984, p. 42; Hosken 2008, p. 56.
47. Carvel 1984, p. 54; Livingstone 1987, pp. 47, 53–55; Hosken 2008, pp. 46–47.
48. Hosken 2008, p. 57.
49. Carvel 1984, p. 59; Livingstone 1987, p. 70; Hosken 2008, p. 48.
50. Carvel 1984, pp. 59, 61–62; Hosken 2008, p. 50.
51. Carvel 1984, p. 63; Livingstone 1987, pp. 83–84; Hosken 2008, pp. 57–59.
52. Carvel 1984, p. 63.
53. Carvel 1984, pp. 63–65; Livingstone 1987, pp. 96–99; Hosken 2008, pp. 57–59.
54. Hosken 2008, pp. 52–53.
55. Carvel 1984, pp. 67–68; Livingstone 1987, pp. 86, 89; Hosken 2008, p. 60.
56. Hosken 2008, pp. 61–62.
57. Carvel 1984, pp. 66–67; Livingstone 1987, pp. 99–100; Hosken 2008, pp. 62–63.
58. Carvel 1984, p. 67; Hosken 2008, p. 64.
59. Carvel 1984, pp. 67–68; Livingstone 1987, pp. 90–91; Hosken 2008, pp. 67–69; Turner 2010, p. 32.
60. Livingstone 1987, pp. 90, 92–94, 107–113; Hosken 2008, pp. 72–77.
61. Carvel 1984, pp. 87, 91, 105; Hosken 2008, pp. 96, 98.
62. Carvel 1984, p. 14; Hosken 2008, pp. 77–78.
63. Carvel 1984, p. 10; Livingstone 1987, pp. 133–136; Hosken 2008, p. 84.
64. Carvel 1984, p. 15; Livingstone 1987, p. 137.
65. Carvel 1984, pp. 16–18; Livingstone 1987, pp. 138–140; Hosken 2008, pp. 88–91.
66. Carvel 1984, p. 20.
67. Carvel 1984, pp. 18–20; Hosken 2008, p. 95.
68. Carvel 1984, p. 19; Hosken 2008, pp. 94–95.
69. Livingstone 1987, pp. 144–145; Hosken 2008, pp. 91–92.
70. Livingstone 1987, p. 151; Hosken 2008, p. 100.
71. Carvel 1984, p. 86; Hosken 2008, p. 92.
72. Hosken 2008, pp. 100–101.
73. Livingstone 1987, p. 154.
74. Carvel 1984, p. 86; Hosken 2008, pp. 94–96, 98.
75. Carvel 1984, pp. 13–14.
76. Hosken 2008, pp. 96–97.
77. Carvel 1984, p. 88; Hosken 2008, p. 98; Turner 2010, p. 80.
78. Hosken 2008, p. 110.
79. Carvel 1984, pp. 184–185; Hosken 2008, pp. 137–138.
80. Carvel 1984, pp. 149, 195.
81. Carvel 1984, pp. 166–175; Hosken 2008, pp. 174–181.
82. Carvel 1984, p. 199.
83. Carvel 1984, pp. 83–84; Hosken 2008, p. 101.
84. Carvel 1984, pp. 115–118.
85. Carvel 1984, pp. 128–133; Hosken 2008, pp. 117–118.
86. Carvel 1984, pp. 135–136.
87. Carvel 1984, pp. 137–138.
88. Carvel 1984, pp. 140–143.
89. Carvel 1984, pp. 148–150.
90. Turner 2010, p. 80.
91. Carvel 1984, pp. 203–204.
92. Carvel 1984, p. 126; Livingstone 1987, pp. 148–149.
93. Carvel 1984, pp. 124–126.
94. Carvel 1984, p. 124.
95. Hosken 2008, pp. 152–155.
96. Turner 2010, p. 154.
97. Hosken 2008, pp. 142–145.
98. Hosken 2008, p. 148.
99. Hosken 2008, pp. 142–143.
100. Turner 2010, p. 90.
101. Hosken 2008, pp. 142–148; Turner 2010, p. 154.
102. Hosken 2008, pp. 145–146; Turner 2010, p. 155.
103. Hosken 2008, p. 156.
104. Carvel 1984, pp. 90–91; Livingstone 1987, pp. 145–146; Hosken 2008, p. 99; Turner 2010, p. 78.
105. Carvel 1984, p. 86; Livingstone 1987, pp. 151–152; Hosken 2008, pp. 99–100.
106. Carvel 1984, p. 153; Turner 2010, p. 86.
107. Carvel 1984, pp. 182–184; Hosken 2008, pp. 126–135.
108. Hosken 2008, p. 139.
109. Hosken 2008, p. 158.
110. Carvel 1984, pp. 88–90, 100; Hosken 2008, pp. 103–104.
111. Hosken 2008, pp. 104–105.
112. Carvel 1984, pp. 95–97; Hosken 2008, pp. 158–159; Turner 2010, p. 86.
113. Carvel 1984, p. 98; Hosken 2008, p. 159.
114. Hosken 2008, p. 161.
115. Matthew Tempest, "Loyalists planned to kill Livingstone", The Guardian, 10 June 2003
116. "My plot to murder Livingstone, by former hitman" thisislondon.co.uk, 1 November 2006
117. Carvel 1984, pp. 157–159; Hosken 2008, pp. 165–168.
118. Carvel 1984, p. 160; Hosken 2008, p. 169.
119. Carvel 1984, p. 161.
120. Hosken 2008, p. 417.
121. Carvel 1984, p. 156.
122. Turner 2010, p. 113.
123. Hosken 2008, p. 155.
124. Hosken 2008, pp. 168–169.
125. Hosken 2008, p. 151.
126. Hosken 2008, pp. 145–146.
127. Carvel 1984, p. 207; Hosken 2008, p. 151.
128. Carvel 1984, pp. 93–95.
129. Hosken 2008, pp. 162–163.
130. Hosken 2008, p. 109.
131. Carvel 1984, p. 102.
132. Hosken 2008, pp. 113–114.
133. Hosken 2008, pp. 191–193.
134. Carvel 1984, pp. 219–223.
135. Carvel 1984, pp. 199–200; Hosken 2008, pp. 195–199.
136. Turner 2010, p. 171.
137. Hosken 2008, p. 197.
138. Carvel 1984, pp. 213–218; Hosken 2008, pp. 198–202.
139. Carter 1999, p. 174; Hosken 2008, p. 202.
140. Hosken 2008, pp. 202–204.
141. Clayton, Hugh (21 September 1984). "Livingstone poll win denounced as 'stunt'". The Times. Retrieved 11 August 2014.
142. Hosken 2008, pp. 235–236.
143. Carvel 1999, pp. 217–218.
144. Carvel 1999, p. 214; Hosken 2008, p. 240.
145. Carvel 1999, p. 220; Hosken 2008, p. 243.
146. Hosken 2008, pp. 243–244.
147. Carvel 1999, p. 277.
148. Hosken 2008, pp. 244–245.
149. Hosken 2008, pp. 274–274.
150. Carvel 1999, pp. 234–235; Hosken 2008, p. 246.
151. Carvel 1999, p. 237; Hosken 2008, p. 253.
152. Carvel 1999, pp. 218–219, 222.
153. Carvel 1999, p. 240; Hosken 2008, pp. 275–276.
154. Carvel 1999, p. 244.
155. Carvel 1999, p. 241; Hosken 2008, pp. 276–277.
156. Carvel 1999, p. 242; Hosken 2008, pp. 278–279.
157. Hosken 2008, p. 79.
158. Hosken 2008, p. 280.
159. Hosken 2008, pp. 283–284.
160. Hosken 2008, p. 285.
161. Hosken 2008, p. 293.
162. Carvel 1999, pp. 246–247.
163. Hosken 2008, p. 241.
164. Carvel 1999, pp. 230–231; Hosken 2008, pp. 256–263; Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 38.
165. Carvel 1999, p. 238; Hosken 2008, pp. 274–275; Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 38.
166. Hosken 2008, pp. 274–275.
167. Hosken 2008, pp. 265–269.
168. Hosken 2008, pp. 280–281.
169. Carvel 1999, p. 239; Hosken 2008, p. 282.
170. Carvel 1999, p. 218; Hosken 2008, p. 240.
171. Hosken 2008, p. 240.
172. Hosken 2008, pp. 240–241.
173. Carvel 1999, p. 232; Hosken 2008, pp. 272–273.
174. Carvel 1999, pp. 231–232; Hosken 2008, pp. 280–281.
175. Carvel 1999, p. 240; Hosken 2008, pp. 273–274.
176. Hosken 2008, p. 283.
177. Hosken 2008, p. 281.
178. Hosken 2008, p. 290.
179. Carvel 1999, p. 253; Hosken 2008, pp. 290–291, 296; Edwards & Isaby 2008, pp. 1–4.
180. Hosken 2008, pp. 296–297.
181. Carvel 1999, p. 267; Hosken 2008, p. 294.
182. Hosken 2008, p. 297.
183. Hosken 2008, p. 299.
184. Hosken 2008, p. 300; Edwards & Isaby 2008, pp. 10–11.
185. Hosken 2008, pp. 305–311; Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 12.
186. Hosken 2008, pp. 312–314.
187. Hosken 2008, p. 314.
188. Hosken 2008, p. 316.
189. "Livingstone to apologise to MPs".
190. Hosken 2008, pp. 316–317; Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 13.
191. Hosken 2008, pp. 316–317.
192. Hosken 2008, p. 322.
193. Hosken 2008, p. 330.
194. Carvel 1999, p. 271; Hosken 2008, p. 321.
195. Hosken 2008, pp. 321–322.
196. Hosken 2008, pp. 322–333.
197. Hosken 2008, pp. 325–327.
198. Hosken 2008, pp. 357–358.
199. Hosken 2008, p. 320.
200. Hosken 2008, pp. 333–334.
201. Hosken 2008, p. 328.
202. Hosken 2008, pp. 328–332; Edwards & Isaby 2008, pp. 22–23.
203. Hosken 2008, pp. 404–405; Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 26.
204. Hosken 2008, pp. 405–406; Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 26.
205. "Mayor of London, the London Assembly and the Greater London Authority, "London Climate Change Agency,"". Archived from the original on 3 October 2007. Retrieved 11 October 2007.
206. Hosken 2008, p. 333; Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 27.
207. Hosken 2008, p. 353; Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 27.
208. "Irish London". BBC London. 12 October 2005.
209. Ken Livingstone (6 June 2006). "Festivals play their part in fighting racism". The Guardian (London).
210. Hosken 2008, pp. 413–414; Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 18.
211. Hosken 2008, p. 339.
212. Hosken 2008, pp. 337, 339.
213. Hosken 2008, pp. 339–342; Edwards & Isaby 2008, pp. 39–40.
214. Hosken 2008, pp. 342–348; Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 24.
215. "Political Studies Association Awards 2003" (PDF). Retrieved 7 July 2010.
216. Hosken 2008, pp. 350–351.
217. "Congestion charge zone increases". BBC News. 19 February 2007. Retrieved 4 April 2010.
218. Hosken 2008, pp. 407–408; Edwards & Isaby 2008, pp. 26–27.
219. Hosken 2008, p. 408.
220. Hosken 2008, pp. 360–383.
221. Hosken 2008, p. 364.
222. Hosken 2008, pp. 408–409; Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 29.
223. Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 16.
224. Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 17.
225. Hosken 2008, p. 377.
226. "Profile: Ken Livingstone". BBC News. 9 May 2003. Retrieved 4 April 2010.
227. Hosken 2008, pp. 353–355; Edwards & Isaby 2008, pp. 13, 39.
228. Hosken 2008, p. 356.
229. Hosken 2008, p. 357.
230. Ashley, Jackie (8 April 2004). "Jail Sharon and create 50% top tax rate, says Livingstone". The Guardian (London). Retrieved 26 April 2012.
231. "Anger at Livingstone Saudi 'rant'". BBC News. 8 April 2004.
232. Edwards & Isaby 2008, pp. 14–15.
233. Hélène Mulholland (11 June 2004). "Livingstone re-elected as London mayor". The Guardian.
234. Hosken 2008, pp. 377–378.
235. Hosken 2008, pp. 279–282; Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 41.
236. Ken Livingstone (4 March 2005). "This is about Israel, not anti-semitism". The Guardian (London). Retrieved 4 April 2010.
237. Hosken 2008, pp. 265–266.
238. Hosken 2008, pp. 369–373.
239. "Mayor blames Middle East policy". BBC News. 20 July 2005.
240. Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 18; Purnell 2011, p. 330.
241. Hosken 2008, p. 374.
242. Hosken 2008, pp. 374–375.
243. Hosken 2008, pp. 375–377.
244. Hosken 2008, pp. 385–386; Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 40.
245. Tryhorn, Chris (10 February 2005). "Livingstone attacks 'scumbag' Standard". The Guardian (London). Retrieved 4 April 2010.
246. Hosken 2008, pp. 387–388; Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 40.
247. Hosken 2008, pp. 390–391; Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 40.
248. "London Assembly censures Livingstone over Nazi jibe". The Scotsman. 15 February 2005.
249. Hosken 2008, pp. 388–340; Edwards & Isaby 2008, pp. 40–41.
250. "Mayor is suspended over Nazi jibe". BBC News. 24 February 2006.
251. Hosken 2008, pp. 398–340; Edwards & Isaby 2008, pp. 40–41.
252. "Ken's suspension order thrown out". BBC News. 5 October 2006.
253. Hosken 2008, p. 397.
254. "Mayor hosts ceremony for Hanukkah". Mayor Of London. 3 December 2005.
255. City Hall marks Jewish festival – BBC News. 28 December 2005
256. Hosken 2008, p. 425.
257. "Mayor defiant over Olympics row". BBC News. 21 March 2006.
258. Hosken 2008, p. 406; Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 24.
259. Hosken 2008, p. 407; Edwards & Isaby 2008, pp. 23–24.
260. Hosken 2008, p. 407.
261. Hosken 2008, p. 409; Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 28.
262. Hosken 2008, pp. 419–420.
263. Hosken 2008, p. 421.
264. Hosken 2008, pp. 418–419.
265. Hosken 2008, pp. 421–422; Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 42.
266. "Oil deal signals lower bus fares". BBC News. 20 August 2007. Retrieved 4 April 2010.; "Livingstone secures cheap oil from Chávez". Financial Times. 20 February 2007.
267. Londoners United and Rejoicing – Muslim Council of Britain Press release.
268. Hosken 2008, p. 423.
269. Hosken 2008, pp. 423–424.
270. Hosken 2008, p. 424.
271. "Mayor critical of government plans to approve desalination plant". Greater London Authority. 15 June 2007.
272. "London Councils expresses regret at Mayor's decision to dump waste and recycling board". London Councils. Archived from the original on 15 October 2007. Retrieved 11 October 2007.
273. Hosken 2008, p. 426.
274. Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 67; Purnell 2011, p. 314.
275. Hosken 2008, pp. 426–427; Edwards & Isaby 2008, pp. 67–69; Purnell 2011, p. 315.
276. Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 100.
277. Hosken 2008, p. 412.
278. Hosken 2008, p. 411; Edwards & Isaby 2008, pp. 20–21, 101.
279. Hosken 2008, pp. 427–431; Edwards & Isaby 2008, pp. 79–82, 97–98, 103–104.
280. "Auditor clears former aide to Ken Livingstone". The Independent on Sunday (London). 12 July 2009. pp. 28, 29.
281. Edwards & Isaby 2008, pp. 200–201.
282. "Johnson wins London mayoral race". BBC News. 3 May 2008. Retrieved 5 May 2008.
283. "Livingstone to be Chavez adviser". BBC news. 28 August 2008. Retrieved 29 August 2008.
284. Hamilton, Fiona (29 August 2008). "Ken Livingstone is new transport adviser for Hugo Chávez". The Times (London). Retrieved 29 August 2008.
285. Carroll, Rory (28 August 2008). "Livingstone to advise Chávez on urban issues". The Guardian (London). Retrieved 29 August 2008.
286. "Livingstone advises Caracas". The Press Association. 28 August 2008. Retrieved 29 August 2008.
287. Owen 2008.
288. age last updated Stars call for ceasefire in Gaza, BBC, 2 January 2009.
289. Annie Lennox calls for end to Gaza bombardment, Associated Press, 2 January 2009.
290. Martin Fletcher (20 January 2011). "Exiles outraged at Livingstone role on Iran TV mouthpiece". The Times. Retrieved 25 April 2012.
291. "Ken Livingstone under fire for earning thousands from Iranian TV role". Thisislondon. Retrieved 15 April 2012.
292. "Durham Miners Gala". Counterfire. 12 July 2010. Retrieved 1 May 2016.
293. "‘Red’ Ken making miners' gala debut". The Northern Echo. 10 July 2010. Retrieved 25 September 2010.
294. "Livingstone speaks out against ‘breathtaking scale’ of cuts | Tribune". Tribunemagazine.co.uk. Retrieved 1 May 2016.
295. Ross, Tim (17 April 2012). "Ken Livingstone: Bin Laden should not have been shot". London: Telegraph. Retrieved 18 April 2012.
296. Dominiczak 2011.
297. "Ken Livingstone: Jews won't vote Labour because they are rich". The Jewish Chronicle. Retrieved 15 April 2012.
298. Cusick, James (22 March 2012). "Livingstone 'says Jews are too rich to vote for him'". The Independent (London). Retrieved 15 April 2012.
299. "Former London mayor forced to apologize over controversial remarks to Jewish activists". Haaretz. Retrieved 15 April 2012.
300. Crines 2013, p. 3.
301. Crines 2013, p. 2.
302. Crines 2013, p. 5.
303. Sparrow, Andrew (4 May 2012). "Boris Johnson wins London mayoral election: Politics live blog". The Guardian. Retrieved 8 May 2012.
304. "London mayor: Boris Johnson wins second term by tight margin". BBC News. 5 May 2012.
305. George Eaton (30 April 2014). "Ken Livingstone: "Boris is a lazy tosser who just wants to be there"". New Statesman.
306. Pippa Crerar (18 May 2015). "Former mayoral rivals for Labour ticket join forces to back Sadiq Khan". The Evening Standard.
307. "Jeremy Corbyn could be prime minister – Ken Livingstone". bbc.co.uk. 24 July 2015. Retrieved 25 July 2015.
308. George Eaton (17 November 2015). "Ken Livingstone to co-convene Labour's defence review". New Statesman.
309. "Ken Livingstone makes 'unreserved' apology for 'psychiatric help' comment – BBC News". Bbc.co.uk. Retrieved 1 May 2016.
310. Watt, Nicholas (1 December 2015). "Blair guilty of 'criminal irresponsibility' over Iraq war, says Livingstone". Guardian. Retrieved 1 December 2015.
311. "Ken Livingstone: Tony Blair to blame for 7/7 bombings". BBC. 27 November 2015. Retrieved 1 December 2015.
312. Rowena Mason Political correspondent. "Ken Livingstone stands by Dan Jarvis hedge fund comments | Politics". The Guardian. Retrieved 1 May 2016.
313. 12 March 2016 at 12:35pm (12 March 2016). "Ken Livingstone was paid £8,000 fee by hedge fund – ITV News". Itv.com. Retrieved 1 May 2016.
314. Taylor, Adam. "Zionism and Hitler? A guide to the wild scandal rocking Britain's left". Washington Post. Retrieved 28 April 2016.
315. "Ken Livingstone suspended by Labour Party in 'anti-Semitism' row". BBC News. 28 April 2016. Retrieved 28 April 2016.
316. Rentoul, John (28 April 2016). "Ken Livingstone has deservedly gone – but Naz Shah made a genuine apology we should be prepared to accept". The Independent. Retrieved 28 April 2016.
317. Mason, Rowena; Asthana, Anushka; Sparrow, Andrew (28 April 2016). "Ken Livingstone's Hitler remarks spark Labour calls for suspension". The Guardian. Retrieved 28 April 2016.
318. Hughes, Laura (28 April 2016). "Ken Livingstone says Labour should reinstate him because everything he said about Jewish people "was true"". The Telegraph. Retrieved 28 April 2016.
319. Beaumont, Peter (1 May 2016). "Ken Livingstone muddies history to support claims on Hitler and Zionism". The Guardian. Retrieved 1 May 2016.
320. "Corbyn may not be antisemitic. But is he a real leader?". The Guardian. 1 May 2016. Retrieved 1 May 2016.
321. "Labour MPs call for Ken Livingstone to be suspended over anti-Semitism remarks". The Independent. 28 April 2016. Retrieved 1 May 2016.
322. "Livingstone's Hitler comments: Was ex-London mayor historically accurate, anti-Semitic or both?". International Business Times UK. 29 April 2016. Retrieved 1 May 2016.
323. Schulze, Rainer. "Labour antisemitism row: there was nothing Zionist about Hitler's plans for the Jews". The Conversation. Retrieved 6 May 2016.
324. "Livingstone Hitler comments 'inaccurate'". BBC News. Retrieved 6 May 2016.
325. Winer, Stuart (25 March 2016). "Livingstone says Netanyahu agrees with him in 'Hitler backed Zionism' row". The Times of Israel. Retrieved 1 May 2016.
326. Ned Simons, Assistant Political Editor (28 April 2016). "Ken Livingstone Branded A ‘Nazi Apologist’ In Angry Confrontation With Labour MP John Mann". The Huffington Post – Huffpost Politics (United Kingdom). Retrieved 30 April 2016.
327. Mason, Rowena; Asthana, Anushka (28 April 2016). "Ken Livingstone suspended from Labour after Hitler remarks". The Guardian. Retrieved 28 April 2016.
328. "Ken Livingstone stands by Hitler comments".
329. "Ken Livingstone's Remarkable LBC Interview In Full".
330. "'How can truth be offensive?' Asks unrepentant Ken Livingstone in anti-Semitism row". Herald Scotland. 30 April 2016. Retrieved 3 May 2016.
331. Hosken 2008. p. 29.
332. Carvel 1984. p. 178.
333. Turner 2010. p. 79.
334. Carvel 1984. p. 194.
335. Greig, Geordie (13 July 2010). "Ken Livingstone: I was a weedy kid but, like Boris, I survived on my wits". London Evening Standard (London). Retrieved 17 May 2014.
336. Hosken 2008, p. 244.
337. Livingstone, Ken (25 January 2007). "Davos 07: why should a socialist mayor come?". The Guardian (London). Retrieved 10 March 2011.
338. Carvel 1984. pp. 68–69, 178.
339. Hosken 2008. p. 26.
340. Carvel 1984. p. 179.
341. Bunder, Leslie (17 November 2005). "Ken Livingstone interview". Something Jewish. Retrieved 29 April 2016.
342. Carvel 1984. p. 180.
343. Carvel 1984. pp. 185–187.
344. Carvel 1984. p. 177.
345. Hosken 2008. p. 101.
346. McCartney 2014.
347. Muir, Hugh (29 April 2016). "Is this self-ignited firestorm the end for Ken Livingstone?". The Guardian. Retrieved 29 April 2016.
348. Livingstone 2011, p. 38.
349. Would I Lie to You? Series 3 Episode 2. BBC Television. First broadcast 17 August 2009.
350. Hosken 2008. p. 66.
351. Hosken 2008, pp. 337–338.
352. Hosken 2008, p. 337; Edwards & Isaby 2008, p. 144.
353. Womack, Sarah (6 November 2001). "Livingstone splits up with long-time lover". The Daily Telegraph (London). Retrieved 4 April 2010.
354. Hosken 2008, p. 337.
355. Decca Aitkenhead, "Ken Livingstone: 'It's an autobiography, not porn'", The Guardian, 21 October 2011. Retrieved 5 May 2012.
356. Hosken 2008, p. 432.
357. Hosken 2008, pp. 360, 432.
358. Hosken 2008, p. 413.
359. Hosken 2008, pp. 359–360.
360. Hosken 2008, p. 358.
361. Charlie Kimber (2007). "Ken Livingstone – the last reformist ?". International Socialism 113 (Socialist Workers Party). Mike Rowley (22 February 2008). "The real reasons to criticise Ken Livingstone". Workers' Liberty (Alliance for Workers' Liberty).
362. "Kate Bush Once Wrote A Song About Ken Livingstone". 28 March 2014. Retrieved 2 November 2012.

Bibliography

Carvel, John (1984). Citizen Ken. London: Chatto & Windus. ISBN 978-0701139292.

Carvel, John (1999). Turn Again Livingstone. Hatton Garden, London: Profile Books. ISBN 978-1-86197-131-9.

Crines, Andrew S. (2013). "Why did Boris Johnson win the 2012 mayoral election?". Public Policy and Administration Research 3 (9): 1–7.

Edwards, Giles; Isaby, Jonathan (2008). Boris v. Ken: How Boris Johnson Won London. London: Politico's. ISBN 978-1842752258.

Hosken, Andrew (2008). Ken: The Ups and Downs of Ken Livingstone. Arcadia Books. ISBN 978-1-905147-72-4.

Livingstone, Ken (1987). If Voting Changed Anything They'd Abolish it. London: Collins. ISBN 0-00-217770-6.

Livingstone, Ken (17 November 2005). Ken Livingstone interview. Something Jewish. Interview with Leslie Bunder (Jewish.co.uk). Retrieved 3 May 2011.

Livingstone, Ken (2011). You Can't Say That: Memoirs. Faber and Faber. ISBN 978-0571280414.

McCartney, Jenny (13 September 2014). "So, Ken Livingstone, do you like Boris personally? 'No'". The Spectator.

Moore, Charles (21 April 2007). "Make London part of Britain Again". The Telegraph.

Purnell, Sonia (2011). Just Boris: Boris Johnson: The Irresistible Rise of a Political Celebrity. London: Aurum Press Ltd. ISBN 1-84513-665-9.

Turner, Alwyn W. (2010). Rejoice! Rejoice! Britain in the 1980s. London: Aurum Press. ISBN 978-1-84513-525-6.

Mulholland, Hélène (24 September 2010). "Ken Livingstone beats Oona King to Labour nomination for London mayor". The Guardian (London: Guardian Media Group).

Owen, Paul (18 July 2008). "Ken Livingstone to run again for London mayor". The Guardian (London: Guardian Media Group).

"Ken Livingstone ties knot at zoo". London: BBC News. 26 September 2009.

External links

• Progressive London
• BBC Profile
• Ken Livingstone : Rebel Mayor (5 May
• The Observer Profile: Ken Livingstone – Capital chap by Jay Rayner, published in The Observer, 10 July 2005
• A left-wing critique of Livingstone, by Charlie Kimber, published in International Socialism journal
• Ken Livingstone speaker profile
• Compendium of articles about Ken Livingstone
• Portraits of Ken Livingstone at the National Portrait Gallery, London
• Archival material relating to Ken Livingstone listed at the UK National Archives